Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to pay for this commission?

328 replies

MikStone · 19/01/2024 08:28

My Sister is an artist and I asked her to paint a portrait of my dog.

Background - she started putting huge signatures across her work in red paint - So many people have told her that the signatures are OTT and distracting and actually ruin the painting - people on Facebook, people in her art group, family members … past customers have asked her not to do it on their portraits but she always does. One person argued with her that the portrait was amazing but was ruined by the signature, they wanted some money knocked off because of it. I asked her “why do you keep doing that when so many people have told you it ruins the pictures??” And she says “it doesn’t ruin them, that’s my style and most people like it” no they don’t!!

anyway when I asked her to do mine I was actually looking around for someone else to do it and when she asked why I hadn’t asked her I told her I don’t like the huge signatures she does. She laughed and said “I don’t have to do the signature!”

So I agreed for her to do it as long as she doesn’t put a massive signature on it.

Weeks later, I’m getting a bit impatient as I really wanted it weeks ago and had I gone to someone else it would have been done by now. She sent me an update on it last week and it was looking amazing, I was so excited about it.

Last night she sent me the finished work - massive red signature across it. I replied saying “why have you ruined it with that stupid signature?! I can’t accept it like that”. She replied saying the signature was a lot smaller than she normally does them and she’s spent weeks on it and needs paying. I don’t want it :-( The agreement was so daft signature, she went against that. WIBU to not accept it?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
triballeader · 19/01/2024 11:56

Portraits are incredibly personal and a portraiture artist will spend time getting to know both the subject and the person commissioning to ensure their style and what the commissioner is looking for are a good match. I have refused commissions when I consider my style and way of working does not suit what someone is looking for. You were very clear that you did not want a bright red signature splashed over the work. That might be appropriate for a tag for graffiti but not for a specified piece of fine art portraiture. The artist did what you had clearly expressed you did not want and has blighted the work. She should expect that to ruin the sale for her. It MIGHT be possible to paint over depending on the pigment and medium used but experience has taught me most reds can be enduring and leach through. (If you know the paint used and the exact name for the red colour I can check for you)

If I produce a finished piece of work the person commissioning is not happy about I do not expect them to pay for that. I do ask for a none returnable deposit for commissions to cover the costs of materials and make it clear that if a person does not pay for the final piece I as the artist own the work to do with as I wish it as well as the copyright.Most portraits cannot be sold on so it pays me to listen and get it right the first time around.

Earning money as an artist is a very tough hussle . You will only ever earn what the target market is willing to pay and if you do not listen to your clients and produce the work they have requested you can expect them to go elsewhere.

You being asked to pay out £200 for a portrait that has been ruined by not meeting your specification is unreasonable.

LadyPoison · 19/01/2024 11:50

I was going to say that of course you should pay then I read the rest of your post!

She knew you didn't like or want the huge signature and were prepared to go elsewhere to avoid it but then did it anyway.

I wouldn't pay for it.

diddl · 19/01/2024 11:47

Lougle · 19/01/2024 11:45

Was it like this?

I thought of that!

Don't think he signed all like that though.

Lougle · 19/01/2024 11:45

Was it like this?

To refuse to pay for this commission?
theDudesmummy · 19/01/2024 11:44

If the sister wants to include her signature in an artwork, whether it is big, small or gigantic, that is entirely her own decision as an artist. But if a piece is commissioned to be a certain way and she accepted the commission and expects payment for it, then she has to do it that way.

Tinkerbyebye · 19/01/2024 11:44

You asked her not to do the signature. She did so went against what you wanted so nope wouldn’t be paying

its time she learnt a life lesson, people don’t want her signature over the painting, either she learns or she stops getting commissions.

if she can’t/wont paint over it then i would not be paying and would get someone else

Lougle · 19/01/2024 11:41

trollopolis · 19/01/2024 10:03

Yes of course I did.

She was "looking around for" another artist, but does not say she had chosen one.

She chose her DSis, on the basis of no "massive" signature.

Their respective (and subjective) views of what is fairly described as "massive" aren't going to get resolved.

As this is also a family matter, then perhaps the wider relationship needs to be taken in to account when pondering what could or should be done next

Wrong. The OP says:

"anyway when I asked her to do mine I was actually looking around for someone else to do it and when she asked why I hadn’t asked her I told her I don’t like the huge signatures she does. She laughed and said “I don’t have to do the signature! ...So I agreed for her to do it as long as she doesn’t put a massive signature on it.”

'Massive signature' in this context refers to the signature as a whole (which is massive) rather than any signature that can be describe as either small or massive or anything in between.

AppaTheSixLeggedFlyingBison · 19/01/2024 11:39

I feel like I need a diagram if not a picture of the actual thing 😂

stillplentyofjunkinthetrunk · 19/01/2024 11:39

You have 3 options so far as I can see...

  1. pay to keep the peace with your sister. In which case I wouldn't accept the painting or display it if you don't like it. Apologise that you should have gone with your instincts but you thought you'd made your feelings clear.

  2. Ask her to fix the painting. Tell her that you have no objection to her signing her work but you aren't prepared to pay for a stylised autograph. Tell her to look at how vincent van gogh signed his paintings small writing, subtle position, colours often chosen to blend in with the picture. Be clear precisely what you are prepared to accept. e.g. a signature in black which fits in a square no more than 1" by 1" in the bottom left corner. Pay if and only if she can do this.

  3. Just don't pay her, don't accept the picture. If and when she brings it up say something like 'Professionals get paid for their time, and do what the customers want. Hobbyists can do whatever they please, but can struggle to get anyone to buy their work.'

All of these approaches have pros and cons.

AppaTheSixLeggedFlyingBison · 19/01/2024 11:38

It's normal for artists to sign their work. But they normally do it in a colour which corresponds to the painting, fairly small, in the corner.

When you say massive do you mean across the picture or just very large under the picture?

TempleOfBloom · 19/01/2024 11:36

Sarvanga38 · 19/01/2024 11:27

Now I'm assuming that you chose her for family reasons.

As the OP says, she said she WASN'T going to use her and was talked in to the fact that the sister would do it as required - and at £200, she's hardly doing it at 'mates rates', is she ... ?!

£200 is very cheap for a commissioned portrait!

LindyLou2020 · 19/01/2024 11:35

@MikStone
Try me next time!

To refuse to pay for this commission?
To refuse to pay for this commission?
Jovacknockowitch · 19/01/2024 11:31

This is why I never get involved with friends and family for business stuff YABU to imagine that a person you complained about for doing this and whom you considered was already unreasonable was going to be different for you. You should pay as a fine for you failure to see this as it was so obvious.

BringOnFebBankHoliday · 19/01/2024 11:28

Glad to see I'm not the only one who really, really, really wants to see these paintings!

Sarvanga38 · 19/01/2024 11:27

Now I'm assuming that you chose her for family reasons.

As the OP says, she said she WASN'T going to use her and was talked in to the fact that the sister would do it as required - and at £200, she's hardly doing it at 'mates rates', is she ... ?!

Gonners · 19/01/2024 11:26

This thread has made me think of the magnificent Pet Portraits By Hercule on Facebook.

MorrisZapp · 19/01/2024 11:21

Does she advertise her work on social media?

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 19/01/2024 11:21

Even Monet didn’t do this! Or Van Gogh.

are you sure the paintings are that good , OP? Perhaps the signature is hiding the bit where the shoulder meets the top of the leg, always hard to get right? Or the accident where someone leant on it before it was dry ( easily done) 🤡

Beautiful3 · 19/01/2024 11:16

She obviously has a large ego, to do that. She verbally agreed not to do the large signature, but lied to you! Just tell her you're notnpaying until she sorts it out. Do not accept it.

FuckoffeeBeforeCoffee · 19/01/2024 11:15

I'm also dying to see some of her work.

Ulysees · 19/01/2024 11:14

I don't know whether she's arrogant, bonkers or both??
I definitely wouldn't pay. There's loads of talented artists crying out for work. Very odd indeed.

MassiveOvaryaction · 19/01/2024 11:13

It's not what you commissioned if you specifically said not to include a massive signature so YANBU not to pay imo. Though maybe you should have specified exactly what size signature would be approved before she started.

TeresaCrowd · 19/01/2024 11:12

I think the issue here might be that you meant no (massive signature) as in you didnt want a signature at all as part of the artwork (fine on the back, side etc but not in the picture) and she read (no massive) signature, as in signature fine, in red fine, on the front fine, as long as it's not massive, which is subjective.

However having seen the work if you ask for it to be removed then she should work round that to deliver work that suits the customer.

Next time avoid family for these things!

Forbreadalone · 19/01/2024 11:12

She can paint over it?

Thehamsterthatcametotea · 19/01/2024 11:09

This is why you never do business with family.

Swipe left for the next trending thread