Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wishing DS was a little more like DD

154 replies

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 04:39

I have twins, not long turned 18, both in last year of sixth form. They are like chalk and cheese. I know neither of them are bad kids and I'm very lucky but sometimes I catch myself wishing DS was just a little more like DD.

Context

  • DD is predicted 4A* at A-Level, goes into school early most days to study and stays an hour late for supported study/independent study, she works her but off quite frankly
  • DD has a part time job, saves most of her weekly wage
  • DD keeps her room/car clean and tidy
  • DD is organised and responsible
  • DD has her flaws too though, she can be quite bitchy and a bit mean, definitely have issues with her being judgmental and a bit of a bully (especially when it comes to how people look)
  • DS is less motivated predicted BCC but claims he will get that up, needs AAB for his first choice uni!! He barely studies though so not sure how he's planning to get the grades up
  • DS had a job and quit, didn't like that his sister was earning more so thought the solution was to give up all together
  • DS is like a tornado, leaves a trail of destruction where ever he goes and can be quite lazy, not very organised either, relies on DD telling him his timetable everyday !!
  • On the other hand you won't meet a nicer funnier lad, he's great to be around just can't get his head screwed on!!

Now I know that being bitchy is an issue and we do call DD out but really I'm banking on the world putting DD in her place (DD has always been that kid that is good at everything and matched with her being very attractive by societies standards she can be quite a lot to handle, although her work ethic, drive, organisation and general ability to be on top of things can't be faulted). However I find DS much harder to parent now, we end up shouting over the mess he leaves (room is his problem but social space). While DD literally doesn't stop, always busy, DS never seems to start, some times it's like time moves slower in his world. Somehow DD has time for a job, study, sport, socialising and alone time, but DS seems to do none of that (I don't even know what he does seems to just sleep eat and go to school!!).

I guess it comes down to yes DD is a bit bitchy but she has a lot of respect for DH and I, and while the world seems to be on DDs side I'm not sure how I can help with that (other than calling her out whenever she makes a bitchy comment). She has friends, she works hard etc.
Where as for DS be needs a lot more parenting, and I was hoping by 18 he'd be a lot more self-sufficient than he is.

We never let on to the kids that this is how we feel but it does make me wish DS was a little more like DD.

AIBU for feeling this way? Anyone have any advice on how I can help either of them with the areas they need to work on?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Goatymum · 03/02/2024 08:51

Are you sure you haven’t got this the other way around?
Your DS sounds like a much nicer person, even if he is messy etc - most teens are! He may be harder to parent but his intrinsic personality sounds fine.
DD sounds like she’s full of herself and the bitchiness is unpleasant. You prob don’t know the half of it - is she a Queen Bee type? Fine if you’re good looking & clever - some people are, but the bitchiness doesn’t have to be a part of that. You don’t know if she’s bullied someone - there are levels of bullying even within friendship groups (exclusion).

Twilightstarbright · 03/02/2024 08:43

I got goosebumps reading this as you could be writing about me and my twin 20 years ago.

Turns out DB has ADHD which was why he found it hard to organise himself. He’s still a much nicer person than me. He’s now a secondary school teacher and fantastic at his job. He matured later than I did and despite my parents putting us in separate schools from 11 people still compared us. Once we hit adulthood there’s less comparison because it’s harder to compare life than it is GCSE results.

DB still needs more support from my parents though, but both seem happy to keep up that dynamic whereas I feel like my relationship with them is one of equal adults.

urbanbuddha · 02/02/2024 18:59

The problem DS is facing is his inability to focus on his studies. I wonder if he’s worried about missing his sister when she moves away. He’ll be out of her orbit, away from the sparkly person he loves who’s always the centre of attention.

Mazpaz · 02/02/2024 17:06

Why would you want your kids identical . Love them for who they are and stop being so judgemental. DD obviously takes this from you
it would be a boring world if we were all alike

RawBloomers · 02/02/2024 16:49

JMaggs93 · 02/02/2024 14:46

Can't quite grasp what I'm reading. As a mother, no matter how successful or academically advanced a child is, I'd much rather them be a kind and decent human being than be bitchy and a bit of a bully (even if it is towards her brother) whilst scoring straight As. Let's not forget that while she may go extremely far and be very successful in life, people don't like someone bitchy and judgemental. Sorry but YABU. Horrible post. Comparing two children and wanting one to be like the other. Just wow.

OP hasn't said the DS is kind and decent.

JMaggs93 · 02/02/2024 14:46

Can't quite grasp what I'm reading. As a mother, no matter how successful or academically advanced a child is, I'd much rather them be a kind and decent human being than be bitchy and a bit of a bully (even if it is towards her brother) whilst scoring straight As. Let's not forget that while she may go extremely far and be very successful in life, people don't like someone bitchy and judgemental. Sorry but YABU. Horrible post. Comparing two children and wanting one to be like the other. Just wow.

IWouldRatherBeOnHoliday · 02/02/2024 13:17

Feels like you're basically saying DD will go further in life in terms of social status/looks/power/influence/earning potential. If that is what you value in life, then I can see why her behaviours are less than desirable.

Your sons strop about earning less than DD suggests he does feel the weight of the comparisons between them. Have you considered that he might have decided its not worth trying if he never matches up to the favoured twin?

Mumto2kids86 · 02/02/2024 12:46

Everyone is different. Boys also mentally develop a little slower. Your son sounds like a nice guy. He might not be academic but being a good, decent guy will get you far in life.

Noglitterallowed · 02/02/2024 12:37

Your poor son! What a disgusting threat!

sounds quite obvious you’ve raised a bullying self entitled princess.

also if how your son is that much of an issue for you maybe the blame should lie at how he was brought up?? Ie- YOUR parenting??
or maybe lack there of as from your responses I’d guess you’d ploughed all your attention into the pretty/clever/popular/bitchy twin

UKAus · 02/02/2024 11:09

Absolutely, classic Narcissistic people do this. Learn manipulation early. Already has this mum wrapped around her finger.

UKAus · 02/02/2024 11:08

Rooting for scapegoat DS over golden child DD. So DD is bitchy and is awful to DS because she is not putting a foot wrong and needs to take this tightly wound individual out on someone else and clearly gets away with it, probably much worse than you are aware. She may crash and burn at Uni when she can't reach perfection anymore. DS seems the most standard and will do very well in life. How hard would it be to be a twin with the sister you describe. Having lots of friends isn't always a marker of success. A friend to many can be a friend to none. Personally more worried about your DD. And poor DS, sounds like DD has your ear. And children do know they are compared by parents, you just don't want to believe they do. Goodluck, hopefully DS knows he is welcome at home in the future.

Motnight · 02/02/2024 10:32

Bullies often are charismatic and charming. It helps keep the people that they are not bullying onside.

seasaltbarbie · 02/02/2024 10:15

Bitchy, mean and a bully are horrible traits. My cousin is like that and has lots of friends because she’s a mean girl and people are scared of here. She’s 22 now and it’s not cute, she’s horrible and has not so many people that like her anymore, even her own sister hates her. Give it a couple of years and people will realise your daughter isn’t nice and will avoid her.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 02/02/2024 10:12

My MIL regularly compares my DH with his younger brother. BIL is very motivated and wants to excel. DH is chilled and happy with what he has.

Over the years this has lead to DH being called "useless", "rubbish" etc, as a running joke in their family. It doesn't bother him because he takes it as a joke but it's not nice to hear. BIL is referred to as golden balls.

However, they both earn about the same. DHs job is actually much more responsible and "important" in the grand scheme of the world. He got there on his own terms in his own time.

DH is also genuinely happier in himself than BIL. It is screamingly obvious.

Between me and my sister, I am the high achiever. Massive differences. But she's the golden child. Different reasons, but everything she does gets celebrated and everything I do is expected and "could have been better".

It could go either way.

My point here is that grades and academic achievements, money etc aren't everything. Let your DS be who he is. And your DD. When they're in their 40s they'll be evenly matched happiness and there's not likely to be any talk of favourite or golden children.

You may not say it to them, but it will come across. And it will sting.

MorningSunshineSparkles · 02/02/2024 10:06

So your DD is bitchy and bullying only towards her brother, but she’s also charismatic and driven and sets incredibly high standards that she gets upset about when they’re not met. I’d be careful with those personality traits, often a form of sociopathy.

Mariposistaaa · 02/02/2024 10:04

I would definitely be more worried about DD. DS may not be academic but there are plenty of careers that don't require this. DD is more likely to become one of those overambitious women who make other colleagues' lives hell in the office as she bullies her way to the top of the ladder (working her butt off for her own gain). While DS may be in a less corporate job but will treat people with respect.
Sorry but DD's qualities don't impress me at all.

danesch · 02/02/2024 09:26

My b/g twins are a bit younger than yours (doing GCSEs). I have found it really interesting reading the comments from other teen twin parents on here, and agree with much of what they say.
I think YANnecesaarilyBU to want your son to work harder for his A Levels and develop a bit more resilience and drive. It sounds like there's a good chance that he will in time. I think YABtotallyU to say you wish he was more like your DD!
One of the things I keep stressing to my DTs is that ultimately they will make their own ways in the world. At the moment, they feel as though their lives are linked - who gets the higher mark in this test etc - but they are really not. DS will take his academic record, life skills and personality out into the world on his own, as will DD. I think it is really hard for close in age siblings, and especially twins, to see that in the intensity of growing up in a family, attending the same school etc, and you are really not helping by comparing them. I think growing up as a twin is really difficult - as parents, we need to try to make that easier where we can.
They are two people. It sounds as though both have many great qualities, and some things you would like them to work on. I think our job as parents is to support our kids as individuals to be the best versions of themselves. When they are twins, this is especially difficult, but especially important.

whatsmyname123 · 02/02/2024 09:02

I have no advice and don't want to seem too judgey but it reads as if your son is a nicer person though? Depends what you value more I suppose.
They're totally different people and there might be a time when your saying you'd like her to be more like him.
This is parenthood, we can't enjoy it all of the time 😂.

Ffs22 · 02/02/2024 08:59

I could never be proud of a bully, no matter how perfect they are in every other respect. I would be concentrating on working on these issues with her( if it’s not too late), rather than getting your DS to clean his room etc..
Well done for raising a kind son though. University will no doubt give him the shove he needs to gain more independence and life skills.

Terfarina · 02/02/2024 08:58

DD sounds like Regina George.

DS is bound to pick up on your negative feelings about him compared with his sister, poor lad.

DangerousAlchemy · 02/02/2024 08:56

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 09:06

@ohdamnitjanet

I'm sorry but why would you want to employ DS who

  • Quit because his sister was making more (and working more)
  • Doesn't know his own timetable 3 weeks into the 2nd term
  • Can't clean up after himself
  • Has no drive to succeed or study

Over DD who

  • Holds down a part time job and works overtime in holidays
  • Studies diligently
  • Is responsible and is able to plan her own time effectively
  • Is tidy and organised

If you are after a friend or someone to play Xbox with DS is your man.
If you want a good employee then it's DD hands down

Being nice doesn't make him a good employee and If you'd pick the lazy nice lad over the ambitious, driven hard working albeit a bit twatty at times girl then you're crazy!! I hope you don't have to hire anyone!

Why are you listing what you perceice to to be all the bad qualities of your son??? its not hard to see where your daughter got her judgemental nature from 🙄 this thread is bonkers. you say you never let your kids know which is your favourite but believe me they will know!! it's apparent in everything you've said so far. Your son is going to resent you forever if you carry on like this!!

Jeevesnotwooster · 02/02/2024 08:48

DS sounds a lot more fun. Suspect he will do fine when he gets into uni and work and isn't living in his sister's shadow all the time.

DangerousAlchemy · 02/02/2024 08:46

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 05:42

I love that everyone here seems to know my DD better than I do!!

Getting a feeling that people are hating on DD because DS is the underdog and no one likes a driven, assertive woman! Last I checked sarcasm isn't a sign of disrespect and I've clarified what I meant by the other comments!

But what exactly are you hoping to achieve with your post @Pheebee ?? People will have their own opinions on here. I feel sorry for twins tbh. I know loads & one is often more of an introvert (like your son) than the other & I also know tons of high-achiever girls who are now struggling with anxiety & depression & eating disorders as they were treated like golden children til 18 then they had to cope in the real world (at top Unis surrounded by other extremely bright & gifted young adults). You may find your DS slower pace of life leads to an easier life for him in the future. I can be judgemental at times & it's definitely not a nice personality trait to have tbh & it's something I try & keep to myself.

Littlemisslaughalot · 02/02/2024 08:43

@Pheebee this post makes me sad that you are firstly comparing them in this way but mostly that you aren't really proud of your son who in your own words is funny and nice to be around. Stop comparing, stop writing about them on here to a bunch of strangers and enjoy each of them for who they are.
You could talk to your son a the issues you have with him at home if it's bothering you.
Be grateful you have two healthy nice children and stop nitpicking their personalites, it's unnecessary.

Howbizarre22 · 02/02/2024 08:42

You are the problem here. Stop valuing dd so much- being popular & charismatic are not important traits. Kindness is. I like the sound of you ds far better. He probably feels like shit because you compare him to his “perfect” sister so bloody much.

You sound obsessive. Have you not got your own life to live? Chill out get a hobby and let them be themselves!! And what’s with the “parenting” speak?? That are adults now- not kids.
Your DD is judgmental? Hmm I wonder where she gets that from.
You sound incredibly highly strung

Swipe left for the next trending thread