Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandad's Pride is being read on milkshake on channel 5 - not acceptable! AIBU

513 replies

grandadspride · 01/12/2023 09:13

Milkshake story den.

Why are we reading books about pride, gender and drag to pre-school children.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
HiddenLegoOuch · 01/12/2023 11:25

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:23

I pointed out that the word 'biology' on it's own doesn't really say much. It has to be more specific because biology is an immense and growing field.

Nope - biology covers it.

The biological reality is that human cannot change sex. Regardless of any other developments and advancements in a growing field - this is an immutable fact.

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:24

Nonoatchristmas · 01/12/2023 11:07

Trans people are not like Tinkerbell, people like the op recognising reality over their beliefs doesn’t ‘cease their existence’ doesn’t make them disappear. They will still believe they’re a different gender to their biological sex but that doesn’t mean everyone has to accept gender beliefs as a scientific reality. People can ‘see’ themselves however they want, but if that wholly hangs on other people validating how they’re seen then unfortunately life is going to be difficult.

You cannot expect the whole human race to suddenly play a very big game of Emperors New Clothes to spare feelings.

Why does it matter to OP what a person identifies as though, why does OP even need to keep calling someone something they are not?

HiddenLegoOuch · 01/12/2023 11:23

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:21

@MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking the posts have been deleted. I have no wish to repeat what OP said.

But… but… you said previously that you didn’t know what was said in the deleted posts, but it must have been really, really transphobic.

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:23

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 01/12/2023 11:06

But you claimed that we don't understand biology. We do.

I pointed out that the word 'biology' on it's own doesn't really say much. It has to be more specific because biology is an immense and growing field.

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:21

@MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking the posts have been deleted. I have no wish to repeat what OP said.

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:20

Nonoatchristmas · 01/12/2023 11:15

Same sex attracted people are lesbian/gay. They will always reject people of the opposite sex because of their biology regardless of their gender beliefs. If you are attracted to someone of the opposite sex, you are not gay. It’s not complex at all, unless you’re denying homosexuality and their right to label themselves as lesbian/gay on this bases alone. Or are we now slipping into TRA homophobia?

I was referring to other issues being complex, not who you are attracted to.

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 01/12/2023 11:20

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 10:47

Of course I have considered what I know to be transphobic - OP's post are.
I accept that others don't/won't see it, sometimes because they don't want to.

(No wire in my name by the way)

Point it out then, the actual transphobia. The exact words in the OPs posts, quoted, that you think constitutes transphobia.

Skirting around all "well I know what it is, but you can't see it so I'm not telling you" is bullshit.

Pulling out "people have DSDs" argument is also bullshit however. Just because some people have a medical condition to do with sex development, it does not mean other people get to demand everyone else validate them as the opposite sex to what they actually are.

What I suspect you mean when you refuse to quote this transphobia is either you can't, or the example you provide would be robustly argued against. And as your arguments consist of "they exist" and "bigot" you'll do pretty poorly.

People can identify however they like. What they cannot do however is force other people to validate them. And if someone refuses, you cannot make them.

Boundaries have been pushed and pushed and pushed by the do what I say or I'll call you a bigot brigade. And now we're at a point where a kids book celebrating individuality and every type of body forced the author into leaving the industry (Rachel Rooney, My Body is Me) - while a kids book showing fetish gear and dodgy references is read out on childrens tv.

grandadspride · 01/12/2023 11:19

Soubriquet · 01/12/2023 11:19

So the defence friends have given are

A) celebrities wear less on tv Hmm
B) go to any pride parade and you will find lots of leather bound people. This book is a fantastic way of introducing it to children so they aren’t afraid.

WTF?! No.

Wtf.

OP posts:
sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:19

Nonoatchristmas · 01/12/2023 11:08

What do you believe being a different gender is then? What exactly in brain development makes you not the biological male or female you were born?

Sex is basically defined by what sexual organs you have, basically male or female, and a few people with conditions where it's unclear/they have been encouraged down one route. Sexual organs can be changed to look like other sexual organs, but they won't actually function as those.

Gender is more complex, in that it takes into account what you identify with - I am pretty sure the complexities of what makes most females feel female and most males feel male isn't completely understood, and thus what would make one feel the opposite gender isn't that well understood either.

It's a complex area but undoubtedly people who do feel 'trapped' in the wrong body exist and go through immense heartache coming to terms with it - all I also is that what accept people for who they feel they are.

Of course that comes with responsibilities and limitations (such as the debate around access to female spaces being limited).

I will say, again, that I do find the images in the book inappropriate - they are too sexual regardless of which body they are on!

Soubriquet · 01/12/2023 11:19

So the defence friends have given are

A) celebrities wear less on tv Hmm
B) go to any pride parade and you will find lots of leather bound people. This book is a fantastic way of introducing it to children so they aren’t afraid.

WTF?! No.

ArthurbellaScott · 01/12/2023 11:15

Petitedress · 01/12/2023 11:09

Did the publisher remove the leather bondage picture or did they just not show it on TV? I noticed a lot of trans references and not many about homosexuality.

Some illustrations had elements removed for UK publication, iirc.

There was a 'furry' pawprint tattoo, and - was it the 'Love is love' slogan?

Nonoatchristmas · 01/12/2023 11:15

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:10

I meant anyone on this thread, as I thought that was being referred to.

I definitely think there are many complex issues around the concept of being trans, but ultimately we all reject people we don't find attractive, based on a whole host of things.

Same sex attracted people are lesbian/gay. They will always reject people of the opposite sex because of their biology regardless of their gender beliefs. If you are attracted to someone of the opposite sex, you are not gay. It’s not complex at all, unless you’re denying homosexuality and their right to label themselves as lesbian/gay on this bases alone. Or are we now slipping into TRA homophobia?

Soubriquet · 01/12/2023 11:14

FelineGood76 · 01/12/2023 10:31

Are there actually people here defending this shit? This world is well and truly fucked. Seriously, if you think this is OK you are either quite dim or are so far down the gender rabbit hole you have lost your mind. We need to ask why this is being pushed so hard to children, and by whom.

There really really are. Including friends of mine on fb. I just wanna give up sometimes

TheKeatingFive · 01/12/2023 11:12

You've been clear about your opinion, yes.

The binary and immutable nature of sex is a biological fact. Not an opinion.

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:10

Nonoatchristmas · 01/12/2023 11:09

How so? Have we not been clear about the distinction between having a belief and an absolute fact yet?

You've been clear about your opinion, yes.

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:10

HiddenLegoOuch · 01/12/2023 11:07

Think again - according to Stonewall, Mermaids…

Rejecting males who consider themselves lesbians is considered bigoted, transphobic and discriminatory.

Genital preferences are transphobic.

Also - have a look at the “cotton ceiling” - it is VERY eye opening and so horrific.

I meant anyone on this thread, as I thought that was being referred to.

I definitely think there are many complex issues around the concept of being trans, but ultimately we all reject people we don't find attractive, based on a whole host of things.

HiddenLegoOuch · 01/12/2023 11:09

I’ve started a count down for the shunting to the naughty corner. I’m surprised the thread has lasted this long in AIBU!

Petitedress · 01/12/2023 11:09

Did the publisher remove the leather bondage picture or did they just not show it on TV? I noticed a lot of trans references and not many about homosexuality.

Nonoatchristmas · 01/12/2023 11:09

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:08

I could say the same to you?

How so? Have we not been clear about the distinction between having a belief and an absolute fact yet?

Nonoatchristmas · 01/12/2023 11:08

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:05

I didn't say you could change sex.

What do you believe being a different gender is then? What exactly in brain development makes you not the biological male or female you were born?

Helleofabore · 01/12/2023 11:08

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:00

I don't even buy into moral high ground being a thing - we all have different views, however some of the OPs comments (which have now been deleted) were definitely transphobic!

As for different sexes, and the concept of gender, I don't disagree with what you have written, however it is also true that understanding isn't really 'complete' in terms of how the sexual organs and 'brain' aspect of sexuality/gender develop.

I do have issue with the images in this book, but not with the existence of trans people per se. OP clearly stated she has both - she is allowed to express that view, but others are allowed to challenge it.

Please show us where it is incomplete where medical science does not yet understand the development paths of sex organs in humans.

And you are now trying to leverage brain sex into the argument. No. YOU wish to believe those who are seeking to create an ambiguity around well established areas of study. Yes. Brains are affected by sex based hormones and interests. However, not one study has been able to prove that any human has a brain that is ‘male’ or ‘female’. If there was, they’d be using it for diagnosis for gender dysphoria.

You seem to be trying to convince others based on pseudoscience theory and misinformation. I would advise you to stop doing that unless you have evidence to prove your claims.

Instead you are here shaming posters discussing the issues with that book. A book even you acknowledge has safeguarding issues around the boundaries needed for children.

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:08

Nonoatchristmas · 01/12/2023 10:53

Of course it’s blatant to you. It’s disagreeing with your ideology which you believe deeply in to the point of refusing to recognise facts. It’s like when someone compares believing in god to ‘adult version of Santa’ - it’s very offensive to those with religion, blasphemy even, but it still doesn’t make god real beyond their personal beliefs. Just like your beliefs do not become reality just because your really really want them to be true.

I could say the same to you?

HiddenLegoOuch · 01/12/2023 11:07

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:03

I don't think anyone said it's transphobic not to find male sexual organs attractive.

Think again - according to Stonewall, Mermaids…

Rejecting males who consider themselves lesbians is considered bigoted, transphobic and discriminatory.

Genital preferences are transphobic.

Also - have a look at the “cotton ceiling” - it is VERY eye opening and so horrific.

Nonoatchristmas · 01/12/2023 11:07

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:01

OP is telling them they don't exist as they see themselves - the post where she expressed this is gone now though (deleted by MN).

Trans people are not like Tinkerbell, people like the op recognising reality over their beliefs doesn’t ‘cease their existence’ doesn’t make them disappear. They will still believe they’re a different gender to their biological sex but that doesn’t mean everyone has to accept gender beliefs as a scientific reality. People can ‘see’ themselves however they want, but if that wholly hangs on other people validating how they’re seen then unfortunately life is going to be difficult.

You cannot expect the whole human race to suddenly play a very big game of Emperors New Clothes to spare feelings.