Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect parents to treat me and DH the same?

377 replies

Tonto2001 · 26/11/2023 08:14

Me and DH both have split parents.

Parents still provide us both with Xmas/birthday gifts or money but all have a different approach to the value.

Now I'm in no way ungrateful for this and dont ever expect anything, this is just about spending more on own child than their partner.

DH mum - for birthdays and Xmas gifts us exactly the same value of gift.

My Mum - will spend more on me than DH.

DH Dad - spends more on DH

My Dad - tends to be equal but can sometimes edge towards me.

I prefer DH's mums approach. And treating us both equal, we are a partnership and family now and feel like thats how I would like to treat DS partner when the time comes.

I have spoke to my Mum about it but it never seems to happen.

DH is also in agreement with me and also the one who brought it up in the first place however won't speak to his own Dad about it.

Is it unreasonable to ask our parents to treat us both equally when it comes to gifting?

OP posts:
iamjustwinginglife · 26/11/2023 11:34

^DH mum - for birthdays and Xmas gifts us exactly the same value of gift.

My Mum - will spend more on me than DH.

DH Dad - spends more on DH

My Dad - tends to be equal but can sometimes edge towards me.^

Overall equal then-your dad and DH mum buy equal gifts. Your mum favours you, DH dad favours him. The phrase* exactly the same value of gift.*^^ does indicate you're valued the gifts though!!

ReignOfError · 26/11/2023 11:35

I buy gifts for my kids and their partners based on what I think they’d like, which means I don’t always spend the same amount each on my sons, let alone my daughters-in-law.

The day any one of them tried to tell me how to spend my own money (apart from generic ‘you don’t need to buy us anything’ comments) would, like others, be the day I stopped spending it on that particular ungrateful, graceless sod.

Drfosters · 26/11/2023 11:37

Gosh I’ve never thought about. Mum mum always spoils me as she knows I struggle to justify buying for myself. She gets my DH some beer or smellies. He’d think she’d gone mad if she spoilt him! I’m very close to my mum though and she loves to buy the girlie things for me as i do for my own daughter.

my MIL spends prob about the same but more because she has absolutely no idea what to get us so usually vouchers. Nice and simple. At Xmas we don’t do adult presents anymore on his side as the family got too large.

I’m keen for the grandparents to treat the grandchildren fairly but not the adults. I’d honestly be happy if we just scrapped pressies altogether tbh!

Ohnoooooooo · 26/11/2023 11:38

I don't give this sort of stuff any thought. Sorry I am not sure why you do.

TheFireflies · 26/11/2023 11:39

Do your parents have partners?
Do you spend exactly the same on their partners as you do on your own parents?

herewegoagain7 · 26/11/2023 11:39

I can't believe the greedy husband managed to have the cheek to bring this up

feellikeanalien · 26/11/2023 11:43

I can't believe this is something that would even cross anyone's mind. It comes across as terribly childish.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 26/11/2023 11:43

I think it is down to the individual buying the presents but I don’t see why it should be equal. Spending more on your own child doesn’t seem strange but equally if they want to spend the same then fine. I don’t think you should say anything to anyone about their spending, just leave it to them to decide.

HaveYouTriedListening · 26/11/2023 11:45

I always give my AC more than their partners, for birthdays and Christmas. The inlaws give their AC more than they give my kids. That's normal.

ithinkmyheadiscavingin · 26/11/2023 11:47

YABU

'Team' or not, you are your mother/father's child, and your husband is his mother/father's child. They treat you accordingly.

Crikeyalmighty · 26/11/2023 11:52

I could have bet your bottom dollar that it was your DH that brought this up- and indeed it is so. A gift is a gift OP, and it's very bad form to be sat counting the cost and incredibly unclassy- tell him so!

Scarletttulips · 26/11/2023 12:01

Your DH sounds immature!

My mum sends us a cash gift for me to distribute - generally 1/4 each for 3 teens and the rest is spent on a day out/Panto as a joint gift.

Dsis splits hers between herself and DD - DD has a partner - I’ve not idea what she does with it.

DSis has 3 kids and splits it between 4 equally - again no idea of they share with partners - nor do I care.

DH is grateful we are thought of.

VivaDixie · 26/11/2023 12:02

After 20 years together I have absolutely no idea how much our parents spend on us - I have never worked it out.

Are you my spoilt sister by any chance?

WhoNeedsFriends · 26/11/2023 12:03

So it's your mum and his dad that do this.

Your DH had got a problem with it so you speak to your mum about it but he won't speak to his dad about it.

Sounds like a DH problem. Why does he only have a problem with unequal gifts if it benefits you not him.

dutysuite · 26/11/2023 12:08

My parents give me more for Christmas and my birthday than they give to DH.
My MIL doesn't do gifts.

JudgeJ · 26/11/2023 12:11

BendingSpoons · 26/11/2023 08:24

It sounds like it's broadly equal overall, so I would just roll with it. It's harder to buy for a partner often. Plus you are adults who can buy your own stuff too!

That was my thought, 2 parents give more or less equal and two give one more than the other! Much ado about nothing really.

strawberry2017 · 26/11/2023 12:16

You are their child, he is not.
You are unreasonable to expect them to treat you both the same

Agapornis · 26/11/2023 12:21

Why does your husband not want your own mother to spend money on you? He sounds jealous and like he feels you don't deserve it. What does he buy you?

CJsGoldfish · 26/11/2023 12:30

So this is really about keeping your DH happy because he complained that YOUR mum spend more on you than him? Aren't you embarrassed by his childishness OP?

Anon0mum · 26/11/2023 12:38

Why does it matter what is spent and if you get more than your DH or vise versa? Is this something your husband has expressed bothered him? Either way there needs to be so maturing
As adults I would have thought that you all would have just been greatfull to receive a gift, rather than counting who gets what.

Enjoy spending time with your parents/ in laws 🤷🏼‍♀️

SpongeBob2022 · 26/11/2023 12:40

In the past my parents would have spent more on me and same with his parents on him. In recent years my parents have started giving us an amount together to choose something for both of us (e.g. one year we bought a coffee machine). DH's parents just get us small token gifts that are roughly equal as they spend more on the grandchildren. All of these ways are completely fine.

If they didn't get us anything at all I wouldn't mind...Christmas gifts are about kids in the family for me now. But as they can afford it I gratefully accept. I can't relate at all to being bothered by this.

If I was ever in a scenario where I was getting £500 more in presents than my husband or something I'd just choose something that we'd both benefit from.

someonethatyoulovetoomuch · 26/11/2023 12:54

margotrose · 26/11/2023 10:58

you’re well within your rights to ask her to spend less on you so that she isn’t going into debt or stretching her budget too far.

Her mum is a grown adult who is free to make her own decisions. She doesn't need to be patronised and told off like a naughty child by her adult daughter!

Where did I say tell her off like a naughty child? Personally if I knew anyone was getting themselves into debt or spending more than they could comfortably afford on me, I would find a nice way to ask them to spend less on any future gifts - I wouldn’t be “telling them off”
or dictating to them. I just wouldn't want to feel responsible for anyone I love struggling to make it to payday. If that makes me an ungrateful monster then fair enough.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 26/11/2023 12:58

DH is also in agreement with me and also the one who brought it up in the first place however won't speak to his own Dad about it.

I think your dh seems grabby. He’s quietly totting up the value and putting ideas in your head and making you refuse generous, well-intended gifts from your own dm while steadfastly refusing to mention anything to his dp. How dare he make you think that your own dm shouldn’t spoil you if she isn’t treating him equally. If your dm is anything like mine gifting generously to her close family brings her joy and it’s almost unkind to make her check her behaviour in this way.

Of course your dm spends more on you than your dh, she is your parent. This is not unusual or abnormal behaviour but for for some reason your dh has made an issue of this and has you thinking that it’s wrong when it absolutely isn’t. Do you think he could be jealous?

My dh used to tell my dm not to buy him anything at all because she spent so much on me and the kids and he always felt guilty. He also insisted that we spoiled her as she was a widow and only got presents from us and my siblings. She still continued to always give him something lovely, although nowhere near to the value of what she spent on me and the dc. None of us would have even thought to query it because she is my mother and while she adored dh, he wasn’t her ds had his own parents to buy for him.

margotrose · 26/11/2023 13:00

someonethatyoulovetoomuch · 26/11/2023 12:54

Where did I say tell her off like a naughty child? Personally if I knew anyone was getting themselves into debt or spending more than they could comfortably afford on me, I would find a nice way to ask them to spend less on any future gifts - I wouldn’t be “telling them off”
or dictating to them. I just wouldn't want to feel responsible for anyone I love struggling to make it to payday. If that makes me an ungrateful monster then fair enough.

But it's not your place to do any of that Confused

If someone tried to tell me, as a grown adult, that I couldn't spend my money on my own child, I'd think they were incredibly rude and a bit odd.

LuckySantangelo35 · 26/11/2023 13:04

@Tonto2001

your DH sounds quite pathetic frankly.