Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell DS Santa isn’t real?

71 replies

Firebrain · 16/12/2023 22:12

DS who is 7, nearly 8, seems to be clocking on that Santa is just fantasy. He keeps asking me logical questions about him.

”How does Santa deliver all the presents to everyone in just one night, it would take ages?” “How do the reindeer fly?” “How can Santa live at the North Pole when there’s just frozen sea and no land?” “Surely someone must have seen him at some point on CCTV!”. I could go on.

I don’t know what to say other than “it’s just magic”. What more can I say? I’m just wondering whether to tell him and then tell him not to tell his brother who is 4.

OP posts:
DappledThings · 17/12/2023 17:44

I'd just answer the questions he asks. So if he asks how can he fly round the world in one night I'd just say I'm not sure. If he asks outright is he real I'd answer that too.

DS asked last year in December aged 6. Was pretty pleased with himself to have worked it out. I don't get the big deal about it.

purpleme12 · 17/12/2023 17:46

I'm not really sure what the problem is with saying it's magic.
I mean whatever age they are the answer is 'it's magic' isn't it.
In my opinion if he's ready to figure it out he'll do it regardless of you keeping the pretence up.

stargirl1701 · 17/12/2023 17:46

Read some origin story books with him like

Three Wishes by Alan Snow

How Santa Works by Alan Snow

Kid Christmas by David Litchfield

A Boy Called Christmas by Matt Haig

LBFseBrom · 17/12/2023 17:47

I think your son is gearing up to telling you he knows that Santa isn't real but doesn't want to disappoint you, also he would rather you no longer insulted his intelligence by lying to him and hopes you will admit. I've never come across a child over seven, in real life, who believes in it.

It always strikes me the whole Father Christmas fantasy is more for parents than children. I remember my mother having a sour face when she realised I did not believe (I don't think I ever did except maybe when I was about three). It was as if I had spoiled things for her!

Mine was never taught the Santa myth was true but we still had magical Christmases.

margotrose · 17/12/2023 17:47

Hellocatshome · 17/12/2023 17:40

My children are older now but it seems primary age kids these days are expected to believe in Santa until year 6 so 11 years old yet are judged to be responsible enough for mobile phones and social media from around 7. Its a weird time to be a child.

It is odd, isn't it?!

Eight year olds aren't babies. They're more than old enough to understand that Santa isn't real. It doesn't have to mean that the magic of Christmas is ruined like most of MN seems to believe.

Purplecatshopaholic · 17/12/2023 17:48

i was that age - kids with older siblings told me at school. Might be what’s happened here but he doesn’t want to ask outright in case that means no presents.. Either look vague and say you don’t know, or say it’s magic. Or admit it and tell him not to say to the younger ones. Whichever sits better with you. He was going to click on around now anyway

muddymudwater · 17/12/2023 17:49

People on here on obsessed with this 'magic' nonsense. It seems to me its actually about the parents who are invested in this.

I never believed in Santa as a child, Christmas still had that lovely magical feel. Its the lights and food and the activities and the time with family and the presents and the special programmes on the tv that makes it magical.

You don't need lies for Christmas to be magical and special for kids. You really don't. You don't need to believe in a literal Santa to enjoy Santa. I know because I was that kid.

Christmas can only be 'ruined' if you lie in the first place. Kids can only be upset at being lied to, if they are lied to.

MsJuniper · 17/12/2023 17:51

My friend told her son at that age after he asked lots of leading questions and she thought he knew. He was devastated!

I just say "no idea, must be magic" to all questions.

JanefromLondon1 · 17/12/2023 17:54

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

Mistresstotheworkwife · 17/12/2023 17:55

I'm surprised everyone thinks 8 is young. I thought this was about the normal age kids stop believing in Santa or related fantasy dudes, but I'm from abroad so perhaps it is different there.

Zanatdy · 17/12/2023 17:57

No, not yet

Mistresstotheworkwife · 17/12/2023 17:57

Looking it up, this is what I found, so I guess it's pretty normal an age here too.

"While children learn the truth about Santa Claus at different ages, most kids stop believing around the age of 8, according to a 2018 study conducted by The University Of Exeter in the United Kingdom"

Sproutier · 17/12/2023 17:59

It's fine not to know the answers. We have gone with always maintaining it's all real, and the children have gone from wholehearted belief through to gently humouring us (they are teens). Sometimes children ask the question before they really want to hear the answer. IME when they actually figure it out they go very quiet on the subject.

CroccyWoccy · 17/12/2023 18:02

My eldest is at the questionning age and I've never ever insisted that Santa is real or lied about it - if they ask any questions I either throw the question back at them ("Well how do YOU think he gets down the chimney?") or make a bit of a joke out of it ("you think I ate the mince pie we left out for santa...I most certainly didn't...but maybe Daddy did, or what about the cat, she looks a bit suspcious?").

I'm hoping not to get to a point where I have to tell them The Truth, but for them to gradually become "in on the joke".

Goldbar · 17/12/2023 18:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

This. Never admit or deny it.

Sproutier · 17/12/2023 18:12

Also belief has a measure of choice in it. There will be rumours going round at school anyway, and kids either choose to believe them or ignore them. Once you say it's definitely not real they lose that choice. That might be fine, but it can cause a lot of upset as PPs have said.

Nineteendays · 17/12/2023 18:12

My (very logical) ds was the exact same at 7. I kept it going another couple of years by just being evasive and saying magic isn’t rational, it doesn’t work like we do. Time works differently for santa etc. I said I didn’t know how some of the things worked because I wasn’t Santa or magic so how could I know. He asked me the Christmas he has just turned 10 to tell him the truth which I did because he was in year 6 by then. I think he’d always half known he wasn’t real but secretly hoped he might be because he did look a little gutted when I confirmed.

dd on the other hand is 8 and completely believes. She’ll probably be about 17 before she twigs 😂

if I were you I’d try and keep it going. Sometimes kids know the truth deep down but really don’t want to know the truth for sure

Stringagal · 17/12/2023 18:15

A shrug and “you have to believe to receive” is your mantra’

Floralnomad · 17/12/2023 18:20

muddymudwater · 17/12/2023 17:49

People on here on obsessed with this 'magic' nonsense. It seems to me its actually about the parents who are invested in this.

I never believed in Santa as a child, Christmas still had that lovely magical feel. Its the lights and food and the activities and the time with family and the presents and the special programmes on the tv that makes it magical.

You don't need lies for Christmas to be magical and special for kids. You really don't. You don't need to believe in a literal Santa to enjoy Santa. I know because I was that kid.

Christmas can only be 'ruined' if you lie in the first place. Kids can only be upset at being lied to, if they are lied to.

This exactly . Christmas is always magical here and our children are adults and we never did FC as a real thing .

TreesWelliesKnees · 17/12/2023 18:27

The NORAD website kept it going for us for a couple of extra years. It's online, so it must be true! It adds to the magic on Christmas Eve too.

purpleme12 · 17/12/2023 18:30

Sproutier · 17/12/2023 18:12

Also belief has a measure of choice in it. There will be rumours going round at school anyway, and kids either choose to believe them or ignore them. Once you say it's definitely not real they lose that choice. That might be fine, but it can cause a lot of upset as PPs have said.

This is so true.
People do choose to believe.
My child knows people at school say he's not real. I think she's chosen to believe yes

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread