Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people aren’t worried about this??

840 replies

Mummytotwonow · 25/01/2024 19:28

https://news.sky.com/story/time-to-think-the-unthinkable-and-consider-uk-conscription-says-britains-former-top-nato-commander-13056148

Sorry if I’ve missed any threads on this.

It’s not just sky news reporting this but for days now in the media this is being raised.

AIBU - to be extremely worried and concerned about this?

Is anyone else not worried?? Are we being prepared ready as “the higher up” know more and the threat is bigger than we’re told.

what age would it be from and to??

l‘m so scared for the world our children are growing up in 😢

Time to 'think the unthinkable' and consider UK conscription, says Britain's former top NATO commander

General Sir Richard Sherriff tells Sky News that even if Russia is defeated in the war against Ukraine, it is going to remain determined to rebuild another empire, subjugate Ukraine, and then move on to other ex-Soviet countries, like NATO members. Tha...

https://news.sky.com/story/time-to-think-the-unthinkable-and-consider-uk-conscription-says-britains-former-top-nato-commander-13056148

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
CoatRack · 27/01/2024 23:15

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 27/01/2024 23:10

No. You definitely wrote "It may make biological sense" about female conscription. Female conscription really really doesn't make biological sense.

Did you omit a "not"?

Ah, I get where you're coming from now.

No, what I was trying to say was "it may make biological sense [to send the men], but it's bad enough...."

In essence it's an anti-conscription sentiment.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 27/01/2024 23:10

CoatRack · 27/01/2024 23:07

Did you misread my post?

No. You definitely wrote "It may make biological sense" about female conscription. Female conscription really really doesn't make biological sense.

Did you omit a "not"?

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 27/01/2024 23:08

Wantthisfriend · 27/01/2024 23:00

Nobody wants to send their own or other peoples children to war.
However, if conscription happens, we should not backtrack on equality and refrain from sending females just because they have a uterus.

Biology doesn't care about civil rights. As I already explained, dead women bear no children.

Page 22 | To wonder why people aren’t worried about this?? | Mumsnet

[[https://news.sky.com/story/time-to-think-the-unthinkable-and-consider-uk-conscription-says-britains-former-top-nato-commander-13056148 https://news....

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4993425-to-wonder-why-people-arent-worried-about-this?reply=132522675

CoatRack · 27/01/2024 23:07

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 27/01/2024 22:55

  1. It doesn't make biological sense to conscript women to combat roles.
  2. Ideally, no one would be conscripted, but if you must conscript, don't conscript women to combat roles.
  3. The possibility of a shooting war with Russia, with conscription a likely aspect of that, has been on the cards since Russia first marched into Crimea in, what, 2014? Yet no one has said a peep about it until this week.

The only reason why some old guy with a chestful of medals is all over the news about it right now is to stop you from looking at something else more immediately important, like the Coalition government's involvement in covering up the Horizon bug and hanging over 700 sub-postmasters out to dry to do so. We are talking about the govt and Post Office perverting the course of justice over 700 times. If they can do this to sub-postmasters, they can do it to any of us.

Edited

Did you misread my post?

Wantthisfriend · 27/01/2024 23:00

Nobody wants to send their own or other peoples children to war.
However, if conscription happens, we should not backtrack on equality and refrain from sending females just because they have a uterus.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 27/01/2024 22:55

CoatRack · 27/01/2024 22:43

Why would you want women/girls to be conscripted?
It may make biological sense but even so, it's bad enough when half the population is being forced away to war.

  1. It doesn't make biological sense to conscript women to combat roles.
  2. Ideally, no one would be conscripted, but if you must conscript, don't conscript women to combat roles.
  3. The possibility of a shooting war with Russia, with conscription a likely aspect of that, has been on the cards since Russia first marched into Crimea in, what, 2014? Yet no one has said a peep about it until this week.

The only reason why some old guy with a chestful of medals is all over the news about it right now is to stop you from looking at something else more immediately important, like the Coalition government's involvement in covering up the Horizon bug and hanging over 700 sub-postmasters out to dry to do so. We are talking about the govt and Post Office perverting the course of justice over 700 times. If they can do this to sub-postmasters, they can do it to any of us.

User135644 · 27/01/2024 22:47

Wantthisfriend · 27/01/2024 21:41

Who were all the women who were conscripted to take over 'men's jobs' during the world wars? Likely the same ones who raised their daughters to demand equality. An achievement that is still ongoing, but advanced to a great extent, since conscription/national service was last used.
Why does being a child bearer now nullify this equality? Women were not allowed to fly jets or work on oil rigs as late as the 1970s, and even today, spurned from many other jobs, because they have a uterus.
If we women go down the 'because I have a uterus' road too, we will never be be truly equal.

Why should mothers with male children 'do their bit' when mothers who have solely female children, shouldnt?
If we become expected to conscript sons, we should be expected to conscript daughters too.

As long as women don't wave white feathers again at the men who refuse to be cannon fodder.

CoatRack · 27/01/2024 22:43

Wantthisfriend · 27/01/2024 21:41

Who were all the women who were conscripted to take over 'men's jobs' during the world wars? Likely the same ones who raised their daughters to demand equality. An achievement that is still ongoing, but advanced to a great extent, since conscription/national service was last used.
Why does being a child bearer now nullify this equality? Women were not allowed to fly jets or work on oil rigs as late as the 1970s, and even today, spurned from many other jobs, because they have a uterus.
If we women go down the 'because I have a uterus' road too, we will never be be truly equal.

Why should mothers with male children 'do their bit' when mothers who have solely female children, shouldnt?
If we become expected to conscript sons, we should be expected to conscript daughters too.

Why would you want women/girls to be conscripted?
It may make biological sense but even so, it's bad enough when half the population is being forced away to war.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 27/01/2024 22:22

Drosera · 27/01/2024 22:07

And yet ever worsening overpopulation is one of our biggest issues. Not the opposite.

Globally, yes. In terms of national survival, not so much. You are aware of the pensions crisis? And if you advocate anyone fighting for this country, you must want it to survive as a country, and that means protecting our ability to create new citizens because a country, to exist, must have land that it controls and people living on the land. No people = no country.

The Russians are mass raping Ukrainian women with the explicitly stated intent of stopping them from birthing future Ukrainian citizens. This is rape as genocide. Murdering the enemy's entire population is a long-attested means of not only winning the current war but preventing future ones because there's no enemy to fight you in the future. Preventing future births has the same effect. A government would have to be certifiably insane to make the enemy's job of wiping us out easier by sending women to the enemy as soldiers.

Yasai · 27/01/2024 22:22

llizzie · 27/01/2024 21:20

Given the present world situation, and having now discovered that the UNRWA in Gaza is involved with Hamas, if you don't think conscription is the answer when we have to defend this country and our allies, what alternative defence would you prefer to conscription?

Since so many young people and adults are into violent video games and knife crime is on the increase, do you think that some sort of training to give young people some responsibility, not just for protection of the nation, but for a grounding in discipline which would hopefully channel their energy into something more productive?

How closely have you been following events in Gaza?

Drosera · 27/01/2024 22:07

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 27/01/2024 22:05

⬆ An object lesson in how to misunderstand what I wrote.

The problem is one of biology and time.

It takes a man nine minutes to start a baby and a woman nine months to finish it. A man can impregnate a woman and die the next day, he'll still be a father. If a woman gets pregnant and dies the next day, she and the baby are both lost. A man can sire multiple babies with multiple women and can even do so with several women at the same time. A woman can usually only have one baby at a time. The limiting factor on birth rate is the number of women, not the number of men.

Without uteruses to gestate children in, you have no children, no future citizens to replace your population. No government sends the uterus bearers to war en masse, they destroy their country's future by doing so.

Rights and equality don't come into this decision at all. It's purely pragmatic.

And yet ever worsening overpopulation is one of our biggest issues. Not the opposite.

Drosera · 27/01/2024 22:06

Carthag · 26/01/2024 00:05

Your post has many truths, however I would answer it as simply as this:-

Nuclear war = Dead earth

Nothing is worth this.

Dead or maimed children.

Nothing is worth this.

Sanctioned murder of ordinary people dressed up as soldiers? No thanks.

It becomes an exercise in damage limitation. Like, if we'd not resisted the Nazis how much more ethnic cleansing would've taken place?

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 27/01/2024 22:05

Wantthisfriend · 27/01/2024 21:41

Who were all the women who were conscripted to take over 'men's jobs' during the world wars? Likely the same ones who raised their daughters to demand equality. An achievement that is still ongoing, but advanced to a great extent, since conscription/national service was last used.
Why does being a child bearer now nullify this equality? Women were not allowed to fly jets or work on oil rigs as late as the 1970s, and even today, spurned from many other jobs, because they have a uterus.
If we women go down the 'because I have a uterus' road too, we will never be be truly equal.

Why should mothers with male children 'do their bit' when mothers who have solely female children, shouldnt?
If we become expected to conscript sons, we should be expected to conscript daughters too.

⬆ An object lesson in how to misunderstand what I wrote.

The problem is one of biology and time.

It takes a man nine minutes to start a baby and a woman nine months to finish it. A man can impregnate a woman and die the next day, he'll still be a father. If a woman gets pregnant and dies the next day, she and the baby are both lost. A man can sire multiple babies with multiple women and can even do so with several women at the same time. A woman can usually only have one baby at a time. The limiting factor on birth rate is the number of women, not the number of men.

Without uteruses to gestate children in, you have no children, no future citizens to replace your population. No government sends the uterus bearers to war en masse, they destroy their country's future by doing so.

Rights and equality don't come into this decision at all. It's purely pragmatic.

Wantthisfriend · 27/01/2024 21:41

Who were all the women who were conscripted to take over 'men's jobs' during the world wars? Likely the same ones who raised their daughters to demand equality. An achievement that is still ongoing, but advanced to a great extent, since conscription/national service was last used.
Why does being a child bearer now nullify this equality? Women were not allowed to fly jets or work on oil rigs as late as the 1970s, and even today, spurned from many other jobs, because they have a uterus.
If we women go down the 'because I have a uterus' road too, we will never be be truly equal.

Why should mothers with male children 'do their bit' when mothers who have solely female children, shouldnt?
If we become expected to conscript sons, we should be expected to conscript daughters too.

llizzie · 27/01/2024 21:20

Given the present world situation, and having now discovered that the UNRWA in Gaza is involved with Hamas, if you don't think conscription is the answer when we have to defend this country and our allies, what alternative defence would you prefer to conscription?

Since so many young people and adults are into violent video games and knife crime is on the increase, do you think that some sort of training to give young people some responsibility, not just for protection of the nation, but for a grounding in discipline which would hopefully channel their energy into something more productive?

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 27/01/2024 20:26

sheetsoflux · 27/01/2024 20:21

We only have 'equal rights' on paper. We've come along way but not far enough. We're still the overwhelming majority of main carers to the disabled, be that our children, relatives, paid care of parents. We usually do the bulk of the slog when it comes to raising DC

I am not necessarily speaking for myself but as a whole. Who are all these men taking our place to care and raise children? Didn't think so

^Who are all these men taking our place to care and raise children?

Who are all these men taking our place to gestate and birth children? Oh wait, they can't.

No government in its right mind sends the uterus bearers off to war en masse. That trumps any notion of sex equality when conscripting soldiers.

sheetsoflux · 27/01/2024 20:21

Wantthisfriend · 27/01/2024 17:11

Perturbed that most of this thread assumes conscription would be directed at males. Lets bring up 'strong' women and promote equality for women and transsexuals? Only when it suits us it seems....

We only have 'equal rights' on paper. We've come along way but not far enough. We're still the overwhelming majority of main carers to the disabled, be that our children, relatives, paid care of parents. We usually do the bulk of the slog when it comes to raising DC

I am not necessarily speaking for myself but as a whole. Who are all these men taking our place to care and raise children? Didn't think so

Justpontificating · 27/01/2024 20:05

Sd1960 · 27/01/2024 19:21

What about the daughters? Shouldn’t they be called up as well?

Yes of course they’ve been on the front line in a combatant role for quite some time now.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 27/01/2024 19:48

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 27/01/2024 19:41

The big story that this conscription "dead cat" panicfest is distracting us all from is the latest Horizon leaks.

The Post Office decided to secretly sack the forensic accountants who found the Horizon bugs as part of the cover-up.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-68079300

And the Coalition Govt of David Cameron knew.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 27/01/2024 19:41

The big story that this conscription "dead cat" panicfest is distracting us all from is the latest Horizon leaks.

The Post Office decided to secretly sack the forensic accountants who found the Horizon bugs as part of the cover-up.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-68079300

SharonEllis · 27/01/2024 19:40

windowframer · 27/01/2024 19:23

Gosh, this is silly. Of course Putin uses the veneer of democratic legitimacy to prop up his regime. Its absolutely essential to the way he holds onto power and controls dissent. But it is not 'worse' on a spectrum of more or less democracy that you can put alongside the UK. Here is just one example of a prisoner of conscience in Russia. This just does not happen in the UK, even though we have and always have had miscarriages of justice.

True (as far as I know). On the other hand, Russia has a mixed electoral system including party list candidates elected by proportional representation, so fewer people whose votes will never count for anything by virtue of where they live. And an elected upper house, unlike our antidemocratic relic of feudal privilege.

So it depends what you're looking for. As with so many aspects of culture and politics, it's easy to overlook the massive democratic deficits in our own country because we've grown up used to them.

Edited

I do hope that one day you meet a dissident Russian. They'll put you straight.

windowframer · 27/01/2024 19:23

Gosh, this is silly. Of course Putin uses the veneer of democratic legitimacy to prop up his regime. Its absolutely essential to the way he holds onto power and controls dissent. But it is not 'worse' on a spectrum of more or less democracy that you can put alongside the UK. Here is just one example of a prisoner of conscience in Russia. This just does not happen in the UK, even though we have and always have had miscarriages of justice.

True (as far as I know). On the other hand, Russia has a mixed electoral system including party list candidates elected by proportional representation, so fewer people whose votes will never count for anything by virtue of where they live. And an elected upper house, unlike our antidemocratic relic of feudal privilege.

So it depends what you're looking for. As with so many aspects of culture and politics, it's easy to overlook the massive democratic deficits in our own country because we've grown up used to them.

Sd1960 · 27/01/2024 19:21

What about the daughters? Shouldn’t they be called up as well?

windowframer · 27/01/2024 19:11

Naptrappedmummy · 27/01/2024 16:50

LBC are asking people to phone in and say whether they would comply with the conscription…

What conscription?

raspberryjuiceandpompoms · 27/01/2024 19:08

@zendeveloper thanks for taking time to explain and for the nudge to do some research on the topic. I understand the issue is actually with in/on particles. In Ukraine «В Украине» sounds grammatically incorrect to me however I can now see how much to unpack here.

Swipe left for the next trending thread