Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to pay for her lunch? DD is 5

471 replies

prideinmystrides · 13/11/2023 20:25

Okay so DD is in Reception class

A classmate's mum had a cake taken in for her (I have done the same and they all seem to really enjoy it! It's a small village school with only 14 kids)

My DD apparently took an extra slice. As reported to this girls mum by her own daughter, the birthday girl

DD was invited over for birthday tea, cake and play. They were going to a trampoline park on Saturday to celebrate properly

The girls mum has messaged to say

'Hi, it was lovely having L round. She's very sweet. Would you please transfer me £20? We got pizzas in but she said she doesn't eat the ones we had so we got her the one she wanted'

AIBU not to transfer her? I have already spoken to DD and asked if she said she wouldn't eat the pizzas the woman had got? She said she wouldn't, because she put sweetcorn on one, and anchovies on the other one?

I haven't asked the woman if this information is true or not, but DD was very matter of fact and just said she couldn't eat it.

I have already explained to her that she was better off just picking those toppings off as it is quite rude fo ask for a separate pizza. She got a little bit embarrassed, seemed to take this on board and just said 'Okay mummy'

AIBU though not to transfer this? I replied that I hadn't realised I needed to send her with cash, and was about to type something else when she said 'you didn't, but I just didn't expect to buy another pizza'

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 15/11/2023 16:34

It does seem odd that they didn't just order her a kids Margherita. £20 for a pizza for a 5 year old! And then asking you to pay! If I'm hosting a child I'll make sure to give them something they like (like most I ask parents what they like to eat) and any decision I made about providing them food I would obviously pay for. Just seems like she wants to get you to pay for half the pizza order!

pomers · 15/11/2023 17:37

Ask for the receipt

Ourlittletalks · 15/11/2023 17:53

YANBU. Who puts anchovies on pizza for a bunch of kids? If it were my child, she’d have picked the toppings off and ate it plain with just cheese, or even just the base with the tomato sauce. I think a good idea for kids parties is to have neutral foods though: chicken nuggets, cheese pizza, cocktail sausages, ham and cheese sandwiches. My daughter recently had a birthday party and two children didn’t like any of the options we had prepared so I made them both sandwiches with crisps and they were happy with those.

however, given that your DD is only 5, I would pay it just to keep the peace and perhaps refrain from allowing her to attend birthday parties for that child in the future.

Ourlittletalks · 15/11/2023 18:03

Goldbar · 15/11/2023 11:44

It also sets kids up for a lifetime of disordered eating.

I had impeccable manners as a child. I once drunk half a glass of undiluted squash because our hosts didn't realise it should be diluted, as I was too polite to point out their mistake. I'm adept at shovelling in food I don't particularly like the taste of well after the point at which I'm full because I was brought up to think that it was rude to decline or leave food. Even if I'm not hungry, don't particularly want it and am trying to lose weight, I'll still accept (and finish) anything I'm offered in someone else's house. Because that is what I was taught was the standard for good manners. Unsurprisingly, I've had trouble regulating my weight at times in my life.

I would never force or expect any child, my DC or others, to eat anything in my house. Food is put out, they take what they want, if they don't like it I'll try to provide a (healthy) alternative and that's that. I would never take offence at a child not eating, nor would I send my DC to play at a house where offence would be taken.

There’s a fine line between telling a child to pick off the toppings they dislike from the pizza and being unable to refuse to finish anything given to them at another persons house. I’m not saying your struggles aren’t valid, but OP isn’t inadvertently causing disordered eating for her child by insisting she be polite and not ask for a separate meal.

Deathinvegas · 15/11/2023 18:13

I vote this time pay the money to keep the peace.
But maybe in the future ask her to call or text you and let you know before she commits to spending £20 on a kid’s pizza on your behalf.
I assume you live in an affluent area where everyone just assumes everyone else has a spare £20 for kid’s pizza?

Deathinvegas · 15/11/2023 18:22

I also agree the toppings do not sound like good choices for 5 year olds but since you’ve only had that story second hand by a 5 year old i personally wouldn’t stake my life on it.
I don’t think it would be too rude to ask the other mum what the problem with first pizza was.
Something a long the lines of “Sorry for the inconvenience, i’ll get that money transferred to you. What was the problem with the first pizza? Could you let me know if it happens again before ordering anything extra?”

Lindar79 · 15/11/2023 19:20

I can’t actually believe someone messaged asking for the money 🤦‍♀️ surely if you’re ordering pizza you would ask what everyone liked / didn’t like and get a general consensus and then order. A plain cheese pizza would’ve done most. I would text back and say that you’re not paying!

HelenHen · 15/11/2023 19:29

This is ridiculous. My daughter was at a party at the weekend. The only food they offered was pizza, she doesn't eat pizza. I fed her afterwards. No big deal.

I've had kids here before who won't eat anything and I've ended up making weird random stuff cos it's what they wanted. Never in a billion years could I imagine asking for money 😂

My initial reaction would have been to pay her for an easy life. But the more I think of it, people are right to say just ignore it, but own your reaction. Don't be apologetic.

If you do decide to pay, say 'sure, just send me the receipt and I'll reimburse you'

Pogue4Life · 15/11/2023 19:54

I’m sorry but I wouldn’t care how long I’d have to see this mum, even if the kids are close. There is no way in earth I would pay £20 for my 5 year old just because they ordered an extra pizza.
I’d apologise if my daughter sounded bossy, and making them feel they had to order another pizza but offer a token amount. If your child is anything like mine. She would have eaten maybe two slices, 3 at a push. Her husband and other child will probably have eaten the rest.

Goldbar · 15/11/2023 20:36

Ourlittletalks · 15/11/2023 18:03

There’s a fine line between telling a child to pick off the toppings they dislike from the pizza and being unable to refuse to finish anything given to them at another persons house. I’m not saying your struggles aren’t valid, but OP isn’t inadvertently causing disordered eating for her child by insisting she be polite and not ask for a separate meal.

But why shouldn't she say what she likes if she is specifically asked?

Presumably they must have asked her at the time of ordering in order to know that she didn't like the sweetcorn and anchovies pizza.

It's a bit much to expect a 5yo to tie themselves in social knots by pretending to like a pizza they don't actually like and won't eat in order to keep the peace and be polite. Kids that age just don't say "order whatever you like. I'm easy with anything". That's an adult thing to do.

I know we all want our kids to be polite and considerate guests, but honestly some people seem to have completely unrealistic ideas about how well 5yos are able to navigate awkward social situations without a parent there to guide them.

Pandajane · 15/11/2023 21:28

YANBU! If you invite a child over and are feeding them, you check with the parents to make sure you have something they will enjoy eating! What kind of host is this woman? Where the did she order this pizza from - some kind of Michelin starred restaurant? £20 for a small pizza? WTAF? Bl**dy cheek!

Boiledfrogs1989 · 15/11/2023 21:32

She’s mad! You expect these things with kids parties!
I’ve taken my daughter and 2 of her friends to mini golf and Pizza Hut for her birthday a few years ago now. The kids all liked different pizzas so they all got small personal size and then they all liked different sides too. Then they all wanted pudding of course! How much food got eaten? About ten bloody bites between them! They were far more interested in going to the toilet every 5 minutes to do silly faces in the mirror.
Its a one off so you suck it up and just appreciate the kids had a good time!
She really shouldn’t be pushing the costs onto you HOWEVER I would pay it cause i just hate awkwardness but I would honestly resent it so bad 😂😂

LuckySantangelo35 · 15/11/2023 21:40

MrsNK28 · 13/11/2023 22:54

personally i paid it. Its my kid who wants to eat.

@MrsNK28

do you not think it’s excessive though?

LuckySantangelo35 · 15/11/2023 21:41

Pandajane · 15/11/2023 21:28

YANBU! If you invite a child over and are feeding them, you check with the parents to make sure you have something they will enjoy eating! What kind of host is this woman? Where the did she order this pizza from - some kind of Michelin starred restaurant? £20 for a small pizza? WTAF? Bl**dy cheek!

@Pandajane

you can swear you know

JMSA · 15/11/2023 21:43

What relevance does the birthday cake comment have to the rest of the story? Confused

MrsNK28 · 15/11/2023 21:48

It is excessive. But i’m not gonna mentioned it. Because it will affect both children relationship. I just know now that she is a cunning lady and next time i’ll be careful.

MuggleMe · 15/11/2023 22:25

You check with a 5yo guest that they'll eat the pizza before you order one. Basic surely. Even so, I'd pay to keep the peace.

K4tM · 15/11/2023 22:34

Instead of ordering extra pizza, she could have delivered child home saying,‘I’m sorry she didn’t eat much. I did my best, but she might need something else to eat.’ A £20 bill is ridiculous. And it’s insulting.

maddening · 15/11/2023 22:39

I would reply that I don't understand how a 5 year old has eaten £20 worth of pizza

BeenThereDoneThatGotTheTshirt89 · 15/11/2023 22:40

I wouldn't be paying anything.

Why were you or even your child not asked what type of pizza she liked before the pizzas were ordered. That is a rookie mistake and all on the other parent.

Also £20 for a pizza? Takeaway pizza around here, you can get individual or mediums sizes for much cheaper.

7 P's come to mind here - proper planning and preparation prevents piss poor performance🤷🏼‍♀️

She'll learn for next time.

Pandajane · 15/11/2023 23:04

@LuckySantangelo35 this is what too much time on Farcebook does to you - I've been in FB jail several times for swearing and I automatically 'clean it up' just in case lol!

Mindyaownbeeswax · 16/11/2023 07:52

So I imagine the cake was cut into a specific number of pieces for everyone so someone will likely have gone without. Then she's not wanted that pizza. The other mum is just fecked off.
If I were you I'd pay and be openly mortified about it all to keep the peace. Small school mentality is not very forgiving!! She's only 5 but needs to be taught these social dos and don'ts to avoid all this asap!!!

Ameteurmum · 16/11/2023 13:23

If they were ordering pizzas on the day why didn’t they just ask the kids what they wanted? I wouldn’t expect 5 year olds to eat anchovies. Surely cheese and tomato would be the safest bet. I think the party hosts are being unreasonable because they haven’t anticipated the needs of their guests and it’s cheeky as fuck to ask you for £20 if it wasn’t discussed ahead of time.However given it’s at a small school and I couldn’t bear the awkwardness of refusing I’d pay the £20

Lucyh999 · 16/11/2023 14:08

Ok this is a weird one indeed. I think it is a bit unreasonable of the host to ask for money from you. If I were the person, I’d have made do and took some pizza, picked the bits off and ad-libbed or something to make it work for your daughter. Or made a sandwich or something.

but she has asked for it and therefore I think you’d be unreasonable to refuse.

Lucyh999 · 16/11/2023 14:22

HelenHen · 15/11/2023 19:29

This is ridiculous. My daughter was at a party at the weekend. The only food they offered was pizza, she doesn't eat pizza. I fed her afterwards. No big deal.

I've had kids here before who won't eat anything and I've ended up making weird random stuff cos it's what they wanted. Never in a billion years could I imagine asking for money 😂

My initial reaction would have been to pay her for an easy life. But the more I think of it, people are right to say just ignore it, but own your reaction. Don't be apologetic.

If you do decide to pay, say 'sure, just send me the receipt and I'll reimburse you'

Actually that’s a really good idea. Just reply and say ‘sorry she was fussy, I’m sure she would have eaten it if you’d picked off the anchovies (wtf child likes anchovies anyway?!) and say just ping me the receipt and I’ll send you the cash’

great idea and watch it disappear