Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect parents to treat me and DH the same?

377 replies

Tonto2001 · 26/11/2023 08:14

Me and DH both have split parents.

Parents still provide us both with Xmas/birthday gifts or money but all have a different approach to the value.

Now I'm in no way ungrateful for this and dont ever expect anything, this is just about spending more on own child than their partner.

DH mum - for birthdays and Xmas gifts us exactly the same value of gift.

My Mum - will spend more on me than DH.

DH Dad - spends more on DH

My Dad - tends to be equal but can sometimes edge towards me.

I prefer DH's mums approach. And treating us both equal, we are a partnership and family now and feel like thats how I would like to treat DS partner when the time comes.

I have spoke to my Mum about it but it never seems to happen.

DH is also in agreement with me and also the one who brought it up in the first place however won't speak to his own Dad about it.

Is it unreasonable to ask our parents to treat us both equally when it comes to gifting?

OP posts:
GettinChillyHereFFS · 26/11/2023 08:29

Is it unreasonable to ask our parents to treat us both equally when it comes to gifting?

You both deserve nothing imo.

jhy · 26/11/2023 08:30

Very childish and embarrassing to calculate this and bring it up.

My dynamic is my DP gets nothing off of his parents (he is not a gift type of person/did not celebrate Christmas until we had DS) yet his parents gift me high amounts of money for my birthday / Christmas (around £200 for each occasion). I find it really awkward.
My parents get DP nothing and token gifts for me.

Ffsmakeitstop · 26/11/2023 08:30

Your DH is a cheeky sod for even mentioning it. He should be grateful for whatever he gets, God I sound like my mum.

My in-laws and parents always treated us all the same apart from very early on in the relationship until we were a definite couple ,but neither of us would have been concerned if they hadn't because we were both brought up to not be greedy.

HannahHannahAnna · 26/11/2023 08:30

I find it weird to get to the age where you're a married woman but you're still worried about how much your daddy is spending on your Christmas gifts

Teatrayderby · 26/11/2023 08:30

Men, particularly those who aren't your offspring, are impossible to buy for anyway. Yabu

Notagainwellreally · 26/11/2023 08:30

It's normal to give your own child (even adult child) more in my opinion. I wouldn't be getting worked up about it anyway, they are free to gift as they choose and you are lucky to have people thinking of you and buying things for you.

BIWI · 26/11/2023 08:31

@Tonto2001 You have 85 votes (so far) and every single one of them has said YABU.

Aparecium · 26/11/2023 08:31

Depends. My parents and my ILs also generally give their own child something of greater value than their DIL or SIL. My parents tend to gift cash, my ILs tend to gift presents. If my parents gave me £100, but dh £10, I would consider that unpleasant. But they don't. Both of us get generous gifts. Both of us keep a little to spend on ourselves and the rest goes into the family kitty anyway. As for my ILs, I don't care that the gift they buy me is of lower monetary value, because it is always a well-thought-out gift. So why should I resent getting a £10 hobby gadget that I will use with great pleasure, just because dh got something more expensive? Mind you, it wasn't always that way. It took them over ten years to accept me as a DIL. I'll gloss over those years and focus on the good years since.

BMW6 · 26/11/2023 08:31

Perfectly normal for a parent to spend/give more to child than partner of child.

Totally abnormal for a child grown up to make such comparisons and whinge about "unfairness"

OrigamiOwl · 26/11/2023 08:32

It is unreasonable for you try and control others and what they want to gift you.

It really can't be a surprise or unfathomable that parents may want to spend more on their own children.

I can't think of any way you could have a conversation with any of your parents without coming off as entitled or grabby.

Ffsnotaconference · 26/11/2023 08:33

Tonto2001 · 26/11/2023 08:29

OK, some context needed here.

I'm not calculating anything, DH brought it up a few years ago and since then it's made me consider how I want to approach it. There's no calculating needed, it's obvious to see how much difference there is.

My mum will try to spend an extortionate amount on me compared to DH, (example being offering to pay for some new glasses for over £200 amongst other things and then saying I'll just get DH a jumper) and that just doesn't sit right with me.

She isn’t his parent though is she?

If you and your husband split up. Will she have the same level involvement with him as she would with you?

Would she be expected to support you equally?

I appreciate you and dh are a family. But to extended family, there is a difference. Your mums relationship with him is entirely dependent on you. It’s a relationship they have directly.

I can believe you have been going over this for years. Adults quibbling about how much their parents is weird.

BrieEncounter · 26/11/2023 08:34

I think even given the wider context and you're update you are still unreasonable

A jumper is a lovely gift?

And the insinuation is that you expect each parent to treat you both as their own. That would mean asking your mum to spend £200 on you and £200 on your DH which is very grabby

We only do secret Santa with family now at Christmas so often we don't get presents from our own parents at all...

Hedonism · 26/11/2023 08:34

Are you twelve??

The response to anyone giving you anything is 'thank you very much', not to sit down and calculate the value of what you got last year or what that person gave your partner 6 months ago.

Who even keeps a record of this?

savoycabbage · 26/11/2023 08:35

So your husband brought it up to you a few years ago that your mum spends more on your Christmas present than she does on his.

Then you spoke to your mum about it.

Then she still did it.

And your husband is annoyed about this.

And his dad does the same but he won't talk to his dad about it.

And your question is how you should tackle this?

ColinFuckingRobinson · 26/11/2023 08:35

Well, it's not the same is it? You are not your in-laws child, and your DH is not your parents child. Just because you chose each other doesn't mean your families develop equal strength feelings of parental love for the spouse of their child.

My late MIL always gave more to exDH on birthdays than me. I didn't expect anything different. I still felt loved and appreciated by her, she was wonderful, but I wasn't under any illusion that our relationship was anything more than fond mil/dil.

Azandme · 26/11/2023 08:35

Tonto2001 · 26/11/2023 08:29

OK, some context needed here.

I'm not calculating anything, DH brought it up a few years ago and since then it's made me consider how I want to approach it. There's no calculating needed, it's obvious to see how much difference there is.

My mum will try to spend an extortionate amount on me compared to DH, (example being offering to pay for some new glasses for over £200 amongst other things and then saying I'll just get DH a jumper) and that just doesn't sit right with me.

Would you spend the same on a niece/nephew as your own child?

No? Why not? Because they aren't your child...

Would you spend the same on your BIL as you spend on your DH? Again, it's going to be a no. They aren't your DH.

Same applies.

I'm guessing your DH brought it up because he wants to receive more. Entitled, grabby, unattractive, and actually odd to think this way.

Ick.

Rjahdhdvd · 26/11/2023 08:36

You can’t tell people how to gift or spend money. Mine and DHs parents do it differently and we just accept that

mondaytosunday · 26/11/2023 08:37

We didn't get presents from our parents as adults - maybe at Christmas but if so I'd expect the actual parents to spend a bit more on their child.,and certainly wouldn't waste any time thinking about the fact I may get a book and my husband a nice sweater. I certainly spent more on my siblings than he did on his.

JourneyToThePlacentaOfTheEarth · 26/11/2023 08:38

Yabu and odd and so is your husband.

Tonto2001 · 26/11/2023 08:38

This is where context is so important.

I would prefer a more modest gift for both of us. I dont want her spending that sort of money on either one of us.
She isn't flush with money but she has some issues so can be a bit impulsive.

I absolutely wouldn't expect her to "match" for DH.

OP posts:
LimeOrangeLemon · 26/11/2023 08:39

My parents are more generous towards me than DH, but it's often in the form of money rather than gifts so it doesn't make any difference as it all goes in the joint pot.

DH's parents are slightly more generous towards him, but give us all small gifts anyway so the more generous one will still be quite small.

Up to them anyway. But if you feel bad about it, maybe you and DH could arrange between you for you to give him a nicer present than he gives you? To make it more balanced.

user1496146479 · 26/11/2023 08:39

Your parents can choose how much of THEIR money they spend! Simple

DemBonesDemBones · 26/11/2023 08:39

This is so grabby.

Notagainwellreally · 26/11/2023 08:39

My mum will try to spend an extortionate amount on me compared to DH, (example being offering to pay for some new glasses for over £200 amongst other things and then saying I'll just get DH a jumper) and that just doesn't sit right with me.
But why not? I don't really get it. She's your mother.
Do you feel the same about gifts from other family members? So if, say, a sister bought you a birthday gift would you expect her to buy your DH one of equal value?
I know I put more money and effort into my sister's birthday gift as I don't get her partner a gift for his birthday at all.

DiaNaranja · 26/11/2023 08:39

Gosh, I'm constantly pleading with family (both sides) to not bother getting me and DH stuff for birthdays and xmas. I'd rather they saved their money, and hate the thought of them stressing over what to get. I always ask them not to bother, and if they insist, I suggest they put the money they'd have spent in the kids savings account. I couldn't care less what they spend on us, and certainly would never compare mine Vs DHs, as that's just weird. Surely for most people, once you have kids, Xmas becomes about the children, not overindulged adults?