Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just told DH I will Divorce him over a fucking wedding Part two

716 replies

KeenHiker · 04/03/2024 09:52

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

I can’t believe the responses that I had.

Essentially I am going to that wedding so it won’t backfire on me and then as people have suggested reassess when everything has calmed down after Easter.

I am never going to look at MiL in the same light as she clearly thinks my daughter is an impediment to her own granddaughter.

Just told DH I will divorce him over a fucking wedding | Mumsnet

This is my first post. I think my head’s going to explode. BiL has shown no interest whatsoever in my daughters, not my eldest who isn’t my husband’...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

OP posts:
shenandoahvalley · 05/03/2024 22:14

My ire is directed at anyone and everyone who thinks that creating such obvious inequality between two siblings who are growing up together under one roof is an acceptable and justifiable way to behave!

The person who is creating that inequality is the parent of the child who’s suffering it.

Next is the DH who is allowing it to go on under his roof. A good man wouldn’t do such a thing. Sounds like the bio dad is in some sort of rehab facility or something - who knows whether it’s delinquency on his part or merely a tragic outcome. If the former, he’d be the worst of the lot.

There is literally nobody else.

2Hot2Handle · 05/03/2024 22:12

shenandoahvalley · 05/03/2024 21:45

@Surprisedbuthappy

Your ire seems to be directed only at the DH and in laws. Presumably because they are the ones with money that they’re withholding.

They (most likely) had that money before OP came on the scene, before possibly/probably the eldest was even born. It’s theirs to do what they wish with, given they (I’m assuming) earned it. Why are you having a pop at them for not sharing it with people they don’t choose to share it with?

Presumably it’s because there’s an innocent child in all this, and she is the one who is going to suffer. But it was her mum who put her in this situation. Not the in-laws (the SIL to be didn’t even know she existed). The fault lies with the mum. If the DH made promises he’s now not keeping (doesn’t seem he is, but if he did) it’s also his fault and he should share the blame.

This really has nothing to do with the in laws. They’re just going about their business, doing their thing. She is not their grandchild.

Have you read OP’s messages? She has said on more than one occasion that she does not expect them to give their step-granddaughter money. In actual fact, she was trying to take on the entire responsibility of providing equality in this situation, by matching their saved money with her own. But they won’t share the information, so she’s not sure what to put aside.

She also accepted that her DH was planning to leave his estate to his biological daughter.

Are you aware that the original post is all about her eldest being excluded from a family wedding and not about her expecting both daughters to inherit the same amount from their father?

When you say OP put her daughter in this situation, do you think that OP had a conversation with her “DH to be” and he confirmed ahead of them marrying and having a child together that he and his family would be spending lot of money on biological children, but not the daughter she already had? Do you think if she had had that conversation with DH, she would have married him and had more children? Again OP has said that he has treated both daughters the same in day-to-day life, so there is no reason to expect DH to suddenly say they will be treated differently, 5 years after having his biological daughter.

I do agree with you that DH should share the blame,
however. He is responsible for setting the tone with his family in all of this.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 21:59

shenandoahvalley · 05/03/2024 21:45

@Surprisedbuthappy

Your ire seems to be directed only at the DH and in laws. Presumably because they are the ones with money that they’re withholding.

They (most likely) had that money before OP came on the scene, before possibly/probably the eldest was even born. It’s theirs to do what they wish with, given they (I’m assuming) earned it. Why are you having a pop at them for not sharing it with people they don’t choose to share it with?

Presumably it’s because there’s an innocent child in all this, and she is the one who is going to suffer. But it was her mum who put her in this situation. Not the in-laws (the SIL to be didn’t even know she existed). The fault lies with the mum. If the DH made promises he’s now not keeping (doesn’t seem he is, but if he did) it’s also his fault and he should share the blame.

This really has nothing to do with the in laws. They’re just going about their business, doing their thing. She is not their grandchild.

My ire is directed at anyone and everyone who thinks that creating such obvious inequality between two siblings who are growing up together under one roof is an acceptable and justifiable way to behave! For one girl to be treated like an outcast while the other has innumerable privileges bestowed upon her.

I have actually said before that I don't think that OP can expect too much of her in-laws - and of course they have a right to pass on their money to whomever they choose. I think if they were nice people the complaints about never spending time with the younger daughter without her older sister present wouldn't have happened, but you can't force people to be decent and they made no promises to treat the girl as their own, so that situation is what it is.

On the hand, the husband absolutely should be expected to live up to his promises to treat OP's daughter as his own - in my opinion.

shenandoahvalley · 05/03/2024 21:45

@Surprisedbuthappy

Your ire seems to be directed only at the DH and in laws. Presumably because they are the ones with money that they’re withholding.

They (most likely) had that money before OP came on the scene, before possibly/probably the eldest was even born. It’s theirs to do what they wish with, given they (I’m assuming) earned it. Why are you having a pop at them for not sharing it with people they don’t choose to share it with?

Presumably it’s because there’s an innocent child in all this, and she is the one who is going to suffer. But it was her mum who put her in this situation. Not the in-laws (the SIL to be didn’t even know she existed). The fault lies with the mum. If the DH made promises he’s now not keeping (doesn’t seem he is, but if he did) it’s also his fault and he should share the blame.

This really has nothing to do with the in laws. They’re just going about their business, doing their thing. She is not their grandchild.

LocalHobo · 05/03/2024 21:39

But, she is an unrelated child to them. Why pretend otherwise? If OP left they'd never see her again and would have no right too.
And with the ops attitude this is likely to happen
This couple have never considered adoption, the elder DD has never been considered the DD of Ops partner by Op.
This situation of making the grandparents hate figures is bazaar, they are following their DS's lead.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 21:31

Justkeeepswimming · 05/03/2024 21:15

@Pamelapamela2024 …..

Can I interject here - she is not a ‘small child’…… she is 10 and in less than 6 years may have left school and be in work.

Even if they told OP what they are saving for DD2, she is due an inheritance separate to this and it is clearly big enough that OP feels uncomfortable and cannot match it.

Regards them getting access, if OP separates the DH will fight for at least 50% custody with better lawyers and more clout. So they will of course see their grandchild and be involved in her life.

Bloody hell! 😯

Why wait until she's 16? Why not send her up some chimneys or something so she can start earning her keep now?

Justkeeepswimming · 05/03/2024 21:25

Also re. talk of toxicity, anything I give to my DC of substantial value will be ringfenced for them and my biological descendants, and I will support them in future to have prenups and other legal protection to prevent them being fleeced in the event that they marry (and to deter anyone in it for the wrong reasons).

Does that make me toxic for wanting to protect my DC/future grandchildren and to prevent money being lost/squandered?

While I would never be unkind or forget the birthday/Christmas of a step sibling if there are any, I absolutely would not want to support them and have finance diverted from my actual relatives…. I don’t want anyone profiteering off my family.

Justkeeepswimming · 05/03/2024 21:15

Pamelapamela2024 · 05/03/2024 20:04

She’s not unrelated and the OP has not left. Do you always deal and form your actions based on such hypotheticals.

she’s a small child who is part of the family unit who their son is bringing up as his own. they may not like it and they may wish it was different but that’s just how it is. If this isn’t down to pure spite and malice around ‘blood’ why not tell the OP what they are saving for their biological GD so she can match it?

they may not have rights to their biological GD if the OP left.

@Pamelapamela2024 …..

Can I interject here - she is not a ‘small child’…… she is 10 and in less than 6 years may have left school and be in work.

Even if they told OP what they are saving for DD2, she is due an inheritance separate to this and it is clearly big enough that OP feels uncomfortable and cannot match it.

Regards them getting access, if OP separates the DH will fight for at least 50% custody with better lawyers and more clout. So they will of course see their grandchild and be involved in her life.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 05/03/2024 20:14

I also pointed out that whilst you cannot make them do anything, they could lose who they deem to be their ‘only’ grandchild if the OP chose to preserve the relationship and unity of her children.

How exactly? She has no more right as a parent then DH. And he's not going to stop his family seeing their grandchild. It's not DH and his family who aren't going to have a choice.

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 20:13

Pamelapamela2024 · 05/03/2024 20:10

You missed my point that it’s those values that sow the seeds of resentment and damage relationships. Whether I approve of them or not is by the by as you rightly point out.

I also pointed out that whilst you cannot make them do anything, they could lose who they deem to be their ‘only’ grandchild if the OP chose to preserve the relationship and unity of her children. It doesn’t sound like it would be of any loss to the two children to be fair. Having people like this within a family is toxic.

I think you’re indulging in a fantasy in which OP takes her two children off to be raised in a land of equality. She doesn’t in fact get to do that, and nor does she unilaterally get to decide that her youngest doesn’t get to have a relationship with her paternal family.

They’re not at risk of losing anything here (actually they’d gain something - being able to see their grandchild alone), it’s OP that stands to lose her marriage and half the time with youngest daughter, and it’s her eldest that risks losing the only father figure she knows.

Pamelapamela2024 · 05/03/2024 20:11

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 05/03/2024 20:07

I think it makes a difference as well, that this is not a long relationship, and the difference in family support and wealth existed way before OP and her child were on the scene.

It's different if they met, neither had a pot to pee in, built an empire together then chose to share it within the household who had been there from day one, for the good and the bad.

This is OP and paternal family having much less in both support and money, arriving in an existing situation, and then wanting to be part of it. You can't blame her for wanting, it's a very nice set up for her that she's not contributed to or been part of for long. You can blame her for the extreme entitlement she portrays.

It's also very double standards to want to deny her youngest private education whilst actively saving only for her eldest child. It's ok for mummy to leave out one of her biological children as she sees "fair" but how dare DH do the same for a child that isn't his.

Wow.

Pamelapamela2024 · 05/03/2024 20:10

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 20:05

Well, whether you approve of those values or not, they ain’t changing!

She isn’t their grandchild and isn’t being treated as one, and I don’t see how it’s a shame for them that their son married OP given that their son has no problem with their opinions, and OP accepted that when she married him. It’s OP that has to come to terms with the reality that yes, her children do not have the same family members, and due to this they’re not going to have the same opportunities. This isn’t going to change, whether she remains with her husband or not. That her paternal family of her eldest aren’t present in her life isn’t the fault of her in laws, and they’re not in any way obliged to step in to remedy this.

You missed my point that it’s those values that sow the seeds of resentment and damage relationships. Whether I approve of them or not is by the by as you rightly point out.

I also pointed out that whilst you cannot make them do anything, they could lose who they deem to be their ‘only’ grandchild if the OP chose to preserve the relationship and unity of her children. It doesn’t sound like it would be of any loss to the two children to be fair. Having people like this within a family is toxic.

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 20:08

Pamelapamela2024 · 05/03/2024 20:04

She’s not unrelated and the OP has not left. Do you always deal and form your actions based on such hypotheticals.

she’s a small child who is part of the family unit who their son is bringing up as his own. they may not like it and they may wish it was different but that’s just how it is. If this isn’t down to pure spite and malice around ‘blood’ why not tell the OP what they are saving for their biological GD so she can match it?

they may not have rights to their biological GD if the OP left.

It’s Op that has to come to terms with the reality of her situation. Regardless of whether she stays or leaves, her husband is an equal parent to her youngest, and he will still be able to provide for her the things her sister lacks.

In the time he has her, and that may very well be 50% of the time, he can of course facilitate the relationship with her grandparents. OP isn’t in fact necessary for that.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 05/03/2024 20:07

I think it makes a difference as well, that this is not a long relationship, and the difference in family support and wealth existed way before OP and her child were on the scene.

It's different if they met, neither had a pot to pee in, built an empire together then chose to share it within the household who had been there from day one, for the good and the bad.

This is OP and paternal family having much less in both support and money, arriving in an existing situation, and then wanting to be part of it. You can't blame her for wanting, it's a very nice set up for her that she's not contributed to or been part of for long. You can blame her for the extreme entitlement she portrays.

It's also very double standards to want to deny her youngest private education whilst actively saving only for her eldest child. It's ok for mummy to leave out one of her biological children as she sees "fair" but how dare DH do the same for a child that isn't his.

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 20:05

Pamelapamela2024 · 05/03/2024 19:59

Nonsense. “Someone who isn’t their grandchild”. It’s not a random child down the road. It damages the relationship if you bring up your children to believe that one should be favoured in this way and not the other - if you foster those sorts of values, you absolutely do sow the seeds to damage it. But those are poor values to instil.

at the end of the day, if the grandparents have the view that only a biological
child is a grandchild then it’s a shame for them that their son married someone with a very young child and chose to have a family with them. But I wouldn’t be fostering a relationship with them and they should realise that their behaviour will not gain them anything and they stand to lose everything.

Well, whether you approve of those values or not, they ain’t changing!

She isn’t their grandchild and isn’t being treated as one, and I don’t see how it’s a shame for them that their son married OP given that their son has no problem with their opinions, and OP accepted that when she married him. It’s OP that has to come to terms with the reality that yes, her children do not have the same family members, and due to this they’re not going to have the same opportunities. This isn’t going to change, whether she remains with her husband or not. That her paternal family of her eldest aren’t present in her life isn’t the fault of her in laws, and they’re not in any way obliged to step in to remedy this.

Pamelapamela2024 · 05/03/2024 20:04

She’s not unrelated and the OP has not left. Do you always deal and form your actions based on such hypotheticals.

she’s a small child who is part of the family unit who their son is bringing up as his own. they may not like it and they may wish it was different but that’s just how it is. If this isn’t down to pure spite and malice around ‘blood’ why not tell the OP what they are saving for their biological GD so she can match it?

they may not have rights to their biological GD if the OP left.

Tryingmybestadhd · 05/03/2024 20:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 05/03/2024 20:00

the eldest is not an “unrelated child”. She is related. She’s part of the family and has no right to be excluded.

But, she is an unrelated child to them. Why pretend otherwise? If OP left they'd never see her again and would have no right too.

Pamelapamela2024 · 05/03/2024 19:59

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 19:46

Yes, they favour their grandchild over someone that isn’t their grandchild. Hardly unusual. She has ‘no right to be excluded’? Neither she nor OP have the right to demand she be considered a grandchild - she isn’t.

It is wrong to deny the ‘favoured’ one, yes, and doing so can absolutely damage relationships in the long term. That is inconvenient to acknowledge this whilst simultaneously ranting about ‘damaged family relationships’ doesn’t mean it doesn’t happen.

Nonsense. “Someone who isn’t their grandchild”. It’s not a random child down the road. It damages the relationship if you bring up your children to believe that one should be favoured in this way and not the other - if you foster those sorts of values, you absolutely do sow the seeds to damage it. But those are poor values to instil.

at the end of the day, if the grandparents have the view that only a biological
child is a grandchild then it’s a shame for them that their son married someone with a very young child and chose to have a family with them. But I wouldn’t be fostering a relationship with them and they should realise that their behaviour will not gain them anything and they stand to lose everything.

CalMeKate · 05/03/2024 19:48

Also just to remind everyone the girls are sisters. Regardless of whether Dad is biologically related or not, the girls are.

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 19:46

Pamelapamela2024 · 05/03/2024 19:39

Dont be so ridiculous. What a disingenuous post.

the eldest is not an “unrelated child”. She is related. She’s part of the family and has no right to be excluded.

There are some awful people on this thread.

and what mad things to say like denying the youngest a fantastic opportunity is unforgivable or will mess up the relationship. It’s not fantastic when it’s clearly favouritism.

if someone swooped in and offered one of your children £100k and not the other, would you accept it because it would be wrong to deny the favoured child.

this thread is just utter madness.

Yes, they favour their grandchild over someone that isn’t their grandchild. Hardly unusual. She has ‘no right to be excluded’? Neither she nor OP have the right to demand she be considered a grandchild - she isn’t.

It is wrong to deny the ‘favoured’ one, yes, and doing so can absolutely damage relationships in the long term. That is inconvenient to acknowledge this whilst simultaneously ranting about ‘damaged family relationships’ doesn’t mean it doesn’t happen.

CalMeKate · 05/03/2024 19:46

I wasn’t going to comment on the private schooling situation but I have a suggestion that hasn’t been mentioned. Could there be some negotiation? Rather than being so black and white, is there some room to discuss with your DH a third option?

When your youngest goes to secondary school it will be the same year your eldest goes to in to Sixth form. I believe I have got this right eldest in to year 12 and youngest in to year 7 during the same year?

Could your eldest go to private school just for those finally 2 years? As a Sixth Form college thing? Then they are both going to private school at the same time but not for the same duration?

My Sister and one of my best friends both went to private school for Sixth Form only and both enjoyed the transition. Myself and my 2 brothers didn’t get this option but none of us resent or care about it at the time or now that we are grown ups. I would have HATED it, and she loved it.

I do resent the fact he pays her rent now and has done for 3 years but that isn’t what we are talking about here.

Pamelapamela2024 · 05/03/2024 19:39

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 05/03/2024 19:27

The "nasty" people who love, support and are very present for their grandchild you mean? Are they nasty for not volunteering to do the job a while other family categorically should be?

Trying to force them to do something they are absolutely not obligated to, whilst the actual responsible people who are not good enough for OP, piss about absent in the background, is not nasty. They do plenty for this child already. OP isn't satisfied. She's damn lucky because they actually have the total right to say "sorry, we don't want a relationship with an unrelated child" yet they don't. To allow the actual paternal relationship to be this shockingly bad, (and OP is partly responsible for this) then complain that an unrelated family aren't volunteering enough to your standards to pick up the slack, is frankly beggars belief.

Dont be so ridiculous. What a disingenuous post.

the eldest is not an “unrelated child”. She is related. She’s part of the family and has no right to be excluded.

There are some awful people on this thread.

and what mad things to say like denying the youngest a fantastic opportunity is unforgivable or will mess up the relationship. It’s not fantastic when it’s clearly favouritism.

if someone swooped in and offered one of your children £100k and not the other, would you accept it because it would be wrong to deny the favoured child.

this thread is just utter madness.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 05/03/2024 19:27

Tryingmybestadhd · 05/03/2024 11:13

Why do you think toxic relationships are needed ? Why does the youngest earn from having someone who clearly doesn’t like their sibling ? Why are these nasty people needed in her life ?

The "nasty" people who love, support and are very present for their grandchild you mean? Are they nasty for not volunteering to do the job a while other family categorically should be?

Trying to force them to do something they are absolutely not obligated to, whilst the actual responsible people who are not good enough for OP, piss about absent in the background, is not nasty. They do plenty for this child already. OP isn't satisfied. She's damn lucky because they actually have the total right to say "sorry, we don't want a relationship with an unrelated child" yet they don't. To allow the actual paternal relationship to be this shockingly bad, (and OP is partly responsible for this) then complain that an unrelated family aren't volunteering enough to your standards to pick up the slack, is frankly beggars belief.

LadyBird1973 · 05/03/2024 18:45

I also think it would be a mistake for the OP to pay for private school for the oldest by herself, if that means such a significant reduction in her own standard of living that it creates even more of a two tier family. And if her h would happily let the situation play out, that's not love!

Swipe left for the next trending thread