Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to ask how elderly grandparents have dealt with trans grandkids

222 replies

Lenalovewitch · 15/02/2024 12:57

My niece who is 15 is visiting from the US at Easter. DN is clearly gay and has recently also identified as a trans boy adopting a gender neutral name and third psn pronouns. My DS is dealing with it well and being as supportive as poss to DN. DN is possibly autistic and struggles socially which seems often the case for young people identifying as trans. Sorry if i am getting the terminology wrong it's a minefield. The situation has been explained now to our DPs. They are in their 80s, conservative and religious. DM is now freaking a bit about the visit and struggling to accept it. One part of me feels DN should just not make a bit deal of it as it's just a week and they are v old but this doesn't seem to be the way of things. Everyone is now is very apprehensive in advance of the visit. DN gets furious if referred to as she or her birth name which is going to be tough if the GPs/ we get it wrong. Anyone been through this with trans teenagers- how did the GPs react .

OP posts:
LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 16:58

TheKeatingFive · 15/02/2024 16:54

And accordingly if we met in real life I'd probably think you were a very unpleasant rude and self-obsessed individual

For what reason?

For applying pronoun use to sex? Or for not believing humans can change sex?

No, because if you decided to misgender me, you'd be making a very deliberate choice to be rude and disrespectful to me as an individual. Much as if I decided henceforth to address you as Mrs Cockwomble because I'm under the mistaken impression that what I've decided I want to call you is the most important factor in our interactions and is sacrosanct and you can't possibly tell me it's rude or you're "compelling my speech".

ItsFunToBeAVampire · 15/02/2024 17:02

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 16:58

No, because if you decided to misgender me, you'd be making a very deliberate choice to be rude and disrespectful to me as an individual. Much as if I decided henceforth to address you as Mrs Cockwomble because I'm under the mistaken impression that what I've decided I want to call you is the most important factor in our interactions and is sacrosanct and you can't possibly tell me it's rude or you're "compelling my speech".

So if someone doesn't use pronouns at all or uses they, you'd complain about them?

Bleakmidwinter1977 · 15/02/2024 17:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

The use of the term "self-obsessed" is interesting here. The vast majority of people don't have the time to indulge in questioning whether of not they are what they actually are. This is what self-obsession implies - to be obsessively pre-occupied with oneself.

TheKeatingFive · 15/02/2024 17:02

No, because if you decided to misgender me, you'd be making a very deliberate choice to be rude and disrespectful to me as an individual.

Ive explained that misgendering doesn't make sense to me as a concept - I've always used pronouns to refer to sex.

If you call me the wrong name, I'd just see that as a bit silly. I'm not going to report you or anything - it just makes things difficult if you're trying to get my attention.

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 17:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 17:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I don't think that @TheKeatingFive IS the outlier.

I think what you are saying that if a person refers you to as being the sex they see you as rather than the gender you identify as you think you have the right to call them back any rude name you want to?

Have I understood that right?

Bleakmidwinter1977 · 15/02/2024 17:13

TheKeatingFive · 15/02/2024 17:02

No, because if you decided to misgender me, you'd be making a very deliberate choice to be rude and disrespectful to me as an individual.

Ive explained that misgendering doesn't make sense to me as a concept - I've always used pronouns to refer to sex.

If you call me the wrong name, I'd just see that as a bit silly. I'm not going to report you or anything - it just makes things difficult if you're trying to get my attention.

Stepping in here after reading back through the thread.
I understand this of the conversation:

  1. Gender is not the same as sex.
  2. You can change your gender but not your sex.
  3. No one here buys into gender stereotypes, so no-one really cares how you present yourself in terms of appearance.
  4. Your name affirms your gender.
  5. He/she affirms your sex.
  6. Gender affirming care implies presenting yourself as the other sex (but you can't change your sex).

Makes zero sense.

TomeTome · 15/02/2024 17:14

I think most people call people by their name or nickname or title they’ve asked but use the pronouns to describe their sex.

Dogfisher · 15/02/2024 17:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

No need to be so rude and sweary. I was explaining my feelings about gender stereotypes because it seems that trans ideology is based on adherence to gender stereotypes and little else.

Also I have never once implied that I would treat you with anything less than respect as I do the actual trans people that I know.

I do not claim to speak for you in any way - not sure where you get that from my post?

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 17:21

Bleakmidwinter1977 · 15/02/2024 17:13

Stepping in here after reading back through the thread.
I understand this of the conversation:

  1. Gender is not the same as sex.
  2. You can change your gender but not your sex.
  3. No one here buys into gender stereotypes, so no-one really cares how you present yourself in terms of appearance.
  4. Your name affirms your gender.
  5. He/she affirms your sex.
  6. Gender affirming care implies presenting yourself as the other sex (but you can't change your sex).

Makes zero sense.

Well no because what you've done there is quote a bunch of different points made by different people who aren't all making the same arguments and don't all have the same beliefs. And you've even added in a few extra points that no one made as far as I can see for good measure.

Bleakmidwinter1977 · 15/02/2024 17:23

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 17:21

Well no because what you've done there is quote a bunch of different points made by different people who aren't all making the same arguments and don't all have the same beliefs. And you've even added in a few extra points that no one made as far as I can see for good measure.

It would be interesting to know which parts I got wrong?

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 17:24

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 17:13

I don't think that @TheKeatingFive IS the outlier.

I think what you are saying that if a person refers you to as being the sex they see you as rather than the gender you identify as you think you have the right to call them back any rude name you want to?

Have I understood that right?

No, I'm simply abiding by their own stated rules that I want to call them is more important than what they prefer to be called.

Naunet · 15/02/2024 17:24

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 16:58

No, because if you decided to misgender me, you'd be making a very deliberate choice to be rude and disrespectful to me as an individual. Much as if I decided henceforth to address you as Mrs Cockwomble because I'm under the mistaken impression that what I've decided I want to call you is the most important factor in our interactions and is sacrosanct and you can't possibly tell me it's rude or you're "compelling my speech".

It’s not rude or disrespectful to use pronouns that reflect someone’s sex. We don’t all believe in gender, and pronouns have always been sex based until about 10 years ago. Forcing someone to use a new gender system absolutely is compelled speech.

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 17:26

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 17:24

No, I'm simply abiding by their own stated rules that I want to call them is more important than what they prefer to be called.

Really? Because to the observer it seems like you are punishing someone for not going along with your belief system.

Rather like if the OP 's niece tantrums if her grandparents slip up.

It all seems exactly like compelled speech to me. You can believe what you like but you are retaliating because a person doesn't share your belief.

SerenChocolateMuncher · 15/02/2024 17:43

Naunet · 15/02/2024 17:24

It’s not rude or disrespectful to use pronouns that reflect someone’s sex. We don’t all believe in gender, and pronouns have always been sex based until about 10 years ago. Forcing someone to use a new gender system absolutely is compelled speech.

I agree.

Furthermore, only a woman can be a trans-man, so referring to a transman as she/her is not misgendering.

I know a few transmen and in all honesty, not one of them would pass as an actual man. Their wispy little beards don't fool anyone.

So, even if they can persuade everyone they know to refer them as he/him, they will still be "misgendered" by

  1. Strangers
  2. People who believe the evidence of their eyes
  3. People who are unaware that they want to be identified as men
  4. People who don't want to play the gender game.
That's the reality. Not because the world is filled with hateful transphobes, but because most trans people are unconvincing as the opposite sex and the rest of us are not compelled by law or morality to participate in this pretence.
pearlydewdroptwins · 15/02/2024 17:46

"Indeed, a courtesy, not an obligation."

@Bleakmidwinter1977 getting back to the OP, I think courtesy between GPs and their grandchild and of course extended family is what is important here. Grandchild is autistic, visiting from another country, so I don't feel a huge discussion about trans and feminism is needed at that point, nor would I suspect would it be welcome. I'm sure the grandparents would after all like to enjoy their visit with their grandchild and son (hence the OP's post in the first place!).

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 17:50

Besides pronouns are the thin end of the wedge.

Compelling pronouns is essential if you want society to treat gender as more important than sex.

A few years ago I would have been more willing to 'be kind' because I wasn't as aware of the harms that flow from using incorrect sex pronouns.

Now it's clear that calling males she is part of the ideology that has led to women being harmed by males in what should be single sex spaces for women and that socially transitioning children by using preferred pronouns has led to harms which are clearly set out in the Cass independent review of gender identity services for children.

pearlydewdroptwins · 15/02/2024 17:53

TheKeatingFive · 15/02/2024 17:02

No, because if you decided to misgender me, you'd be making a very deliberate choice to be rude and disrespectful to me as an individual.

Ive explained that misgendering doesn't make sense to me as a concept - I've always used pronouns to refer to sex.

If you call me the wrong name, I'd just see that as a bit silly. I'm not going to report you or anything - it just makes things difficult if you're trying to get my attention.

How would you know which sex Leftlion is if they present as male when you first meet with no knowledge that they'd transitioned? Surely it's not down to biological sex but down to how someone presents?

TheKeatingFive · 15/02/2024 17:56

How would you know which sex Leftlion is if they present as male when you first meet with no knowledge that they'd transitioned?

To be perfectly honest, I'm not sure many people pass in real life. Even if they do, there are lots of potential problems for other people if sex is misreoresenred, so I don't think this is a good situation to create.

Bleakmidwinter1977 · 15/02/2024 17:57

pearlydewdroptwins · 15/02/2024 17:53

How would you know which sex Leftlion is if they present as male when you first meet with no knowledge that they'd transitioned? Surely it's not down to biological sex but down to how someone presents?

I was under the impression that being a male was related to sex, not gender.
Where do the people stand who believe gender is intrinsically related to sex?

pearlydewdroptwins · 15/02/2024 18:00

Bleakmidwinter1977 · 15/02/2024 17:57

I was under the impression that being a male was related to sex, not gender.
Where do the people stand who believe gender is intrinsically related to sex?

That's why I said presented as male.

What pronouns would you use?

ilovesooty · 15/02/2024 18:01

Bleakmidwinter1977 · 15/02/2024 16:58

Indeed, a courtesy, not an obligation.

No one said it was an obligation. Of course manners are generally appreciated.

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 18:04

pearlydewdroptwins · 15/02/2024 18:00

That's why I said presented as male.

What pronouns would you use?

Honestly the way I feel about the assault that genderism has had on women's rights and the harms it does to children if the person presented as male but was female I'd either avoid pronouns altogether or just correctly sex them.

I know it's not me you asked and I can't speak for anyone else but I'm getting mightily riled that society is expected to go on to be kind to gender believers even though the harms to women and children have become clear.

SerenChocolateMuncher · 15/02/2024 18:05

pearlydewdroptwins · 15/02/2024 17:53

How would you know which sex Leftlion is if they present as male when you first meet with no knowledge that they'd transitioned? Surely it's not down to biological sex but down to how someone presents?

Because the vast majority of trans people are unconvincing as the opposite sex. I know quite a few trans people and none of them would fool anyone.

Dweetfidilove · 15/02/2024 18:09

They can call her by her chosen name and limit further conversation/keep everything as generic as possible if she’ll get furious at being called the wrong pronoun etc.

I call all the children in my family the wrong name, he for she, she for he; so it would probably be best I keep schtum around someone who gets quite furious with this 🤷🏽‍♀️.

Swipe left for the next trending thread