Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex husband worth a million and offered me only £7000 financial claim

309 replies

AmyJahabee · 16/01/2024 13:57

Hi all,

I made a financial claim against my ex husband and he offered me £5000 and he is worth almost a million. Is this suppose to be a joke.

we were married for 7 years I was not working at the time so he pay for everything whilst I look after the house, no children involved in the marriage. Is that all I get because I didn’t contribute financially? It’s been 3years since the divorce, he has put in so much lies about me towards his statement. I’m going to decline the offer.

can I just decline or ask for a reasonable amount?

OP posts:
Barbarella73 · 16/01/2024 17:59

Lovesacake · 16/01/2024 17:14

Op it sounds like you need to report him to the police for what he did to you? Have you spoken to rape crisis or woman’s aid?
his violence doesn’t mean he owes you money but he does deserve a criminal record

This is it, in a nutshell.

Notimeforaname · 16/01/2024 17:57

You need to report the beatings and rapes, not look for financial compensation

BlueGrey1 · 16/01/2024 17:54

Did you get the house?
if not where did you and the children live after you separated and for how long and who was paying for this
What is your and the children current living situation

BintuBombatu · 16/01/2024 17:52

Oh your other thread, you say you have two children, and had just broken up with a new boyfriend.

You’ll need to post accurate information if you want advice.

Are the child your ex-husband’s?

Sodndashitall · 16/01/2024 17:50

AmyJahabee · 16/01/2024 17:08

A lot of you are judgemental:

this guy verbally and physically abuse me throughout the relationship. So you expect me to stay forever with torture?

he treated me with so much disrespect and humiliation throughout the marriage and relationship, he’s 20 years older than me I was 18 ( I had no family just me living by myself with no one looking out or guiding me. I was isolated) when we met, I was young stupid and naive. This was 17 years ago. He would constantly rape me, physically beat me. No one in his family respected me, I was cleaning cooking and his mum refer to me as the maid of the house.

when we got divorced I was aware I can make financial claim against him, got no legal advice or nothing.

for me it’s not about the money is the way I was treated like a trash and nothing!!

I have a good job so I can maintain myself but that’s not the point here. Why was I treated like that?

OP he sounds like a horrible person. Unfortunately that doesn't really come into play for the financial settlement.
If you didn't work and he had the majority of this cash prior to the marriage and there's no children, you are not likely to get that much. I can't say whther 7k is the right amount as it involves understanding the full financial picture.
I'd say refuse the 7k and then find a solicitor. If you don't know one just Google and read reviews or ask around at work

Loubelle70 · 16/01/2024 17:47

Appleofmyeye2023 · 16/01/2024 17:33

Off track I know…but

Why do you not advise your clients to first head to ADVICE NOW website. Save their half an hour for pertinent questions once they’ve got their own heads around process. If they head to free solicitor consult first they’ll get 30 minutes of solicitors telling them such basic stuff, vague, and then a sell.

please look at this site, and think about changing your advice to also or instead, look there first.

honestly, sending women to solicitors first sends them down a pathway of high bills. There’s so much of process you can do yourself ..even a reasonable 8 year old could. We need to empower women to take command of this, and use solicitors for the actual specific tasks they can’t do themselves.

OP has been given advice about solicitor...within that 30 minutes solicitor will tell her if she has a case... then she can choose what to do... go her own way or use solicitor at cost. Exactly the information we would give at WA and citizens advice. Don't insult my professionalism...OP has suffered DV DA if she needs support she can contact us.

Givemegoldensun · 16/01/2024 17:47

What are you talking about? You do realise that the vast majority of Mumsnet users are women in their thirties and forties most of whom will have grown up in the nineties with working and middle class working mums. I was born in 1986 and my mum was a middle manager for social services. She stopped work when she had children but only for maternity leave, returning part time until we started primary school at which point she went full time. Almost all of her friends were similar, working in middle paying professional jobs- teachers, librarians, therapists, artists, academics etc. pretty much all of them were university educated (admittedly usually first generation) and none of them were stay at home mums or wives. That’s not to say there weren’t SAHM, but they were certainly not the norm.

CoasttoCoastlines · 16/01/2024 17:45

Are you being disrespectful to me? My "knowledge of british history"?
Are you serious? I live in the UK!

Well, British has an upper case B if you want to be pedantic.

I hate to think what kind of nanny you were as you appear to be very angry here if anyone dares to say you've got the wrong idea.

Honestly, what you are saying is that women like me who started work in the mid 1970s, lived through the times of Woodstock (you won't know what that was!), wore hippy beads, long skirts- oh and minis too- are lying.

You're negating our lived experiences.

redastherose · 16/01/2024 17:44

AmyJahabee · 16/01/2024 17:08

A lot of you are judgemental:

this guy verbally and physically abuse me throughout the relationship. So you expect me to stay forever with torture?

he treated me with so much disrespect and humiliation throughout the marriage and relationship, he’s 20 years older than me I was 18 ( I had no family just me living by myself with no one looking out or guiding me. I was isolated) when we met, I was young stupid and naive. This was 17 years ago. He would constantly rape me, physically beat me. No one in his family respected me, I was cleaning cooking and his mum refer to me as the maid of the house.

when we got divorced I was aware I can make financial claim against him, got no legal advice or nothing.

for me it’s not about the money is the way I was treated like a trash and nothing!!

I have a good job so I can maintain myself but that’s not the point here. Why was I treated like that?

OP all of that is vital information which explains why you weren't working full time. Please contact a solicitor, if you were subjected to abuse you would be entitled to legal aid for a solicitor. The facts here indicate that you may well be able to make a claim for a decent split of the assets. Also, the total length of your relationship counts not just the time you were married so if you dated for 2 years before marrying they will take into account a 9 year relationship not just the 7 years you were married.

Puffalicious · 16/01/2024 17:43

CoasttoCoastlines · 16/01/2024 17:41

@NannyAnabela This is a wind-up surely?

Did you work for middle Eastern or Asian families where women had to stay at home?

You are being very rude- and very silly- about women like me who started work in the early 1970s and were surrounded by other professional women.

I think you should butt out as you're in danger of making yourself a laughing stock. (And I think some of your posts have already been deleted for being so rude.)

You've summed it up.

Fingeronthebutton · 16/01/2024 17:42

You havnt got a hope in hell of getting any more, and nor should you.

Puffalicious · 16/01/2024 17:41

NannyAnabela · 16/01/2024 17:38

I join this site as I though it is of british mothers, or mothers that are in the UK.
It doesn't seem to be entirely the case.

Are you being disrespectful to me? My "knowledge of british history"?
Are you serious? I live in the UK!

It seems to be you who don't know about - not even british history - but british society and culture.

You "graduated" but you don't even seem to be able to read my post!.

Poor women have always worked, that is called poverty. They worked in the fields, in the factories. We are not talking about that type of work.
We were talking about couples who have the financial, social and cultural status in which they can choose for the woman to be a homemaker and stay at home.

We are talking about women who could chose to go to a highschool, a college, a university and chose what they studied and which not only job but career they had.

Women started working in a more widespread way after WWII because they work was needed, the men were in the war and many returned wounded or didnt return at all.

The first choices that women started to have was to be a teacher, a nurse, an air stewardess, a secretary.
Then it followed with Lawyers, Economist - very rare, doctors.
It is only in the last 20 years that women can chose any job they want and that having a university degree is the normal.

Edited

Honestly. Give it a rest. Why are your experiences more 'correct ' than the rest of us. Those of us responding to you ARE from the UK, many born here & raised here as children, so actually know their own lives.

VenhamousSnake · 16/01/2024 17:41

so you had no children and were lucky enough not to have to work your whole marriage and you think you should be compensated?

This. Sounds like he was paying while you were studying?

The fact that he was abusive is a separate issue and I'd suggest you seek legal advice if you want to pursue that with police etc

CoasttoCoastlines · 16/01/2024 17:41

@NannyAnabela This is a wind-up surely?

Did you work for middle Eastern or Asian families where women had to stay at home?

You are being very rude- and very silly- about women like me who started work in the early 1970s and were surrounded by other professional women.

I think you should butt out as you're in danger of making yourself a laughing stock. (And I think some of your posts have already been deleted for being so rude.)

EddieMunson · 16/01/2024 17:39

And to return to the 21st century, leaving NannyAnabela to go back to hanging around outside Buckingham Palace, hoping to see Queen Victoria…

OP, don’t you have two children with your husband?

Shoutinglagerlagerlager · 16/01/2024 17:39

Leyenda · 16/01/2024 14:22

  1. Ignore 99% of the advice you get on Mumsnet, particularly any from envious posters criticising you for having been a housewife. I recognise that we don’t know your situation, or your culture, we don’t know if your husband bullied you into being a fulltime housewife so he could control you, we don’t know if you spent those years trying to conceive or had losses, and we don’t know your current physical or mental health situation. Perhaps most importantly, you have not asked anyone here for advice on what choices you should have made a decade ago. Nor should you accept advice on that.
  2. Google ‘divorce solicitor near me’ then phone 5 of them, explain your ex husband has £1m but has made an insulting offer and ask if they will give you a free initial meeting. They will. It is also possible someone might accept your case with the deal that they get paid out of a settlement.
  3. If after seeing a few divorce solicitors for free meetings you really can’t afford to hire one, make plans to represent yourself and ask your local Citizens Advice Bureau for help.
  4. Never accept someone’s opening offer, particularly if they are looking to hurt you.

This is the only advice you need OP

Puffalicious · 16/01/2024 17:38

CoasttoCoastlines · 16/01/2024 17:37

@NannyAnabela Can I respectfully suggest you stop posting these comments. They are doing you no favours as they are completely, and utterly wrong. And they are just showing what you don't know.

I am older than you are.

I started work in 1974 after finishing university.

I even wore mini skirts in the 1960s.

I went jogging. I wore trousers. I had 'documents'.

I think perhaps your work was with a certain culture, where the men didn't allow their wives to be free and do what western-born women in the UK did.

It's meant you have a very false idea of life in those times.

👏

topnoddy · 16/01/2024 17:38

Did you have a solicitor when you got divorced then ?

NannyAnabela · 16/01/2024 17:38

I join this site as I though it is of british mothers, or mothers that are in the UK.
It doesn't seem to be entirely the case.

Are you being disrespectful to me? My "knowledge of british history"?
Are you serious? I live in the UK!

It seems to be you who don't know about - not even british history - but british society and culture.

You "graduated" but you don't even seem to be able to read my post!.

Poor women have always worked, that is called poverty. They worked in the fields, in the factories. We are not talking about that type of work.
We were talking about couples who have the financial, social and cultural status in which they can choose for the woman to be a homemaker and stay at home.

We are talking about women who could chose to go to a highschool, a college, a university and chose what they studied and which not only job but career they had.

Women started working in a more widespread way after WWII because they work was needed, the men were in the war and many returned wounded or didnt return at all.

The first choices that women started to have was to be a teacher, a nurse, an air stewardess, a secretary.
Then it followed with Lawyers, Economist - very rare, doctors.
It is only in the last 20 years that women can chose any job they want and that having a university degree is the normal.

Puffalicious · 16/01/2024 17:38

NannyAnabela · 16/01/2024 17:26

I worked in the UK from 1990 until 1995 as an Au-Pair and Mother's Helper.

I am talking about what I saw, experienced and learnt during that time. Real life.
People that existed, people that I worked for while living inside their houses; their friends and families.

Many of those people are still alive today.
I was only 7 years younger that one of those mothers, they are in their 60's nowadays.

I think some people need to go and read some newspapers, magazines and watch some TV programmes to know how things were in those days. Not that long ago. I am talking about 35 years ago. - Or Just talk to their family members!

Edited

Yes, but that's YOUR experience, others' are very different. Society isn't one colour for everyone.

I went to university in 1988. I travelled the world afterwards. I've now been teaching 29 years. I've had 3 children, a divorce & another marriage along the way. My sisters are similar (and my brothers). My beloved mam (born 1940) worked before children & went back to work when I went to school, continuing to work until she was 68.

Working class background. Absolutely not unusual in any way in our area. My best friend's mother ran her own, v successful business; my good friend's mother was a lecturer; another a pharmacist, and on it goes.

Alohapotato · 16/01/2024 17:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

we don't know her circunstamces maybe she was ill.

CoasttoCoastlines · 16/01/2024 17:37

NannyAnabela · 16/01/2024 17:26

I worked in the UK from 1990 until 1995 as an Au-Pair and Mother's Helper.

I am talking about what I saw, experienced and learnt during that time. Real life.
People that existed, people that I worked for while living inside their houses; their friends and families.

Many of those people are still alive today.
I was only 7 years younger that one of those mothers, they are in their 60's nowadays.

I think some people need to go and read some newspapers, magazines and watch some TV programmes to know how things were in those days. Not that long ago. I am talking about 35 years ago. - Or Just talk to their family members!

Edited

@NannyAnabela Can I respectfully suggest you stop posting these comments. They are doing you no favours as they are completely, and utterly wrong. And they are just showing what you don't know.

I am older than you are.

I started work in 1974 after finishing university.

I even wore mini skirts in the 1960s.

I went jogging. I wore trousers. I had 'documents'.

I think perhaps your work was with a certain culture, where the men didn't allow their wives to be free and do what western-born women in the UK did.

It's meant you have a very false idea of life in those times.

NannyAnabela · 16/01/2024 17:34

You are amazing.
You have the audacity to call me a liar!

What I have said is the truth and I stand by every word that stated, because it is the real truth.

It is my generation - I am European (from a very developed society) - the first to study on a widespread way, have careers and have children.

Many people of my generation - and after - have chosen not to have children so that they don't lose the professional, social and financial status, amongs other reasons.

The generation of mothers who are now on the thirties to forties is the first one to have careers on a widespread way. Not saying that a few women from the upper classes didn't have careers, they did, but they were rare.

Having children before getting married?????
Which social class are you refering to?
Not in my country, not in the UK, in the social class that I belong to or move in.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 16/01/2024 17:33

Loubelle70 · 16/01/2024 17:29

I work at womens aid OP...We would advise contacting solicitor, 30 mins pro bono..then ask if they can represent you and take fee from settlement.

Off track I know…but

Why do you not advise your clients to first head to ADVICE NOW website. Save their half an hour for pertinent questions once they’ve got their own heads around process. If they head to free solicitor consult first they’ll get 30 minutes of solicitors telling them such basic stuff, vague, and then a sell.

please look at this site, and think about changing your advice to also or instead, look there first.

honestly, sending women to solicitors first sends them down a pathway of high bills. There’s so much of process you can do yourself ..even a reasonable 8 year old could. We need to empower women to take command of this, and use solicitors for the actual specific tasks they can’t do themselves.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 16/01/2024 17:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This ^