Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this be an absolute NO for you? Golliwog encounter.

995 replies

skatermom · 20/01/2024 16:13

We've recently moved to a new village. Really lovely place, really nice people. We needed a Violin teacher for my DS who is in secondary school. His teacher lives too far away now and we were looking for somewhere that wasn't too far away.

How lucky we were to find a classical string instrument teacher a walking distance from home. I spoke to him over the phone and he sounded lovely. He is in his 50s and teaches lots of children in the area. He also plays the guitar and sings in the choir of the local church. We went to see him in his cottage-like home for an assessment and he took us into his small music room. It was gorgeous! Lovely instruments around, beautiful decor, very old style but really nice. One side had little figurines of angels and fairies, one wall had really old photos of what looked like old relatives from before the 1970s, he had a frame of old miniature trains etc.

I sat on the rocking chair he offered while he talked loads around planning the ABRSM grades and the different classical violinists. I'm not very musical but listened on. Then it was time for my DS to play so I sat back and listened while looking around. I looked towards my left and there was a cabinet with glass dolls and about 25 miniature Golliwog / Gollywog figurines. Now, I should probably say here that I'm black.

I froze from shock and just looked on and pretended not to see them. I'd never seen one in person before! When we finished, we made some follow up arrangements and left with a promise to get back in touch.

The man was so very lovely, seemed so kind and welcoming and encouraging that I don't know whether to be offended!

AIBU to ignore it and just keep taking DS for the lessons? He's the only one at the level we need in a 3mile radius.
What would you do in my shoes?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Clarinet506 · 25/01/2024 17:51

@Clarinet506 thank you for posting. Such a horrible experience.
When we hear this experience side by side with those experiences of people oh so loving their Golliwogs, does it make people rethink those bits of their childhood and how they so loved an representation of hate or is it an eye roll it gets? I don't know if my saying anything to the teacher would have made any difference to how he feels about them. Surely, I won't be the first in the world saying they were offensive?
Thank you again.

Thanks @skatermom. I think you've handled the whole tricky situation perfectly. Nobody could ask for more. Hopefully what you said to him will have made him at least look into the history a little, and give it some thought, and if he still wants to cling to the memorabilia after that, then he'll have your words (and probably those of others) hanging around the figurines like a miasma 😁

When we hear this experience side by side with those experiences of people oh so loving their Golliwogs, does it make people rethink those bits of their childhood and how they so loved an representation of hate or is it an eye roll it gets?
I don't know. I hope it's the former. This: <and how they so loved an representation of hate> is a BRILLIANT way to phrase it

DeeCeeCherry · 25/01/2024 17:59

Josette77
Although I'm also curious why it's an issue if any posts expose racists and bigots? Isn't it a good thing people get exposed for racist views?

Good for who, exactly? There've been numerous golly/racist threads over the years. Perhaps Black people aren't ecstatically reading them thinking 'oh good, racism exposed!' - whilst knowing they'll never stop.

Josette77 · 25/01/2024 18:11

DeeCeeCherry · 25/01/2024 17:59

Josette77
Although I'm also curious why it's an issue if any posts expose racists and bigots? Isn't it a good thing people get exposed for racist views?

Good for who, exactly? There've been numerous golly/racist threads over the years. Perhaps Black people aren't ecstatically reading them thinking 'oh good, racism exposed!' - whilst knowing they'll never stop.

Because if racists are faced with thoughtful posts like @Clarinet506 they may rethink their actions or hopefully people who have overlooked the damage caused by things like this may have their eyes opened and learn how to be more of an ally.

At least that would be the hope. White people should be learning how to spot racism and speak up.

More importantly this is in theory a board for everyone. Many issues with husbands, kids, schools are repeatedly brought up, so why do ones on racism bother you?

DeeCeeCherry · 25/01/2024 18:13

Clarinet506

Thank you for sharing your experience. As awful as it is.

The 'I loved my golliwog' folk are disingenous. They know it's wrong thats why in cowardly fashion, they hid those toys. I think tbh these posts and threads arise as these bigots get off on trying to upset Black people. I won't give them the satisfaction as I find their boastful stupidity meaningless

We rarely get doors slammed in our faces these days, you know! They're a lot cleverer than that. They know it's wrong, they know it's frowned on, they know they could be ostracised for it, and some of them take great delight in fawning over a PoC whilst loathing them inside. A bit like the way some misogynists are married to women?

^Exactly this.

I don't take conversations about feminism, sexism etc on MN seriously at all because so many will dish out the same bigoted behaviour they accuse men of

Clarinet506 · 25/01/2024 18:22

@Clarinet506in relation to your final paragraph:

One of the most telling signs of a racist is overblown friendliness on first meeting. It doesn't always follow, obviously, but it's happened to me that way on quite a few occasions.

Would you mind sharing what happened? Do you mean turning on you once out of earshot or displaying some sort of internalised racism? I'm just curious.

Sure @Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong I'll try:

Not turning on me once out of earshot, no. Displaying racism a while after meeting me - yes.

Racists often resent the label, and will go out of their way to prove what a lovely, friendly person they are by going over the top with me (and others) on first meeting. But at the same time, they resent having to hide their views and will do this strange dance of mental gymnastics where they're airing racist views at the same time as they're acting oh-so-charmingly. (I'm sure there are parallels in the world of misogyny. Or perhaps think of the way a narcissist will often love-bomb you at first, or shower you with ostentatious gifts?)

An example: a man I worked with (one step away from being my line manager) was courteous to a fault, laughed and joked with me, made me the centre of any compliment going in the office, etc. I hadn't worked with him too long before he made his racist views known (quoting Enoch Powell's 'river of blood speech', saying that people should 'go back home', considering mixed race people as 'neither fish nor fowl', a few instances of the P-word under his breath after Asian staff had left the room - that kind of thing. He wanted it both ways; 'like me', he was saying to everyone in the room, 'because see here, how lovely I am!' But he reserved the right to keep hold of his cherished views, and to air them. As long as he wasn't saying these words to me or about me, he thought it was fine, just office bants.

Other low-level stuff includes being made an extra fuss of in a book group by a woman who proceeded to discuss the themes of The Underground Railroad in a way that was derogatory to the current descendants of slaves in the US. She'd laid her path out, you see, with the friendliness. She thought it cloaked her in innocence, or something.

Those are two that stick in my memory, but there are dozens of microaggressions, some involving my hair, that would lose impact in their description if I tried, I think. I've just noticed throughout life that a big part of the playbook is this performative nicey-niceness.

(To be honest, I sometimes think I preferred it in the 70s and 80s when they called us to our faces.)

Caliope27 · 25/01/2024 18:22

"I grew up in the 70s and 80s (note lack of apostrophe - look it up) and these objects did indeed give "their name to a foul racist slur that was bandied about in every playground in the country" as viques so eloquently puts it."

While these dolls and figures are rightly recognised for what they are and shunned now - it's unlikely that they gave their name to the disgusting 'W' word. The earliest recorded use of that nasty name was in the 1920s was it being used as demeaning and derogatory sea slang. It was also adopted in the second world war as a derogatory term for oriental people. Nasty stuff... but it's pretty clear that the articles you can find on the Net saying it originated from the dolls are probably not correct.

I grew up in the same era as you and never heard the dolls being called the W word. They were the Robertson's gollies, and me and my friends called our dolls the same. All a bit moot now really, as times have changed for the better and the fact that people had those dolls at that time doesn't mean they would condone having them now.

(There's a lot of disagreement about those apostrophes too). 😁

DeeCeeCherry · 25/01/2024 18:36

Daddydog
Don't worry, as a black person I've corrected OPs post so it conforms with @DeeCeeCherry views on how we are all supposed to write...

"Sup, took Lil' man to lessons an some cracker-ass-cracker disrespected him wit som racist ass shit. Should I bust a cap in his ass or give teach a hood pass"

Funny tho😂 if a bit cringe to think all Black people speak like that..I mean we are a global majority

People who've lived and detailed their racism experiences sound as if they've lived it. Because they have and there are points can absolutely identify with.

As opposed to sounding like AI or some garbled non-Black wannabee Peckham youth practising street slang

Never thought I'd see the word 'cracker' written on here - surprised you'll get away with that on MN. It's not spelt like that either by the way, in the context you mean. Which you would know surely...?🤔 Unless...

Maybe your talking about Jacobs Cream Crackers then

Clarinet506 · 25/01/2024 18:44

Thanks @Caliope27 - when you're using it in the plural sense - the seventies and the eighties (70s and 80s) - there's no need for an apostrophe because it's not denoting a missing word, and there's no possessive sense. If we're talking about something belonging to the decade, say a 70's dress or 70's music, then you'd need one, because it's possessive. At least, that's how I understand it.

Sorry. I made a mistake in implying the W-word came directly from gollies. You're absolutely right about the sea slang and its use against east Asian people. I meant to say that the kids in my school leapt on the word once they had a physical representation of Black people (as they saw us) to bandy about. It was one of their favourite names for me, sometimes the whole word (golliwog) and sometimes the W-word.
Jim Davidson and Bernard Manning have a lot to answer for in polluting the playgrounds of the period (and it all filters down; those were adult shows, but all my tormentors seemed to watch them).

I can only speak for my school, as that's where I went. And as I've said in other posts, it's possible you never heard it at yours because it didn't happen. It's also possible that Schrödinger's Racism was going on. And there's another possibility: when I was at school, ableist slurs went over my head, until I learned to tune into them a bit more and see how other people were suffering. As children, we can be blind to things that don't affect us directly.

Runnerinthenight · 25/01/2024 19:24

CurlewKate · 25/01/2024 09:56

@Runnerinthenight "He comes across as overly sentimental perhaps. I'm not convinced that he's racist... "

You don't have to wear a white hood and burn crosses to be a racist.

Do you know whether or not he's racist?

I don't?!

CurlewKate · 25/01/2024 19:32

@Runnerinthenight "Do you know whether or not he's racist?"

Yes I do. He displays gollywogs in his house. He's a racist.

Runnerinthenight · 25/01/2024 19:42

CurlewKate · 25/01/2024 19:32

@Runnerinthenight "Do you know whether or not he's racist?"

Yes I do. He displays gollywogs in his house. He's a racist.

If it was that straightforward, why is this discussion even happening? If there's absolutely no room for any context?

Runnerinthenight · 25/01/2024 19:46

@Clarinet506 I'm sorry you had to go through that. Dreadful that the school didn't do anything about it.

As I posted earlier, I only ever encountered one black pupil during my entire school career. There weren't many poc even in uni.

I think any right-minded person was appalled by the likes of Bernard Manning and Jim Davidson. Unfortunately not everyone was.

Ableism was disgusting too. My primary school had what was officially called, a "deaf and dumb" unit. Just dreadful.

CurlewKate · 25/01/2024 19:48

@Runnerinthenight "
If it was that straightforward, why is this discussion even happening? If there's absolutely no room for any context?"

I don't know. Because for some bizarre reason that I don't understand and nobody has been able to satisfactorily explain, many British people rush to defend gollywogs.

Mirabai · 25/01/2024 19:54

if a bit cringe to think all Black people speak like that

Isn’t it a bit cringe to think all black people speak like anything? I’ve still no idea what you meant by that.

Your judgement on the OP was that she doesn’t sound black. Originally I thought you were black but after your post I inferred I was wrong - because what black person would ever say that? I can’t imagine any black friend of mine saying anything of the sort. In the context of a lot of white posters making ignorant goady comments about race, it just sounded like more of the same.

Posters just assumed you were referring to some derogatory stereotype.

TipulophobiaIsReal · 25/01/2024 20:12

for some bizarre reason that I don't understand and nobody has been able to satisfactorily explain, many British people rush to defend gollywogs

For many, it's the result of the entirely understandable and natural human psychological need to reduce cognitive dissonance.

You were given a golliwog when you were tiny, too young to know anything about anything. It was given to you by someone you love, who as a child you were predisposed to think of as all good. You loved the person and loved the golliwog. Everyone around you seemed to think they were fine.

At some point, you are told that golliwogs are racist and cause hurt and harm to innocent people. The person you loved either knew, or should've known, or wilfully refused to understand, that golliwogs were racist. You have love and affection for a (perhaps unwittingly) racist person and a racist item. Your wider culture is endemically racist. That makes you, the person you love, and your whole society racist.

The easiest, simplest way to keep everything the way you thought it was, with no complicated bad feelings about yourself and the people you love, is to decide that actually, golliwogs are fine, you're a good, non-racist person, the person you love is a good, non-racist person, and your culture isn't harmful to anyone. That way of thinking will cause the least damage to what you felt and thought you knew about yourself and the people you care about. In order to feel that you are not a bad person, it must be that those people who object to golliwogs just don't understand, and are getting all wound up about an innocent cuddly toy.

It's just the least psychologically costly way, from their perspective, to resolve the dissonance between "I am a basically good person, my loved ones are basically good people, my culture is basically a good culture" and "I loved a disgusting cuddly racist caricature as a child".

CurlewKate · 25/01/2024 20:22

@TipulophobiaIsReal That's very interesting-and make sense. It also explains why the Britain First-type right wingers are gollywogophiles. "how dare they take away our childhoods"

Mirabai · 25/01/2024 20:23

Josette77 · 25/01/2024 18:11

Because if racists are faced with thoughtful posts like @Clarinet506 they may rethink their actions or hopefully people who have overlooked the damage caused by things like this may have their eyes opened and learn how to be more of an ally.

At least that would be the hope. White people should be learning how to spot racism and speak up.

More importantly this is in theory a board for everyone. Many issues with husbands, kids, schools are repeatedly brought up, so why do ones on racism bother you?

I do understand why @DeeCeeCherry finds all the gollybuggery annoying - don’t we all. Well - apart from the gollybuggerers. And I understand why she thinks the thread must be fake. But the fact is the same themes come up over and over again on here because people face the same issues.

I don’t think racists would change their mind on @Clarinet506’s posts but I think people who don’t live in multiracial areas might.

Runnerinthenight · 25/01/2024 21:31

TipulophobiaIsReal · 25/01/2024 20:12

for some bizarre reason that I don't understand and nobody has been able to satisfactorily explain, many British people rush to defend gollywogs

For many, it's the result of the entirely understandable and natural human psychological need to reduce cognitive dissonance.

You were given a golliwog when you were tiny, too young to know anything about anything. It was given to you by someone you love, who as a child you were predisposed to think of as all good. You loved the person and loved the golliwog. Everyone around you seemed to think they were fine.

At some point, you are told that golliwogs are racist and cause hurt and harm to innocent people. The person you loved either knew, or should've known, or wilfully refused to understand, that golliwogs were racist. You have love and affection for a (perhaps unwittingly) racist person and a racist item. Your wider culture is endemically racist. That makes you, the person you love, and your whole society racist.

The easiest, simplest way to keep everything the way you thought it was, with no complicated bad feelings about yourself and the people you love, is to decide that actually, golliwogs are fine, you're a good, non-racist person, the person you love is a good, non-racist person, and your culture isn't harmful to anyone. That way of thinking will cause the least damage to what you felt and thought you knew about yourself and the people you care about. In order to feel that you are not a bad person, it must be that those people who object to golliwogs just don't understand, and are getting all wound up about an innocent cuddly toy.

It's just the least psychologically costly way, from their perspective, to resolve the dissonance between "I am a basically good person, my loved ones are basically good people, my culture is basically a good culture" and "I loved a disgusting cuddly racist caricature as a child".

That makes so much sense! Great post.

I think there's a part of a lot of us that feels, I don't know, a bit 'tainted' about having had them?

I never liked them anyway so I never had any attachment to them whatsoever, and I have no idea where the ones we had went! I imagine they were thrown out when my parents had their house renovated 40 years ago.

I think too you just really want to get it across that you didn't ever have the things for any racist reason? Because you didn't know at the time it was a thing.

Clarinet506 · 25/01/2024 22:05

@TipulophobiaIsReal fantastic post! I think this must be it

Clarinet506 · 25/01/2024 22:07

@Mirabai <<gollybuggery annoying - don’t we all. Well - apart from the gollybuggerers>> 😁😁I'm never going to forget that. The day is made!!

Justpontificating · 25/01/2024 22:47

Runnerinthenight · 25/01/2024 19:42

If it was that straightforward, why is this discussion even happening? If there's absolutely no room for any context?

This has been discussed for pages and pages as @CurlewKate knows.
It has been shown that
There is no evidence either way
You can never assume anything
The Golliwogs are family memorabilia
He said no one had mentioned they were racist to him before
Hes been kind to the OP and has not made racist marks

It is very basic and wrong to just jump to such simple conclusions and immediately shame people.

Minymile · 25/01/2024 22:50

Justpontificating · 25/01/2024 22:47

This has been discussed for pages and pages as @CurlewKate knows.
It has been shown that
There is no evidence either way
You can never assume anything
The Golliwogs are family memorabilia
He said no one had mentioned they were racist to him before
Hes been kind to the OP and has not made racist marks

It is very basic and wrong to just jump to such simple conclusions and immediately shame people.

I should note @Runnerinthenight the last comment was not related to your comment
Just using this as a running thread

Runnerinthenight · 25/01/2024 22:53

Minymile · 25/01/2024 22:50

I should note @Runnerinthenight the last comment was not related to your comment
Just using this as a running thread

NP!

CurlewKate · 26/01/2024 05:55

@Justpontificating "It has been shown that
There is no evidence either way
You can never assume anything
The Golliwogs are family memorabilia
He said no one had mentioned they were racist to him before
Hes been kind to the OP and has not made racist marks"

Would you say the same if we were talking about a swastika armband?

Josette77 · 26/01/2024 06:39

Justpontificating · 25/01/2024 22:47

This has been discussed for pages and pages as @CurlewKate knows.
It has been shown that
There is no evidence either way
You can never assume anything
The Golliwogs are family memorabilia
He said no one had mentioned they were racist to him before
Hes been kind to the OP and has not made racist marks

It is very basic and wrong to just jump to such simple conclusions and immediately shame people.

When he found out they were racist though he said he would move them, and launched into stories about how special they are to him.

If I found out I had something racist in my home I'd get rid of it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread