Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to ask how elderly grandparents have dealt with trans grandkids

222 replies

Lenalovewitch · 15/02/2024 12:57

My niece who is 15 is visiting from the US at Easter. DN is clearly gay and has recently also identified as a trans boy adopting a gender neutral name and third psn pronouns. My DS is dealing with it well and being as supportive as poss to DN. DN is possibly autistic and struggles socially which seems often the case for young people identifying as trans. Sorry if i am getting the terminology wrong it's a minefield. The situation has been explained now to our DPs. They are in their 80s, conservative and religious. DM is now freaking a bit about the visit and struggling to accept it. One part of me feels DN should just not make a bit deal of it as it's just a week and they are v old but this doesn't seem to be the way of things. Everyone is now is very apprehensive in advance of the visit. DN gets furious if referred to as she or her birth name which is going to be tough if the GPs/ we get it wrong. Anyone been through this with trans teenagers- how did the GPs react .

OP posts:
Dogfisher · 15/02/2024 15:20

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 15:15

"I don't have a problem with trans people, they can do what they want as long as they don't dare actually be trans" is the message you're putting across here.

No, I think that she is saying that trans people should respect the rights of others as I am sure the vast majority of them do.

But we must be able to say that no human being can change sex and that men (however they identify) have no place in women's single sex spaces. Compassion works both ways and women and girls are vulnerable in ours society.
I would be surprised for example if any FtM teen used men's loos - now why would that be? Safeguarding is a thing and vulnerable teens like the one in the OP must be protected.

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 15:20

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 15:15

"I don't have a problem with trans people, they can do what they want as long as they don't dare actually be trans" is the message you're putting across here.

I don't want to launch into an argument with you but I believe that people can wear what they want and present as they wish without making demands of others to go along with their beliefs.

As it is impossible for anyone to change sex, males who identify as trans should be respectful that they are not women and should stay out of women's single sex spaces to respect the safety and dignity of women.

Respect works both ways.

Ladybrrrd · 15/02/2024 15:20

Three people in a row perpetuating this stupid idea that trans people think they are changing sex or that that they don't understand their own biology. It's trans gender, it's about their gender. A gender is a thing that people may or may not believe in. No one's forcing you to believe that their sex has changed (and if they have changed any secondary sex characteristics it's none of your business).

What they're asking is to acknowledge how they'd like to be addressed. Like if someone has a nickname that prefer, or uses their middle name. My mate has two names which he switches between depending on what company we're in. It's not difficult to remember. It's a courtesy, even if I know what's on his birth certificate.

Whatevershallidowithmylife · 15/02/2024 15:21

DM is 83 and would just roll her eyes at this - as I would. Lot of nonsense - only when someone has had a sex change would we believe they are something other than what sec they’re born as.

Laiste · 15/02/2024 15:21

It's about finding the comfortable line between being polite (using the chosen name) and how far you're being asking them to go along with a make believe world.

Will they be expected to not allude to anything about the child's past at all?

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 15:22

Ladybrrrd · 15/02/2024 15:20

Three people in a row perpetuating this stupid idea that trans people think they are changing sex or that that they don't understand their own biology. It's trans gender, it's about their gender. A gender is a thing that people may or may not believe in. No one's forcing you to believe that their sex has changed (and if they have changed any secondary sex characteristics it's none of your business).

What they're asking is to acknowledge how they'd like to be addressed. Like if someone has a nickname that prefer, or uses their middle name. My mate has two names which he switches between depending on what company we're in. It's not difficult to remember. It's a courtesy, even if I know what's on his birth certificate.

Ok well, if it's to do with gender all's good.

Males who identify as woman gender should know that they have no place in women's single sex spaces.

myphoneisbroken · 15/02/2024 15:22

Lots of transphobic remarks on this thread - what a surprise.

Just to say that my parents (late 70s/80s) have been fantastic with DC who is trans. I am sure they have their own thoughts on this, but have chosen to prioritise their relationship with DC. Of course they sometimes get the name/pronoun wrong but DC never takes offence because they know the GPs are loving and doing their best.

SomeCatFromJapan · 15/02/2024 15:23

Three people in a row perpetuating this stupid idea that trans people think they are changing sexor that that they don't understand their own biology. It's transgender, it's about theirgender. A gender is a thing that people may or may not believe in. No one's forcing you to believe that their sex has changed (and if they have changed any secondary sex characteristics it's none of your business).

Judging by the amount of transwomen on X/Reddit claiming to have period symptoms, they seem to actually believe they are changing sex in some cases.

Dogfisher · 15/02/2024 15:24

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 15:18

I know multiple trans men who transitioned in their 30s, 40s, and even 50s. Trans men in general tend to be less visible, but just because you personally aren't seeing it doesn't mean it doesn't exist.

But you are presumably aware that MtF late transitioners far outweigh numbers of middle aged women transitioning?

And also that many more teenage girls transition than teenage boys - these girls are really, really vulnerable.

Dogfisher · 15/02/2024 15:25

Lots of transphobic remarks on this thread - what a surprise

Please do report as MN are (rightfully) hot on this and will remove the posts.

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 15:27

Dogfisher · 15/02/2024 15:24

But you are presumably aware that MtF late transitioners far outweigh numbers of middle aged women transitioning?

And also that many more teenage girls transition than teenage boys - these girls are really, really vulnerable.

Every trans social or support group I've ever been a part of (and there've been a lot going back to the 90s - I'm one of these older trans men you think doesn't exist) has a pretty even mix of ftms and mtfs of all ages.

KimberleyClark · 15/02/2024 15:28

I can remember fully transitioned trans women back in the 70s e.g Jan Morris and April Ashley.

Dogfisher · 15/02/2024 15:29

Three people in a row perpetuating this stupid idea that trans people think they are changing sex or that that they don't understand their own biology

https://twitter.com/IndiaWilloughby/status/1559530487680569344?lang=en

https://twitter.com/IndiaWilloughby/status/1559530487680569344?lang=en

bellinisurge · 15/02/2024 15:30

She's gay. I presume they're ok with that. Why wouldn't they be?
Anything else is just window dressing.

makeanddo · 15/02/2024 15:31

Name change is not a big deal - I worked with a woman who changed her name as she didn't like her birth name. Many names can be male/female anyway. I would just try to remember.

I agee with others re pronouns though, it's compelled speech. The best way is to just use their name, slip ups are understandable.

I wonder what would happen if the child was told that Grandma and Grandad have changed their names and are now (insert any name). Is it ok if they go off on one if they are misgendered/misnamed etc?

The crux of this is the me me me and tantrums that seem to come along with all of this. If you want to identify as another gender and change your name, dress differently then crack on. It makes zero difference to me. BUT you can jog on if you think I'm going to play the 'a human can change sex' and are the opposite sex if they say so stupidity.

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 15:31

SomeCatFromJapan · 15/02/2024 15:23

Three people in a row perpetuating this stupid idea that trans people think they are changing sexor that that they don't understand their own biology. It's transgender, it's about theirgender. A gender is a thing that people may or may not believe in. No one's forcing you to believe that their sex has changed (and if they have changed any secondary sex characteristics it's none of your business).

Judging by the amount of transwomen on X/Reddit claiming to have period symptoms, they seem to actually believe they are changing sex in some cases.

Edited

Or maybe they're just reporting a genuine effect that taking oestrogen has on the human body? Taking testosterone has most certainly impacted my biology profoundly, of course it works the other way as well.

hariboss · 15/02/2024 15:32

those people crying transphobia, would you please copy and paste specific examples of this from the thread as I haven't seen any? Thanks.

DelusionalBrilliance · 15/02/2024 15:33

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 14:39

It's not "compelled speech" to call people what they prefer to be called, it's the basic minimum courtesy of polite society, and we do it all the time in all sorts of situations. I think it's a bit anachronistic when women take their husband's name when they marry, but I don't feel I'm entitled to simply continue calling them by their maiden name - it's obviously not up to me. There's a client at work I'd love to call a twat, is it "compelled speech" that I'm not allowed to use that language in the workplace (or at least not without consequences)? My BIL has a first name that I really loathe because it's the same name as one of my exes - is it "compelled speech" that I can't just arbitrarily decide to call him Stephen instead? We change what we call people and how we address people all the time, and there are so many situations in life where we can't just say exactly what we want to - if it only becomes "compelled speech" when there's a trans person involved that just sounds like you have a problem with trans people.

So… what you’re saying for example is, if BIL name is Ben, you call him Ben because he is Ben, and someone forcing others to call him something else, just because they don’t like the name Ben, would be compelled speech and forcing people to call him something he’s not?… interesting!

You say you can’t arbitrarily change his name, but you could arbitrarily change your own and force others to play along?

bellinisurge · 15/02/2024 15:34

If she has a tantrum because they use the wrong name, I would respectfully suggest she is at fault.

Ladybrrrd · 15/02/2024 15:35

SomeCatFromJapan · 15/02/2024 15:23

Three people in a row perpetuating this stupid idea that trans people think they are changing sexor that that they don't understand their own biology. It's transgender, it's about theirgender. A gender is a thing that people may or may not believe in. No one's forcing you to believe that their sex has changed (and if they have changed any secondary sex characteristics it's none of your business).

Judging by the amount of transwomen on X/Reddit claiming to have period symptoms, they seem to actually believe they are changing sex in some cases.

Edited

There's various trans women on reddit who are talking about symptoms such as mood, appetite, weight changes as a result of hormones, which is very believable. Not claiming they are actually menstruating, and many people weighing in to explain what may be happening. Not a suggestion they are changing sex. Does highlight a need for further study in to trans healthcare. Also plenty of trans people on Reddit who are firmly against calling them periods. You can find whatever opinion you want on Reddit. You can find GC people calling for the ban of all treatment of trans people of any age. Doesn't make it representative of an entire groups opinion.

Also, directed at another poster, some compelling and interesting portraits and interviews with older trans people of all kinds here. How silly to suggest that because you didn't know any trans men back then means they didn't exist!

https://www.tosurviveonthisshore.com/portraits

PORTRAITS — To Survive on this Shore

https://www.tosurviveonthisshore.com/portraits

myphoneisbroken · 15/02/2024 15:35

@hariboss If you can't see why posts are transphobic I'm not going to waste my time getting into it with you. I understand that people have the right to express GC views but the way they are being expressed on this thread is hateful (even if it has been normalised on the feminism: sex and gender boards). We are talking about a young person here.

hariboss · 15/02/2024 15:36

myphoneisbroken · 15/02/2024 15:35

@hariboss If you can't see why posts are transphobic I'm not going to waste my time getting into it with you. I understand that people have the right to express GC views but the way they are being expressed on this thread is hateful (even if it has been normalised on the feminism: sex and gender boards). We are talking about a young person here.

🤣🤣 that's the standard response. Every single time.
Makes me wonder why they're not mad keen to highlight and call out the specific examples of transphobia, if they exist?

RobertaFirmino · 15/02/2024 15:37

I don't see the name issue as being any different from when Rebecca asks you to use her full name as she hates being called Becky.

TomeTome · 15/02/2024 15:37

Changing your name or clothing isn’t anyone’s business really. Asking people to change the pronouns they use is more problematic because for most people they refer to your sex not what you are called or how you dress.

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 15:38

DelusionalBrilliance · 15/02/2024 15:33

So… what you’re saying for example is, if BIL name is Ben, you call him Ben because he is Ben, and someone forcing others to call him something else, just because they don’t like the name Ben, would be compelled speech and forcing people to call him something he’s not?… interesting!

You say you can’t arbitrarily change his name, but you could arbitrarily change your own and force others to play along?

No, I'm saying if he tells me his name is Ben I have no right to start calling him Stephen, and if I did he'd be perfectly reasonable to think I was being a dick and to not want much more to do with me.

Likewise if I told you my name, you'd have no business decided you weren't going to use it and wanted to call me something else instead. Likewise the person the OP describes.

Of course you could choose to call me something else - I can't actually compell your speech after all - but you couldn't expect me to not then think you were rude and unpleasant and for others to think so also.

Swipe left for the next trending thread