Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Customer service situation at work - investigation

256 replies

Londdi · 08/01/2024 17:51

I work in a swimming pool. Week ago customer walked in 2 mins before closing time. It was long and exhausting day -we had competitions in a pool / I did job for two people and didn’t even have a break. She starts off by “I recently got a membership…” which is usually query that needs some work on computer - our computers do get turn off 30 mins prior so I interrupted “I don’t think I’ll be much help out computers are already off” I don’t think I used any negative tone, but I was extremely tired about to grab a coat and go home. The customer got extremely upset that I didn’t let her finish . In normal circumstances I would apologise and let her continue and just stayed extra, but she was on a phone and started saying to the person on a line how disgusting my customer service is etc. wanted to speak to manager . So I left home as my manager said knowing how tough that day was. Am I in a wrong here ? This customer wants me fired . I know I probably should have not interrupt and it was a mistake, but is it really that huge to get fired over ? Am I being unreasonable and my behaviour was that bad? (Been in company for 8 years).

OP posts:
Yayhelen · 09/01/2024 19:22

The employer should have a formal process/policy or guidance on conduct issues - is there an intranet or a HR person? Get a copy of this in the first instance to familiarise yourself with what the process is and what point in the process you are at. It should also confirm if you are able to bring representation to the meeting (a union rep or other non direct manager/colleague) if that’s something that would comfort you.
Other than this you should just state what you have said on this thread, that it was close to closing, you had been covering for someone and it had been a long day, that your intent was to pre-empt her issue and be apologetic in informing her you probably wouldn’t be able to help, that you can see how it came off as rude (despite this not being the intention) and (had she given you the opportunity) you would have apologised to the customer.

If this is the first issue of this type it’s likely that you will just be reminded about appropriate behaviour and may have a note added to your employee record.

If you need to, you can contact ACAS for further information on what your employer can and can’t do in this sort of situation (it won’t be specific to you, just the statutory requirements).

All the best.

CantFindMyMarbles · 09/01/2024 19:22

The worst outcome in this situation should be a verbal warning. But just because she feels you wronged her and we’re snarky with her doesn’t actually make it the case.
you couldn’t help her. 2 minutes tk closing.

Blogswife · 09/01/2024 19:16

You were rude yes and she was justified in complaining . She didn’t know that you’d had a bad day and it’s not her fault and shouldn’t affect your customers
No doubt your premises advertise that they are open up to a certain time and therefore she’s right to expect a service until the doors close …. However it’s not really a sacking offence - a warning should be enough , assuming you haven’t got a history of bad service that is . If you have form for this type of behaviour then dismissal could be an option

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 09/01/2024 19:09

Tagyoureit · 09/01/2024 09:59

🤣🤣🤣

I no longer work but if every customer facing worker decided to do that you'd be well and truly fucked! There would be no one around to work!

But every customer facing worker wouldn't leave because most of them know how to deal with difficult customers. OP seems to have had to deal with one, at the very low end of the scale (I could tell you some tales!), and can't cope - which shows me she is not really suited to the job. She could have easily let the woman finish and then make an appropriate response - cutting someone off mid flow is one of the rudest things anyone can do.

I don't know anyone who left their job because of difficult customers - more likely difficult staff.

I'm not in the UK - maybe we have different views here.

catcoaster · 09/01/2024 19:09

Mrsttcno1 · 08/01/2024 18:28

1000% this.

You’ve got absolutely no idea what she was going to ask, she could have been about to ask about opening/closing times, she could have been about to ask if you have to book slots, she could have been about to ask if you needed a £1 coin for a locker. Cutting a customer off because you couldn’t be arsed isn’t an excuse really, and even if you couldn’t have helped her, you could have still provided her with service by explaining that she can either call back between x-x times, or failing that you could offer to check and give her a call tomorrow.

If I called up somewhere that I was paying a membership for and the member of staff didn’t even let me ask my question before telling me they couldn’t help I wouldn’t be happy

This. It could have been a very simple query, you presumed hers would need the computer because they usually do. You were very rude to cut her off on this basis. You shouldn’t be sacked, but she is right to complain.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 09/01/2024 19:03

Noshowlomo · 09/01/2024 08:34

You can tell the people who have worked in retail/customer facing roles on this thread. The ones who support the OP.
Everyone bleating on about customer service is king, clearly have never seen the absolute worst of humanity which you do in customer facing roles.
The “maybe you shouldn’t work in customer service” means nothing, because absolutely everyone who does or has had been on the receiving end of shit from the public. So if everyone quit, the next lot would also be on the receiving end of shit from the public. Working in customer service seems to make you an emotional punch bag and we’re all human. The OP doesn’t clock on and turn into a robot. 8 years and no issues, so I’d say she’s a great candidate to work in CS. A lot give up much sooner due to their treatment and how they are talked to by customers.
Be better customers !

Nope - I worked in customer service of one kind or another for almost 50 years. The place I worked for the longest, 26 years, were passionate about customer service, it was the cornerstone of the business. I think OP was extremely rude.

Surely you realise that we have all struck difficult customers - way more difficult than the woman OP is talking about - and yet none of us quit because we couldn't deal with it. It was our job to deal with it. If someone goes into customer service thinking it's all going to be fluffy and sweet then they really, really, shouldn't be in the job. I don't know of a single person who left because they couldn't deal with the customers so you are talking rubbish.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 09/01/2024 18:50

margotrose · 09/01/2024 06:27

specifically going in two minutes before closing is, especially doing whilst on your phone. It's rude!

But the customer is not paid to be polite and considerate about timing - OP is. That's her job. It's not the customers fault if she doesn't get paid after closing - they're doing nothing wrong with coming in at 5.58 and asking a question.

This seems to be the point very few are getting here. While it's nice if customers are pleasant, not all of them are, and they don't have to be. They are not the ones getting paid to do a job!!! Where I used to work we were open until 12pm on Saturdays, and the number of people who walked in the door a couple of minutes beforehand and started to shop you wouldn't believe. However, none of the shop staff muttered about turned off computers, and they certainly weren't rude - they stayed until the last person left the shop, even if that was half an hour later. If there are no customers there are no jobs, so whether you like the customer or not, or how rude they are, you are being paid to offer a service and you grit your teeth and do it. OP didn't even let the woman ask her question, which is extremely rude. The work ethic of some posters on this thread is beyond belief, some people seem to have the idea that if they are not being paid for an extra couple of minutes' work then they won't do it.

It isn't up to staff to judge how rude a customer is.

Neriah · 09/01/2024 18:31

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 09/01/2024 18:19

I hate to say it but this woman's generation is accustomed to a totally different level of customer service.

i think we have the OP's twin here 🤭

To be fair, that woman's generation, of which I am one, is definitely accustomed to a different level of customer service. It incudes actual customer service, not having someone cut you off mid-sentence, and not having it assumed that you age suggests that you are either stupid or technologically inept.

This comes from a 66 year old who is having to teach teenage / early 20's apprentices how to answer and speak on a phone; how to create documents that don't have text speak in them; what a spell checker is; and why it is a really, really good idea to not tell the Director that being on time for work, or even actually, like, turning up at all, is an antiquated notion ( if they knew what antiquated meant, of course).

Stars2theside · 09/01/2024 18:28

What a disgusting woman. It always makes me sick when people say they want someone to be fired - a normal working class person, not any politician, of course!
That is someone’s livelihood you want taken away because you feel you have been spoken to rudely - how dare they?!
My first ever job, a woman was p’d off that I hadn’t reduced something - it had plenty of days in date left - which I explained to her and she went off screaming at me about how dare I answer her back - so of course, I did answer her back at that point and said I answered a question, that’s not the same as “answering back”!! I worked in a very posh well known supermarket and she screamed about she wanted me fired!! Batshit.
OP - I feel for you, and I really hope that common sense prevails. Some people are just batshit and it says more about her than it does you. Good luck xx

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 09/01/2024 18:22

weirdoboelady · 08/01/2024 21:27

This is what I think happened, and if I am correct, this is what I think you should say.

'The customer came in and it became clear to me that she was going to need help from the computers, which had already been switched off. She was on the phone, so I tried to convey to her in a quick and efficient manner that we were unlikely to be able to help her (so her phone call wouldn't be interrupted for too long for nothing). I now quite understand that although I was trying to be helpful, my manner in trying to say things quickly came across to the customer as rude, and I would like to apologise for this. It was not my intention to be rude to the customer, only to be helpful, and I am sorry that I did not convey this in a more skilled way.'

That's not what I'm reading from tbe OP - but nice spin

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 09/01/2024 18:19

Jom222 · 08/01/2024 21:02

I hate to say it but this woman's generation is accustomed to a totally different level of customer service. It's like they think it's 1975 and a clerk is waiting just to assist them with any minor thing, happily and never ever overworked LOL.

My experience in retail was that the customers who go straight from an unrewarding experience straight to I'LL HAVE HER HEAD ON A PLATTER are obv unreasonable and nothing will please her.

If you run across her in future you can expect her to smirk triumphantly at you if she doesn't take the opportunity to yell at you for your mistreatment of her, A Very Important Customer.

Try not to let it get you down!

I worked for a veterinarian in the 80's whose assistant offended a wealthy woman who demanded she be fired so the Dr 'fired' her in front of said client. For a long time when this client came in the assistant would make herself scarce. Finally client saw the assistant and was indignant that she was still there. The Dr told her she was a single mother and he had to take pity on her and rehired her. My god the audacity of some people and they ways we coddle them!

I hate to say it but this woman's generation is accustomed to a totally different level of customer service.

i think we have the OP's twin here 🤭

Platypuslover · 09/01/2024 18:17

what an entitled twat that is. Rude to start with that’s she’s on the phone while speaking to you in the first place but then Hs complains about you?!

unless there is a recording of what was said, I’d demand to know what she says and insists you were polite she is lying and demand she gets banned in return.

If I was that manager I would not want people like that there. She’ll offend and upset just about every staff member and other customer.

mandlerparr · 09/01/2024 18:14

Whatever you do in the meeting, don't try and explain how you just knew she was going to blather on for 10 minutes or any other things about how you know this and that because that is what every other person who shares characteristics with her has done.
Best thing is to probably say that you didn't mean to interrupt her and did want to apologize but were not able to at that time.
Frankly, I am sort of mad for her. I probably would not insist on you being fired for that alone, but if I was her and came across all your excuses here, then I probably would change my mind to at least demanding you were retrained in customer service. It was not her fault you were tired and all the other things you said. And it is 100% your fault that you lumped her in with other people who came before her and assumed things about her. I can tell that you just assume this is a simple case of interrupting, but it was more than that, wasn't it. Other people are right. She could have just been asking what your hours were or if there was a dress code or a pamphlet of rules or something.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 09/01/2024 18:12

Londdi · 08/01/2024 19:40

Our membership enquires are usually quite technical in nature (app/smartphone) and the lady was pensioner …. Yes it was an assumption based on reality . Didn’t mean to shame someone based on age . Like I wouldn’t shame my own mum but I understand that it’s much harder to understand for older generation or explain what the issue is.

It gets better and better 🤦‍♀️

Nanny0gg · 09/01/2024 18:12

Noshowlomo · 09/01/2024 08:34

You can tell the people who have worked in retail/customer facing roles on this thread. The ones who support the OP.
Everyone bleating on about customer service is king, clearly have never seen the absolute worst of humanity which you do in customer facing roles.
The “maybe you shouldn’t work in customer service” means nothing, because absolutely everyone who does or has had been on the receiving end of shit from the public. So if everyone quit, the next lot would also be on the receiving end of shit from the public. Working in customer service seems to make you an emotional punch bag and we’re all human. The OP doesn’t clock on and turn into a robot. 8 years and no issues, so I’d say she’s a great candidate to work in CS. A lot give up much sooner due to their treatment and how they are talked to by customers.
Be better customers !

I've worked in retail.

She was rude.

And her attitude about her customers isn't ideal either

Nanny0gg · 09/01/2024 18:08

Rorous · 08/01/2024 20:56

IMO you were rude not letting her finish. Don’t think you’ll be fired though, especially if you’ve worked there 8yrs without a problem. When you go to your meeting it would be good to show understanding/that you are sorry for the way you handled it.

… I would also keep your views on age and technical ability to yourself; you’ll have probably upset a few pensioners with good technical skills on here!

Indeed...

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 09/01/2024 18:07

Londdi · 08/01/2024 19:00

@PuppyMonkey
yes. That was exactly why I interrupted her. She was older lady I didn’t want her to give the whole 10mins talk for me to tell her I can’t help (didn’t mentioned this as obviously I felt like there is no point as she took it different way).
also no I didn’t know her question - but being in this job I kind of expected her to ask what 80% people ask us when they first join and I do always need computer for that. So I wasn’t tried to be rude . Also the tone here wasn’t one of being annoyed. I said it more like “oh no! I can’t help” there was what felt like apologetic tone.

Ageist as well as rude 🤣

Onthebusallday · 09/01/2024 17:55

Working in a public facing environment comes with certain hazards , such as rude and entitled customers, including those who come in 1 minute before closing.

However, opening hours are just that..this lady may have busted a gut to get to you before closing in a rare opportunity to solve a problem. You shut her down and were obviously ready to leave as the clocked ticked over.

What kind of you day you had doesn't matter..your job is to provide customer service and you didn't do it.

If I was your manager I would treat it seriously and have a frank conversation with you over the realities of the job. No need to chuck warnings about.

Anon133 · 09/01/2024 17:52

The only thing you did wrong OP was not let the woman finish her sentence. She was more rude by remaining on her phone whilst asking you a question (having worked in customer service, that is my biggest pet hate), but unfortunately that’s the kind of thing we sometimes have to deal with 🙄

Hopefully it goes no further than just a quick chat with your manager.

ClumsyNinja · 09/01/2024 17:44

The random Customer is clearly being a dick here and obviously they don't get to say who gets hired and fired.

Leave it to the managers to placate them. Dealing with shitty customers is presumably just one of the things on their vague job description that they're paid to deal with. 🤷🏻‍♀️

masterblaster · 09/01/2024 17:38

I think the problem here is the “usually” in “usually requires computers”. You should have let her finish, and been polite.

But no, you should get an unofficial reprimand (as in, told to do better) prior to an official one, for a very minor thing.

melj1213 · 09/01/2024 17:07

sandyhappypeople · 09/01/2024 14:42

from OP:
last entrance to centre is hour before close time. We need to do cash up

So according to the above, the woman didn't come in 2 mins before closing time, she came in 2 mins before last entry.

My point is, if the customer thinks the leisure centre closes at 8pm and comes in at 6:58.. she's not actually coming in 2 minutes before their advertised closing times.

No you've misinterpreted the OP when she was clarifying to another poster why the computers were already off before the centre closed (IE last entry is 1hr before close so no computer is needed after that)

The customer came in two minutes before the centre closed and the OP was going home

From the OP:

Week ago customer walked in 2 mins before closing time.

I was extremely tired about to grab a coat and go home.

Neither of those things give a hint of being an hour before closing time, unless the OP sits in her coat for the last hour ...

TroysMammy · 09/01/2024 16:30

Londdi · 08/01/2024 18:13

And I mean I was about to lock the doors and walk home so the computer would be off 2 mins when building is closing in most places I guess

I imagine the customer walked in just before the doors were locked.

PriOn1 · 09/01/2024 15:20

The main trouble is not the customers but those colleagues that always manage to get everyone's backs up and escalate every bad situation.

I call bollocks on this.

You’re one of those customers.

TinyTear · 09/01/2024 14:58

Not how I interpreted. I understood that the woman not only missed last entry but nearly missed the centre being open

Maybe the @Londdi OP can confirm