Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not understand DH love for his sisters!

105 replies

2024NewStart · 02/01/2024 12:47

I really don’t understand this, I’ll give brief details: DH is not remotely close with his 2 older sisters at all. When I first met them he couldn’t even name their kids! They never visit us even though living a mere 20 minutes and another 45 minutes away. He only sees them when they visit his mum who lives 5 minutes down the road from our house.

They haven’t even seen or felt the need to see our new home which we lived in for past 2 years. When I first joined the family I would call/text them and give birthday gifts and Christmas to the kids, I found the sisters really rude, once the eldest even commented someone brought their child a rubbish cheap car (I had got it! And it wasn’t cheap). She fully well knew I had got it btw it wasn’t an innocent mistake. Their whole attitude was off, I actually didn’t stop talking to them I just stopped putting in the effort and they’ve not got in touch with me for 4 years. They are not interested in our children or our lives. All of this is important for the real issue I have:

every year whenever it’s one of our kids birthdays DH insists they have to be invited! There is a huge age gap between their kids and our kids my eldest is 7 and their eldest is 24. My youngest is 4 and their youngest is 19. Even just now he exploded at me that his sisters have to be there! I explained I might be doing a really girly party like a bath bomb making etc. But he still wants them there, he’s insisting as every year my family can’t come if his is not there. I find any conversation with him just impossible. The sisters only have boys btw. Not that I want to stop them coming but I really don’t want grown men who I hardly know and who my kids know nothing about at their party. Also remember we haven’t spoken for over 4 years. 5 years ago when they came to my eldest party (she was 2) they sat in the corner sulking and saying they were bored.

I cannot understand why DH forgets he has sisters but suddenly remembers them when it’s a party. I really hate my DH btw, I find his very difficult. He doesn’t discuss but just shouts and screams at me. I usually don’t care about things but the childrens parties are a huge deal for me. His sister celebrated her 50th a couple of years ago and only invited him! Is this unreasonable to not want grown men at my daughters party plus their bitchy mothers who will critique everything and not even talk to me like they have gone before? Even my friends noticed on the last party they came to that they were purposely being cold and distant with me and other guests.

so my AIBU is why does he “love” them so much that he’s willing to destroy our lives for them? He didn’t come last 2 parties as I said no way are they invited

OP posts:
wordler · 02/01/2024 13:16

Just have two different birthday events - one is just for your kids and their friends so do the bath bomb one there, and then have a family birthday celebration with cake and nibbles and invite both sides of the family and other adult friends to that.

Winnipeggy · 02/01/2024 13:18

Tell him he can organise a party with his family and you go ahead and do the bath bomb thing. There you go, lucky daughter gets 2 parties.

Also, if you hate your DH - leave him.

DeedlessIndeed · 02/01/2024 13:19

Aishah231 · 02/01/2024 13:12

Hi OP. I don't think you can win this one so adopt a different approach. Let your DH organise the birthday party - he probably won't bother so you can do a last minute nice day with a small number of people. Then a month or so later organise a different event (don't call it a party) for your DD. That way you get the event you want how you want.

This is the way OP.

It sounds as if your relationship is descending into tit-for-tat, so just leave them to sort it amongst themselves.

AuntySueDoesntGiveAShit · 02/01/2024 13:19

2024NewStart · 02/01/2024 13:01

@MintJulia thats not true. I tried my hardest in trying to become part of the family. I remember your username btw! There’s so much they have done such as telling me they don’t consider me to be part of their family when I asked them over on my eldest daughters first Christmas. They also told me in India they abort baby girls and how unlucky we are to have a daughter. They said everyone will be disappointed that it’s a girl. Yet he want them at her birthdays. I have tried my hardest but I can’t anymore. They are not welcome in my home or near my kids anymore.

Edited

Wtf - that's an awful thing to say.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 02/01/2024 13:19

Why are you married to someone you hate?

I have teenagers and there’s no fucking way they’d attend a birthday party making bath bombs for their young female cousin!

SlothMama · 02/01/2024 13:22

If you hate him then leave him?

Silverbirchtwo · 02/01/2024 13:23

Have you got one of those indoor soft play places, only suitable for young children? Or a 'gym' or swimming party at a local centre. Book something that is totally unsuitable for adults and say they can come if they want and help supervise.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 02/01/2024 13:24

2024NewStart · 02/01/2024 13:11

Thank you all. I just asked him (trying to clear the air) “why is it so important to you your sisters and nephews come to the party”, his response was “I don’t care if they come or don’t but it pisses me off seeing your sister there”. Only one of my sister comes every year as her daughter and mine are the same age.

Edited

He sounds rabidly jealous that you have a good relationship with your sister.

He doesn’t want his sister there. He just doesn’t want you to have yours there.

He wants you to not have something you want. That says a lot

dapsnotplimsolls · 02/01/2024 13:25

Does he hate your sister? Or does he hate the fact that she'll turn up and be pleasant and his sisters will be cows?

Gingerbee · 02/01/2024 13:25

wordler · 02/01/2024 13:16

Just have two different birthday events - one is just for your kids and their friends so do the bath bomb one there, and then have a family birthday celebration with cake and nibbles and invite both sides of the family and other adult friends to that.

Makes sense

HappySonHappyMum · 02/01/2024 13:25

Organise a Childs birthday party without them and then an extra family party that they can be invited to - would solve the issue I think

minipie · 02/01/2024 13:25

I agree it is clearly jealousy

But rather than try to improve his own sibling relationships or maybe form a good relationship with your sister, he chooses to be jealous

therealcookiemonster · 02/01/2024 13:27

@2024NewStart OP am I correct in thinking you married an Indian man? are you of south Asian origin?

family dynamics and obligations are very different in that context. maybe he wants you to invite them just not to offend them? but they probably won't come anyway?

however, in any context, your husband sounds unreasonable. as do his family. are you happy with him otherwise?

Luxell934 · 02/01/2024 13:27

I don't see how inviting them to a party once a year is "destroying your lives"???
You say he insists "every year" they have to be invited but then you say you haven't spoken in 4 years?
They obviously don't even take you up on the invite if you haven't spoken in 4 years anyway so I don't see the big deal in inviting them? You know they won't come anyway??? Maybe he's inviting them because they are his family after all despite what you think of them. You don't have to like his family but you do hav e to respect that your husband obviously wants to keep trying with them.

Catza · 02/01/2024 13:30

I don't see an issue in inviting family members who won't come anyway. And what is this rubbish about "I don't want adult men at my children's party"? Does it include all adult men? Your husband? Your sister's husband?
They are cousins. Age difference is irrelevant. I happily attend birthday parties for my young cousin who are 15 years younger than me. We are family.

Goldbar · 02/01/2024 13:32

Your issue is a DH one. I'm sorry, but you need to focus on this not the wider family issues.

As an aside, I would love to see older teenage boys and young adults attending a bath bomb making party. If they actually turned up, I'd make sure they fully participated 😂.

Personally in your shoes I would hold two parties. A low effort, shop-bought cake affair with no party food to which you invite your "D"H and his awful family.

Then the "real deal" party with the nice cake, food and activities. I wouldn't even tell your husband this is happening. If you can do it when he's at work/out of the house or at a relative's house, great. Invite your sister and your children's friends and make it lovely.

Your DC won't care about their dad not being there. Children don't like volatile, angry adults spoiling things for them.

goodgriefsean · 02/01/2024 13:32

I get on fine with my SIL but my teenage nephews would still have no interest in coming to my daughter's birthday party that is activities targeted at 9 year old girls so the insistence that his sisters and their children come is odd to me, surely they'd be bored rigid.

The obvious solution is an age appropriate party with her friends and similar aged cousin and a separate drop in gathering for family which her aunt's and older cousins are welcome to attend.

The fact that you hate your husbands behaviour and resent his family and he feels the same about your sister is a much deeper issue than birthday parties though, this is a symptom of a bigger problem.

Nevermind31 · 02/01/2024 13:34

You organise one party, your DH another.

mottytotty · 02/01/2024 13:36

I really hate my DH btw, I find his very difficult. He doesn’t discuss but just shouts and screams at me.

Not sure why posters are asking why you hate him when it’s obvious that he’s abusive.

OP, you are worth so much more than this. Can you leave him?

mottytotty · 02/01/2024 13:37

Catza · 02/01/2024 13:30

I don't see an issue in inviting family members who won't come anyway. And what is this rubbish about "I don't want adult men at my children's party"? Does it include all adult men? Your husband? Your sister's husband?
They are cousins. Age difference is irrelevant. I happily attend birthday parties for my young cousin who are 15 years younger than me. We are family.

What 24yo MAN wants to attend a bath bomb making party with little girls?

Avatartar · 02/01/2024 13:37

I think you ABU - you need to leave DH if you hate him and his family that much - then all problems with them will be solved

mottytotty · 02/01/2024 13:38

Luxell934 · 02/01/2024 13:27

I don't see how inviting them to a party once a year is "destroying your lives"???
You say he insists "every year" they have to be invited but then you say you haven't spoken in 4 years?
They obviously don't even take you up on the invite if you haven't spoken in 4 years anyway so I don't see the big deal in inviting them? You know they won't come anyway??? Maybe he's inviting them because they are his family after all despite what you think of them. You don't have to like his family but you do hav e to respect that your husband obviously wants to keep trying with them.

Because they don’t invite OP to their parties, they only invite OP’s DH.

And yet OP is being forced to invite and screamed at if she refuses.

pikkumyy77 · 02/01/2024 13:39

Look birthday parties and having blood relatives there to celebrate is just a big cultural thing in some cultures. They aren’t little kid parties for the child they are family events that let the whole world know that you snd your little family are valued. My brazilian friend rented a hall and had 250 people to her two year old’s birthday.

So it is important to your dh that his family comes to the birthday and he is hirribly hurt that your family respect and love you and his family don’t.

Having saud that he sounds horrubly selfish and childish because he can’t acceot that he doesn’t have the relationship he wants with his family.

If I were you I would make a big production out of inviting them then forget about it. They won’t come. Or tell him you will leave him if he doesn’t get his shit together.

TheNameIsDickDarlington · 02/01/2024 13:39

Surely he can see that adult men will not want to make bath bombs with a load of 7 year old girls, he mist realise he's asking a completely stupid and ridiculous thing.

I haven't read the full thread so apologies if this has been suggested, could your daughter have a friends party (doing the bath bombs) and then a family party another day at your house? That way your DH gets to have his family there and your DD can have a proper kids birthday party with her friends.

CoconutSty · 02/01/2024 13:39

So his nephews are 19 and 24? Why on earth would they want to come to a child's party, bath bombs or otherwise?? Are they that desperate, or is your DH a complete idiot??