Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS keeps being moved at school

261 replies

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 09:27

Ds has recently gone into year 2 and has had a brand new teacher. He previously had the same teacher from nursery to year 1 and he was doing so well in school. He was getting star pupil every week loved his teacher and he was progressing so well.

New teacher keeps moving him pretty much everyday and the reasons he is giving us seem petty unless he is lying but I have no reason not to believe him. She hasn’t contacted us to tell us he’s been messing around or everything and we see her everyday.

We paid £100 for him to go on a school trip and when we picked him up he looked so sad my heart broke for him. He eventually told us that she told him he was being rude for kicking a paper towel and made him sit at the front of the coach away from his friends.

He went into school this morning and she said hi “DS” and he just walked past her. We also seen her on bonfire night and he didn’t even want to say hi then either. I have never seen him like this before ever.

Something in my gut isn’t sitting right! Surely if he was misbehaving so badly we would have some kind of contact? He is a good kid never had any issues with him ever.

OP posts:
SnapdragonToadflax · 15/11/2023 10:49

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 09:35

He didn’t reply to her and she said “oh ok good morning mrs (teacher) because he didn’t respond.

I don’t want to force him if he doesn’t feel like it though as that’s what I have previously been making him do and he obviously feels a certain way.

But that's incredibly rude of him, he needs to be polite to his teacher even if he doesn't like her. We all have to bite our tongues and be polite to people we either don't like or don't get on with. He's old enough to understand.

It's almost impossibly unlikely that the teacher has taken against your son for no reason. Teachers don't have the time for vendettas, they just want all the kids to get on with their work and not disrupt the classroom. If he's been messing around and got a reputation which means she's now hot on his behaviour, that's his own fault and you need to support her.

Chocolatepeanutbuttercupsandicecream · 15/11/2023 10:48

I think the whole idea of “more mature” expectations in year 2 is ridiculous! They’re 6/7 years old; in some countries they wouldn’t even be in school yet.
I’m a firm believer that all behaviour is communication, and your little boy is clearly communicating that he is unhappy in school. I think speaking to the teacher, in a neutral manner, and focusing on the changes in his demeanour, is a good place to start.

Celticliving · 15/11/2023 10:48

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 10:29

Well he said yesterday his friend put a ruler on his eye lids and everyone was giggling but he was only one to be moved.

I'm sorry but what your child tells you (at 6 years old) is not necessarily going to be what actually happened.
Not many kids are going to say "my teacher keeps moving me because I'm really disrespectful and disruptive and I'm really naughty and I keep causing my friends to laugh at me".
Most kids will tell you the bare minimum; either because they know they are in trouble, they don't see it as causing trouble or because they don't remember it as it happened.

MNCrazies · 15/11/2023 10:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Soonenough · 15/11/2023 10:46

Teacher probably is disappointed you don't discipline your son when he is being rude to her on front of you.
Important life lesson here . Things don't always go your way even at 6. And again, only his mother thinks he is special.

Notwhatyouwanttohear · 15/11/2023 10:46

Maybe your dc is withdrawn because he is finally getting called out on his obnoxious behaviour and doesn't like it.

Ignoring a teacher and you condoning it, can see where the issue arises.

UndertheCedartree · 15/11/2023 10:46

brokenhearted2 · 15/11/2023 09:54

Maybe. But then again if an adult were being a bully or abusive you wouldn't surely tell your child to 'be nice'. That's how kids, esp girls end up abused. Invalidating their experience and demanding that they are nice to the perpetrators is very very unhealthy

This absolutely. Telling DC that they should ignore their feelings and always be polite to adults is a breeding ground for a child being vulnerable to abuse.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 15/11/2023 10:41

OP I could have written your post many years ago. It turned out the teacher was in fact low level bullying my DD to the point her personality changed and she became very withdrawn. It happened over the school year and it took us all that time to realise that all the minor things DD was coming home and telling us about were building up in her head as her just not being good enough. I pulled her out of the school after witnessing the teacher bully DD in front of other staff including the HT and he denied it happened.

I'm not saying this is happening with your DS but when a teacher takes a dislike to a student then they will punish something minor (like kicking a paper towel) which for any other student would just be a "please don't do that again". Your DS does not sound rude or like a spoilt brat. He sounds like a 6 year old who's struggling to deal with being punished for things that aren't really that big of a deal.

Good luck speaking to the teacher

MNCrazies · 15/11/2023 10:41

PennyFleck · 15/11/2023 09:33

Not what you are asking, but if I was with my child and he rudely ignored and WALKED PAST an adult saying 'Hi' specifically to him, never mind if it is a teacher or not, I think you are being extremely unreasonable accepting his unacceptably rude behaviour.
Did you haul him back and say, "When an adult speaks to you, you respond politely - it's very rude to walk off" ?
If not, you are condoning this rudeness from a 6-7 year old boy. This is a slippery slope, OP.

I bloody well hope she didn’t, what kind of message is that setting?!

That an adult outranks him because what, they’re older?
Doesn’t work that way, perhaps you need to grow up and join us in the real world. Respect is earned, relationships are built and he does not owe anyone anything by default.

This fucking website, I swear…

UndertheCedartree · 15/11/2023 10:40

PennyFleck · 15/11/2023 09:33

Not what you are asking, but if I was with my child and he rudely ignored and WALKED PAST an adult saying 'Hi' specifically to him, never mind if it is a teacher or not, I think you are being extremely unreasonable accepting his unacceptably rude behaviour.
Did you haul him back and say, "When an adult speaks to you, you respond politely - it's very rude to walk off" ?
If not, you are condoning this rudeness from a 6-7 year old boy. This is a slippery slope, OP.

The OP has explained how sad and upset her DS is and him not responding to the teacher was a symptom of that. I fail to see how 'hauling' him back and speaking to him harshly would help. The OP rightly wants to get to the bottom of the issue and solve the cause.

Maxus · 15/11/2023 10:38

You need to speak to the teacher and then work with her to try and calm your child's behaviour. Because if you don't your child will turn into a year 11 who constantly disrupts the class and at that age the other teens will not take that disruption lightly. That's happening in my child's class right now and it's always the kids who did low level disruption in primary school.

HamsterBanana · 15/11/2023 10:35

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 10:34

No I’m not defensive I think it’s difficult as a parent you send them to school and you don’t know what is happening during the day. It has come as a shock these last couple of months because no one has ever told us that he has been misbehaving at school. Him having the same teacher for all them years probably isn’t great either. But his new teacher doesn’t give me that nice friendly feeling either almost feels very cold.

Cold like walking past someone who says hello and ignoring them? Fine one to talk when your teaching your son it's okay to behave in that manner.

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 10:34

No I’m not defensive I think it’s difficult as a parent you send them to school and you don’t know what is happening during the day. It has come as a shock these last couple of months because no one has ever told us that he has been misbehaving at school. Him having the same teacher for all them years probably isn’t great either. But his new teacher doesn’t give me that nice friendly feeling either almost feels very cold.

OP posts:
Cordeliathecat · 15/11/2023 10:34

I had this with my son. He adores his year4 and 5 teacher. I’ve never seen him so happy in school.

When he was given his year 6 teacher he took an intense disliking to her which resulted in him being rude and petulant towards her which obviously got him into a bit of trouble.

Prior to this my son was always top of the class, very clever, kind sweet boy, always received a lot of praise.

Ultimately he didn’t like change. He was acting out because at an irrational level he wanted everything to stay the same and have his old teacher back.

It was my job as a parent to teach him that life doesn’t work like that. He will always experience change and will not always click with everyone but that doesn’t mean he can act out. Eventually he just sucked it up and things improved once he fell into line.

The best thing you can do for your child is to support the teacher. You absolutely should force him to be polite to his teacher and any other adult for that matter. Manners are the best asset we can give to our children.

Maxus · 15/11/2023 10:31

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 10:23

When he was getting star of week it was for his maths and reading not for behaviour.

Star of the week is designed manly for the naughty kids. Of course they are not going to say star is for not hitting someone for example of course they are going to say it's for maths etc.

Soonenough · 15/11/2023 10:30

@Cupsoftea2 Of course you are being defensive as I knew you would . You say I don't know your child but these two examples form my opinion . And you can see that others have supported that. He is complaining to you as he knows that rather than address the issues and tell him that he is wrong to kick stuff or be rude to his teacher , you are indulging him . Maybe he wouldn't be "picked on " by a teacher if he just behaved himself . This won't get better if you continue , he is only a child now , but this can lead to an entitled obnoxious teenage boy .

I know you think this is harsh but I do have professional experience.

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 10:29

cardibach · 15/11/2023 10:25

In your OP you say the reasons he's being moved seem petty to you but you haven't given any examples (apart from one where he says everyone was laughing and he got moved - well, you have to move someone to split up a group, and maybe he was the one setting the laughing going by silliness). What reasons does he give?

Well he said yesterday his friend put a ruler on his eye lids and everyone was giggling but he was only one to be moved.

OP posts:
NeedToChangeName · 15/11/2023 10:27

Luxell934 · 15/11/2023 10:15

Here’s a thought. Imagine having 25-30 kids in one room, if you ignore the low level behaviour like chatting when the teacher is talking, kicking stuff around, getting out of their seat when asked to sit down, not following instructions etc etc the classroom will pretty soon end up in chaos. Low level behaviour can escalate and become more serious if they think that they can get away with these things. Then these children disrupt everyone’s learning.

and sorry to burst your bubble but star of the week is so very rarely given to the most well behaved/polite children. It’s given to those who need a boost as a behaviour tool to those who are struggling with behaviour/emotional issues.

Stop making excuses for your sons obvious poor behaviour.

Agree with this

cardibach · 15/11/2023 10:25

In your OP you say the reasons he's being moved seem petty to you but you haven't given any examples (apart from one where he says everyone was laughing and he got moved - well, you have to move someone to split up a group, and maybe he was the one setting the laughing going by silliness). What reasons does he give?

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 10:25

I have rang them anyway so I will wait and see what the teacher has to say.

OP posts:
Dramatic · 15/11/2023 10:25

It's very possibly your son is showing lots of low level behaviour and this is why he's being moved. My step daughter is in year 3 and will constantly come home telling us stuff like " I was put on the tracker because I had a drink of my water" (tracker is their first line behaviour sanction) and as it turns out she had been repeatedly messing with her water bottle while the teacher was doing whole class teaching, this only goes on for 5 minutes at the start of the lesson and the kids know they aren't allowed to mess with anything on their table. So it's not always quite as the child tells you.

Also kicking the paper towel, yeah I agree with the teacher there, clearly he shouldn't have been doing it and I'd support the teacher with whatever she thought was appropriate to do at that moment.

InTheRainOnATrain · 15/11/2023 10:24

The paper towel sounds minor in theory but if you’ve got 30 kids stood at the side of a road with passing traffic then you need to be really strict about standing still in order to keep everyone safe. Also if he’s overexcited and being silly that isn’t safe on a bus either, and removing him from his friends seems like reasonable enough punishment and a good way of calming him down to ensure everyone including him stays safe.

At my DC’s school they are expected to say good afternoon/good morning to every teacher. Even my 2YO has to say it every morning as he walks into his nursery class. I can’t imagine my DC ignoring a teacher and I wouldn’t just let it go. I have colleagues I can’t stand but you don’t just blank people do you?

Year 2 is going to be stricter, expectations will increase and it sounds like he’s struggling to adjust to that. Definitely talk to the teacher and see what can be done to help him but I wouldn’t go in assuming that the teacher is in the wrong because nothing you’ve said suggests that’s the case.

InsomniacA · 15/11/2023 10:24

OP, what do you think the teacher should do if your son ignores her in the classroom? For example, if he ignores her when she is giving instructions or explaining? Or he ignores her the first time she asks him to do or not do something? Because it doesn't seem much of a stretch to expect that if he is doing this at the gates and the bonfire night in front of you, the behaviour is more blatant in the classroom when you are not there.

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 10:23

When he was getting star of week it was for his maths and reading not for behaviour.

OP posts: