Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what a "normal" sibling relationship looks like

44 replies

bubbleteais · 14/11/2023 12:34

I am an only and am getting curious about siblings which probably stems from my genetic readings. I know I might be a bit annoying as I just posted her but I am BORED

Just curious!

I don't even have a cousin close in age. All of them are 5+ years older and most are of the opposite sex.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pharmachameleon · 14/11/2023 19:00

I haven't spoken to my sister for about 10 years. She would pick a fight in an empty house and I'm truly terrified of her. I get on ok with my brother. We have nothing in common and have a big age gap but we Watsapp fairly regularly.
I would love to have a close relationship with siblings but it just wasn't to be. My DH and friends fill the gaps.

tuvamoodyson · 14/11/2023 17:20

1 older sister and we are very close, speak/text every day, we are there for each other at any time day or night…close with all my family though, I’m very blessed.

Torganer · 14/11/2023 17:01

I count my brother as one of my best friends. We don’t live near each other, but text and call often and try and see each other as much as we can. Would drop anything to help each other out.

dixeypeach · 14/11/2023 16:50

I'm the eldest of three we all live in a 30 mile radius (that's including my mum and dad) I have a brother 2 years younger than me I see him most days as he picks up my son for work, I wouldn't say was in each others pockets close but we get on. My sister is 9 years younger than me and we are very close, speak everyday on the phone see each other regularly. My sil (brothers wife) is an only child and she's just like a sister to us really we've kind of adopted her. I can't imagine having no siblings and I think that's why I like the fact that I've had a big family (5 children) they will always have each other.

swallowedAfly · 14/11/2023 16:49

My sibling and I have tried by the way and I think it hurts both of us that we can't make it work. There's just such strong dynamics at play and much as she tries she'll fall into abusive type behaviour if she's feeling bad about herself or if she doesn't approve of something (because we're very different including different values) or if I say no to something and defend that boundary.

I suspect often whether siblings get on or not depends how their parents coped with having more than one child and whether they were treated fairly and grew up in a functional group dynamic.

Handyweatherstation · 14/11/2023 16:47

I have two brothers, one older, the other my twin. Me and older brother have never been close but get on better these days. He was very jealous when me and my twin came along and was very aggressive to us for a long time, but he improved a great deal after I gave him a rather firm telling-off and said how good things could be for us as a family if he stopped being such an arse. Me and my twin are very close and are in touch most days, either by email or a phone catch up and we've written to each other for years. There's something lovely about having a connection since we shared a womb and I can't imagine him not being there. He's one of my favourite people in the world.

swallowedAfly · 14/11/2023 16:46

Bear in mind there'll be a kind of selection bias on this thread. For many with difficult relationships or traumatic stuff they won't want to post and dredge stuff up. Far simpler and quicker if you're saying yeah we all get on alright or we're not super close but always get on ok at family occasions.

I'm one who doesn't get on with their sibling largely because we were raised not to get on and set against each other by my mother who played the golden child v scapegoat game and a lot of my sister's self esteem was based upon feeling above me and she was encouraged to think nothing of abusive behaviour by others or her towards me.

That's not all that comfortable to talk about so I nearly didn't post but wanted to say the first paragraph I wrote.

My son is an only by the way.

hopeishere · 14/11/2023 16:40

It's really interesting to read this thread though because I struggle with DHs family not getting on!!

hopeishere · 14/11/2023 16:36

My sister and I are close. We drifted a bit when she got married and had kids but are close again now. We can really make each other howl with laughter. I enjoy spending time with her.

DH. Totally different story. He and his brother sort of got on, certainly spent a lot of time together but it was a weird relationship based on slagging people off. He's not speaking to him now due to a disagreement over his dads will. I know his brother is upset by this but he also lacks self awareness and is painting himself as the injured party. DH refused to see him on his (DHs) birthday.

They have a sister. They don't get on with her; she's gay and left wing and there's always tension / friction when she visits. They also don't like her partner.

But they all sort of go through the motions. DH and I were taking about Christmas presents earlier and I said why was he bothering; the three of them exchange gift vouchers and it's so impersonal and transactional.

RM2013 · 14/11/2023 16:34

1 sibling, 4 years younger. We weren’t close growing up because of age difference. I left home at 19 into my own house. He then left home and moved away at 17 and still lives in a. City 3 hrs drive away.
my parents visit him and his family but we rarely see them. When we do we get on ok but I don’t feel it’s a close relationship as we have very little in common - sad really

ExTheCheater · 14/11/2023 16:27

We have sibling Saturdays/Sundays. Go out for food, make food, have drinks, go for walks or days out. They are less now but we still see each other atleast weekly for a few hours at our parents. It's nice.

CarolinaInTheMorning · 14/11/2023 16:13

There are four of us, two men, two women. We had the usual spats as children, but we are close as adults. Deaths of parents brought us even closer. We are in regular communication with each other (mostly text) and see each other fairly often, even though it means travel.

SoVTired · 14/11/2023 16:04

One sister, 8 years younger than me. She is the golden child (which she freely acknowledges, and therefore we had totally different childhoods, even without the substantial age difference.
Clashed growing up, clashed even more when I had to move back home in my mid 20s.
Now extremely close, good mates, supportive of each other. Speak daily.

girlfriend44 · 14/11/2023 15:58

There is no normal. Everyone is different.

Relationships can change over time as well.

You can become estranged then be friends again. You never know what's round the corner even if you have a great relationship now you might not always.

Different partners coming into people's lives, can change the dynamic also.

onawave · 14/11/2023 15:53

No idea. On the one hand I know I could call my sister at 3am if I needed her and she would be here in a shot. On the other hand I know if one of us says hello in slightly the wrong tone of voice we could end up not talking for a couple of months. We have no middle ground really. Drives my mum up the wall.

Jumbalya0367 · 14/11/2023 15:53

I have 2 brothers 1 sister.
Close with my brothers, don’t speak everyday or even once a week, but they phone or text for advice and we have fun when we see each other. They are fantastic uncles to my kids - take them out etc.

It’s the same with my sister, however I’m just naturally even closer to her and we speak most days.
We always tell each other we love each other which I really love.

I am the eldest and by quite a lot 9, 11 and 13 years so I suppose I’ve always mothered them.

Saying all this they also are the most annoying people I know 😂😂 We can clash but its always soon forgotten. Couldn’t be without them though -I’m very lucky

PinkflowersWhiteBerries · 14/11/2023 15:49

I have 2 sisters. Usual arguments etc as teenagers, but close now we are older.

Going through some major life events - divorce, serious illness, death of parents - plus helping each other out with childcare etc, really built those relationships.

We live fairly close to each other as well now, so see each other regularly . We are all fairly open and direct so that actually helps - things don’t fester.

DH is not at all close to his siblings. Every family / sibling is different

allhellcantstopusnow · 14/11/2023 15:42

I've got a sister. We're friends and go off and do things together, look after each others children etc.

She's great 😊

EvilElsa · 14/11/2023 15:06

My sister (two years age difference) is my best friend. Contact daily (messaging) and often meet up for days out. We were pretty close growing up with the odd teenage scraps!
DH is non contact with his younger sister (4 years ago difference). No big falling out or anything, just have absolutely nothing in common and nothing to say to each other. Growing up they were not particularly close either. No hatred, just indifference.

Stephisaur · 14/11/2023 15:03

Brother & Sister are both older than me by ~10 years.

None of us are super close, but we love each other. My Sister & I share a dark sense of humour, so mostly just send each other bad taste memes. I don't have that much in common with my brother, but he delights in winding me up when we see each other. Still love him though, and if I needed him I know he'd be here in a pinch.

We all only see each other at family events though, we don't tend to hang out otherwise.

SkaneTos · 14/11/2023 14:43

I'm a woman, and my brother is one of my best friends. He is my only sibling, and he is two years older than me.
We have the same sense of humor, and similar opinions. We text each other every day, and we talk on the phone at least twice a week. We don't live in the same part of the country anymore, but we travel to see each other around three times a year.

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 14/11/2023 14:20

I’m one of three and it’s definitely a case of three being a crowd, despite a tiny age gap between me and one sibling we’ve never had much in common.
We see each other 2/3 times a year and text every month or so and get on, happily go for a few drinks and have a laugh but we aren’t close.

My two siblings despite an over a decades age gap are really close to each other and see each other several times a week, go out and do things together etc.

As children none of us got on at all…

SFG112112 · 14/11/2023 14:08

Used to be close to my younger DB until his Covid conspiracy theories/anti vaxxer views caused problems and I found out he is a cheating, selfish husband and lies to the rest of the family about me and DH. He also got sacked from his job because of his attitude.

Rarely see or hear from him now. Makes me sad. Still on good terms with his wife (SIL) and kids though.

mrsplum2015 · 14/11/2023 14:01

It's so varied.

I don't have a relationship with my sibling but it's really just about the fallout from our upbringing.

While I feel sad sometimes I count myself really lucky to have an extremely wide group of very close friends who have always been there for me and enjoy time with my children and I. They are our chosen family rather than assumed.

My children are very close to each other ( aged between 10 and 20 ) but the way they are spaced in terms of sex and age means they don't have any direct rivalry with each other. Pius my exDh and I are very aligned in terms of family values, encouraging family relationships etc.

Mothership4two · 14/11/2023 13:48

As another only and a lifelong sibling watcher I would say there is definitely no normal sibling relationship. Fortunately I have a cousin who I'm close to and is like my sister. On DH's side the siblings are close and all get on and see each other regularly. My DM's large family are still close (they are in 70s/80s now) except for a brother who has mysteriously pretty much cut everyone off. DF's side are not close at all and his younger brother was quite toxic towards him. My two DS are reasonably close but don't socialise together except to watch sports.

Swipe left for the next trending thread