Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this be an absolute NO for you? Golliwog encounter.

995 replies

skatermom · 20/01/2024 16:13

We've recently moved to a new village. Really lovely place, really nice people. We needed a Violin teacher for my DS who is in secondary school. His teacher lives too far away now and we were looking for somewhere that wasn't too far away.

How lucky we were to find a classical string instrument teacher a walking distance from home. I spoke to him over the phone and he sounded lovely. He is in his 50s and teaches lots of children in the area. He also plays the guitar and sings in the choir of the local church. We went to see him in his cottage-like home for an assessment and he took us into his small music room. It was gorgeous! Lovely instruments around, beautiful decor, very old style but really nice. One side had little figurines of angels and fairies, one wall had really old photos of what looked like old relatives from before the 1970s, he had a frame of old miniature trains etc.

I sat on the rocking chair he offered while he talked loads around planning the ABRSM grades and the different classical violinists. I'm not very musical but listened on. Then it was time for my DS to play so I sat back and listened while looking around. I looked towards my left and there was a cabinet with glass dolls and about 25 miniature Golliwog / Gollywog figurines. Now, I should probably say here that I'm black.

I froze from shock and just looked on and pretended not to see them. I'd never seen one in person before! When we finished, we made some follow up arrangements and left with a promise to get back in touch.

The man was so very lovely, seemed so kind and welcoming and encouraging that I don't know whether to be offended!

AIBU to ignore it and just keep taking DS for the lessons? He's the only one at the level we need in a 3mile radius.
What would you do in my shoes?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
PriOn1 · 21/01/2024 00:16

they have always been adamant that Golliwogs were just a little character toy in their day. They didn't see them as representing black people

There was one in the toybox at my grandma’s house and I loved the Robinson’s jam ones. I had no idea they were supposed to represent black people, though it’s obvious when you realise the implications of the name.

I don’t know the answer to your conundrum, OP. It seems a shame to stop the lessons if he’s otherwise a good teacher and was kind to your son. Inappropriate though the figurenes are, it’s not impossible he inherited everything and never got rid or even thought much about it. You do say the whole room was very old fashioned.

I think go with your gut. I don’t think it’s awful to continue, if that’s what you want. Your son might never even notice. You only did as you had time to look round. If you want to stop, that would also be perfectly reasonable.

PropertyManager · 21/01/2024 00:17

Sceptical123 · 20/01/2024 23:58

What an awkward and awful situation for you to encounter out of nowhere, OP, how hideous. I think like other players have said it would be pretty obvious by how he treated you and your son as to how he felt about non-white ppl. If he was racist then he would likely be making excuses that he had no spaces available etc. or he was having to stop teaching for a while to put you off. He may not remove or cover the figurines on a following visit if he’s unaware of their racist context, which I do think is plausible in a small rural village, especially if he has limited exposure to current affairs beyond news programmes, daily politics and old re-runs of film and tv programmes which have left him in a cultural time warp. This situation is not uncommon, especially with access to retro tv channels and old dvd collections and with the growing need for older generations to insulate themselves in nostalgia for sense of security or whatever other reason. I do think this is a likely scenario OP, and if he doesn’t have younger friends or family members to flag this up when visiting his home he probably doesn’t even notice them as he is so used to them just being in the background.

That said it is completely understandable the shock you must have felt when you noticed them and how conflicted on how best to process and handle the situation while you were there.

If you go back he may have removed them, on the other hand he may not, as, like I said, he may not even notice them beyond being ‘wallpaper’ if he’s had them there for decades. Another scenario is he may have thought they didn’t bother you - or he may be feeling extremely awkward about the best way to proceed and whether removing them would flag up the awkwardness of the situation more and decide to just leave them where they are - who knows. It’s a very uncomfortable and difficult situation for you as you must be conflicted in numerous ways and confronting someone in their own home or even over the phone, however gently, is a really difficult thing to do, so I wouldn’t blame you for not wanting to and seeking a tutor elsewhere. As it’s a small village near to your own could you perhaps mention his name to ppl where you live (omitting perhaps the figurines) as it’s likely someone may know or have heard of him and they might be able to give you a bit more info.

It’s a real shame there are so few tutors near to you and he ticks a lot of the right boxes but misses a critical one. If you decide to give this person the benefit of the doubt, would it be possible for him to teach your son at your home instead?

Lets be honest, the guys not racist, they are some collectable vintage figures he has in his own home.

He is probably over subscribed, so won't give a hoot if the OP uses him or not, he's certainly not going to re-arrange his room for her.

Her sons not bothered, good lad, shows a lot of sense, will go far.

skatermom · 21/01/2024 00:30

MCOut · 20/01/2024 22:26

Okay, let’s take racism out of it for a second.

Imagine you were in the same situation with your DD and instead of golliwogs you noticed of collection of vintage posters which could be construed as sexist. Would you really feel the need to go out of your way to give this person a chance to prove he is not a misogynist?

Sure he might be okay, but if he’s not then that negatively impacts your child. OP doesn’t owe him anything. Why take the risk when there will be other violin teachers available?

Exactly this @MCOut taking racism out of it because I don't know if he's racist or just has the memorabilia, is it socially or psychologically safe for my son to see these figurines every time he attends, subconsciously learning that it's okay to see them around when majority of the population think they are highly inappropriate?

Yes, let's say he isn't racist or mean to be, I really don't want to be schooling someone about the appropriateness of their choice of collectibles. The question is if I'm okay with my child being there.

@Sceptical123 he is perfect aside from this one thing. He appears likes in the village, known in church and all. However, we're the newbies, it's possible no one has had a problem before us. But no, it's not that remote a village, he is educated and does work in the main town, uses the internet and email! He is not that disconnected from every day life. He does travel to other students to teach though.

@Mirabai @madeinmanc the teacher is a highly qualified music teacher, has degrees and qualifications in music and in teaching. All my children play an instrument and follow ABRSM grades and are on the higher grades now so I know well where to find music teachers. The problem is that we are now far away from majority of the ones that can teach to the grade DS is now and this teacher is the closest. The hope was that he would take himself there and I won't need to keep driving him to music. It's looking like I may need to do that.

OP posts:
Myotherdogsanoodle · 21/01/2024 03:54

PropertyManager · 21/01/2024 00:14

Interestingly, Golly had no racial aspect at all from his first appearance in the 1890s in Florence Upton's children's book, through becoming the second most popultist childrens toy in europe early in the 20th century until...

...nice Mr Hitler decided they looked like black people and therefore were not acceptable toys for good pure bred ayrian kids to play with and banned them.

so one of the most ardent racists in history banned the golly, because it looked like a group he didn't like.

That’s not actually true about Florence Upton. I believe she based her Gollywog character on minstrels, which are themselves a racist caricature, hence the way it’s dressed.

wombat1a · 21/01/2024 04:10

GrimDamnFanjo · 20/01/2024 16:44

I'm torn between this response and thinking surely everyone knows it isn't acceptable to have items like this on display?

OP I'm sorry you've been put in this situation.

I'm in my 50s and am a bit surprised that some posters think we are old enough to be naive about this.

Er no, I can very very easily understand that a middle aged bloke in small villlage UK would have no idea that this was considered unacceptable by many people today.

I can also very easily believe that if you tried to explain to them that it was considered unaccepable they wouldn't understand it either because they just won't see the link because to them equating a tiny doll figure to racism they just won't see it.

middler · 21/01/2024 04:19

people in their 50s had them as toys, or it is a sentimental collection he has inherited.... if he is a good teacher walking distance, I would overlook it as he seemed like a nice man. People collect weird things and in this case something that has in recent times been deemed no longer accepatble even though it was when he was a young person.

I doubt he will be showing his collection to your son. That would change things....

I have a colleague who showed me a picture of his recent holiday and his friend had hunted and killed the most beautiful mountain lion and he proudly showed it. I felt sick but just swallowed my response because whilst I don't agree with hunting or golliwog collecting some people don't hold my view. You could share with him how offensive they are, he may not know.

middler · 21/01/2024 04:40

Knowing how many ineffectual music teachers are out there, I would try him out and just let your son know if at any time he feels uncomfortable he can stop.

Or you could....Send him this article below and ask him to consider keeping his collection somewhere else in the house. I would be so upset if I had something in my home that made someone feel uncomfortable and maybe I was not aware of it. We are all having to get more educated today on how to make sure we are being respectful of others and this man just maybe did not get this - he may be horrified to find out the impact of that collection on someone.
https://jimcrowmuseum.ferris.edu/golliwog/

The Golliwog Caricature - Anti-black Imagery - Jim Crow Museum

https://jimcrowmuseum.ferris.edu/golliwog

Badgerandfox227 · 21/01/2024 04:45

Could you ask the teacher to come to your house? I dont think I could put my child in that situation each lesson, even if they said they were ok with it.

Anahenzaris · 21/01/2024 04:48

I didn’t know they were a socially unacceptable toy. To me they don’t signify anything other than being a kids toy. I wouldn’t have thought anything of seeing one, because I hadn’t been taught that they were racist.

OP find a different teacher, you obviously think owning these childhood toys means a person is racist, and/or that your child seeing them would cause him harm. Why would you send your child somewhere that you believe will cause him harm? Doesn’t matter if this is the best teacher since sliced bread, a lovely person completely without racism - you don’t trust him and think he’ll harm your son. Find a different teacher.

Oh - and don’t cause trouble by trying to close down his business, or trying to get him thrown out of the church choir. That’ll likely backfire. You’re new to the community, and going in sounding war trumpets against someone who is well liked because he hasn’t thrown out toys from his youth is going to make your family OTHERS very quickly.

MikeRafone · 21/01/2024 05:18

Oh - and don’t cause trouble by trying to close down his business, or trying to get him thrown out of the church choir. That’ll likely backfire. You’re new to the community, and going in sounding war trumpets against someone who is well liked because he hasn’t thrown out toys from his youth is going to make your family OTHERS very quickly.

what a vile paragraph of putrid words

Banrion · 21/01/2024 05:33

If he drives to others' houses, couldn't he come to your house? That way your fears about the psychological impact on your son are gone as he's not exposed to them.

Josette77 · 21/01/2024 05:40

Anahenzaris · 21/01/2024 04:48

I didn’t know they were a socially unacceptable toy. To me they don’t signify anything other than being a kids toy. I wouldn’t have thought anything of seeing one, because I hadn’t been taught that they were racist.

OP find a different teacher, you obviously think owning these childhood toys means a person is racist, and/or that your child seeing them would cause him harm. Why would you send your child somewhere that you believe will cause him harm? Doesn’t matter if this is the best teacher since sliced bread, a lovely person completely without racism - you don’t trust him and think he’ll harm your son. Find a different teacher.

Oh - and don’t cause trouble by trying to close down his business, or trying to get him thrown out of the church choir. That’ll likely backfire. You’re new to the community, and going in sounding war trumpets against someone who is well liked because he hasn’t thrown out toys from his youth is going to make your family OTHERS very quickly.

This screams of racism.

Hobbesmanc · 21/01/2024 07:05

middler · 21/01/2024 04:19

people in their 50s had them as toys, or it is a sentimental collection he has inherited.... if he is a good teacher walking distance, I would overlook it as he seemed like a nice man. People collect weird things and in this case something that has in recent times been deemed no longer accepatble even though it was when he was a young person.

I doubt he will be showing his collection to your son. That would change things....

I have a colleague who showed me a picture of his recent holiday and his friend had hunted and killed the most beautiful mountain lion and he proudly showed it. I felt sick but just swallowed my response because whilst I don't agree with hunting or golliwog collecting some people don't hold my view. You could share with him how offensive they are, he may not know.

I'm just not sure why you would swallow your own totally legitimate opinion and reactions just to please a stranger? If someone showed me a photo of a hunted animal I'd be disgusted and I'd tell them my feelings?

Outwiththenorm · 21/01/2024 07:19

RaccoonOnTheSofa · 20/01/2024 17:00

But bad people don’t always seem like bad people on the outside. They can be very charming.

Absolutely this. My elderly neighbour had vile racist views (which he was happy to express after a pint) and yet was charming and polite to the Pakistani family on our street (“I don’t mean them, they’re not like the rest”).

youarethroughtothenextround · 21/01/2024 07:23

Itslegitimatesalvage · 20/01/2024 16:18

Someone his age will have them because they were a children’s toy when he was a child. He’ll have probably collected them decades ago, they’ll hold childhood memories and that’s all he sees when he looks at them. Obviously now they have a very different connotation, and they are offensive and really not something to be cherished but some people still do. I’m not going to sit here and tell you that you’re wrong to feel how you feel because you’re not wrong. But I don’t think I’d look at this as the racist violin teacher but rather the nostalgic and rather politically tone death violin teacher. I wouldn’t let it stand in the way.

If he's in his 50s he should know.

luckylavender · 21/01/2024 07:38

madeinmanc · 20/01/2024 16:21

I'm just wondering - some kind of grotesque inheritance? Did he perhaps inherit the family home?

I'm in my 60s. I had a golliwog as a child. But if I'd 'inherited the family home', that trash would not be on display.

42n82noluv · 21/01/2024 07:45

I'm Black, in my 40's and it would be a hard no from me.

Hoglet70 · 21/01/2024 07:45

I had a Golliwog as a child. He is in my loft. I couldn't throw him away because my Nan bought him for me and I can remember five year old me loving him and being so excited to get him as my elder sister already had one. I had no clue as a child that there were any awful connotations, he was just like any of my soft toys.

Mcmach1 · 21/01/2024 07:53

Ask the Q.
People have a blindness to things that don't affect them.
Also perfectly possible to have a convo with someone in racist point of view. Not something to fear they have a reason that makes sense in their head.

TheGoogleMum · 21/01/2024 08:02

Some rural villages don't seem to get it. One holiday in the last few years the village we stayed in local shops nearly all sold them (they displayed signs saying not to take photos of them! We have no idea why. Made a point to buy from the shops that didnt have them). We're white but from a multicultural city and know it isn't OK.

I don't know what you should do OP, and my view as a white person probably isn't so helpful but I guess I wanted to add that some rural villages are like this (but it isn't fine!)

PuppyMonkey · 21/01/2024 08:08

This bloke doesn’t sound like he’s a simple rural hillbilly, he works in the next large town and is an educated person, who runs a business, not bloody Benny from Crossroads. He should know better.

MaggieNextDoor · 21/01/2024 08:21

He’s in his 50s, he’s not some doddery old man who’s completely unaware of the world around him. I would be very surprised if he was unaware of the racism associated with golliwogs. I certainly wouldn’t consider employing him to teach my child anything unless he acknowledged the figurines were unpleasant and removed them from sight.

TipulophobiaIsReal · 21/01/2024 08:22

TheGoogleMum · 21/01/2024 08:02

Some rural villages don't seem to get it. One holiday in the last few years the village we stayed in local shops nearly all sold them (they displayed signs saying not to take photos of them! We have no idea why. Made a point to buy from the shops that didnt have them). We're white but from a multicultural city and know it isn't OK.

I don't know what you should do OP, and my view as a white person probably isn't so helpful but I guess I wanted to add that some rural villages are like this (but it isn't fine!)

Oh they get it perfectly. The golliwogs are a message of defiance, a sign of what proud, independent thinkers they are Hmm

Mirabai · 21/01/2024 08:29

PropertyManager · 21/01/2024 00:14

Interestingly, Golly had no racial aspect at all from his first appearance in the 1890s in Florence Upton's children's book, through becoming the second most popultist childrens toy in europe early in the 20th century until...

...nice Mr Hitler decided they looked like black people and therefore were not acceptable toys for good pure bred ayrian kids to play with and banned them.

so one of the most ardent racists in history banned the golly, because it looked like a group he didn't like.

Not interesting or even true. Upton’s golly character was based on a black minstrel doll that belonged to her aunt.

Mirabai · 21/01/2024 08:33

@skatermom Nearest isn’t always best.