Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this be an absolute NO for you? Golliwog encounter.

995 replies

skatermom · 20/01/2024 16:13

We've recently moved to a new village. Really lovely place, really nice people. We needed a Violin teacher for my DS who is in secondary school. His teacher lives too far away now and we were looking for somewhere that wasn't too far away.

How lucky we were to find a classical string instrument teacher a walking distance from home. I spoke to him over the phone and he sounded lovely. He is in his 50s and teaches lots of children in the area. He also plays the guitar and sings in the choir of the local church. We went to see him in his cottage-like home for an assessment and he took us into his small music room. It was gorgeous! Lovely instruments around, beautiful decor, very old style but really nice. One side had little figurines of angels and fairies, one wall had really old photos of what looked like old relatives from before the 1970s, he had a frame of old miniature trains etc.

I sat on the rocking chair he offered while he talked loads around planning the ABRSM grades and the different classical violinists. I'm not very musical but listened on. Then it was time for my DS to play so I sat back and listened while looking around. I looked towards my left and there was a cabinet with glass dolls and about 25 miniature Golliwog / Gollywog figurines. Now, I should probably say here that I'm black.

I froze from shock and just looked on and pretended not to see them. I'd never seen one in person before! When we finished, we made some follow up arrangements and left with a promise to get back in touch.

The man was so very lovely, seemed so kind and welcoming and encouraging that I don't know whether to be offended!

AIBU to ignore it and just keep taking DS for the lessons? He's the only one at the level we need in a 3mile radius.
What would you do in my shoes?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
madeinmanc · 20/01/2024 16:35

I'd be wondering - unless there's some huge backstory - what else he might do or how else he might behave. The music teacher - pupil relationship is an unusually intimate and powerful one. A music teacher can shape us as musicians and influence our development in ways not seen in other relationships. All people who have learned an instrument understand this fact, and it's why abuse and inappropriate relationships have been rife in this setting.

Bearing this in mind, is this someone who you trust to exert such power over your child when other excellent musicians are widely available?

(Edit: and maybe the answer is that it is, I'm just thinking aloud here. Just why bother with him?).

TipulophobiaIsReal · 20/01/2024 16:35

madeinmanc · 20/01/2024 16:19

Someone his age will have them because they were a children’s toy when he was a child.

He's "only" in his fifties so I don't think the dates are right.

My DP is in his fifties and his favourite cuddly soft toy when he was little was a golliwog. Slept with it at night, etc. He's pissed off about it now, that he was given a racist toy to love when he was too little to understand that, and he threw the thing away many years ago, but the ages do add up.

My guess would be the figurines are probably Robertson's ones collected over time; they were very popular, unfortunately. I… don't think I'd be comfortable with a music teacher who keeps these things on display. Everybody knows what they mean and how they can make people feel, so displaying them is a deliberate statement of something. I'd maybe understand someone being attached to them for personal reasons and not throwing them away entirely; someone feeling that while it's upsetting that something they cherished at the time was actually putting racist shit in their head and in their life, they're a part of their own history; maybe someone feeling it's an important part of our shared history and shouldn't be entirely glossed over with everyone pretending it never happened, something like that, possibly. If I was being generous. Stored away somewhere.

But displaying them for everyone to see, in the place you invite clients into, so that innocent people are unexpectedly confronted with the horrible things and their racist implications? I don't think that says anything good about a person.

FuckingHellAdele · 20/01/2024 16:35

MandyMotherOfBrian · 20/01/2024 16:31

Definitely around late 60s/ early 70s, I had a Golly toy (I’m 52) albeit inherited from my mother, born 1950. However, it had ‘disappeared’ by the time my brother came along eight years later in 1979. So if it was inappropriate before the end of the 70s it is, at the very least, tone deaf to still have them now.

I'm not saying golliwogs didn't EXIST when people in their fifties were younger. I'm saying that they haven't been 'cherished childhood toys' for a long time.

We've known for decades now that they are racist. Anyone in their fifties who still has these, or worse, has them on display, is a problem.

ManateeFair · 20/01/2024 16:35

Bigearringsbigsmile · 20/01/2024 16:14

I would ignore it and do the lessons

I bloody wouldn’t.

ohtowinthelottery · 20/01/2024 16:37

I had a toy golliwog as a child. After my parents died I found it in the loft, rescued it and brought it home as it held memories from my childhood. It is stored away with other childhood treasures. To me it's a cuddly toy which holds memories in the same way as the other teddies I kept. I am absolutely not racist in any way. I have family members who married a person of dual heritage and a friend who is black.
I feel sure that the music teacher's attitude towards you means that they also aren't racist but that the figures on display also hold childhood memories which back then were just toys like any others. It may not even be on their radar that they are now considered offensive - not everyone is on Mumsnet - where else would you hear about this kind of thing?
However, as they are a professional inviting people in to their home you might wish to point out the meaning of them and I think their response will tell you everything you need to know and base your decision on that.

Vistada · 20/01/2024 16:37

Can we all just calm down please.

I would wager this man is not a racist - having welcomed a black woman and her child into his home, and by OPs account being "lovely" and "kind" to them both.

What he is, I think, is a man in a small village who has likely lived in a bubble and is incredibly, incredibly naive.

OP: it's not for me to make this decision - but I think it would be an overreaction to stop the lessons.

Mothership4two · 20/01/2024 16:38

I'm in my late 50s and was given one as a child and remember them on the Robinson jam jars. I also remember seeing The Black and White Minstrel Show which ran until 1978 on BBC. So it was very much around and accepted when I was little. I know they are collectors items now, but I would be very taken aback to go to someone's house and see them displayed.

OneTC · 20/01/2024 16:39

I have a knitted one at home that's very dear to me. I wouldn't put it on a shelf though, she lives in a box with some other dolls. It's dear to me be because she's one of my earliest memories

I was surprised once seeing one at a (white) friend's house, on a bookshelf in the front room. she's younger and considerably more right on than me so it really took me by suprise, she wouldn't entertain any discussion of it though

goldierocks · 20/01/2024 16:39

I'm in my late forties and remember the Robertsons golly badges very well. We also had a 'Here Comes Golly' book in the infants library at primary school (this would have been in the mid 1980's).

Robertsons only ceased using the golly image in 2001.

@skatermom if I were you, I'd ask the tutor to remove them while your DS has his lesson. His reply will tell you everything you need to know.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 20/01/2024 16:40

You could send away Robertsons tokens on jam in the mid 1990s

I learn something new on here every day ... honestly hadn't realised they were still going as late as that Confused

BrokenWing · 20/01/2024 16:40

Itslegitimatesalvage · 20/01/2024 16:18

Someone his age will have them because they were a children’s toy when he was a child. He’ll have probably collected them decades ago, they’ll hold childhood memories and that’s all he sees when he looks at them. Obviously now they have a very different connotation, and they are offensive and really not something to be cherished but some people still do. I’m not going to sit here and tell you that you’re wrong to feel how you feel because you’re not wrong. But I don’t think I’d look at this as the racist violin teacher but rather the nostalgic and rather politically tone death violin teacher. I wouldn’t let it stand in the way.

I am in my 50s and unless he has been living in a box he knows the issues around these "toys" and if he is inviting customers, including young people, into his home they should not be on display.

OP, perhaps ask him to remove them from display as you do not want to see them and you do not want your child to see them. His reaction will tell you if he is worth continuing lessons with.

MinervatheGreat · 20/01/2024 16:40

LauraNorda · 20/01/2024 16:29

If you cannot get over his collection you should find someone else. If there is no-one else within your defined distance, then you are going to have to make a decision.

His home, his rules.

Edited

This ^
You have a choice to go or not.

If you ask him to remove them he has a choice too and his choice maybe to the detriment of continuing with lessons.

hattie43 · 20/01/2024 16:40

Wouldn't bother me at all , it's his music teaching I'm going for not his taste in dolls . These dolls were given away by Robertson jam I think for kids to collect and that's probably why he's got them .

SkulkHollow · 20/01/2024 16:41

Vistada · 20/01/2024 16:37

Can we all just calm down please.

I would wager this man is not a racist - having welcomed a black woman and her child into his home, and by OPs account being "lovely" and "kind" to them both.

What he is, I think, is a man in a small village who has likely lived in a bubble and is incredibly, incredibly naive.

OP: it's not for me to make this decision - but I think it would be an overreaction to stop the lessons.

Edited

You can't not be aware of the incredibly problematic nature of these things, so the only logical conclusion to reach about someone with them proudly on display is that it's a deliberate act of racism.

That really is all there is to it.

BobbyBiscuits · 20/01/2024 16:41

That is grim. I wouldn't employ someone who had those. (I'm white, not like it matters). Esp. if your kid will be alone in their home, with them in the background while he's teaching them. God knows what horrible views he might have.

There was one girl I worked with, in a majority POC workplace, and she wore gollywog badges. I was absolutely horrified. I asked her what she was doing and she just said 'oh, they are historical.' Absolutely rank. Please don't send your kid there. It's worth the hassle to go further afield for a teacher that isn't an ignorant racist.

Userengage · 20/01/2024 16:41

That’s lovely that so many of you had them as treasured toys growing up but times have moved on and unless you live in the back of beyond and beneath a rock, by the time you reach 50 you would have heard and know that that these dolls are racist depictions of black people and that they are offensive.

Personally, I would let him know why we would not be taking up lessons with him and look further afield.

Vistada · 20/01/2024 16:42

SkulkHollow · 20/01/2024 16:41

You can't not be aware of the incredibly problematic nature of these things, so the only logical conclusion to reach about someone with them proudly on display is that it's a deliberate act of racism.

That really is all there is to it.

I very much disagree.

Arightoldcarryabag · 20/01/2024 16:42

I wouldn't dream of telling you how to feel or react, despite the invitation.
For me, I'd see it as a red flag and probably raise it, but I'm a white person of not too dissimilar age to the teacher.
You are in a position to either challenge his stereotype, to challenge their behaviour or to just cut yourself off.
Ultimately as they are in their own home they may feel that they can display whatever they like but I'd question the legality with him using his home as a place of business.

Proceed however you feel best, but don't feel guilty about however you feel about it as quite frankly it's a bit shocking.
I wouldn't be surprised given you'd only spoken on the phone before your last visit, if they weren't removed prior to a next visit and he had been somewhat embarrassed. Despite how they are perceived by us, if they have a sentimental value and he's somewhat of a hoarder, he just may have never considered the harm in not disposing of them.

BackOfTheMum5net · 20/01/2024 16:42

Casually having racist iconography lying around and not understanding why people are upset by it due in fact indicate you hold racist views, even if you don’t think about it that much @Frederica145 .

The brave thing to do would be to explain what a golly means and why it would be uncomfortable for your child to be taught in such an environment. Lots of people do think “Oh, it’s just how we thought of Black people then, no harm was intended.” I suppose his reaction would tell you how important having racist icons around his house was. He might have inherited it and not know what to do with it, or having someone to look down upon because of race might be part of his world view in which case he’s not suitable to teach your child OP.
But if you just wanted to walk away, that’s ok too.

Starseeking · 20/01/2024 16:43

He would have known what your reaction would be, even if not on the phone, certainly once he saw you, and still brought you into that situation.

If it was me, I wouldn't be going back there again, never mind putting money in his pocket.

Mayjune11 · 20/01/2024 16:43

I would do the lessons but I’m white. I can’t speak for you as a black person if you are offended though.

AlisonWonderbra · 20/01/2024 16:43

duckpancakes · 20/01/2024 16:21

I'd also mention something to the pastor of the local church

Why?

GrimDamnFanjo · 20/01/2024 16:44

Vistada · 20/01/2024 16:37

Can we all just calm down please.

I would wager this man is not a racist - having welcomed a black woman and her child into his home, and by OPs account being "lovely" and "kind" to them both.

What he is, I think, is a man in a small village who has likely lived in a bubble and is incredibly, incredibly naive.

OP: it's not for me to make this decision - but I think it would be an overreaction to stop the lessons.

Edited

I'm torn between this response and thinking surely everyone knows it isn't acceptable to have items like this on display?

OP I'm sorry you've been put in this situation.

I'm in my 50s and am a bit surprised that some posters think we are old enough to be naive about this.

lljkk · 20/01/2024 16:44

The only part of this story that would interest me would be .... I'd want to ask him why he keeps them. "You know those figures can be considered rather offensive so I wondered why you keep them."

I'd be interested to hear his perspective.

Maybe he inherited them & it feels wrong to bin them. You don't know if you don't ask.

neighboursareselling · 20/01/2024 16:45

Itslegitimatesalvage · 20/01/2024 16:18

Someone his age will have them because they were a children’s toy when he was a child. He’ll have probably collected them decades ago, they’ll hold childhood memories and that’s all he sees when he looks at them. Obviously now they have a very different connotation, and they are offensive and really not something to be cherished but some people still do. I’m not going to sit here and tell you that you’re wrong to feel how you feel because you’re not wrong. But I don’t think I’d look at this as the racist violin teacher but rather the nostalgic and rather politically tone death violin teacher. I wouldn’t let it stand in the way.

Agree with this.

If he was racist you would pick it up from him without needing to see his doll collection.

Have a casual conversation with him and see what it throws up.