Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Daughter still hurt over childhood

259 replies

Gran648 · 21/02/2024 09:25

My daughter and I have a good relationship and we live close by so I see her and my 18 month old grandson most days.

A few years ago, she started going to therapy and soon after brought up how much her childhood had affected her, which I took very personally. I feel bad now but rather than listening I got very defensive and lashed out back at her.

I had my DD1 (now 35) when I was 23, her dad didn’t want to know when she was born. We lived with my mum/step dad who supported us until she was around 5/6 so they were very close and like parents to her. Sadly, my mum became ill with cancer and passed away when my daughter was 7. This had a huge impact on both me and her. A lot of grief. Around this time I had started a new business and my partner of a year or so moved in with us in a new place (now married) and a few years later we had another DD. My partner was a lifeline for me when my mum died and we all became close to his family. Around this time my DD also started seeing her dad again and she would go there every weekend. Her relationship with him hasn’t been great for various reasons. In the early years, DD1 also didn’t have a great relationship with my partner.

My DD is now saying how isolated and segregated she felt and as though she had lost her family unit when my mum passed away, and I had a new one with my partner and DD2 and also a business that I was running. She feels as though she wasn’t given enough support and it was hard for her to blend into a new family. This hurts me very deeply and something I had never intended. It seems she has carried this with her for years and now I feel as though I am the focal point for her anger. We’ve had several arguments about it.

I just wondered if anyone else has any experience of anything like this and aibu for getting defensive about it?

OP posts:
TomeTome · 21/02/2024 12:03

Atethehalloweenchocs · 21/02/2024 11:51

Life is not one thing or another, it can be true that we do our best and that still did affected someone negatively. This thread is full of examples of people whose parents have denied or invalidated their feelings by taking your kind of view. OP does not have to go down that route if she is brave and takes some responsibility.

you say life is not one thing or another while insisting the daughters world view must be centred. What I was saying was I don’t think that a good idea.

LSTMS30555 · 21/02/2024 12:01

Comedycook · 21/02/2024 10:34

I might get flamed but I've noticed a new trend whereby lots of young adults are going into therapy and looking at their perfectly ordinary (probably not perfect but not horrendous) childhoods and playing the victim and blaming all their problems on it.

It doesn't sound like a totally perfect childhood no, but it doesn't sound particularly traumatic or awful.

I think she's being unfair

100% agree with this.
It's the latest trend

BroughttoyoubyBerocca · 21/02/2024 11:59

Acknowledge her hurt, explain that you were trying your best at the time. It’s likely she wasn’t at the heart of all decisions you made but here we are. It sounds like you turned things around well but she still feels the hurt.

Be kind, be humble, you made the decision to be with your partner, start your business, have another child, she didn’t, acknowledge that.

Show her love, spend time 121 with her.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 21/02/2024 11:59

My sibling often refers to how they were overlooked and not given enough attention, and refers to our terrible childhood... it's funny because I remember it as the opposite, that they were so loud they were the centre of everything and I melted into the background to facilitate them.

But I'd never get anywhere if I tried to argue it, as they've had so much therapy they insist the world is out to get them. So I just go along with it and grit my teeth for an easier life.

I think this is very common. But I would just say I don't think your siblings is the way they are because "they've had so much therapy" or (necessarily) because of anything in their childhood. I think they sought therapy because they were unhappy due to some unmet need, which may also have been why they needed to dominate the family when young, and it still wasn't enough. Some people just are not happy and not capable of self reflection or balance in recognising the needs of others in their lives. I don't know if therapists are poor at finding ways to manage this or if (as I suspect) it doesn't really matter what a therapist says if their patient is only open to one perception of events.

JustHereWithMyPopcorn · 21/02/2024 11:59

I think any mother would be defensive if told by their child that they didn't have a good childhood. It's a natural reaction. We do our best by our children but we are not perfect, not one of us.

I had a pretty bad childhood in many ways but, as I've got older and had my own children, I have reflected on it and realised that my mum had a huge amount to deal with and little to no support from my dad or other family, and actually I can acknowledge my own struggles while still understanding she did what she could in the circumstances she was in.

We need to let these things go (unless we are talking about actual abuse) what do we expect our parents to do about it at this stage in our lives?

Alwayslookonthebrightside1 · 21/02/2024 11:59

OP I haven’t had chance to read all the comments here but there was a thread this week from a step parent that found it difficult having their step children home and there were lots of comments from the perspective of the child / those that were raised in a blended family which might be interesting for you to read

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/stepparenting/5011329-this-is-just-fairly-standard-in-blended-families-isnt-it

This is just fairly standard in "blended families" isn't it? | Mumsnet

Step parents, even when not ^unhappy^, still not really enjoying the time DSC are at their home and feeling a bit on edge / find it easier to relax an...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/stepparenting/5011329-this-is-just-fairly-standard-in-blended-families-isnt-it

TomeTome · 21/02/2024 11:57

shepherdsangeldelight · 21/02/2024 11:43

Notice you didn't quote the whole post to give some context - which was that random people on the internet do not know more about the DD's childhood than DD herself does.

I think it's pretty outrageous to think that a random opinion based on a one sided summarised version of events should have more weight.

I quoted the part I was responding to. I’m not sure what you mean by (quoting a section to clarify what I am addressing) I think it's pretty outrageous to think that a random opinion based on a one sided summarised version of events should have more weight. more weight than what?

pontipinemum · 21/02/2024 11:56

YABU to have been defensive. She tried to talk to you about how she feels. Some parts of your DDs life are very similar to mine. I also went for counselling in my late 20s/ 30s I tried to speak to my mum about how my upbringing had affected me and I was either wrong/ lying or exaggerating. It forced a big wedge between us.

We eventually talked through things and honestly some subjects are just a no go zone with us and she has absolutely rewritten history over a lot of it. But we both want a relationship so we live in the present.

I have had to accept that not everything was her fault and that she did do what she thought was right at the time. Altho I'm still not sure I actually believe that she didn't just do what was easiest for her a decent bit of the time too, but I can't say those things.

She has had to accept that she did f*ck up over some stuff. I'm not sure if she actually believes that either because she likes to be the victim who had no say over how her life went. But also doesn't say that.

I'm projecting my experience IDK what you're like. Just trying from your DDs POV. Life is messy

She had me at 22, dad not around, GPs stepped in, became very career orientated, choose an absolutely woeful step father.

DysmalRadius · 21/02/2024 11:56

When you argue, what's your position? She says she felt isolated and as though she didn't fit in, and you say...?

SpeedyDrama · 21/02/2024 11:53

I had an awful childhood with a very selfish mother. So I do understand where your daughter is coming from, she wants her bad experiences seen, recognised and not dismissed. Many grown children from my generation feel similar, there are many of us who feel we had to grow up too quickly, put aside our feelings as children to support the adults around us. I suspect your daughter feels the same way, she simply had to accept huge changes in her life which she had no choice or control over and now she’s trying to find some closure you’ve become defensive. By doing so, it instantly regresses the situation back to her feeling like that child who felt displaced rather than an adult who’s trying to move on.

I do understand from the other side as well. My mother used to say ‘I am a person in my own right!’ during my childhood, often to excuse inappropriate or selfish behaviour. But there is a truth to it, I am a single parent now and it does feel like being a parent is wholly who I am at times. It can be so difficult to separate giving yourself completely to the children you have and remembering you’re allowed to be an adult with their own wants and needs at times. The compromises are huge and can be unfair. You feel guilty all of the time and sometimes it can be easy to bury that in order to put your wants first. You had a right to move forward with your adult life but it did impact your daughter and it’s only right to recognise that. Whilst you were rebuilding your family/adult life and planning the future after a very difficult few years, you may have not recognised that young children live in the moment and such huge changes were just too much for her. She’s entitled to use the voice she didn’t have back then, as hard as it may be to hear now.

shepherdsangeldelight · 21/02/2024 11:51

TheYearOfSmallThings · 21/02/2024 11:41

Honestly I think your daughter's therapist should be careful here. Your daughter feels how she feels, and some of that comes from her childhood (which, like most people's, was imperfect) and some of it comes from herself and where she is in life and how she feels about that. I have seen several friends pick apart loving family relationships because their parents could never be sorry enough for things that were never within their control. In no case has this helped the friend - it has left them with a sense of self righteousness and isolation.

That's not what's happening here though. OP has not told her DD that she is sorry for what happened to her or tried to understand her point of view. She has argued that she is wrong.

of course it's possible to be sorry for things not within your control. I can be sorry that my friend is ill and misses out on doing a thing she wanted to. She is allowed to be sad and upset about it. I wouldn't tell her that there is nothing anyone can do about it so she's not allowed to have those feelings.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 21/02/2024 11:51

TomeTome · 21/02/2024 11:40

I honestly don’t think her daughter’s word is the only thing that matters. I think that’s an outrageous way to think about life.

Life is not one thing or another, it can be true that we do our best and that still did affected someone negatively. This thread is full of examples of people whose parents have denied or invalidated their feelings by taking your kind of view. OP does not have to go down that route if she is brave and takes some responsibility.

Chypre · 21/02/2024 11:50

As a daughter myself... When my parents stopped arguing that whatever hurt me never happened, that I don't remember things correctly, that it was all for my own benefit and finally admitted that indeed it was hard, indeed it was unfair, and they are SORRY (no ifs', no buts', not trying to compete in grief that it was hard on them too), when I finally got an apology and validation, it all changed. Like a flick of a light switch, turning off all the negatives, case closed, boom .

WhoIsnt · 21/02/2024 11:48

It's tricky.

Her feelings are real. But her feelings are not facts. If you want to move forwards, you have to acknowledge that she feels a certain way and that you're sorry that she's hurt.

My sibling often refers to how they were overlooked and not given enough attention, and refers to our terrible childhood... it's funny because I remember it as the opposite, that they were so loud they were the centre of everything and I melted into the background to facilitate them.

But I'd never get anywhere if I tried to argue it, as they've had so much therapy they insist the world is out to get them. So I just go along with it and grit my teeth for an easier life.

time4anothername · 21/02/2024 11:48

Every weekend to her Dad suddenly, a Dad who had only just come into her life? Not even EOW? How could she not feel pushed out? How could she blend in with your new family with so little leisure time together? It's not suprising to feel defensive on your part at first but now's the time perhaps to put yourself into the shoes of that little 7 year old and acknowledge how lonely and hard her life felt at that time and how that experience shaped her relationships.

Tiggermom · 21/02/2024 11:46

She didn’t see her DF, her DGM died, you had a new business to presumably busy, you had a new DP, then a new DSis, then she spends whole weekends with DF, reducing her time with you. Shes bound to be affected by all that - but it’s not really your fault - though she could have possibly had more attention from you - but I can see why she feels upset but much of it eg DGM death,DF not stepping up initially is nothing to do with hou

shepherdsangeldelight · 21/02/2024 11:43

TomeTome · 21/02/2024 11:40

I honestly don’t think her daughter’s word is the only thing that matters. I think that’s an outrageous way to think about life.

Notice you didn't quote the whole post to give some context - which was that random people on the internet do not know more about the DD's childhood than DD herself does.

I think it's pretty outrageous to think that a random opinion based on a one sided summarised version of events should have more weight.

ZoeCM · 21/02/2024 11:42

Comedycook · 21/02/2024 11:39

It's certainly not perfect but it's hardly beyond the realms of normal. A grandparent dying is sad but not an unusual occurrence.

Yes, but she's not angry at the OP for her grandmother dying, she's angry that the OP moved in a man she didn't like while she was grieving.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 21/02/2024 11:41

Honestly I think your daughter's therapist should be careful here. Your daughter feels how she feels, and some of that comes from her childhood (which, like most people's, was imperfect) and some of it comes from herself and where she is in life and how she feels about that. I have seen several friends pick apart loving family relationships because their parents could never be sorry enough for things that were never within their control. In no case has this helped the friend - it has left them with a sense of self righteousness and isolation.

Spinet · 21/02/2024 11:40

I think it is perfectly normal to feel defensive when someone criticises you. That doesn't mean she is wrong. It doesn't mean her recollection is 100% accurate either.

OP, your DD has given you a real gift here by opening the conversation with you. You can reopen it by apologising for your reactive (entirely understandable) defensive response and offer to talk through things with her. This is going to be a series of conversations rather than one big one, isn't it. You can accept that your daughter's early life was difficult - your life was difficult then too, wasn't it? You probably made mistakes, too, just like the rest of us do. If you can do this in an open way - admitting that you probably will get defensive and upset, who wouldn't? - I think your relationship will become even better than it is now.

TomeTome · 21/02/2024 11:40

I honestly don’t think her daughter’s word is the only thing that matters. I think that’s an outrageous way to think about life.

Comedycook · 21/02/2024 11:39

ZoeCM · 21/02/2024 11:33

I think that's very harsh. The OP's daughter lost her granny, had an unrelated man with whom she "didn't have a great relationship" move on into her home when she was very young, and felt as though she didn't belong either with her dad or her new "blended family". It must have been horrible at that age.

Adults justify blending families with "I deserve to be happy, children are resilient, they'll be fine" - and then when those children grow up and tell them that they weren't resilient and weren't fine, they don't want to hear it.

It's certainly not perfect but it's hardly beyond the realms of normal. A grandparent dying is sad but not an unusual occurrence.

MrsKeats · 21/02/2024 11:36

You can't argue about someone's valid feelings.
That's a huge mistake.

Daylightsavingscrime · 21/02/2024 11:35

Gran648 · 21/02/2024 09:25

My daughter and I have a good relationship and we live close by so I see her and my 18 month old grandson most days.

A few years ago, she started going to therapy and soon after brought up how much her childhood had affected her, which I took very personally. I feel bad now but rather than listening I got very defensive and lashed out back at her.

I had my DD1 (now 35) when I was 23, her dad didn’t want to know when she was born. We lived with my mum/step dad who supported us until she was around 5/6 so they were very close and like parents to her. Sadly, my mum became ill with cancer and passed away when my daughter was 7. This had a huge impact on both me and her. A lot of grief. Around this time I had started a new business and my partner of a year or so moved in with us in a new place (now married) and a few years later we had another DD. My partner was a lifeline for me when my mum died and we all became close to his family. Around this time my DD also started seeing her dad again and she would go there every weekend. Her relationship with him hasn’t been great for various reasons. In the early years, DD1 also didn’t have a great relationship with my partner.

My DD is now saying how isolated and segregated she felt and as though she had lost her family unit when my mum passed away, and I had a new one with my partner and DD2 and also a business that I was running. She feels as though she wasn’t given enough support and it was hard for her to blend into a new family. This hurts me very deeply and something I had never intended. It seems she has carried this with her for years and now I feel as though I am the focal point for her anger. We’ve had several arguments about it.

I just wondered if anyone else has any experience of anything like this and aibu for getting defensive about it?

It doesn’t sound like she had a great time of it - grandparent she was close to dying, not seeing much of her dad, your new partner moving in and a new half-sibling. It’s a lot to deal with if you’re a child.

None if reflects badly on you though. It’s not like you did anything wrong by the sounds of it. If I were you I’d try listening to her instead of trying to shut her down.

EightChalk · 21/02/2024 11:34

I think maybe, and I say this as someone who had a good step-parent experience, sometimes parents don't realise quite how horrible it can be to have another adult imposed on you as a child. Your parent loves them, but you don't, and you might not even particularly like them; they are THERE in your home, with their own ways of doing things, and worse, they get to have parental authority over you. It seems like parents sometimes expect their children to warm up to the step-parent too quickly, because they themselves are fond of them. Fondness isn't transferable between people.