Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not understand DH love for his sisters!

105 replies

2024NewStart · 02/01/2024 12:47

I really don’t understand this, I’ll give brief details: DH is not remotely close with his 2 older sisters at all. When I first met them he couldn’t even name their kids! They never visit us even though living a mere 20 minutes and another 45 minutes away. He only sees them when they visit his mum who lives 5 minutes down the road from our house.

They haven’t even seen or felt the need to see our new home which we lived in for past 2 years. When I first joined the family I would call/text them and give birthday gifts and Christmas to the kids, I found the sisters really rude, once the eldest even commented someone brought their child a rubbish cheap car (I had got it! And it wasn’t cheap). She fully well knew I had got it btw it wasn’t an innocent mistake. Their whole attitude was off, I actually didn’t stop talking to them I just stopped putting in the effort and they’ve not got in touch with me for 4 years. They are not interested in our children or our lives. All of this is important for the real issue I have:

every year whenever it’s one of our kids birthdays DH insists they have to be invited! There is a huge age gap between their kids and our kids my eldest is 7 and their eldest is 24. My youngest is 4 and their youngest is 19. Even just now he exploded at me that his sisters have to be there! I explained I might be doing a really girly party like a bath bomb making etc. But he still wants them there, he’s insisting as every year my family can’t come if his is not there. I find any conversation with him just impossible. The sisters only have boys btw. Not that I want to stop them coming but I really don’t want grown men who I hardly know and who my kids know nothing about at their party. Also remember we haven’t spoken for over 4 years. 5 years ago when they came to my eldest party (she was 2) they sat in the corner sulking and saying they were bored.

I cannot understand why DH forgets he has sisters but suddenly remembers them when it’s a party. I really hate my DH btw, I find his very difficult. He doesn’t discuss but just shouts and screams at me. I usually don’t care about things but the childrens parties are a huge deal for me. His sister celebrated her 50th a couple of years ago and only invited him! Is this unreasonable to not want grown men at my daughters party plus their bitchy mothers who will critique everything and not even talk to me like they have gone before? Even my friends noticed on the last party they came to that they were purposely being cold and distant with me and other guests.

so my AIBU is why does he “love” them so much that he’s willing to destroy our lives for them? He didn’t come last 2 parties as I said no way are they invited

OP posts:
mottytotty · 02/01/2024 13:57

Catza · 02/01/2024 13:54

#bekindtoyourfamily. It's a better approach than being mean to everyone, like yourself. We didn't actually hear the sister's side. For all we know, OP may have been problematic herself, hence no invitation to sister's 50th. No way of knowing, is there?

When do you ever hear the other side?!

The only person being mean is YOU, dismissing OP’s feelings and experiences with her in laws.

And look at you steadfastly ignoring these people telling OP that in India they abort baby girls and how unlucky OP and her DH are to have a daughter.

Yes, you are just brimming with kindness. Not.

mottytotty · 02/01/2024 13:58

Ohlookwhoitis · 02/01/2024 13:55

This is standard on Mumsnet now. It doesn't matter how obvious it is that abuse is happening or an OP is in the right, it's just a pile on to 'prove' an OP 'wrong'. Seriously, it's happening on every single thread now.

It’s truly disgusting. And then they have hypocrisy to pretend they’re the kind ones.

TiptoeTess · 02/01/2024 13:59

He sounds horrible, and so do they.

Leave the lot of them and live a happy life.

Ohlookwhoitis · 02/01/2024 13:59

Catza · 02/01/2024 13:45

Any 24 year old who cares about their family. The issue, however, is not whether they want to attend or not. The issue is that the OP refuses to invite even though they are likely to decline.

😂😂😂Imagine a 24 year old man attending a 5 years old bath making party. This is the biggest reach I may ever have seen on Mumsnet. Trying to make that sound normal.

AuntySueDoesntGiveAShit · 02/01/2024 13:59

I don't get how people are missing the part where the husband's family said that the daughter would have been aborted if they were in India.

Goldbar · 02/01/2024 14:01

Ohlookwhoitis · 02/01/2024 13:59

😂😂😂Imagine a 24 year old man attending a 5 years old bath making party. This is the biggest reach I may ever have seen on Mumsnet. Trying to make that sound normal.

I'd love to see this 😂. I can perhaps imagine a father doing this with his daughter (under sufferance), but an older cousin, no.

whynotwhatknot · 02/01/2024 14:01

they sound horrid and your husband is no better screaming at you

get rid

Pigsinpainauchocolat · 02/01/2024 14:03

He sounds rabidly jealous that you have a good relationship with your sister.

He doesn’t want his sister there. He just doesn’t want you to have yours there.

He wants you to not have something you want. That says a lot

Bingo! He's so jealous that you and your sister have a good relationship. But his reaction is awful - so immature like a toddler snatching a toy because another child has it. Pathetic. I couldn't respect a man like this.

Ohlookwhoitis · 02/01/2024 14:05

Catza · 02/01/2024 13:54

#bekindtoyourfamily. It's a better approach than being mean to everyone, like yourself. We didn't actually hear the sister's side. For all we know, OP may have been problematic herself, hence no invitation to sister's 50th. No way of knowing, is there?

If you would tolerate being treated like this, then you need to learn some boundaries. "Oh everyone's welcome in my house". Does that include people who excluded you from THEIR party? People who sat at a previous party moaning how bored they were? People who mocked the presents you bought their children? Not to mention the abortion comment.

moomoomoo27 · 02/01/2024 14:05

AuntySueDoesntGiveAShit · 02/01/2024 13:59

I don't get how people are missing the part where the husband's family said that the daughter would have been aborted if they were in India.

It's a bizarre thing to say as well because it's not even remotely true. India loves their girls and women. Obsessively so, because they are very orientated toward having the biggest population and see it as an important national goal and a big measure of success.

DillyDallyingAllDay · 02/01/2024 14:06

As I read your OP I have a feeling you were asian/brown- is this the case? (If so you might get better advice on the Asian board) I'm going to assume it is, as this seems to line up with your sister in laws irrational behaviour and the fact that they dislike you but they actually came to the previous birthday. I have found this insane attachment to ones family to be very culturally asian, it's literally nothing you've done but culturally you can't be liked- is your mother in law involved in your lives? is she still around?
Personally, if you're not looking to leave your husband, you need to 'handle' the situation with his family. You need to completely step back from his family- if he wants to invite them, he's welcome to. Sounds like you're the one planning and sending invitations etc- don't facilitate him inviting them. If he asks if you've invited them, make sure you make it known that they don't like you, do he can handle inviting them.
You obviously don't want to ruin your daughters actual party, so maybe as someone else has suggested, you have two 'events' one just for your child's friends and one for the family- maybe the kids party can be in the am, and family in the evening. Or have the kids party one day after school if that works, and family on her actual birthday. If you family have children the same age, invite them to the children's one as well.
Best of luck!

Goldbar · 02/01/2024 14:07

mottytotty · 02/01/2024 13:58

It’s truly disgusting. And then they have hypocrisy to pretend they’re the kind ones.

Yes, I agree. The bath bomb thing is some light relief but really the whole situation is very worrying and I don't know why people are pretending otherwise.

OP, be careful. The rage, the contempt, the anger and the control issues, together with apparent efforts to isolate you from your family, have strong parallels with several cases recently that did not have happy endings. Can you talk to someone without your husband knowing?

DillyDallyingAllDay · 02/01/2024 14:10

And PS your husband doesn't 'love' his sisters. This insistence at inviting them to a party is purely out of a sense of obligation that he must not celebrate anything without his family; regardless of how little he actually cares for them. It's a tit for tat, if your family is there he has to have his otherwise it's just not 'fair' irrespective of that fact whether they treat you with respect and fairness.

Ohlookwhoitis · 02/01/2024 14:10

ActDottie · 02/01/2024 13:57

The odd bit to me is why men aged 19-24 would even want to go to little kids parties? The age difference is enough of a reason why they shouldn’t be invited. From my experience parties for kids are all kids of the same age doing an age appropriate activity. It would be really awkward if they did turn up!

That said the most worrying bit of your post is you said you hate your husband!

Exactly. Are the 5 years old expected to get an invite back to a 24 year olds birthday celebration. People tying themselves in knots on here with such silly comments. I have a 25 year old nephew...I can only imagine the look on his face if I invited him to my DDs birthday party. 😂

FreeAdamsApples · 02/01/2024 14:16

the childrens parties are a huge deal for me

That is why he ruins them for you. What's he like on your birthdays?

Your husband is abusive. Please try and speak to Women's Aid or similar. Soon.

Flowers
Goldbar · 02/01/2024 14:18

FreeAdamsApples · 02/01/2024 14:16

the childrens parties are a huge deal for me

That is why he ruins them for you. What's he like on your birthdays?

Your husband is abusive. Please try and speak to Women's Aid or similar. Soon.

Flowers

Yup. It's about keeping you on eggshells waiting to see how he behaves.

MintJulia · 02/01/2024 14:53

'his response was “I don’t care if they come or don’t but it pisses me off seeing your sister there”. '

OK, OP, This isn't about his love for his sisters. He's just trying to ruin the party and separate you from your family. He sounds vile. Why do you stay with this man? You don't like him, he bullies you, tries to isolate you and is openly aggressive.

Surely it's time to leave.

Redpaisley · 02/01/2024 15:00

Catza · 02/01/2024 13:45

Any 24 year old who cares about their family. The issue, however, is not whether they want to attend or not. The issue is that the OP refuses to invite even though they are likely to decline.

And OP has no reason to not wanting to invite them?

It is ok for sisters to say bad things about the niece but when it comes to party tehy are entitled to their invite hust because they are from husband side and Op must follow strict rules of equality when it comes to invitation even though Op's sister never said mean things about their niece whereas his sister did. Daughter's birthday should be about daughter.

Redpaisley · 02/01/2024 15:02

DillyDallyingAllDay · 02/01/2024 14:10

And PS your husband doesn't 'love' his sisters. This insistence at inviting them to a party is purely out of a sense of obligation that he must not celebrate anything without his family; regardless of how little he actually cares for them. It's a tit for tat, if your family is there he has to have his otherwise it's just not 'fair' irrespective of that fact whether they treat you with respect and fairness.

This.

MCOut · 02/01/2024 15:07

It’s not necessary for you to invite them to the kids party, because they will just be bored so in that sense, yanbu. I agree with those saying you should host a separate family event and they can come to that.

Redpaisley · 02/01/2024 15:10

DillyDallyingAllDay · 02/01/2024 14:06

As I read your OP I have a feeling you were asian/brown- is this the case? (If so you might get better advice on the Asian board) I'm going to assume it is, as this seems to line up with your sister in laws irrational behaviour and the fact that they dislike you but they actually came to the previous birthday. I have found this insane attachment to ones family to be very culturally asian, it's literally nothing you've done but culturally you can't be liked- is your mother in law involved in your lives? is she still around?
Personally, if you're not looking to leave your husband, you need to 'handle' the situation with his family. You need to completely step back from his family- if he wants to invite them, he's welcome to. Sounds like you're the one planning and sending invitations etc- don't facilitate him inviting them. If he asks if you've invited them, make sure you make it known that they don't like you, do he can handle inviting them.
You obviously don't want to ruin your daughters actual party, so maybe as someone else has suggested, you have two 'events' one just for your child's friends and one for the family- maybe the kids party can be in the am, and family in the evening. Or have the kids party one day after school if that works, and family on her actual birthday. If you family have children the same age, invite them to the children's one as well.
Best of luck!

What does being brown have got to do with this? Abuse is abuse. Op feels the abuse despite her being from south Asia. Culture should not come into this. I am south Asian and i sometimes prefer a fresh perspective from outside than a cult-like family oriented attitude we south Asians have where woman has to self sacrifice for the sake of inlaws and family irrespective of how bad they treat her.

Do we need to segregate people based on region or skin colour they belong to here? Some things are basic human rights or general human feelings, nothing to do witj culture.

Redpaisley · 02/01/2024 15:13

2024NewStart · 02/01/2024 13:11

Thank you all. I just asked him (trying to clear the air) “why is it so important to you your sisters and nephews come to the party”, his response was “I don’t care if they come or don’t but it pisses me off seeing your sister there”. Only one of my sister comes every year as her daughter and mine are the same age.

Edited

Does he care that his daughter may like to spend time with same age cousin sister?

Flyhigher · 02/01/2024 16:21

A you invite them later for drinks?

pikkumyy77 · 02/01/2024 17:02

moomoomoo27 · 02/01/2024 14:05

It's a bizarre thing to say as well because it's not even remotely true. India loves their girls and women. Obsessively so, because they are very orientated toward having the biggest population and see it as an important national goal and a big measure of success.

Uh—femicide, abandonment of baby girls, and selective abortion are enormous features of Indian society even though they are publicly disavowed.

Boomer55 · 02/01/2024 17:04

Your problem is living with someone you hate. His sisters are irrelevant..