Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to work?

737 replies

howdypartnerrr · 16/02/2024 11:45

I worked full time until having DC, and part time since youngest DC was a few months old.

I just don't want to do it anymore. The amount I bring home is minimal.. and I find I'm spending my days off doing housework and just not having the energy to take DC to toddler groups etc. my youngest would start school in sept 2026.. so I'm thinking about just quitting until then. DH says it's up to me as my money just goes into my bank, I don't contribute to any bills so it wouldn't affect the household. My job is quite stressful.. and other more relaxed jobs involved working weekends etc and I did that with eldest dc, working weekends, Christmas Eve, Easter Sunday etc. don't want to do it again.

What do you think?

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 19/02/2024 15:21

greendaisie · 19/02/2024 15:17

Why are you all scaremongering the op like this? There are as many, probably way more actual stories that go like this:

-She doesn't really like her job. Reduces hours first but still thinks not the same as being SAHM.

-She ditches the job and for the first few years while kids are small do many playdates and experiences that makes her feel its all worth it. Big difference to the kids and you "only live once"

-The husband is very happy with the arrangement. Dinners done. House tidy. Someone to look after kids when sick/ school closed. He concentrates in his career and progresses easily while she tells everyone they are a "team"

-A few more years in kids in late primary. She still stays as a SAHM. They still need her and it's all good for the family.

  • The husband and his wife remain happily married and, after their children grow up, they embark on a fun and happy retirement together.

Just as I thought. You only want the people who you disagree with to stop discussing it.

MixedCouple · 19/02/2024 15:19

I was lucky once I got married to quit my Job. Worked since I was 16 and stopped mid thirties.
Now with DC no way I want to go back.
DH covers all finances plus my spending and working would mean time away from DC.
Maybe will go back once they have flown the nest but no rush at all.

wontforget · 19/02/2024 15:18

Why are you all scaremongering the op like this?

have you actually read the thread?

Loads have said to the OP that she should go for it

greendaisie · 19/02/2024 15:17

Why are you all scaremongering the op like this? There are as many, probably way more actual stories that go like this:

-She doesn't really like her job. Reduces hours first but still thinks not the same as being SAHM.

-She ditches the job and for the first few years while kids are small do many playdates and experiences that makes her feel its all worth it. Big difference to the kids and you "only live once"

-The husband is very happy with the arrangement. Dinners done. House tidy. Someone to look after kids when sick/ school closed. He concentrates in his career and progresses easily while she tells everyone they are a "team"

-A few more years in kids in late primary. She still stays as a SAHM. They still need her and it's all good for the family.

  • The husband and his wife remain happily married and, after their children grow up, they embark on a fun and happy retirement together.
wontforget · 19/02/2024 15:16

howdypartnerrr · 19/02/2024 12:42

Omg each to their own!! If you want to be a SAHM ladies, that's ok! It affects no one else in the world but you and your family!
If you want to be a career woman working in a big city earning mega bucks and putting your children in childcare.. that's fine too! If you want to work in a cafe/pub/shop.. also fine!

I just asked if people think I should leave my job as it's affecting my MH.. please can we stop with the debate.

OP good grief

you have clearly made your decision

So… why keep coming back?

Have you handed in your notice yet?

TinyTeachr · 19/02/2024 15:14

OK, you soind like your job makes you (and the rest of the family, sometimes) pretty miserable. It doesn't bring in muxh money either.

To me that's a no-brained. Quit! Your DH has also said had support that position.

What you do after that is a personal choice. You could retrain for another job, or be a SAHM. There are pros and cons to both, but you have the luxury of time to make that decsion as you have a DH who earns well and will supporr you.

It doesn't matter what suits other families. It's about what suits you. Quit the lousy job now, spend the time with your young children and when you are feeling less stressed you'll be able to think about long term plans.

SouthLondonMum22 · 19/02/2024 15:14

greendaisie · 19/02/2024 14:17

@SouthLondonMum22 despite the op asking several times to avoid debating the pros and cons of SAHP you continue to be very vocal in your feminist views.

Op, good luck with your decision and hopefully you'll feel happier and less stressed soon.

Which you've also done. As have several others, I'm not sure why you are only naming me or what your point actually is? Other than trying to silence me because you don't agree with me and well, good luck with that.

Ultimately, this is AIBU and debate is common. OP's rarely get to control how the comments go.

Amumof287 · 19/02/2024 15:12

CagneyAndLazy · 19/02/2024 10:32

My husband had no problem supporting my family for a short time.

And perhaps you could now pick up the slack and support the family and he could take time off and get into fitness, etc?

Sounds a great way to live, to be honest.

He earns double what I could ever earn and he loves work. He’s ambitious and thrives on climbing the ladder which he has done. He has loads of time for fitness. Not everyone hates their job. He loves his and he loves me working part time so we spend all of our weekend/evenings doing what we want- spending time with the kids, fitness and socialising.

We’re really happy with our setup. I will certainly be picking up plenty of shifts now that I’m back and will be contributing more than I what I was previously as my hourly rate is significantly more doing agency work. The reason for the 0 hour contract is one of our child has significant health needs so that allows me to cancel work at short notice when he’s in hospital or poorly.

OP should do what is right for her and her family and her children. I will never regret taking that time off with my toddler

girlswillbegirls · 19/02/2024 14:54

OP please. Have a look at Mumsnet daily entries.
It's like this:

-She doesn't really like her job. Reduces hours first but still thinks not the same as being SAHM.

-She ditches the job and for the first few years while kids are small do many playdates and experiences that makes her feel its all worth it. Big difference to the kids and you "only live once"

-The husband is very happy with the arrangement. Dinners done. House tidy. Someone to look after kids when sick/ school closed. He concentrates in his career and progresses easily while she tells everyone they are a "team"

-A few more years in kids in late primary. She still stays as a SAHM. They still need her and it's all good for the family.

-One of these happens: He finds someone/ loses interest/ starts with an addition/ has a breakdown after being promoted again/ mental illness/ health illness.

The dream team is gone

-She panicks. Looks for a job but after x amount of years she can only get an entry level job. Shit.

I am a bit older than you OP. I have seen the above umpteen times.
Retrain now with the idea of moving to a job that will pay you well. But start retraining now and get a job just afterwards.
Do not make the mistake most women make. Your issue is that you are in a low paid job that you hate. Change but change now.
Abandoning the workforce is never the answer.

Debtfreegoals · 19/02/2024 14:53

Sounds like you’ve already made up your mind - at the end of the day it’s really what’s best for your family. I didn’t have the choice because we needed two incomes but if you feel it’s not needed, then do what’s best for your children.

greendaisie · 19/02/2024 14:17

@SouthLondonMum22 despite the op asking several times to avoid debating the pros and cons of SAHP you continue to be very vocal in your feminist views.

Op, good luck with your decision and hopefully you'll feel happier and less stressed soon.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 19/02/2024 14:17

My only caveat would be that I would want access to household money. If you're working it that DH works and you are home with the children, you're each contributing to your joint life and so shouldn't have to wait for him to hand his card over if you buy anything.
I wouldn't see it as spending his money, you'll be working full time looking after children and a home, it's just unpaid.

Once your youngest goes to school, you could look at school jobs. TA's in my SEN provision aren't on the best of wages, but they are term time and weekday which fits in with their children and lives.

CagneyAndLazy · 19/02/2024 14:13

SouthLondonMum22 · 19/02/2024 12:32

Your post is also typical of someone claiming not to be sexist but every other comment is actually sexist. Of course you think it should be the woman.

It's incredibly lazy to suggest that a woman who works is jealous of a SAHM or feels guilty. It also implies that no woman works by choice which just simply isn't true.

It's also obvious that you have little to no experience of nurseries and again, are resorting to lazy generalisations that simply aren't true.

Exactly.

Man not working = cocklodger.

Woman not working = perfectly fine and "just enjoy your children!" is all the justification needed.

AmethystSparkles · 19/02/2024 13:55

Of course you should stay at home. You’ll be happier and everyone around you will be happier.

SouthLondonMum22 · 19/02/2024 13:52

Bouledeneige · 19/02/2024 13:14

I think working women always feel guilty and think they could do better. They are spinning a lot of plates but clearly think in the balance of things it's worth it financially (or they gave no choice financially) but also for purpose and reward, to use their skills, education and knowledge. Both my DC were quite shy when little and you can always ask yourself if they would have been different if I'd stayed home. But would I have been a happy Mum staying home and what would I have done with myself when they went to school full time? I hate housework!

Despite those fears and guilt I am lucky that both my DC are confident and fulfilled young adults - who just happen to be proud of my achievements. My DD said once to her Dad 'I'd like to be like Mummy when I grow up - a boss at work, a lovely fun Mum with lots of friends.'

I'm not saying this to diss staying at home. I've missed out on lots of things but I've also had a really exciting life. There is no perfect right answer. And kids don't know what life would have been like the other way and make their own assessment of you as a parent on their own criteria. I wouldn't want to live your life or you mine. That's fine.

I am on my own now. But I'm independent and have a good life and future pension. So be it.

I don't feel guilty. There's really nothing to feel guilty about, just as my husband doesn't feel guilty for working either.

I do think societal pressure means that working women are more likely to feel guilty which is why ''mum guilt'' is a thing but you don't really hear about ''dad guilt''.

Caerulea · 19/02/2024 13:40

Leave the job, look after your small ppl. Your hubby actually sounds very very supportive in leaving this entirely in your own hands with no pressure.

It will be better for, your kids & your marriage. You'll be happier.

I'd say this regardless of the income tbh (I'm SE but atm won't even be making minimum wage), I do think it's more important to be happy & for your kids to be happy. So even if you were scraping by financially by you being a SAHM (I've done that, my parents did that - without government support too) I'd say the same. But that's not even a concern for you, so stop 😊

tattygrl · 19/02/2024 13:17

I think that following what you feel you need (and are safely able to do) is sensible and worth it.
Stopping paid work for a period of time is not the same as saying "I'm going to surrender my sovereignty and financial stability to my male partner forever".

Taking this time off paid work might give you the rejuvenation you need to re-evaluate things, enjoy time at home and with your family, and see what ideas you have for your future/what opportunities arise.

Bouledeneige · 19/02/2024 13:14

I think working women always feel guilty and think they could do better. They are spinning a lot of plates but clearly think in the balance of things it's worth it financially (or they gave no choice financially) but also for purpose and reward, to use their skills, education and knowledge. Both my DC were quite shy when little and you can always ask yourself if they would have been different if I'd stayed home. But would I have been a happy Mum staying home and what would I have done with myself when they went to school full time? I hate housework!

Despite those fears and guilt I am lucky that both my DC are confident and fulfilled young adults - who just happen to be proud of my achievements. My DD said once to her Dad 'I'd like to be like Mummy when I grow up - a boss at work, a lovely fun Mum with lots of friends.'

I'm not saying this to diss staying at home. I've missed out on lots of things but I've also had a really exciting life. There is no perfect right answer. And kids don't know what life would have been like the other way and make their own assessment of you as a parent on their own criteria. I wouldn't want to live your life or you mine. That's fine.

I am on my own now. But I'm independent and have a good life and future pension. So be it.

Unicorntearsofgin · 19/02/2024 12:53

howdypartnerrr · 19/02/2024 09:47

@Unicorntearsofgin Thank you. A lady I worked with passed her radiography last year, and was told she would not be getting a pay rise for passing it - even though she helps out doing OPG's for the dentists. She is still on £10.50ph Sad

That’s really bad! I promise lots of dentists will pay for your training and pay you fairly for extra skills. However not to sidetrack but if you want to take time out do it just keep your GDC number up x

howdypartnerrr · 19/02/2024 12:42

Omg each to their own!! If you want to be a SAHM ladies, that's ok! It affects no one else in the world but you and your family!
If you want to be a career woman working in a big city earning mega bucks and putting your children in childcare.. that's fine too! If you want to work in a cafe/pub/shop.. also fine!

I just asked if people think I should leave my job as it's affecting my MH.. please can we stop with the debate.

OP posts:
Justifiedcheese · 19/02/2024 12:37

MidnightPatrol · 16/02/2024 12:09

All good and well if your relationship doesn't fall apart.

Or if your DH loses his job. Happened to us, my job was vital in keeping us afloat.

ElaineMBenes · 19/02/2024 12:34

Wallywalks · 19/02/2024 12:10

My husband also regrets the time he missed by going to work but as you have highlighted someone has to do it. I couldn't care less if it is the husband or wife who stays at home. I'm simply pointing out that the op's family earns £80,000 which is quite sufficient for anyone to live on. Any more than that is for extras, luxuries. National insurance contributions aren't an issue as she has young children. I'm objecting to people only commenting on the chance of divorce leaving them having to support themselves when there are other things that are lost by working. Most SAHMs don't feel confident to tell working parents what their children have missed out on and I won't do it either. However, I notice working parents are always very quick to tell SAHMs and anyone who will listen how happy their children are at nursery/endless wraparound care, how well they've come on etc etc. There is a big barrier that SAHMs aren't allowed to say what we think because there is a big outcry that "aren't we the lucky" ones and that they "couldn't afford it". It is mostly middle class people whose husband's earn way more than mine, who come out with this tripe and who want to have a massive pension so they can retire in style but feel guilty for working and leaving their kids with the youngsters who couldn't pass their own school exams. This is a generalisation but it's largely true. This is the first time I have ever commented on a post and I won't be doing it again but your reply is very typical of the resentment that those who choose to care for their own children face.

No, I have absolutely no issue with people who chose to be a SAHP. It is a perfectly valid choice. Unlike you, I won't tell any woman that her choices around work and childcare are wrong.

I do, however, have a HUGE issue with people telling women to stop working for luxuries when in fact they are simply providing for their family financially in the same way that men do. Yet men do this without the implication they are working for frivolities.

And please tell me what my child has missed out on because I chose to work? Spoiler alert....nothing!

And yes, having a decent pension is important. I don't want to live in poverty when retire.

SouthLondonMum22 · 19/02/2024 12:32

Wallywalks · 19/02/2024 12:10

My husband also regrets the time he missed by going to work but as you have highlighted someone has to do it. I couldn't care less if it is the husband or wife who stays at home. I'm simply pointing out that the op's family earns £80,000 which is quite sufficient for anyone to live on. Any more than that is for extras, luxuries. National insurance contributions aren't an issue as she has young children. I'm objecting to people only commenting on the chance of divorce leaving them having to support themselves when there are other things that are lost by working. Most SAHMs don't feel confident to tell working parents what their children have missed out on and I won't do it either. However, I notice working parents are always very quick to tell SAHMs and anyone who will listen how happy their children are at nursery/endless wraparound care, how well they've come on etc etc. There is a big barrier that SAHMs aren't allowed to say what we think because there is a big outcry that "aren't we the lucky" ones and that they "couldn't afford it". It is mostly middle class people whose husband's earn way more than mine, who come out with this tripe and who want to have a massive pension so they can retire in style but feel guilty for working and leaving their kids with the youngsters who couldn't pass their own school exams. This is a generalisation but it's largely true. This is the first time I have ever commented on a post and I won't be doing it again but your reply is very typical of the resentment that those who choose to care for their own children face.

Your post is also typical of someone claiming not to be sexist but every other comment is actually sexist. Of course you think it should be the woman.

It's incredibly lazy to suggest that a woman who works is jealous of a SAHM or feels guilty. It also implies that no woman works by choice which just simply isn't true.

It's also obvious that you have little to no experience of nurseries and again, are resorting to lazy generalisations that simply aren't true.

Tryingandfailingagain · 19/02/2024 12:20

This reads as nothing really to do with money, and everything to do with lack of aspiration, independence and/or work ethic. Have you tried moving to another practice? You’re only working 2 days a week, honestly, I am really struggling to see how you’re too tired to take dc to toddler groups.

LorlieS · 19/02/2024 12:19

@Wallywalks So you're saying families with two working parents are only doing so to afford a luxurious lifestyle?