Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to work?

737 replies

howdypartnerrr · 16/02/2024 11:45

I worked full time until having DC, and part time since youngest DC was a few months old.

I just don't want to do it anymore. The amount I bring home is minimal.. and I find I'm spending my days off doing housework and just not having the energy to take DC to toddler groups etc. my youngest would start school in sept 2026.. so I'm thinking about just quitting until then. DH says it's up to me as my money just goes into my bank, I don't contribute to any bills so it wouldn't affect the household. My job is quite stressful.. and other more relaxed jobs involved working weekends etc and I did that with eldest dc, working weekends, Christmas Eve, Easter Sunday etc. don't want to do it again.

What do you think?

OP posts:
matrixxx · 23/02/2024 13:30

Of course there are reasons you may need to take time out of the workplace in the future@SouthLondonMum22. Or your DH, whatever. What if one of your children is long-term or seriously ill (heaven forbid). What if they are school refusers, or anorexic, or suicidal . Nobody can assume these things won't happen. Life is more complicated than ever for teens now - so much influence from social media. So many teens and pre-teens who school refuse or isolate themselves because of mental health issues, gender confusion, bullying. A family member has recently had to leave work because her daughter is school refusing and at high risk from self-harm - this came out of nowhere. I hope none of this ever comes your way. But if your work plans do ever need to change, I hope you won't be too hard in yourself and I hope your DH won't be either because there are many times in life when there really are more important issues than who earns what in a family.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 13:18

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 13:02

SouthLondonMum22 - all that has happened on this thread is that a woman is considering dropping a job which she hates, is low paid and only 2 days per week.

Derailing any thread where any woman is considering SAH or working part-time with this incessant 'wider society, equality, gender stereotypes and sexism' comes across as overkill.

That's not to say there isn't a time and place for such 'wider discussion.' Why not start your own thread about it?

You say you have felt judgement from society for your decision to use childcare at 12 weeks. In that sense, I can understand where you are coming from. But, without wanting to sound patronising, why not 'be the person you want to see.' If you don't like judgement, stop dishing it out on threads where the OP isn't asking for it.

Imagine if, on any thread where someone mentioned changing nursery or adding an extra day or something like that - if there was a poster who relentlessly came on trying to incite a wider discussion about the structural societal impact of childcare on babies.' On every thread. It would be a bit ridiculous wouldn't it.

I am 50 now and I just feel life is to short for all this. You say you're having twins? Congratulations! Nobody knows what life will throw at us, as I'm sure you are aware. There may even be circumstances when you, as a mother of three, need to take time out of the workplace in future. It helps not to think to rigidly about these things. That's all I have to say really.

On many occasions threads take on a life on their own within the comments and a discussion between several posters happen. I'm not sure why it is such an issue to some people now, there's no need to start a new thread on it since those who wish to discuss it already come back to this thread.

Discussion of the wider issue isn't the same as judging individual women who are SAHM's. I also don't need to imagine it, in any threads on AIBU especially which include the discussion of working mothers, a comment is always made about the poor babies getting palmed off to nursery for a stranger to raise them. I was called sick for putting a 3 month old in nursery in a previous thread, I'd certainly never call a SAHM sick for doing what she believes is best.

Why would I need to take time out of the workplace in the future just because I'll be a mother to three other than the 12 weeks of maternity leave when the twins are initially born? I can't think of any circumstance unless I suddenly became physically/mentally unable to work for whatever reason which can obviously happen to anyone at any time.

CagneyAndLazy · 23/02/2024 13:17

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 11:59

That's correct. I've also never tried to dictate what other women should do, I've said multiple times on this thread that people are going to do what they want to do.

But it absolutely has an impact on everyone and wider society, such as like you said about the fact I'm judged in society far more than my husband.

Several people on here are clearly interested in the discussion when it comes to wider society as opposed to individual choices and the impact it has on equality, gender stereotypes and sexism. This is a place for discussion and debate, not for ''yes, do whatever you want'' or it would make for very dull discussion/debate and render AIBU to be pretty pointless.

As I said before, I'm not sure why you think silencing others who wish to engage and discuss the issue is necessary. I know I certainly won't be policed on what I can or can't comment as I'm sure several others will also feel the same.

If you don't want to engage, that's fine but clearly several people are interested and wish to discuss and debate.

Completely agree with you - on all counts.

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 13:02

SouthLondonMum22 - all that has happened on this thread is that a woman is considering dropping a job which she hates, is low paid and only 2 days per week.

Derailing any thread where any woman is considering SAH or working part-time with this incessant 'wider society, equality, gender stereotypes and sexism' comes across as overkill.

That's not to say there isn't a time and place for such 'wider discussion.' Why not start your own thread about it?

You say you have felt judgement from society for your decision to use childcare at 12 weeks. In that sense, I can understand where you are coming from. But, without wanting to sound patronising, why not 'be the person you want to see.' If you don't like judgement, stop dishing it out on threads where the OP isn't asking for it.

Imagine if, on any thread where someone mentioned changing nursery or adding an extra day or something like that - if there was a poster who relentlessly came on trying to incite a wider discussion about the structural societal impact of childcare on babies.' On every thread. It would be a bit ridiculous wouldn't it.

I am 50 now and I just feel life is to short for all this. You say you're having twins? Congratulations! Nobody knows what life will throw at us, as I'm sure you are aware. There may even be circumstances when you, as a mother of three, need to take time out of the workplace in future. It helps not to think to rigidly about these things. That's all I have to say really.

CagneyAndLazy · 23/02/2024 12:52

LorlieS · 23/02/2024 12:14

@girlswillbegirls So you cite that two of your SAHM friends are in "terrible marriages" but then you go on to say they "have unconditional love for their partners."
So in essence they're miserable but don't leave because they love their partners?
Not my sort of idea of a good life tbh!

I read it slightly differently - that they chose to become SAHMs because of their unconditional love, at that point in time.

I could be wrong though (it has happened on the odd occasion 😉)

LorlieS · 23/02/2024 12:14

@girlswillbegirls So you cite that two of your SAHM friends are in "terrible marriages" but then you go on to say they "have unconditional love for their partners."
So in essence they're miserable but don't leave because they love their partners?
Not my sort of idea of a good life tbh!

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 11:59

tryingtoenergise · 23/02/2024 11:30

@SouthLondonMum22 - forgive me if I have this wrong, but are you the poster whose baby went into full-time nursery at 12 weeks? And you have been very honest that you hated SAH in those 12 weeks because you found it extremely boring.

No judgement from me. However, I understand your point that, in society, you are more likely to feel judged for this rather than your husband. I completely get that.

However, going on and on about 'sexism' to women who feel the opposite to you - ie. they couldn't imagine NOT being with their baby - is a total irrelevance. Having a full time job with a young baby is not less 'sexist' - it just means (in your case) you were not cut out to SAH and oreferrrd ti work. In other cases, women are forced to return to work before they are 100% ready. It's obvious that everyone is different and this derailing of every thread with chants of 'sexism', gets nobody anywhere.

Its not as simple as 'sexism.' It's women acting instinctively and yes, in many cases, this may be different to their men. It's not all about 'socialisation', it really isn't. If you know that, you know it. Other women are just as independent-thinking as you - they are just different in this respect. That's ok.

If you're happy with your DH and using childcare from 12 weeks, that's absolutely fine and it's great you can be honest. You need to do what makes you happy. But you can't dictate this for everyone because, you must realise, many (most?) women would never choose to live like that because they have different priorities and it would make them very unhappy indeed. Would a society where all babies were in childcare at a young age be any happier? I don't think so. Choice and respecting other women's choices is always preferable - on an individual and societal level. You have made your choices, let other women make theirs. Women who feel an urge to SAH are, like you, just being honest with themselves. I don't want to get into this any further because it just goes nowhere but surely you can understand this. If another woman tells you how she feels and what she wants for her children and in her marriage, just believe her and accept it.

That's correct. I've also never tried to dictate what other women should do, I've said multiple times on this thread that people are going to do what they want to do.

But it absolutely has an impact on everyone and wider society, such as like you said about the fact I'm judged in society far more than my husband.

Several people on here are clearly interested in the discussion when it comes to wider society as opposed to individual choices and the impact it has on equality, gender stereotypes and sexism. This is a place for discussion and debate, not for ''yes, do whatever you want'' or it would make for very dull discussion/debate and render AIBU to be pretty pointless.

As I said before, I'm not sure why you think silencing others who wish to engage and discuss the issue is necessary. I know I certainly won't be policed on what I can or can't comment as I'm sure several others will also feel the same.

If you don't want to engage, that's fine but clearly several people are interested and wish to discuss and debate.

tryingtoenergise · 23/02/2024 11:57

girlswillbegirls - of course. Anything can happen to anyone. We all surely have friends in all kinds of situations with all kinds of husbands (or wives), children, jobs (or not) health situations and finances. People navigate their lives in the way that makes most sense to them.

girlswillbegirls · 23/02/2024 11:34

I didn't want to come across moralising or patronising. I certainly do not feel insecure at all. In fact this is something I don't talk about IRL. I think we are only 3 mums in my DD class who work full time. I was asked why would I do that multiple times. So I think it's more socially accepted to be a SAHM or work very part time, at least where I love.

Tomorrow I'm meeting friends. Two of them I'm actively helping them to return to the workforce after 15 years + being SAHMs. They are both in terrible marriages. They are my friends, and I want to really help with their CV and my network. It's hard to suddlenly earn enough money when things go wrong and you have been out of the workforce. Their decision to be SHAMs comes from a place of love. Inconditional love to theirs children and partners. They are truly lovely people.
Maybe you could read our posts as an alternative view. You can both love your children and not lose your independence.
I talk from experience and of course my own point if view. I was ill when my children were small with cancer and still feel that you can enjoy life and contribute/ have a career. We are truly fortunate to be alive and do all the ordinary things.

tryingtoenergise · 23/02/2024 11:30

@SouthLondonMum22 - forgive me if I have this wrong, but are you the poster whose baby went into full-time nursery at 12 weeks? And you have been very honest that you hated SAH in those 12 weeks because you found it extremely boring.

No judgement from me. However, I understand your point that, in society, you are more likely to feel judged for this rather than your husband. I completely get that.

However, going on and on about 'sexism' to women who feel the opposite to you - ie. they couldn't imagine NOT being with their baby - is a total irrelevance. Having a full time job with a young baby is not less 'sexist' - it just means (in your case) you were not cut out to SAH and oreferrrd ti work. In other cases, women are forced to return to work before they are 100% ready. It's obvious that everyone is different and this derailing of every thread with chants of 'sexism', gets nobody anywhere.

Its not as simple as 'sexism.' It's women acting instinctively and yes, in many cases, this may be different to their men. It's not all about 'socialisation', it really isn't. If you know that, you know it. Other women are just as independent-thinking as you - they are just different in this respect. That's ok.

If you're happy with your DH and using childcare from 12 weeks, that's absolutely fine and it's great you can be honest. You need to do what makes you happy. But you can't dictate this for everyone because, you must realise, many (most?) women would never choose to live like that because they have different priorities and it would make them very unhappy indeed. Would a society where all babies were in childcare at a young age be any happier? I don't think so. Choice and respecting other women's choices is always preferable - on an individual and societal level. You have made your choices, let other women make theirs. Women who feel an urge to SAH are, like you, just being honest with themselves. I don't want to get into this any further because it just goes nowhere but surely you can understand this. If another woman tells you how she feels and what she wants for her children and in her marriage, just believe her and accept it.

toomuchfaff · 23/02/2024 11:25

After reading so many MN posts about financial abuse - think - is there any possibility your DH could/would end up holding the purse strings and you'd regret not having a contributory place in the house? Any likelihood he will turn into one of the raging monsters we see so many posts about that DH wont let me do X because he sees my role as insignificant?

Mumof2NDers · 23/02/2024 10:45

tryingtoenergise · 23/02/2024 10:16

There's 'discussion' and then there's 'unhealthy obsession'. The second is very obvious to all except, sadly, the posters concerned. They are not giving 'advice' - its way beyond that. They are repeatedly trying to reassure themselves that their own decisions and marriages are really ok, which is quite sad. If you are truly happy, what other women do has no impact on you - that's the key. You can live and let live. People who moralise, patronise and whose thinking is inflexible and repetitive are quite evident. It comes from a place of insecurity, whether they can recognise it or not.

^^This with bells on!!
I couldn’t care less what other people do
with their life. Their life, their choice!
I have 2 DC’s (16 and 24) and have always worked full time but only because I’ve had to. DH has always had minimum wage jobs so me staying at home wasn’t an option. If he earned well I would have stayed home while they were small.

BadCovers · 23/02/2024 10:44

Thoroughly seconded, @SouthLondonMum22. Sexism and unthinking gendered assumptions in general, aren’t something that magically ends at the edges of an individual life.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 10:40

tryingtoenergise · 23/02/2024 10:16

There's 'discussion' and then there's 'unhealthy obsession'. The second is very obvious to all except, sadly, the posters concerned. They are not giving 'advice' - its way beyond that. They are repeatedly trying to reassure themselves that their own decisions and marriages are really ok, which is quite sad. If you are truly happy, what other women do has no impact on you - that's the key. You can live and let live. People who moralise, patronise and whose thinking is inflexible and repetitive are quite evident. It comes from a place of insecurity, whether they can recognise it or not.

Sexism has an impact on everyone. It's import to discuss it, I'm not sure why you seem to want to silence those who are interested in engaging and discussing when it's easy to simply not join in if you aren't interested.

Are those who argue that working mothers are selfish, materialistic and don't even raise their own children on this thread also insecure and are trying to reassure themselves that their decisions and marriages are really ok? Or does it magically only apply to those who wish to discuss the impact gender stereotypes and sexism has on society and equality in a wider context?

tryingtoenergise · 23/02/2024 10:16

There's 'discussion' and then there's 'unhealthy obsession'. The second is very obvious to all except, sadly, the posters concerned. They are not giving 'advice' - its way beyond that. They are repeatedly trying to reassure themselves that their own decisions and marriages are really ok, which is quite sad. If you are truly happy, what other women do has no impact on you - that's the key. You can live and let live. People who moralise, patronise and whose thinking is inflexible and repetitive are quite evident. It comes from a place of insecurity, whether they can recognise it or not.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 08:34

Calamitousness · 23/02/2024 08:22

Really @girlswillbegirls
well I’ll be quite honest. It’s not being posted as ‘opinion and info’ it’s coming across very much like there is only one way to run your family life. I am trying to balance that by saying that yes it is actually as simple as both ‘competent. Sentient. Adults’ makai g their own choices how to live their life. Try it !

There's been a variety of opinions, especially as it is such a long thread.

Of course people will ultimately do what they want, Mumsnet would be very quiet though if no discussion happened.

Calamitousness · 23/02/2024 08:22

Really @girlswillbegirls
well I’ll be quite honest. It’s not being posted as ‘opinion and info’ it’s coming across very much like there is only one way to run your family life. I am trying to balance that by saying that yes it is actually as simple as both ‘competent. Sentient. Adults’ makai g their own choices how to live their life. Try it !

BadCovers · 23/02/2024 08:14

FatPrincess · 22/02/2024 19:52

Well, I agree. It's a massive female privilege to have that choice but say that on here and you'll be chased with pitchforks! 🤣

Honestly, the only two places I’ve ever come across the (to me, deeply odd and reactionary) idea that women’s work/careers become optional once they give birth is (1) on here and (2) in a village I lived in for a few years where I was one of only two WOHMs in DS’s class of 27 kids, and considered ‘odd’ for working because DH had a ‘big job’.

Stats suggest just under three quarters of women with young children work, and that a significant number of those who don’t would prefer to work if they had good, reliable, affordable childcare.

girlswillbegirls · 23/02/2024 08:09

@Calamitousness The OP posted a question here and people are giving different points of view. If she didn't have any doubt about what she is about to do, she wouldn't post it in a forum.

We have discussed risk, we have discuss responsibility. Also how men also deserve to enjoy their kids and not just be the sole breadwinners. It's deeper than "we made the decision as a couple". You can stop being a couple for various reasons and it happens, in fact all the time. It's for the OP and whoever is reading this that our point of view might be valuable.

Calamitousness · 23/02/2024 07:29

Here’s a thought. How about people
can be different and some split their outgoings equally with equal responsibility then save the rest as their own money ( which I don’t understand) some can proportionally represent their earning power to contribute to family outgoings (again to me bizarre but each to their own) or some families can operate as one and whatever income is completely shared whomever is working whatever hours and they decide amongst themselves if one chooses to stay home or both work full time or a full/part time combo. But ultimately it’s individual couples shared decision making how the household and finances work. That’s actual life. Nobody needs all the you should do it my way because it’s not fair to the other partner blah blah. Other partner is part of the shared decision making in how their family works. He/she doesn’t need a random on the internet being all paternalistic for them. So you do you. And if circumstances ever change for whatever reason then your shared decisions can change.

FatPrincess · 22/02/2024 22:04

BananaPalm · 22/02/2024 21:38

@SouthLondonMum22 Surely the aim should be for both people to really enjoy their lives? I couldn't imagine opting out of financial responsibility to 'really enjoy' my life whilst watching the person I'm supposed to love work like a dog for 35 years.

Couldn't agree more. If a man said "is it ok for me to not to work and let my wife support me" I'm sure he wouldn't be met with all this "yeah, just quit your job and live off your wife".

Either you're an adult who has an equal responsibility for sustaining yours and your children's lives (emotionally, physically, financially, etc) or you're just another child yourself. I'm obviously excluding any disabilities or people just rich enough not to have to have to work.

Once the finances are shared, though, it becomes 'our' money. The royal 'we'.

"We earn enough that I don't need to work".

BananaPalm · 22/02/2024 21:38

@SouthLondonMum22 Surely the aim should be for both people to really enjoy their lives? I couldn't imagine opting out of financial responsibility to 'really enjoy' my life whilst watching the person I'm supposed to love work like a dog for 35 years.

Couldn't agree more. If a man said "is it ok for me to not to work and let my wife support me" I'm sure he wouldn't be met with all this "yeah, just quit your job and live off your wife".

Either you're an adult who has an equal responsibility for sustaining yours and your children's lives (emotionally, physically, financially, etc) or you're just another child yourself. I'm obviously excluding any disabilities or people just rich enough not to have to have to work.

OneMoreTime23 · 22/02/2024 20:30

LorlieS · 22/02/2024 18:06

@girlswillbegirls Absolutely. To me it's total double standards here.

I’ve just been fish-hooked on another thread for suggesting the main earning mum continue working and dad go part time. 🤷🏻‍♀️

FatPrincess · 22/02/2024 19:52

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/02/2024 18:52

Surely the aim should be for both people to really enjoy their lives? I couldn't imagine opting out of financial responsibility to 'really enjoy' my life whilst watching the person I'm supposed to love work like a dog for 35 years.

Well, I agree. It's a massive female privilege to have that choice but say that on here and you'll be chased with pitchforks! 🤣

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/02/2024 18:52

FatPrincess · 22/02/2024 11:38

Well, like most things that offer reward there's a risk element. Maybe he leaves you for a younger model and you struggle financially. Or maybe he doesn't and you quit full time work at 30yo and get to really enjoy your life while he works another 35 years.

Surely the aim should be for both people to really enjoy their lives? I couldn't imagine opting out of financial responsibility to 'really enjoy' my life whilst watching the person I'm supposed to love work like a dog for 35 years.