Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH being selfish not wanting to give DD the money

518 replies

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 14:17

Hi all,
First off, DD has no idea the money exists, so this isn’t coming from her or her being greedy, but here is the situation.

Early last year DHs lovely grandparents sadly passed away within 6 weeks of each other at 98 and 4 weeks off of 100. They were incredibly loving, kind people, they still lived at home (they had carers but hated the thought of a nursing home). They only had one child (DHs mum) who had two children, DHs sister never had children and DH and I only have DD, who’s 24 almost 25.
We all live in Cumbria, apart from DD who as moved to London, works in Risk Analysis for a big bank and is very happy.

DH and I are early 50s very recently mortgage free (woohoo about time!), we have savings and are comfortable with our pensions (both public sector workers so perhaps the only good thing going for us!)

DHs sister is also mortgage free, as are his parents.

His grandparents house has now been sold, considering we are north west the £500,000 sale price for a dated 3 bed bungalow has come as an unexpected surprise to all. His parents (mum) was the only named beneficiary in their wills so it’s mostly up to her. They had no debt, funerals prepaid etc.

DHs mum has decided she wants give a large chunk (£425,000-£450,000) to my DD (her only grandchild) as a house deposit. DD loves where she lives (Clapham North/Brixton) and probably wouldn’t get a house or flat that would last her for very long outright in that area (or maybe even anywhere in London?) so a mortgage would be needed. The rest of the money would be split between his parents, his sister and us. With some given to DD just to have fun with, holidays or clothes etc.

DH and I have also been saving for DD for the last 24 years. She didn’t require much help through uni (just accomodation and se paid her phone and sent occasional gift cards) so we have about £140,000 set for her. Some we will keep back to help with her wedding if she chooses to get married, but most was intended to help with a house deposit.
DH now thinks we shouldn’t give DD what we have saved, he thinks £425,000 is plenty and if she lived in the north would buy her a bloody nice house! I feel like that’s unfair, the £425,000 isn’t from us, it’s from a combination of her great grandparents whose money it is and her grandparents, aunt and us all being willing to pass on inheritance so she can benefit from it. The money we saved is just from us wanting to provide her with security and I think she is still entitled to that.
DD is one of the kindest, funniest, smartest most beautiful people I know and I want to give her all the help we can to ensure she is happy and successful, I think we should give her the money we have saved like initially planned and then keep a good chunk back as a wedding fund (I’m not sure how much weddings are these days but £25,000 held back maybe?)
DH wants to spend the money on us, holidays, shopping and cutting to part time hours (which we can afford anyway now our mortgage is paid).

AIBU to think he is being greedy and selfish and DD is entitled to all the money including what we saved for her. She doesn’t know she is getting the inheritance or the money we have saved so he insists she won’t know either way!

OP posts:
Pegasusforme · 20/02/2024 15:42

Does your DD have any student debt from University?

DollyLolly1989 · 20/02/2024 15:43

I'm with your husband on this. That's a bloody lot of money for your daughter, regardless of how she came about the money.

DodgeDog · 20/02/2024 15:44

I’m with your DH too. She is unexpectantly inheriting a lot of money, more then enough to be comfortable. As a direct result of her incredibly large inheritance your DH is inheriting much much less than expected. The other alternative is that DHs parents give much less to her and much more to your DH and his sister. Keeping 20k aside for a wedding seems kind but not essential.

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 15:45

Pegasusforme · 20/02/2024 15:42

Does your DD have any student debt from University?

No, her aunt (same one in this situation) paid all her undergrad fees and everyone chipped in to cover her postgrad. We paid for accommodation and she worked mostly for everything else.

OP posts:
Pegasusforme · 20/02/2024 15:47

How much will she need for a deposit for a house in London? How much mortgage will she be able to get on her wage?

I would take emotion out of it and crunch the numbers first.

How much rent is she paying currently?

DodgeDog · 20/02/2024 15:47

Your Dd doesn’t need a 60k safety fund, how ridiculous. This decision is for your husband to make as it’s his inheritance which has been reallocated to dd

paintingvenice · 20/02/2024 15:49

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 15:41

She is aware we have savings for DD too, she has historically spent more on DD than us. She and her husband are both GPs and are fairly comfortable, they aren’t worried about finances at all and want DD to have the best start.

But is she aware that the savings that you have for DD will now not be going to her and you are going to be taking them instead? I totally get that she is happy to give up a share of the inheritance to give DD the best start, but is she aware that in giving up her share, you aren’t going to pass on savings so are going to benefit to the tune of £100k?

Her earnings are pretty irrelevant here. She thinks you have savings for DD, she is happy to give up an inheritance share for your DD, she is expecting that she will get both lots of money. Is she aware that in giving up her inheritance share your DH has made the decision to take the savings pot for yourselves rather than passing it on as the sister expects?

saraclara · 20/02/2024 15:50

she has historically spent more on DD than us.

Again, how phenomenally lucky is your DD? This kind of thing is why I feel that she had to be given the opportunity to achieve some financial success and responsibility herself. Because it seems that so far everything had just fallen into her lap due to her family's generosity. And it's clearly likely to continue to as she's the only possible beneficiary in her generation of your family, and clearly adored by all.

At 24 there's a real danger of her not recognising the value of money and her efforts, or having empathy to recognise that this is not what other people's lives are like. She can afford a decent sized mortgage to probably double that deposit, and to be honest, she should. Otherwise she's not going to experience having to budget, either.

You say that she's a good saver. So she probably already has and will continue to amass savings if her own. Time to step back and let her take some financial responsibility for herself.

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 15:50

DodgeDog · 20/02/2024 15:47

Your Dd doesn’t need a 60k safety fund, how ridiculous. This decision is for your husband to make as it’s his inheritance which has been reallocated to dd

It’s not his inheritance, it’s his mum’s inheritance. I put money into DDs savings I should get a say what happens with that surely?

60k incase she, gets married, falls ill, loses her job, goes through a messy divorce, support grandchildren and if none of that is necessary extra inheritance when the time comes.

OP posts:
SallyWD · 20/02/2024 15:52

Wow, all I can is that in any of these scenarios your daughter is extremely lucky!! Whatever happens she's being gifted close to half a million pounds. This is extremely rare. The most I ever got was £1000 when my parents sold my grandparents house. The rest they kept themselves to buy a nicer house and to save. I was very thankful to have £1000 and I learnt valuable lessons having to pay my way in life.
I kind of agree with your husband. £425,000 is more than enough. I think giving her another £140,000 on top of that is kind of excessive and that you'd be spoiling her, in a way. She's in an extremely fortunate position and it's also fine for her to stand on her own two feet a little (like everyone else has to).

Choux · 20/02/2024 15:52

Unless her friends are all similarly as fortunate, being gifted a 2 bed London flat outright (assuming she wants to buy a property now - she may not) plus having no student debt could cause some issues with friends if they are having to fund everything in their lives themselves and juggle student loans. And she may attract both romantic and friend gold diggers / scroungers. Big financial differences impacts friendships.

saraclara · 20/02/2024 15:53

Choux · 20/02/2024 15:52

Unless her friends are all similarly as fortunate, being gifted a 2 bed London flat outright (assuming she wants to buy a property now - she may not) plus having no student debt could cause some issues with friends if they are having to fund everything in their lives themselves and juggle student loans. And she may attract both romantic and friend gold diggers / scroungers. Big financial differences impacts friendships.

Yep. She will be cocklodgers dream girlfriend!

Jellycatspyjamas · 20/02/2024 15:53

I’d find it very hard to characterise my DH as selfish in this position. Your DD will receive much more than many young people in her situation - she’s incredibly fortunate. She has no student debt and with her inheritance could find herself mortgage free depending on what she decides to buy.

You have saved all your lives, presumably making financial decisions to go without to help her into adulthood. She doesn’t now need that help. You could have a very nice standard of living, step back from work, travel etc. Your DH has a very demanding job, and he’s selfish for thinking that the money you’ve both saved might ease things for you at this stage of life?

I don’t think it’s necessarily a good thing for young people to have it all handed to them, needing to plan and save and experience a degree of pressure helps develop resilience. By all accounts she is doing well under her own steam and is about to have the best part of half a million handed to her. More money isn’t going to substantially improve her quality of life but it could increase yours significantly as you approach retirement.

MCOut · 20/02/2024 15:54

Neither of you are being unreasonable. I completely understand your impulse to make sure your DD is as financially secure as possible. Similarly your DH isn’t being unreasonable to want to have more money for you both to enjoy yourselves.

Compromise is the right way to go. Let him have a think about what it is he wants to do and negotiate how much you’re going to gift your DD accordingly. Housing in London is extremely expensive. I think people might be overestimating her salary. If she’s buying alone, she won’t be able to borrow as much as people are probably assuming.

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 15:54

Choux · 20/02/2024 15:52

Unless her friends are all similarly as fortunate, being gifted a 2 bed London flat outright (assuming she wants to buy a property now - she may not) plus having no student debt could cause some issues with friends if they are having to fund everything in their lives themselves and juggle student loans. And she may attract both romantic and friend gold diggers / scroungers. Big financial differences impacts friendships.

So what do you suppose happens with the money from the sale of the house to prevent this?

OP posts:
TheSeasonalNameChange · 20/02/2024 15:55

I think you need to split the difference with the sister so she can make her own choice. She needs to know she's going without to fund you, not your daughter.

Twodogsonthecouch · 20/02/2024 15:55

I honestly believe you can do too much for your children.
I have 4. We are lucky enough to have well paid jobs and they have had a good education, lots of extracurricular activities, and annual holidays etc all their lives. They are now aged 29, 27,25 and 23. They have good jobs and lots of life skills. My MIL died 10 years ago and for long and complicated reasons part of her estate was only recently liquidated. Because my DH has a big family and it was only a small part of her estate anyway DH got £4000 he was not expecting. We have enough money. We gave them £1000 each. They are thrilled. It will allow them an extra holiday, gym membership, nice handbag..whatever. Is it life changing..absolutely not. But they have been given a great start anyway. Ar some point they will inherit from us and my dad, who is still alive and has assets. But in the meantime they will work and budget and go on cheap holidays and I really believe that will be the making of them. Let your DD live her life and grow her lifestyle independently as much as possible. I honestly think it will stand to her

mindutopia · 20/02/2024 15:55

I think what your dh is saying is sensible. Do keep some of that savings still for a rainy day - either for both of you or your dd. You never know what the future holds and what you may need. But I was gifted about half of that amount in my early 40s as an inheritance, and that has set me up well for life. Your dd will be able to get a lovely home for herself which will be a great investment. You've worked hard to save money for her and you can help her with setting up her home, any moving costs, decorating, updates to enhance the investment.

But it sounds like it's also time to enjoy your lives. You are mortgage free, so take some time to reduce your working hours, travel, enjoy a bit of fun.

Pegasusforme · 20/02/2024 15:56

Giving her a deposit is fine it won’t put her real friends off.

What are her expectations for the property she would want to buy in the area?

How much mortgage can she get on her wage? Then look at your options.

Backinthedress · 20/02/2024 15:57

Choux · 20/02/2024 15:52

Unless her friends are all similarly as fortunate, being gifted a 2 bed London flat outright (assuming she wants to buy a property now - she may not) plus having no student debt could cause some issues with friends if they are having to fund everything in their lives themselves and juggle student loans. And she may attract both romantic and friend gold diggers / scroungers. Big financial differences impacts friendships.

I admit, I would hand over the money with immensely strong suggestions to be discreet about whether it's owned or rented and to what extent

GinForBreakfast · 20/02/2024 15:58

I really don't think it serves young people well to give them enormous amounts of money. Learning to earn, save and live within your means is part of growing up and gives you the attitudes and skills for a successful life in the long term. There are risks inherent, no matter how sensible she is once she has the money it's hers to do what she wishes - decisions you might not be on board with.

Basically, I'm Team DH.

MCOut · 20/02/2024 15:59

Choux · 20/02/2024 15:52

Unless her friends are all similarly as fortunate, being gifted a 2 bed London flat outright (assuming she wants to buy a property now - she may not) plus having no student debt could cause some issues with friends if they are having to fund everything in their lives themselves and juggle student loans. And she may attract both romantic and friend gold diggers / scroungers. Big financial differences impacts friendships.

I get where you are coming from because we had this in our friendship group to some extent. Most of us will not receive an inheritance, whereas the others happen to be from well off families.

Ultimately envious people need to manage their own envy. Those who were upset got over it. There will always be people better off in life so this is not OP or her DD’s problem.

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 15:59

MCOut · 20/02/2024 15:54

Neither of you are being unreasonable. I completely understand your impulse to make sure your DD is as financially secure as possible. Similarly your DH isn’t being unreasonable to want to have more money for you both to enjoy yourselves.

Compromise is the right way to go. Let him have a think about what it is he wants to do and negotiate how much you’re going to gift your DD accordingly. Housing in London is extremely expensive. I think people might be overestimating her salary. If she’s buying alone, she won’t be able to borrow as much as people are probably assuming.

This is a good point I have no idea what her salary is, never discussed it with her. She lives in a flat with one friend (they both work from home so wanted an office in the 3rd room), no idea what the friend does or how much she makes. I couldn’t even guess how much DD makes as it’s not an industry I know but she seems comfortable and happy.
Shes been with her boyfriend for a year but I’m not sure if they would love together yet.

OP posts:
Pheasantsmate · 20/02/2024 16:00

TheSeasonalNameChange · 20/02/2024 15:55

I think you need to split the difference with the sister so she can make her own choice. She needs to know she's going without to fund you, not your daughter.

100% they need to discuss this with the sister and be open that they had savings for their daughter that they are no longer going to pass on with the daughter getting such a windfall. Is the sister still happy to give up her share knowing it is essentially paying for the OP and partners holidays etc.

SnakesAndArrows · 20/02/2024 16:00

Two things to think about.

One, if your daughter marries and then divorces, half of the money from her DGGM’s house goes to her ex.

Two, when you’re both old enough to need care it won’t be cheap. Having a large rainy day fund will in of itself be a gift to your DD who will not have to worry about you receiving sub-standard care or providing it herself.

Swipe left for the next trending thread