Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Customer service situation at work - investigation

256 replies

Londdi · 08/01/2024 17:51

I work in a swimming pool. Week ago customer walked in 2 mins before closing time. It was long and exhausting day -we had competitions in a pool / I did job for two people and didn’t even have a break. She starts off by “I recently got a membership…” which is usually query that needs some work on computer - our computers do get turn off 30 mins prior so I interrupted “I don’t think I’ll be much help out computers are already off” I don’t think I used any negative tone, but I was extremely tired about to grab a coat and go home. The customer got extremely upset that I didn’t let her finish . In normal circumstances I would apologise and let her continue and just stayed extra, but she was on a phone and started saying to the person on a line how disgusting my customer service is etc. wanted to speak to manager . So I left home as my manager said knowing how tough that day was. Am I in a wrong here ? This customer wants me fired . I know I probably should have not interrupt and it was a mistake, but is it really that huge to get fired over ? Am I being unreasonable and my behaviour was that bad? (Been in company for 8 years).

OP posts:
MindHowYouGoes · 09/01/2024 08:27

You were very rude and I’d have complained about you too. Since you started out thinking you were in the right and full of excuses maybe this isn’t the first time a customer has found you curt or unhelpful. Also ageist - just because the woman was older it doesn’t mean she doesn’t know how to work an app.

id have a think about how you could adjust the attitude a bit so you can be prepared to have a useful conversation with your manager. Definitely don’t mention the fact you just wanted to go home.

Neriah · 09/01/2024 08:23

Londdi · 08/01/2024 19:40

Our membership enquires are usually quite technical in nature (app/smartphone) and the lady was pensioner …. Yes it was an assumption based on reality . Didn’t mean to shame someone based on age . Like I wouldn’t shame my own mum but I understand that it’s much harder to understand for older generation or explain what the issue is.

When in a hole, stop digging. As one of the older generation and over pension age, I will lay bets that I and many of my similarly aged mates coulod run rings around you with any technology you care to select.

You really need to address your bias and prejudices around older people.

DeeLusional · 09/01/2024 08:20

Towerofsong · 08/01/2024 21:14

Sounds like she could have come in 25 minutes before closing and your response would be the same 'computers are off'

Why are the computers turned off half an hour before closing? They should only take 3 minutes to lower down!

OP isn't management, the time the computers are turned off isn't down to her.

forcedfun · 09/01/2024 08:10

margotrose · 09/01/2024 06:27

specifically going in two minutes before closing is, especially doing whilst on your phone. It's rude!

But the customer is not paid to be polite and considerate about timing - OP is. That's her job. It's not the customers fault if she doesn't get paid after closing - they're doing nothing wrong with coming in at 5.58 and asking a question.

So you are only polite and considerate when you are being paid to be?

Good grief. No wonder some people are monstrously rude to those working in customer service. It's almost like some (vile) people get a kick out of being rude and treating those in customer service like dirt.

IBE45 · 09/01/2024 08:09

margotrose · 09/01/2024 06:27

specifically going in two minutes before closing is, especially doing whilst on your phone. It's rude!

But the customer is not paid to be polite and considerate about timing - OP is. That's her job. It's not the customers fault if she doesn't get paid after closing - they're doing nothing wrong with coming in at 5.58 and asking a question.

Of course they're not, but it's about being a decent human being. I don't purposely go into places at closing time and delay people getting out on time, because I realise that their time is just as important as my own. I agreed that OP could have been politer, no doubt about it. People working in customer facing roles are often poorly paid, understaffed and have to put up with a lot of crap from people, why make their jobs harder or more unpleasant just because you can? I know this is true of many roles, but again why actively do it.

This thread has made me realised how differently I think from so many mumsnetters. It's a bit depressing actually.

JenniferJupiterVenusandMars · 09/01/2024 07:20

Coconutter24 · 08/01/2024 20:57

If you have any meetings with work regarding this please do not say what you just wrote! You’re basically saying you couldn’t be bothered to explain to her because she’s old and probably wouldn’t get it.

You were rude to her you shut her down before she’d even got the question out and you could have handled it much better. Regardless of how crap of a day you were having it wasn’t the customers fault. I do get how frustrating it is though when it’s time to nearly clock off and a customer comes in but they are still a customer and you were still at work

WTF OP!?
You definitely have a very poor attitude that’s offensive and ageist.

PriOn1 · 09/01/2024 07:17

You say you were doing the work of two people without a break that day. Are they short staffed in general? If they are, they’re not going to sack someone who’s been there eight years over something so minor.

It doesn’t sound like a sackable offence anyway and the client was rude as well. Do you know from the manager how it was resolved? Might it be that she complained about the manager as well?

Anyway, as most people who work with the general public know, there are a few despicable people in the world who seem to enjoy making other people’s lives a misery and she’s clearly one of them. Anyone normal and decent wouldn’t address you when on the phone and certainly wouldn’t moan to the (possibly fictional) person on the other end of the line, rather than engaging with you properly.

I hope that it comes to nothing, OP, but surely the worst would be a verbal warning not to do it again. If you have a proper contract, it’s not a sackable offence.

Good luck.

Rocksonabeach · 09/01/2024 07:11

SkulkHollow · 08/01/2024 22:36

Would you be "really pissed off" or would you, like any reasonable person, be slightly put out at worst and then move on?

I can't imagine ever getting upset about something so utterly minor as this.

yes I think I might be a bit pissed off if I had just paid hundreds or thousands for a membership and was just cut off rudely and told we were shut and technically they were open.

but I think the issue here is the place shuts at 5 pm and the person is paid to 5 pm and really the person needs to be paid longer and finished later.

the issue of the customer being on her phone is a separate one.

RandomUser82 · 09/01/2024 06:52

I work in a home furniture shop. New years day-open til 5. Couple come in at 4.40 looking at mirrors. Customer service gives the usual "15/10/5 minutes til closing" announcements. 2 minutes (yes really) to 5 they tell me they want a mirror, I'm usually very polite but I actually couldn't help myself saying "now!?" They sheepishly nodded. I unhooked the mirror and they said and can you carry it to my car? Now this mirror was a very big mirror. I said no. I said I'll carry it to the door but I clock off in 2 minutes. They said what if we pull the car to the door, will you put it in? I still said no. I don't get paid 1 minute after 5. I was half expecting a complaint but none has come so far. I don't understand people who come in so close to closing to browse. Yeah nip in for something you forgot, but don't expect workers (it would have been everyone in the shop) to stay late for you.

margotrose · 09/01/2024 06:27

specifically going in two minutes before closing is, especially doing whilst on your phone. It's rude!

But the customer is not paid to be polite and considerate about timing - OP is. That's her job. It's not the customers fault if she doesn't get paid after closing - they're doing nothing wrong with coming in at 5.58 and asking a question.

NaughtybutNice77 · 09/01/2024 03:10

You were rude and unprofessional. If a formal complaint has been raised I would expect some sort of formal 'action' eg a verbal warning.
It doesn't constitute gross misconduct, so presuming your previous conduct has been good it's not a cause for dismissal.
Take it on the chin and move on.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 09/01/2024 02:25

SkulkHollow · 08/01/2024 21:05

Honestly, don't worry about it. There is no way you will lose your job over this.

I don't even think you were particually rude from what you say. People need to chill the fuck out and accept that people working customer facing jobs occasionally don't behave according to some ridiculous, made up standard.

Actually, they do. It's their job.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 09/01/2024 02:17

Tagyoureit · 08/01/2024 19:10

Meh, I couldn't get worked up over this. You were a tad rude but someone wanting you to lose your job is really a foul, bitter person!

Customers are twats and after nearly 20 years in customer facing roles, that is sadly a fact I can't ever see chaging!

There's an easy answer to that - if you aren't suited to a customer service role then you shouldn't be doing it. There are plenty of othes who actually do care about providing good service, who would be far better in the role.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 09/01/2024 02:11

Missingmyusername · 08/01/2024 20:56

^This
I’d be trotting out the old line “I’m sorry you feel that way” etc to the customer to placate them. Of course you won’t get the sack. Customer sounds like a dick.

You do realise what a job in customer service entails? The clue is in the name - you are supposed to be providing a service to the CUSTOMER. I wonder how some of you even get, let alone keep, jobs.

Nanny0gg · 09/01/2024 00:59

MaisyAndTallulah · 08/01/2024 20:12

Maybe but your post is far from helpful. I mean, you're pretty rude yourself.

Because I am sick to the back teeth of people thinking it's OK to refer to anyone over the age of 60 as doddeting old fools. It's the one acceptable -ism

IBE45 · 09/01/2024 00:48

Muchof · 09/01/2024 00:09

I don't see what is not normal about approaching a member of staff with a question two minutes before closing time. Confused What do you think the cut off should be, five minutes before closing time, ten minutes? Or how about just closing time.

And why do you think you are the only person that spotted this, it is right there in the first sentence.

Edited

Approaching a member of staff if you're already in the building using the facilities isn't not normal. But specifically going in two minutes before closing is, especially doing whilst on your phone. It's rude! Staff in these places aren't often paid beyond closing time and often already don't get out on time without people coming in the door at closing time with queries which they can't even hang up the phone for. If she couldn't get of the phone it clearly wasn't urgent. OP could have been a bit politer, apologised and said she'd get back to her tomorrow etc. But we're all human and no one in customer service can be 100% on it all the time. Lastly, customers who say that they would like people to be fired over minor infractions are generally not normal.

VanillaImpulse · 09/01/2024 00:43

In the meeting it might be worthwhile bringing up the fact that you didn't get your break you were legally entitled to and also were doing the work of two people.

Muchof · 09/01/2024 00:09

IBE45 · 08/01/2024 23:59

I think people are missing the fact that the customer came in two minutes before closing. Normal people don't do this! People who do this are generally trouble makers or people who think they're far more important than everyone else.

I don't see what is not normal about approaching a member of staff with a question two minutes before closing time. Confused What do you think the cut off should be, five minutes before closing time, ten minutes? Or how about just closing time.

And why do you think you are the only person that spotted this, it is right there in the first sentence.

IBE45 · 08/01/2024 23:59

I think people are missing the fact that the customer came in two minutes before closing. Normal people don't do this! People who do this are generally trouble makers or people who think they're far more important than everyone else.

forcedfun · 08/01/2024 23:53

Rocksonabeach · 08/01/2024 22:18

I would be really pissed off though if I rushed to pop into the gym that I had just paid a membership for, before they shut at 5 pm, and I said ‘I’ve just brought a membership and …’ the member of staff cut me off. I don’t know what type of day she’s had but equally she doesn’t know if my aunt had a heart attack that day either or if I’ve just had a bad day and she’s brought a membership - she’s the customer. Offer to apologise. Offer to retrain if needed etc shutting at 5 pm doesn’t mean you finish at 5 pm it means customer can’t come in after 5 pm. When I used to work somewhere that shut at 5 pm we were all paid until 5.30 pm and staying until then. Else you need to state of being paid only until 5 pm that the doors shut at 4.30 pm and clients need to be aware of this.

It's a leisure centre not a&e, people don't need anything so urgently it won't wait till the next day.

I used to have people hammering on the door of the deli I worked in because they had promised their wife they would be olives or whatever for the dinner party and were running late. Err no, it's not life or death.

I doubt the members want to pay an additional 10% on their fees so that staff can all work half an hour longer every day.

Paw2024 · 08/01/2024 23:27

Been there with that type of customer
Told most days how awful our customer service is. Been told I should lose my job
Which translates to I offered an appointment which was too far in advance as we are booked up
The immediate reaction is for them to rant how awful my customer service is. It's not, they just don't like what I'm saying and that's not bad service!

I get why you close down - last admissions are way before you close so technically you shouldn't need the computer for anything

If anything it'll probably be training/warning but it's not really something they would sack you for

Christmascarrots · 08/01/2024 23:09

Rocksonabeach · 08/01/2024 22:18

I would be really pissed off though if I rushed to pop into the gym that I had just paid a membership for, before they shut at 5 pm, and I said ‘I’ve just brought a membership and …’ the member of staff cut me off. I don’t know what type of day she’s had but equally she doesn’t know if my aunt had a heart attack that day either or if I’ve just had a bad day and she’s brought a membership - she’s the customer. Offer to apologise. Offer to retrain if needed etc shutting at 5 pm doesn’t mean you finish at 5 pm it means customer can’t come in after 5 pm. When I used to work somewhere that shut at 5 pm we were all paid until 5.30 pm and staying until then. Else you need to state of being paid only until 5 pm that the doors shut at 4.30 pm and clients need to be aware of this.

Sure we’ll all put in an extra 30 mins, just in case the recently bereaved have a query about their gym membership.

MadCatLady27 · 08/01/2024 23:07

I used to work in a call centre and had a few customer complaints, you're generally taken into a meeting room, made to listen to the call and asked how you'd deal with it differently and if they're doing customer service training, made to attend it. So imagine they will go over what happened and ask you how you should have done it differently

Also last minute customers are frustrating, but it was drummed into you that the call was in the queue before closing time, therefore it must be answered.

SkulkHollow · 08/01/2024 22:36

Would you be "really pissed off" or would you, like any reasonable person, be slightly put out at worst and then move on?

I can't imagine ever getting upset about something so utterly minor as this.

Rocksonabeach · 08/01/2024 22:18

I would be really pissed off though if I rushed to pop into the gym that I had just paid a membership for, before they shut at 5 pm, and I said ‘I’ve just brought a membership and …’ the member of staff cut me off. I don’t know what type of day she’s had but equally she doesn’t know if my aunt had a heart attack that day either or if I’ve just had a bad day and she’s brought a membership - she’s the customer. Offer to apologise. Offer to retrain if needed etc shutting at 5 pm doesn’t mean you finish at 5 pm it means customer can’t come in after 5 pm. When I used to work somewhere that shut at 5 pm we were all paid until 5.30 pm and staying until then. Else you need to state of being paid only until 5 pm that the doors shut at 4.30 pm and clients need to be aware of this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread