Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH being selfish not wanting to give DD the money

518 replies

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 14:17

Hi all,
First off, DD has no idea the money exists, so this isn’t coming from her or her being greedy, but here is the situation.

Early last year DHs lovely grandparents sadly passed away within 6 weeks of each other at 98 and 4 weeks off of 100. They were incredibly loving, kind people, they still lived at home (they had carers but hated the thought of a nursing home). They only had one child (DHs mum) who had two children, DHs sister never had children and DH and I only have DD, who’s 24 almost 25.
We all live in Cumbria, apart from DD who as moved to London, works in Risk Analysis for a big bank and is very happy.

DH and I are early 50s very recently mortgage free (woohoo about time!), we have savings and are comfortable with our pensions (both public sector workers so perhaps the only good thing going for us!)

DHs sister is also mortgage free, as are his parents.

His grandparents house has now been sold, considering we are north west the £500,000 sale price for a dated 3 bed bungalow has come as an unexpected surprise to all. His parents (mum) was the only named beneficiary in their wills so it’s mostly up to her. They had no debt, funerals prepaid etc.

DHs mum has decided she wants give a large chunk (£425,000-£450,000) to my DD (her only grandchild) as a house deposit. DD loves where she lives (Clapham North/Brixton) and probably wouldn’t get a house or flat that would last her for very long outright in that area (or maybe even anywhere in London?) so a mortgage would be needed. The rest of the money would be split between his parents, his sister and us. With some given to DD just to have fun with, holidays or clothes etc.

DH and I have also been saving for DD for the last 24 years. She didn’t require much help through uni (just accomodation and se paid her phone and sent occasional gift cards) so we have about £140,000 set for her. Some we will keep back to help with her wedding if she chooses to get married, but most was intended to help with a house deposit.
DH now thinks we shouldn’t give DD what we have saved, he thinks £425,000 is plenty and if she lived in the north would buy her a bloody nice house! I feel like that’s unfair, the £425,000 isn’t from us, it’s from a combination of her great grandparents whose money it is and her grandparents, aunt and us all being willing to pass on inheritance so she can benefit from it. The money we saved is just from us wanting to provide her with security and I think she is still entitled to that.
DD is one of the kindest, funniest, smartest most beautiful people I know and I want to give her all the help we can to ensure she is happy and successful, I think we should give her the money we have saved like initially planned and then keep a good chunk back as a wedding fund (I’m not sure how much weddings are these days but £25,000 held back maybe?)
DH wants to spend the money on us, holidays, shopping and cutting to part time hours (which we can afford anyway now our mortgage is paid).

AIBU to think he is being greedy and selfish and DD is entitled to all the money including what we saved for her. She doesn’t know she is getting the inheritance or the money we have saved so he insists she won’t know either way!

OP posts:
Wishimaywishimight · 20/02/2024 15:05

I'm with your DH - time to spoil yourselves a little thanks to lots of hard work and saving. Your daughter is set up well for the future. She can surely use her substantial inheritance to pay for her own wedding (should she have one) as well as put down a huge deposit on a house? You have saved a huge amount for her but she really doesn't need it now. Splash out yourselves - go on the holiday of a lifetime, buy a new car, whatever it is that takes your fancy and save some for your own future.

EarringsandLipstick · 20/02/2024 15:09

I think it's lovely your DD has so many people who love and care for her, and want to help her get on in life (which she already seems to be doing very well at!).

However, I'm a bit shocked that almost every penny is being allocated to your DD, from the £500k sale of the property.

Even if you / DH / DSIL / DPs don't have immediate financial issues, why is it not being split more evenly to allow other choices you wouldn't ordinarily have made e.g. a special holiday, contribution to a holiday home or home upgrades that aren't needed but might be nice and so on.

I think giving DD a significant portion of the £500k is a lovely thought; but am baffled that none of it will effectively come to the immediate family (your MIL).

saraclara · 20/02/2024 15:09

Seriously, your posts make me want to weep.

A 24 year old is about to get over £400k as an inheritance, and you want to give her another £150k. That's much more than I will ever have if I sold my decent house and totted up all my savings. And as for what help I can give my own daughters...

And yet you feel that your daughter will somehow be hard done by if she only gets the £400k? And she presumably has an excellent salary for her age.

A quarter of her inheritance would be life changing for my daughters (also in an expensive part of the country, and a decade or more older than yours).
So give over with your 'poor daughter' narrative.

We all want the best for our kids but she really doesn't need that extra £150. Let her gain the self respect of earning and saving towards her home. This money isn't all she has or will ever earn or inherit.

invyqn · 20/02/2024 15:14

Have a lovely holiday yourselves. And decide what to do with the rest.

Maybe invest some in a pension for her.

keep some for yourselves. Your DH is tight - fair’s fair!

invyqn · 20/02/2024 15:14

Not tight - RIGHT

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 15:19

saraclara · 20/02/2024 15:09

Seriously, your posts make me want to weep.

A 24 year old is about to get over £400k as an inheritance, and you want to give her another £150k. That's much more than I will ever have if I sold my decent house and totted up all my savings. And as for what help I can give my own daughters...

And yet you feel that your daughter will somehow be hard done by if she only gets the £400k? And she presumably has an excellent salary for her age.

A quarter of her inheritance would be life changing for my daughters (also in an expensive part of the country, and a decade or more older than yours).
So give over with your 'poor daughter' narrative.

We all want the best for our kids but she really doesn't need that extra £150. Let her gain the self respect of earning and saving towards her home. This money isn't all she has or will ever earn or inherit.

Edited

I’m sorry if I gave off a “poor daughter” narrative I really didn’t mean that. Of course she is incredibly lucky and I know she will be
beyond grateful. I know that most will never receive this (frankly we never expected she would).
I don’t think she will be hard done by with £400,000 it’s more the ethics of it to me. We saved for DD, I don’t think other circumstances should influence that.
Of course she is lucky, she does save and has been saving since she got her first job at 16. I’d never even consider giving her anything if she was reckless. We have never told her about the money as we wanted her to work for herself and not be reliant or think she had an easy ride.

OP posts:
rockpoolingtogether · 20/02/2024 15:20

Keep the money you saved for her. That was before you knew she would have this inheritance

Choux · 20/02/2024 15:21

I agree with @EarringsandLipstick that your 20 something DD with a promising sounding career is going to be gifted £450k by her DGM and the rest of the family get nothing to enjoy / remember the GGPs. That's a young age to get so much. And you also want to gift her £100k on top of that? Altogether that would buy her a flat outright in a lot of the capital. Will that change her outlook, desire to work, progress up the career ladder?

Parents want to help their children but that should not be at the detriment of their own lives and enjoyment. You can spend your own savings on you given that we all only get one go at life. Remember also that at some point your MIL will presumably pass on a house to someone. If that's in 20-30 years and comes to your DH then you will likely not be of an age to use that on travel etc. And if that money also goes directly to your DD then she will be extremely wealthy particularly if your SIL provides for DD in her will.

I would talk to your DD about what her future plans re property buying and where she would like to live and hold off on giving her your money on top of DGM money.

saraclara · 20/02/2024 15:24

Seriously though @HelnPink , they're is no 'ethics' about this money. It's not hers, it's yours, and always has been. In your head you seem to have given it to her already. You haven't, and your husband recognises that. It's money you thought you'd need to give her and now you won't need to.

It's like saving for the new engine that the mechanic told you that your would need for your car, but then finding that actually it's a smaller repairable fault, that's only going to cost 10% of what you saved. You don't give the garage that whole amount because of 'the ethics'.

DinnaeFashYersel · 20/02/2024 15:24

candgen625 · 20/02/2024 14:21

I'm with your husbands. 425k is alot of money. Keep some aide for a "wedding fund" but spend some on yourself. Maybe retire a bit earlier

Completely agree with this.

Choux · 20/02/2024 15:25

As the only one in her generation in her family your DD is potentially going to inherit the value of 4 houses plus other associated savings (from her GGPs, DGM, DPs and potentially aunt) and you wan to give her your life savings on top and then carry on working FT till retirement age??? Give your head a wobble!

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 15:29

Choux · 20/02/2024 15:25

As the only one in her generation in her family your DD is potentially going to inherit the value of 4 houses plus other associated savings (from her GGPs, DGM, DPs and potentially aunt) and you wan to give her your life savings on top and then carry on working FT till retirement age??? Give your head a wobble!

Well … even with the money I’m in no hurry to retire, I work in a small village school, have for 2 decades and dress the thought of leaving!! DH may want to step down into a less high pressure role or retire early but we can afford that anyway right now!

I’m going to suggest a 80k for us (plus the 20k from his mum from the sale of the house) and 60k for DD, wedding, safety net fund.

OP posts:
saraclara · 20/02/2024 15:29

Choux · 20/02/2024 15:25

As the only one in her generation in her family your DD is potentially going to inherit the value of 4 houses plus other associated savings (from her GGPs, DGM, DPs and potentially aunt) and you wan to give her your life savings on top and then carry on working FT till retirement age??? Give your head a wobble!

Not to mention that if she meets a husband or partner through work or the kind of social life that working in risk management for a big bank in London will afford her, he's likely to be doing very nicely thank you, too, and contributing financially to their home and lifestyle.

This girl has a golden future ahead of her.

Byeckythump · 20/02/2024 15:30

I definitely wouldn't give her a big chunk on top of the 400+ inheritance. What I would do is use the money you saved for her for nice things for you all. Maybe give her 5k towards furnishing her new place as a new home gift. Use some of it to be able to regularly visit her and treat her to nice meals out. As she gets older if she has her own family you could help her out with baby kit, pay for a cleaner during mat leave, all those extras that will help her and also make you feel good. I wouldn't feel guilty about using some to smooth retirement, a few trips with your husband, maybe finishing work a bit early.

It's a wonderful position to be in, don't ruin it by arguing with your husband, you need to be able to see each other's point of view and work it out together.

Pruntysisters · 20/02/2024 15:30

Not many people get to inherit this sort of money from great grandparents.

I know you say you don’t need the money but maybe your husband thinks his mother should have given him and his sister some of the pot. As she hasn’t keeping back the £140,000 you saved for your daughter just redresses the imbalance somewhat.

As another poster said it looks like she’s set to inherit a fair bit more down the line.

Porfirio · 20/02/2024 15:32

Personally, I'm your circumstances I would see the money you have saved for your daughter as being dead money, it's already been earmarked for your daughter.

Bieber if your husband is going to feel resentful now that your daughter is going to inherit elsewhere as well then a good compromise would be to take some money out for you and your husband to have a holiday/trip of a lifetime and the give her what you have saved.

If you don't want a holiday, then a fixture to your home such as a new kitchen, or a conservatory or a garden room or a new car.

paintingvenice · 20/02/2024 15:34

You say this his sister is happy for the bulk of the money to go to your daughter, but is she aware that this will essentially put an extra £100k in your pocket? If she is aware and still happy crack on, otherwise it feels a little rum to me.

londonmummy1966 · 20/02/2024 15:36

It's an interesting one as in many parts of the country the difference between getting £425k and nearly £600K would be missing out the first step or two on the housing ladder which given stamp duty and related moving costs would be a good thing to do. However in the area your DD lives that budget is basically a 2 bed flat either way so the £140k isn't currently that life changing. In those circumstances I might be inclined to hang on to that and see it as a rainy day fund for anyone in the family who might need it. If it isn't needed then perhaps give it to your DD on the birth of a first child at a time when finances are likely o be tight.

Whatever you do make sure that her grandmother does a deed of variation so that the gift is treated as coming from her great grandmothers estate. Otherwise there is a risk of an additional inheritance tax charge if the grandmother dies within 7 years.

HappyFitnessQueen · 20/02/2024 15:36

I think you should keep the money you saved for her. This means that you can afford to keep being generous to her over your lifetime, as and when it is needed. It sounds as though you and your husband have worked hard, and would also benefit from it. You've only got one life...you need to make sure you live it to the max too. It feels a bit martyr'ish to be worrying about the ethics. What do you think your daughter would want for you both? I'm sure she would want you to benefit from it rather than it sit in an account for her when she has plenty already. You don't know if ill-health is around the corner for either of you. Keep it as a buffer.

MississippiAF · 20/02/2024 15:38

I agree with your DH

BeadedBubbles · 20/02/2024 15:38

I'm totally with your dh. You saved the £140k to give your dd a leg up. She doesn't need it now she's getting over £400k! If she won the lottery or was marrying a multi-millionaire would you still want to give her the £140k?

I don't think it will be doing your dd any favours having such a large amount of money at such a young age - even without the extra £140k. I agree with a pp who said that it's good to be able to show what you've worked for. She would be able to buy a small flat in Clapham outright without the extra £140k. But does she want to commit to living in that area? One of my dcs is renting in London and we are able to help with a deposit, but at 27 they still prefer the flexibility of renting.

ladykale · 20/02/2024 15:39

Your husband is not being selfish.

The circumstances have changed.

Obviously you should keep the money if she is getting 425k, bizarre that you wouldn't. Given that you are both teachers do you have that sort of amount saved?

She also doesn't need to buy a house in cash. She could get a mortgage and spend £800k on a house if she wanted.

What a bizarre post

TheDowagerDoughnut · 20/02/2024 15:39

I don't think you are unreasonable for wanting to give her both pots.

But I think you ARE unreasonable for calling your husband greedy and selfish because he thinks you shouldn't.

Frankly, I would not give a 24 year old that much money because I (genuinely!) think there is a gift in having to earn things for yourself. But that's a disagreement in ethics that, if we were married, we would have to talk about and try to come to an agreement. I wouldn't much appreciate being called greedy or selfish for it.

101Nutella · 20/02/2024 15:41

@HelnPink I think helping your daughter is amazing. The economists have shown that statistically it’s really hard now to have what was regarded as normal 30/40 years ago in terms of wage vs home ownership.

childcare in London is £90 a day standard in various boroughs- only set to rise with wage increases. It’s really tough. If you could set some aside to help maternity leave so she has the choice of 1 year if wanted and also being able to work as little or much as she wanted? That’s a proper leg up as the loss of earning and therefore pension women face can lead to financial insecurity later in life. That would have made so much difference to my maternity leave. The constant pressure of money worries/inflation etc really took the shine off it and made me panic when we suddenly needed to buy age appropriate things as baby grew.

and some in a trust fund for grandchild of the time comes? Continue the leg up? Schools can be under a lot of pressure at moment so option for private/selective fee paying to give them a leg up too?

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 15:41

paintingvenice · 20/02/2024 15:34

You say this his sister is happy for the bulk of the money to go to your daughter, but is she aware that this will essentially put an extra £100k in your pocket? If she is aware and still happy crack on, otherwise it feels a little rum to me.

She is aware we have savings for DD too, she has historically spent more on DD than us. She and her husband are both GPs and are fairly comfortable, they aren’t worried about finances at all and want DD to have the best start.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread