Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell DS Santa isn’t real?

71 replies

Firebrain · 16/12/2023 22:12

DS who is 7, nearly 8, seems to be clocking on that Santa is just fantasy. He keeps asking me logical questions about him.

”How does Santa deliver all the presents to everyone in just one night, it would take ages?” “How do the reindeer fly?” “How can Santa live at the North Pole when there’s just frozen sea and no land?” “Surely someone must have seen him at some point on CCTV!”. I could go on.

I don’t know what to say other than “it’s just magic”. What more can I say? I’m just wondering whether to tell him and then tell him not to tell his brother who is 4.

OP posts:
JudyGemstone · 16/12/2023 22:30

My son asked me outright in July when he was about 5 or 6, I told him the truth because it felt wrong to outright lie in those circumstances. He was told not tell anyone especially not his little sister!

WickerMam · 16/12/2023 22:36

I think it depends on the child. My DC1 was always slightly unsettled by Santa. I think he had a subconscious "this makes no sense, why are you lying to me?" feeling.

We confirmed the truth just after xmas last year, when he was 8. Rather that ruining the magic, this year is the first that he seems to be really enthusiastically enjoying the run up, now that he understands what is going on.

He has been really good at helping to make it special for his younger sibling too. DC2 is very different though - he is better at just accepting things and going with it, and loves the idea of Santa, elves, etc. I am happy to just bat off his questions, where it felt wrong lying to DC1 for some reason.

AnnaMagnani · 16/12/2023 22:38

You can give him a straight answer in February, be prepared for him then to believe again next December.

Definitely not one week before the big day.

CharliesAngels81 · 16/12/2023 22:40

My daughters once set up an iPad, hiding behind the sofa pointing at the door hoping to catch Santa.

Luckily my partner spotted a flash of light else we were screwed 😂😂

MiddleClassProblem · 16/12/2023 22:40

If he directly asks then that’s one thing but to decide to tell him because has been asking other questions seems a misstep.

Jossse · 16/12/2023 22:40

I'm probably going to be torched for this but... here goes... I asked my children when they were similar questioning/age, if you were to still get presents from Santa but he isn't real is it a big deal?? They said no... so I told them the truth. He's not real. I said it's a game adults play, it's ok for us to play along too, we don't ruin it for others especially children and those who believe. I felt it's important to be truthful with my children rather than lie to them. We still did Santa's gifts. They still played along did stockings chopped up carrots for reindeer, mince pie and drink for Santa, everything as before and played the game ans loved it all. At least you're not lying to your child and can still keep the fun of it all. Not believing in Santa doesn't mean you don't get presents from him. It can still be fun Good luck OP

margotrose · 16/12/2023 22:45

I suspect at eight he already knows the truth - kids aren't daft.

ScruffMuffin · 16/12/2023 22:54

I'd try to keep it going for a few more days, as it's almost Christmas! But how is almost 8 too young, as some PPs think? My DD1 asked me at the same age (mid-year) so I told her. Asked her not to tell her little sister or her friends, and she never did. DD2 is a teenager now but has admitted she stopped believing around 8 as well.

Vintageport · 16/12/2023 22:59

I’d tell him- but then I never believed in Father Christmas and neither have my children… and we are Christmas mad. It really doesn’t spoil any ‘magic’.

Mariposista · 16/12/2023 23:27

For heck’s sake don’t tell him a week before Christmas

Circularargument · 16/12/2023 23:43

Yesididntdothat · 16/12/2023 22:13

God no he's far too young.

Ridiculous. We never promulgated the Santa myth (told them the story of St Nicholas instead - probably also fiction though the person was real) and neither of ours were remotely traumatised

Vintageport · 16/12/2023 23:50

Circularargument · 16/12/2023 23:43

Ridiculous. We never promulgated the Santa myth (told them the story of St Nicholas instead - probably also fiction though the person was real) and neither of ours were remotely traumatised

Same here- Father Christmas was presented in the same way as postman pat or the gruffalo- a character from a story who is fun to read about and do pretend play about.

Yesididntdothat · 16/12/2023 23:52

Circularargument · 16/12/2023 23:43

Ridiculous. We never promulgated the Santa myth (told them the story of St Nicholas instead - probably also fiction though the person was real) and neither of ours were remotely traumatised

But if you never "did" Santa then you have no experience of a child who does believe asking questions, do you?

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 16/12/2023 23:55

My dd8 asked this year and I started telling her the story of Saint Nick and where traditions like stockings and chocolate coins came from. I never really answered her question but she was interested in the stories so I left it at that. She hasn’t asked since.

MamaMode · 16/12/2023 23:56

My 7 year old DD told 'me' a few weeks ago that Santa ain't real, well more precisely she said "mum Santa's not real is he? I think it's you putting the presents under the tree". I just responded that Santa gives gifts to those who need it most, and parents like to buys nice gifts for their children too, then sort of changed the subject. I didn't really want to confirm and end the magic for DD, but didn't want to deny and continue a lie now that she's starting to cotton on. Dd has not asked any further questions and seems very engrossed in all the elf antics as usual. But DD is pretty inquisitive so I know there will be more questions (about my response) at some point 😩🤣

Vitriolinsanity · 17/12/2023 16:42

I told DS that Santa uses Smyths Toys and (in the day) Toys R Us as refuelling depots to collect more toys.

Also, the suit repels CCTV hence no pictures.

Then along came Arthur Christmas and gave me another couple of years!

margotrose · 17/12/2023 16:44

Yesididntdothat · 16/12/2023 23:52

But if you never "did" Santa then you have no experience of a child who does believe asking questions, do you?

He's eight.

The chances of him actually believing is tiny, surely?

Yesididntdothat · 17/12/2023 17:02

Do you reckon? Not in my own experience or my dc.

MiniCooperLover · 17/12/2023 17:05

He's asking you to reassure him, not dash his hopes.

birdglasspen · 17/12/2023 17:36

Don’t lie to him. He obviously knows it’s a heap of lies. My kids dont believe they still have a wonderful Christmas. Some of the replies on here make me want to cry. Why do people get so upset if their kids aren’t stupid enough to believe in it!

LlynTegid · 17/12/2023 17:37

Depends on your son, but if you do decide to tell him the reality, he should be under strict instructions not to tell others.

Tooth fairy next set of questions??!!

margotrose · 17/12/2023 17:38

Yesididntdothat · 17/12/2023 17:02

Do you reckon? Not in my own experience or my dc.

Of course. Nobody I know genuinely believed in Santa at that age.

margotrose · 17/12/2023 17:38

MiniCooperLover · 17/12/2023 17:05

He's asking you to reassure him, not dash his hopes.

Or maybe he's asking to see whether his mum will tell him the truth.

Hellocatshome · 17/12/2023 17:40

margotrose · 17/12/2023 16:44

He's eight.

The chances of him actually believing is tiny, surely?

My children are older now but it seems primary age kids these days are expected to believe in Santa until year 6 so 11 years old yet are judged to be responsible enough for mobile phones and social media from around 7. Its a weird time to be a child.

Notmetoo · 17/12/2023 17:41

No don't tell him. Just continue saying it's magic and he will work it out when he is ready.
I never told my children he wasn't real we didn't need to I think probably they always knew but they wanted to believe and just stopped believing when they were ready