Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just told DH I will Divorce him over a fucking wedding Part two

716 replies

KeenHiker · 04/03/2024 09:52

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

I can’t believe the responses that I had.

Essentially I am going to that wedding so it won’t backfire on me and then as people have suggested reassess when everything has calmed down after Easter.

I am never going to look at MiL in the same light as she clearly thinks my daughter is an impediment to her own granddaughter.

Just told DH I will divorce him over a fucking wedding | Mumsnet

This is my first post. I think my head’s going to explode. BiL has shown no interest whatsoever in my daughters, not my eldest who isn’t my husband’...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

OP posts:
Justkeeepswimming · 05/03/2024 18:10

BruFord · 05/03/2024 16:41

I’ve just realized that I used to know a blended family in which the older children went to state and the younger children went to private schools.

Dad married first wife, had two children, they divorced and he got full custody, v. limited contact with their mother ( it was addiction-related).

He remarried and had two more children. His older children went to state schools; second wife paid for private for her two.

I knew the second wife, we were pretty good friends until they moved and we didn’t keep up the friendship. The older children seemed to adore the younger ones and their step-Mum. Obviously I have no idea how they felt about the school choices, but I suppose they accepted that their Dad couldn’t afford it?

I know that this isn’t really a helpful anecdote, but I’d forgotten about it-perhaps these choices are actually more common than we realize?

@BruFord

We chose a state school over private for DC as it was rated higher than local private and has comparable facilities.

We intend to have another child and are moving for more room… however in the new area the reverse is true so younger child will go to private school.

We also envisage that should any of the kids not get into free grammar we will pay for private at secondary level.

Therefore we are doing the best for each individual child depending on circumstances at the time, how we’re prioritising money and levelling the playing field as far as possible (ie paying for rugby lessons right now, but private would have coaching included).

At the current school most Mums have designer handbags, Range rovers and the like - they aren’t having to fork out for fees, but live in a nice area with a good school. At the private school there will be much less of that, especially as some have 3-4 kids to pay for. There are always compromises and things to weigh up.

Tryingmybestadhd · 05/03/2024 17:57

GasPanic · 05/03/2024 11:39

Have you considered the fact that it is also easy for people on here to suggest to other people what to do when it is not costing them tens or potentially hundreds of thousands of pounds ?!

Maybe if it was they might think differently...

My step kids live in another country , for them to come to us we pay for every flight , we also pay for every flight to come to us before we then head abroad to go on holiday twice a year . I should add that when I say we , I’m the main earner as earn 3x more than Dh does ( we both work full time ) we both have 2x children from previous relationships and one together. So yes I know exactly how hard it is to have to actually use “ my “ money for children that are not biologically mine . I do it without resenting them or my DH because I love him and them , and because I truly believe for us to be a fair family without screwing up the kids they need to know we love them all equally and will do the same for all of them . I also should add one of DH children is actually his stepchild that calls him dad as he married his mum when he was 4 years old , therefore no dna related to him or me but still 100% our family .
So please do not assume everyone is as horrid as this family and some of the posters here or think the same way as you !

Tryingmybestadhd · 05/03/2024 17:44

LadyBird1973 · 05/03/2024 15:08

@GasPanic I absolutely know that if I married a man who had a small child, with no biological mother on the scene, and I promised my dh that I would raise that child as if they were my own, I would not pay for private education only for the child that was biologically mine!

If I couldn't easily afford private education for both, neither would get it. I wouldn't want to be the kind of person who could raise siblings and not treat them as equally important.
Now it's possible (probable) that I might love my biological child more but if I was the only mother in both their lives, neither child would know that from my treatment of them.
I couldn't stay married to a man who was okay with differentiating between children when both of them see him as their dad.

When I’m almost giving up on humanity , someone who thinks the same way as me 🙏

BruFord · 05/03/2024 16:41

I’ve just realized that I used to know a blended family in which the older children went to state and the younger children went to private schools.

Dad married first wife, had two children, they divorced and he got full custody, v. limited contact with their mother ( it was addiction-related).

He remarried and had two more children. His older children went to state schools; second wife paid for private for her two.

I knew the second wife, we were pretty good friends until they moved and we didn’t keep up the friendship. The older children seemed to adore the younger ones and their step-Mum. Obviously I have no idea how they felt about the school choices, but I suppose they accepted that their Dad couldn’t afford it?

I know that this isn’t really a helpful anecdote, but I’d forgotten about it-perhaps these choices are actually more common than we realize?

Justkeeepswimming · 05/03/2024 15:56

KeenHiker · 05/03/2024 09:30

I am sitting in a cafe having taken my kids to school.

I am no nearer a resolution as evidenced here there is a lot to weigh up.

I don’t want to come on to defend myself in any way but to challenge what some people have posted.

I was privately educated until 11. I have a career and I am financially independent but not at a point where I could solely pay for a private education without compromising on essentials.

Adoption was never discussed and I don’t believe this would have affected my in-laws’ attitude.

I have never ever expected my in-laws to leave an inheritance to my daughter and the inheritance that my husband referred to recently does not come directly from his parents.

What I did expect that the inevitable disparity in their finances because I do accept that they have different fathers, would play out some decades in the future when they were mature and quite possibly my eldest would not necessarily have been privy to the youngest’s affairs.

I haven’t stopped facilitating a relationship with my eldest daughter’s family because they do nothing for me but because my daughter would become very distressed seeing her grandmother becoming distressed. My daughter’s father can no longer live independently because of choices he has made.

As a result of this thread I might try to speak with his sister to see if she would be willing to see my daughter independently of her mother.

Some posters are blaming me for all of this but as another poster said I didn’t possess a crystal ball.

I still don’t know what to do but my daughter doesn’t know any of this and the relationship she has with DH is a positive one.

I am upset that MiL sees her as an impediment to her own granddaughter and upset that she isn’t regarded as family for a photo with a 96 year old woman, incidentally a very minor part of the wedding and prompted by a cousin not the old lady herself.

I am shocked as the in-laws all of them, are always nice and polite showing no signs of this attitude.

The SiL, while I accept that she reached out, hasn’t really apologised and I don’t think feels that they have done anything wrong. Her own sister’s stepchild, completely unknown to me seems more independent than mine and is being brought up in a different setup.

I don’t think I can add anything else.

@KeenHiker

Read your updates OP sorry you are no closer to resolution.

Firstly, if you went to Prep yourself you know precisely what you are asking your younger daughter to give up. Sometimes you can be lucky and have a really good state school, but mostly there is no comparison. If your husbands present or future neices/nephews are likely to go the private school route your daughter will end up misaligned to her cousins, and she will no doubt be aware at some point - either through her own intelligence or the family grapevine - that you and her sister were the reason behind her having a great opportunity taken away… which is going to place both you and DD1 in an even worse position than now.

Secondly, if you are working full time, feel so strongly that your elder daughter should receive the same treatment and have the precedent for 50:50 division of bills. Then you could consider funding your elder daughters education - which would be fair - and either working more/seek promotion or ask your DH to support more of the ‘essentials’ during the seven years of senior school. This may mean kissing goodbye to a car, fancy holidays and handbags, but if your daughter is your priority then it will be worth it. The majority of people I know have to compromise to send their children to private school. And splitting the fees between you seems fair. Remember there are bursaries and other means of support your daughter may be entitled to on the basis of her academic ability and/or absentee father.

You have been incredibly naïve to think that your elder daughter would not be aware of her sisters wealth - your younger daughter was always going to have massive financial advantage due to her family. And your elder is not a dimwit and would have sussed things out early on whenever she has nicer clothes, presents, activities etc bought for her and later obviously when her younger sister appears with a brand new car and is on the housing ladder years before her. Your husbands family will get gifts and things of course - but it will be token and polite.

Please do try to facilitate contact with your former partner’s family - this is the only way of your elder daughter having a sense of who she is and proper familial relationships. There is no compromise for that and it is more worthwhile pursuing than fabricating a mirage and trying to force your husbands family to step in as a sticking plaster - it’s all fake. Awful about your elder’s father, but make the best of it you can.

Regards the photo with Granny; it is a two minute photograph, the woman is very elderly and doing this will give a lot of joy to the people who will miss her when she is gone. Presuming most of the children pictured will have some of her wealth trickling down to them too…. So really it would be very inappropriate for your elder daughter to be included - she isn’t related to this woman.

My advice would be don’t destabilise your children any further by creating another broken home. Your DH does sound reasonable and has contributed to your elder daughter having a vastly better quality of life than she would have had if you hadn’t met him. He is prepared to step up and parent her and to contribute to her well being, but there are limitations as he is not her father - he is a step father. If you feel so strongly about your elder daughter also having a private school education then you need to pay for it and suck it up that you have to compromise to do this and ask for some support with day to day things from your husband for the time period.

Go to the wedding and get on with it. Accept the photo is going to happen and allow the grandmother some 1:1 time with your younger daughter. In about 10yrs or so whenever your husbands parents have passed or gone gaga you are really not going to have to worry about making accomodations regarding his family; they will all scatter to the wind. Don’t upset yourself about them. Also in 8yrs time your elder daughter is going to Uni so no point upsetting the apple cart - if she was 2 and you had another 16yrs of childhood left you’d have a point but this is really going to be beyond conversation in a flash when your daughter is an adult.

What you need to ascertain now, beyond the wedding and private school issue, is what other plans your husband has up his sleeve, be it with his own money, or using for example a trust fund set up for DD2. Because you need to prepare yourself and your elder daughter for this and work out ways to bolster her resilience and self esteem. Think big things - does he plan to pay for more expensive activities (horse riding/skiing) and school trips for DD2, gap year, all Uni fees + accom, car, wedding, house deposit, health insurance, is he contributing to an ISA for her for her 18th?

You need to find out all this now, because it does diverge your daughters paths somewhat. And he is well within his rights to want to do any one of those things for his own offspring but not feel responsible to do the same for DD1 because she isn’t his and he has not formally adopted her, nor has he any intention of doing so.

AllThePotatoesAreSinging · 05/03/2024 15:56

ohthejoys21 · 05/03/2024 15:54

Yes similar age gap and being full siblings we lived together in the same house 100% of the time. In fairness though he did sit for private schools but was too lazy to do the optional bit at the end of the exam. The fact is though he went to a good faith school (not private) whereas mine was private.

I appreciate he was given the chance whereas op's dd may not be, but my point was it was never an issue for my brother, myself or any of us because we were not a step family.

Thanks for answering, but like you say at least he was given the opportunity. The problem here is that eldest dd isn’t being offered the same opportunities as her younger sister.

ohthejoys21 · 05/03/2024 15:54

Yes similar age gap and being full siblings we lived together in the same house 100% of the time. In fairness though he did sit for private schools but was too lazy to do the optional bit at the end of the exam. The fact is though he went to a good faith school (not private) whereas mine was private.

I appreciate he was given the chance whereas op's dd may not be, but my point was it was never an issue for my brother, myself or any of us because we were not a step family.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 15:52

BMW6 · 05/03/2024 15:21

This is often an issue with blended families isn't it.

Say, for example, OP's DH did pay private school fees for eldest girl.
What would happen if OP then divorced him? Would he be expected to carry on funding tuition for a child who is not actually his?
If Yes, and the OP then married someone else, would DH3 be expected to pick up the tab so dd can continue her private schooling?

A lot of what ifs here - who knows? I imagine it would all form part of the divorce settlement negotiations.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 15:49

ohthejoys21 · 05/03/2024 15:38

It's funny how issues are so magnified in a step family. I went to private school, my brother to a good state school and it was a total non issue for all involved.

Did this situation come about because your parents decided only you were worthy of a private education or for some other reason? Was your brother excluded from the family in other ways, for example did you ever get invited to a wedding with your parents that your brother wasn't invited to?

AllThePotatoesAreSinging · 05/03/2024 15:49

ohthejoys21 · 05/03/2024 15:38

It's funny how issues are so magnified in a step family. I went to private school, my brother to a good state school and it was a total non issue for all involved.

And was there a similar age gap and did you both live in the same house 100% of the time for your entire childhood (or the birth of whichever of you is youngest? Which one of you is youngest?)

ohthejoys21 · 05/03/2024 15:38

It's funny how issues are so magnified in a step family. I went to private school, my brother to a good state school and it was a total non issue for all involved.

BMW6 · 05/03/2024 15:21

This is often an issue with blended families isn't it.

Say, for example, OP's DH did pay private school fees for eldest girl.
What would happen if OP then divorced him? Would he be expected to carry on funding tuition for a child who is not actually his?
If Yes, and the OP then married someone else, would DH3 be expected to pick up the tab so dd can continue her private schooling?

LadyBird1973 · 05/03/2024 15:08

@GasPanic I absolutely know that if I married a man who had a small child, with no biological mother on the scene, and I promised my dh that I would raise that child as if they were my own, I would not pay for private education only for the child that was biologically mine!

If I couldn't easily afford private education for both, neither would get it. I wouldn't want to be the kind of person who could raise siblings and not treat them as equally important.
Now it's possible (probable) that I might love my biological child more but if I was the only mother in both their lives, neither child would know that from my treatment of them.
I couldn't stay married to a man who was okay with differentiating between children when both of them see him as their dad.

BruFord · 05/03/2024 15:03

Now that the OP has clarified that adoption was never considered nor discussed, I think it’s clear that the eldest child was never going to be part of her DH’s family. Neither the OP nor her DH has ever taken steps to achieve this.

The wedding situation is horrible, but his family are following their lead, tbh.

HollyKnight · 05/03/2024 14:52

Maybe he should pay 50% of the school fees for both children and OP pay the other 50%. That would be fair and equal right?

shenandoahvalley · 05/03/2024 14:22

The issue here is that for some people, blood is thicker than water. In her naivety, OP thought that in her DH and in-laws being polite, civil, kind, generous even, that wasn't the case with this family. Her eldest DD will soon feel the brunt of how wrong her mum was.

It's also very easy to see on these two threads who has to write the cheques each term/year for private education and who doesn't; and who has to consider the consequences of having money for their children, their relationships with each other, their grandchildren and their relationships with each other (that's once you've accounted for yourself in terms of later life care). Once you've got money, you can't pretend you don't. They're great problems to have - but they are problems. It's very easy to make glib statements when you don't know first hand how even 20 grand can ruin a sibling relationship if not dealt with properly.

FWIW my own personal opinions on this are actually much more aligned with OP. I think it would be heinous to have two girls living in the same house, with one being so much more privileged than the other. They're half-sisters. But, the DH isn't wrong. The in-laws aren't wrong. Sadly, I think the OP was wrong to put her eldest into this situation. MN is LITTERED with women who refuse to accept new men into their lives because of the way they might, or would feel obliged to treat their existing children. But, here they all are now. The only guaranteed outcome in this scenario is that one daughter or the other is going to be badly impacted by OP's choices, whether or not she and DH split, whether both or one or neither girl gets a better education. It's a very sad situation. I really don't know what I'd do in OP's shoes.

Longma · 05/03/2024 13:14

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

Evilspiritgin · 05/03/2024 13:13

Did you ever say to your dh , when he mentioned private school for d2 , that you would like for d1 to have the same opportunity

Drapion · 05/03/2024 13:12

I absolutely feel for your situation as I have a similarish set of circumstances. My eldest daughter is not my husband's. He claimed from the very beginning that he would treat her like his own. Unlike your situation extended family have been wonderful in that respect. Always treated equally to the other children. Inheritance from grandparents will be impacted but it will go directly to husband rather than kids. Inheritance from us is split equally 4 ways (2 stepchildren, my daughter and our child).

However what I have noticed is that he treats her very differently to my son. He is critical of her, shows her a lot less affection, parents her in a way I disagree with. Last night I read him the riot act. Gave him a step by step list of changes and what him to action them from today. He knows that if he doesn't that's it.

Even the ultimatum is upsetting, knowing that I forced him to step up rather than him doing it himself out of love.

Blended families are so difficult to get right. Sorry I have no ideas to improve your situation. But for me I'd be direct, I'd spell out frankly the issues and the impact if not dealt with, and finally solutions. His willingness to listen and change will tell you what your next steps should be.

ProudMNslapper · 05/03/2024 12:46

I have a child, who is adopted.

My parents always referred to their grandchild and their adopted grandchild.

But it’s not what you think.

My son is the grandchild. The adopted grandchild is the daughter of my cousin who lost one parent and was no contact with another (for good reason).

In their will they left 5% each to my son and cousin’s daughter. The remaining 90% was split between my sister (no kids) and me. No arguments/negative comments from my sister.

Reading this I am counting my blessings that I have my family and not the OP’s husband’s.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 12:24

GasPanic · 05/03/2024 12:19

No one is saying that he has "absolutely no obligations" though.

You're trying to polarise the debate.

People are simply saying that it is not unreasonable for his obligations to have limits.

Oh, I'm pretty sure PPs have said he has no obligations, but OK I may be misquoting.

Tryingmybestadhd · 05/03/2024 12:23

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 11:45

Because not treating a child that isn’t their granddaughter like a granddaughter isn’t ’toxic’. It isn’t their fault that she has no relationship with her paternal family, and it’s not on them to step into those roles.

Op knew how they considered her before she married her husband, and she knew her husband had no problem with it. These ‘nasty people’ are the youngest daughter’s family, that love and are loved by her. She shouldn’t have to miss out on her paternal family because her older sister doesn’t have one.

You have a different definition to me . Anyone that treats a child the way they treat the OP
oldest in relation to the wedding is toxic imo . In fact they are vile

GasPanic · 05/03/2024 12:19

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 12:11

I'm sure you're right about that. I know I absolutely wouldn't change my values though. It's very black and white for me - as I'm sure you can tell. Just as it's black and white for you and others that this man has absolutely no obligations towards the child he took in at a very young age because he isn't her biological father.

No one is saying that he has "absolutely no obligations" though.

You're trying to polarise the debate.

People are simply saying that it is not unreasonable for his obligations to have limits.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 12:11

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 12:02

Maybe you genuinely would, and that would be your call. If you chose not to that would also be your call.

It’s very easy to confidently state what you ‘definitely would’ do with money that you don’t have, in a situation you’re not in. It’s amazing how many people that, having come into money, quickly change their minds in regards their stated values though.

I'm sure you're right about that. I know I absolutely wouldn't change my values though. It's very black and white for me - as I'm sure you can tell. Just as it's black and white for you and others that this man has absolutely no obligations towards the child he took in at a very young age because he isn't her biological father.

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 12:02

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 11:50

I can't speak for everyone, but if I were in the position to spend hundreds of thousands of pounds on a child in my care, and who had been in my care since a toddler, then I would! I do mean genuinely in the position to spend that money and not if I could just about scrape it together but with great sacrifices. I obviously do not know this man's financial position so I'm not saying he should do that!

What I definitely wouldn't do is spend all that money on one child only out of two in my care if I couldn't do it for both.

Edited to add: Yes, even if one of those children was my biological child and the other was not but had been living in my home as my child from a very young age!

Edited

Maybe you genuinely would, and that would be your call. If you chose not to that would also be your call.

It’s very easy to confidently state what you ‘definitely would’ do with money that you don’t have, in a situation you’re not in. It’s amazing how many people that, having come into money, quickly change their minds in regards their stated values though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread