Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want this working pattern - DH disagreement

188 replies

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 14:19

Currently stuck in a disagreement with DH so would like to know what other people would do.

I am due to start a new role at work in a months time. It’s a promotion with a jump in salary, as I’m coming back off maternity leave I’ve been offered a few different options in terms of working pattern and the deadline for coming back to them with a final decision is this Tuesday!

Option A (DHs preference) -
WFH 4 days out of 5
Hours would be 9-3

Option B (My preference)
WFH 3 days out of 4
Mondays not working
Tuesdays - Friday working 9-4:30

Thankfully work have agreed to keep my salary the same on either option (full new amount) as the drop in hours isn’t that significant.

DH prefers option A as it means in a few months time when DD can start pre school we’d save a lot in nursery fees, as those hours match up more nicely with the school hours they stick to. I prefer the idea of having a full day off with DD though.

YABU - option A
YANBU - option B

OP posts:
DisforDarkChocolate · 03/03/2024 22:26

B otherwise you are setting yourself up to be the default parent for all the pick ups, sick days etc. No wonder DH likes A.

Choux · 03/03/2024 22:22

Hercisback · 03/03/2024 21:44

If its so flexible and no one seems particularly bothered when the work gets done, why do they need your maternity cover to continue?

I suspect if we heard from OPs manager it would turn out OP hasn't been performing as well as she thinks she has been.

By missing several hours when she should be working most weeks she may well be doing ok and she may have a lot of potential but she won't have been delivering as much as she could.

As you move up the ladder - she said the new role is a promotion despite the maternity cover still being in situ - the workload increases and slacking off regularly won't get the job done. Someone will cotton on that she is missing for the last hour of every wfh day and that that is impacting on her contribution to the company.

spainspain · 03/03/2024 22:20

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 17:23

You're over 40 aren’t you Grin

Wow, ageist much?!

WorkCleanRepeat · 03/03/2024 22:03

I'd go with B (I do A and hate it)

You get to do every school pick, drop off and meal time with no day off. I'd rather pay the childcare.

Bournetilly · 03/03/2024 21:52

I’d go for option B at the moment, not sure if you’ve said how old your DD is (sorry) but assuming shes around 18months.

I wouldn’t want to put my DC in preschool until they were closer to 3 as they are less relaxed than a nursery setting (where I am anyway). Also if she’s in preschool would you need to find childcare for all school holidays? Whereas nursery is just year round childcare.

It would also be lovely to have an extra day off with your DD and means you can attend activities/ classes if you wanted to.

NewName24 · 03/03/2024 21:51

Who said I don’t pull my weight?

You did. You said you are planning to not work the hours you are employed to work.

Then you've added to it here
The amount of times at work during the summer I’d finish a few hours early every Friday to get some tanning done in the garden 😅

I'm 100% on board with flexibility if the work you do allows it. But that means doing the hours later in the evening or on a NWD if you've ducked out from your normal hours, which is completely different from accepting a contract for X hours, but actually doing X-5 or whatever it is.

Hercisback · 03/03/2024 21:44

If its so flexible and no one seems particularly bothered when the work gets done, why do they need your maternity cover to continue?

StealthMama · 03/03/2024 21:44

So is it a job share if they need someone to fill the hours you're not contracted for?

Or is the work divided between you both somehow?

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 21:29

CrazyHedgehogLover · 03/03/2024 21:27

I’d personally go with Option B.. for the sake of working an hour and a half later on them days (as opposed to the option A) but also you get an extra day with option B to spend with little one.. sounds absolutely fine personally I would jump at that choice!

however, if cost is the issue here.. then Option A would be more sensible.. I would go for Option B though until little one was starting school then I’d request the option A if possible? Take time to spend with your little one while you can!

I’d not say cost is an issue, but it’s a factor (not helped by our mortgage going up so much at the same time!) it’s doable, but there is nearly £800 benefit every month once DD can start pre school if I did option a

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 21:28

StampOnTheGround · 03/03/2024 21:21

My manager wouldn't care less if I finished early some days, nipped out sometimes etc. as long as all my work gets done (which it does!).

A day off a week with your DD will be lovely, maybe worry about school hours later down the line and enjoy the day off for now (is what I would do) 😊

Precisely, it’s sad so many on here can’t grasp that not all workplaces are the same.

The amount of times at work during the summer I’d finish a few hours early every Friday to get some tanning done in the garden 😅

Work gets done, targets met - no issue

OP posts:
CrazyHedgehogLover · 03/03/2024 21:27

I’d personally go with Option B.. for the sake of working an hour and a half later on them days (as opposed to the option A) but also you get an extra day with option B to spend with little one.. sounds absolutely fine personally I would jump at that choice!

however, if cost is the issue here.. then Option A would be more sensible.. I would go for Option B though until little one was starting school then I’d request the option A if possible? Take time to spend with your little one while you can!

StampOnTheGround · 03/03/2024 21:21

My manager wouldn't care less if I finished early some days, nipped out sometimes etc. as long as all my work gets done (which it does!).

A day off a week with your DD will be lovely, maybe worry about school hours later down the line and enjoy the day off for now (is what I would do) 😊

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 21:12

StealthMama · 03/03/2024 21:08

@Dutchairfryer then you should just ask for your contract to state xx hours per working week where the working week is (presumably) Monday to Friday.

Then it doesn't matter when you work provided you are delivering your side of the contract.

Due to them needing to continue my maternity cover if I choose one option over the other this won’t fly

Again, my workplace is flexible so I don’t need to worry about the specifics too much, but a day off vs not is a change to consider

OP posts:
Sunglassesweather · 03/03/2024 21:12

If you can do the nursery run at 3pm with either option, what's the advantage of option A? Might as well pick option B and get a day off too? Or have I misunderstood?

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 21:11

StealthMama · 03/03/2024 21:10

@Dutchairfryer no they're not. UK Employment Law doesn't allow for it.

Doesn’t allow for what?

OP posts:
StealthMama · 03/03/2024 21:10

@Dutchairfryer no they're not. UK Employment Law doesn't allow for it.

StealthMama · 03/03/2024 21:08

@Dutchairfryer then you should just ask for your contract to state xx hours per working week where the working week is (presumably) Monday to Friday.

Then it doesn't matter when you work provided you are delivering your side of the contract.

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 21:06

StealthMama · 03/03/2024 21:05

Contracted hours are the minimum time requested in exchange for xx salary. It's a simple contractual agreement.

If someone is regularly doing less than their contracted hours in exchange for the same salary then that can be deemed as not pulling their weight.

Good thing I don’t work somewhere that sees it like that.

Many workplaces and roles are what you deliver over how many hours worked

OP posts:
StealthMama · 03/03/2024 21:05

Contracted hours are the minimum time requested in exchange for xx salary. It's a simple contractual agreement.

If someone is regularly doing less than their contracted hours in exchange for the same salary then that can be deemed as not pulling their weight.

Twiglets1 · 03/03/2024 21:03

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 14:41

I could pick up DD on option 2 and do an hour (tbh I most likely wouldn’t bother) when DH was home

And I’d like to keep DD off nursery on the Mondays to get some time together. She is currently in nursery 3 days a week so would just be adding an extra day for that option.

I think if you already know that you won't get any work done after picking up your daughter, you should opt for choice A so you can finish work at 3pm.

Once I had established my hours were 9-3 I would probably try to drop a day in the future when childcare costs have reduced. Then you get the best of both worlds - a short working day and a day off once a week to spend how you want.

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 21:02

StealthMama · 03/03/2024 20:55

Why do your hours have to be over set days at all? Neither of proposed contracts aren't flexible at all, xx hours over x specific days.

Where's the flexibility?

Don't forget your 'contracted hours' are important to your holiday allowance, pension contributions and other benefits that will
Calculated based on that.

It’s a formality, most people have contracted hours, but reality is different.

My old hours were fixed from a contractual pov but I could work when it suited me.

With DD though I can see a benefit in ensuring some change is officially laid out

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 21:00

NewName24 · 03/03/2024 20:49

Wow, OP, you are really showing yourself up now.

I completely agree with @Kimmeridge
Yes, I am over 40, and I'm also a Manager, and would take a very dim view of one of my Team not pulling their weight.
Fortunately, they all do - yes even those under 40, which seems to be surprising to you.
It is people like you doing that, that make so many employers dislike people working from home, which then makes it difficult for all the people who would benefit from it.

Oh, and I have adult dc, nieces, nephews, friends of my dc and dc of my friends who are all considerably under 40 but would all totally agree with me, Kimmeridge, others on this thread, and all decent, honest people. So your ageist remarks are utter nonsense.

Who said I don’t pull my weight?

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 20:59

ShaunaTheSheep · 03/03/2024 20:48

As your DH has a fixed pattern albeit on varying days, can you request flexibility to work around his shift patterns? Do longer days when his shifts allow? Presumably his schedule is set out well ahead so you would be able to plan your diary accordingly.

I could but not sure how beneficial that would be, since it wouldn’t make a difference regarding childcare etc.

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 20:59

Neurodiversitydoctor · 03/03/2024 20:46

He can still request fixed shifts- and arguably ought to, it would be good for him to have a day of sole childcare and very good for your nursery bill.

I think I’ll take DHs word on his workplace requirements over someone on MN.

He is one of 3 consultant paramedics within our region and his days depend on availability of the other 2 and the snr response officers. He cannot fix his days.

OP posts:
StealthMama · 03/03/2024 20:55

Why do your hours have to be over set days at all? Neither of proposed contracts aren't flexible at all, xx hours over x specific days.

Where's the flexibility?

Don't forget your 'contracted hours' are important to your holiday allowance, pension contributions and other benefits that will
Calculated based on that.