Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to pay for her lunch? DD is 5

471 replies

prideinmystrides · 13/11/2023 20:25

Okay so DD is in Reception class

A classmate's mum had a cake taken in for her (I have done the same and they all seem to really enjoy it! It's a small village school with only 14 kids)

My DD apparently took an extra slice. As reported to this girls mum by her own daughter, the birthday girl

DD was invited over for birthday tea, cake and play. They were going to a trampoline park on Saturday to celebrate properly

The girls mum has messaged to say

'Hi, it was lovely having L round. She's very sweet. Would you please transfer me £20? We got pizzas in but she said she doesn't eat the ones we had so we got her the one she wanted'

AIBU not to transfer her? I have already spoken to DD and asked if she said she wouldn't eat the pizzas the woman had got? She said she wouldn't, because she put sweetcorn on one, and anchovies on the other one?

I haven't asked the woman if this information is true or not, but DD was very matter of fact and just said she couldn't eat it.

I have already explained to her that she was better off just picking those toppings off as it is quite rude fo ask for a separate pizza. She got a little bit embarrassed, seemed to take this on board and just said 'Okay mummy'

AIBU though not to transfer this? I replied that I hadn't realised I needed to send her with cash, and was about to type something else when she said 'you didn't, but I just didn't expect to buy another pizza'

OP posts:
SkySecret · 14/11/2023 11:18

Something just doesn’t sit right about this.

so she went to her mates house and they only ordered two pizzas to feed a family of 4 plus a guest kid? And didn’t ask what the singular guest likes on her pizza before ordering them? And one happens to be anchovies (weird choice of topping) and OP also just happens to have anchovies on pizzas too?

I dunno what it is but it just all sounds odd 🤣

ClareBlue · 14/11/2023 11:20

If you read TFT you see that the only non family member at the house was the OP DD. They just ordered their standard family choices without asking their one guest if she might like it or what her preference would be.
Most of us would not be OK with that at any age, but to exclude a 5 year old from the choice and then say she demanded a different Pizza is unfair.

ClareBlue · 14/11/2023 11:25

Maybe this is a plan to get all their Pizzas bought. They go through the whole class inviting each pupil on their own each Friday, order weird Pizzas and then charge the parents for the additional normal one that their guest requested. The charge to the parent is at a level that pays for all of the Pizzas, free Pizzas every Friday 😂

Olive19741205 · 14/11/2023 11:34

Caterpillarsleftfoot · 14/11/2023 06:53

On a side note I find it bizarre that people think sweetcorn is an unusual choice for a 5 year old. Surely that's a very run of the mill thing to eat?

Also whilst I think £20 is extortion and I wouldn't have asked for the money. I would be frustrated by a child refusing to eat anything offered. Especially when picking off the sweetcorn and eating the pizza is an easy alternative. This is the problem with children eating different meals to adults at home and not being expected to eat whatever is on offer.

In our house the children have always from 6 months old eaten with us, exactly the same foods and not been given an alternative. It wouldn't even cross their minds that something else would be offered at someone's house.

Edited

Well aren't you just brilliant. Well done. You should write a book for all us plebs to follow your lead.

MrsB74 · 14/11/2023 15:08

NImumconfused · 13/11/2023 20:30

Why would anyone put anchovies on a pizza they're offering to children they don't know - surely you'd include something safe like a margarita?

This. Everyone surely knows to always get at least one margarita when children are involved. £20 is also ridiculous and it’s cheeky to ask for money from guests if they didn’t previously check likes especially at that age. That must have been an enormous pizza!

I presume you are thinking she’s still annoyed about the cake? Also ridiculous.

I would probably (begrudgingly) pay up and explain to DD about manners (which you have). She’s only 5 though, hardly a huge crime. I think I would give this mum a wide berth too.

Yenifertree · 14/11/2023 15:12

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable at all! Especially if it was just your daughter and the birthday girl. I always check what kids like to eat when they are coming for tea, I couldn’t bear to see anyone go hungry, and cater accordingly.

Having said that, I’d probably pay just to keep the peace, but keep my fingers crossed the friendship fizzled. I wouldn’t dream of asking someone to pay when I’d invited their child!

Padz · 14/11/2023 15:21

I’d pay the money but I’d be having a word to clarify what happened.
Did your DD ask for another pizza or was she offered it? Needs to be said out loud as it sounds like your DD wouldn’t have asked.

Dinomum79 · 14/11/2023 15:26

I think she is trying to make a point - I think there is a deeper issue with parenting styles clashing. Maybe she thinks your daughter is demanding?
I would pay it too but I think she is really cheeky. She doesn’t seem to subscribe to the small world theory!

Luxell934 · 14/11/2023 15:31

Fair play your 4 year old knowing what an anchovy is.

Northernladdette · 14/11/2023 15:42

She’s a CF. I’d refuse and hope other parents thought she was a CF too 😩

Fmlgirl · 14/11/2023 16:07

i wouldn’t eat pizza with corn and anchovies and I’m 39. I would never ask people for money for a party I’m hosting. Maybe they are really hard up but it seems totally silly to not choose simple cheese pizzas or whatever for kids that age.

Stoptheworld1000 · 14/11/2023 16:27

Imagine if she's asked all the parents for £20, she will be quids In. I would think that most 5 years olds would refuse a pizza with anchovies on.

BowlOfNoodles · 14/11/2023 16:41

I'd pay but there wouidnt be anymore play dates

SecondUsername4me · 14/11/2023 16:41

Stoptheworld1000 · 14/11/2023 16:27

Imagine if she's asked all the parents for £20, she will be quids In. I would think that most 5 years olds would refuse a pizza with anchovies on.

There is no all the parents - OPs child was the only one invited.

Whiteday · 14/11/2023 16:53

Fmlgirl · 14/11/2023 16:07

i wouldn’t eat pizza with corn and anchovies and I’m 39. I would never ask people for money for a party I’m hosting. Maybe they are really hard up but it seems totally silly to not choose simple cheese pizzas or whatever for kids that age.

As it happens I love both, particularly anchovies! But can you imagine the rudeness of not asking a guest what they wanted to have on their pizza?

It's the sanctimonious, but got what they were given and put up with it from six months old, that I find very odd!!

Busephalus · 14/11/2023 17:13

I've ordered many pizzas for various kids over the years, margaritas only, never asked for money. I might bung her something to keep the peace,but not £20, surely your dd did not eat a whole pizza on her own

Jcf1977 · 14/11/2023 17:13

Kids party you would order the plainest pizza plus maybe the birthday girls favourite. Loads of smaller children have problems with toppings and surprises in food. So that their first cf move.
secondly, one small margarita pizza is maybe £8/9. second cf move
yes your kid could have been more accommodating but would probably have come home hungry. Party giver is really responsible for making sure everyone has a good time, hence it’s more usual to order a load of plain food which everyone can eat even if it’s not their favourite
not sure what the cake thing is about but maybe your kid got the mums backup with this move and she took against her.
send the money, know she is a cf and move on.

Fmlgirl · 14/11/2023 17:22

@Whiteday you are right and that mum probably really, really wanted to make a point and diss OP’s kid in the process - it’s quite messed up.
I would probably transfer them the money and never speak to the mum ever again.

jc12689 · 14/11/2023 17:24

Who puts anchovies on pizzas for a children's party?

Casperroonie · 14/11/2023 17:31

prideinmystrides · 13/11/2023 20:25

Okay so DD is in Reception class

A classmate's mum had a cake taken in for her (I have done the same and they all seem to really enjoy it! It's a small village school with only 14 kids)

My DD apparently took an extra slice. As reported to this girls mum by her own daughter, the birthday girl

DD was invited over for birthday tea, cake and play. They were going to a trampoline park on Saturday to celebrate properly

The girls mum has messaged to say

'Hi, it was lovely having L round. She's very sweet. Would you please transfer me £20? We got pizzas in but she said she doesn't eat the ones we had so we got her the one she wanted'

AIBU not to transfer her? I have already spoken to DD and asked if she said she wouldn't eat the pizzas the woman had got? She said she wouldn't, because she put sweetcorn on one, and anchovies on the other one?

I haven't asked the woman if this information is true or not, but DD was very matter of fact and just said she couldn't eat it.

I have already explained to her that she was better off just picking those toppings off as it is quite rude fo ask for a separate pizza. She got a little bit embarrassed, seemed to take this on board and just said 'Okay mummy'

AIBU though not to transfer this? I replied that I hadn't realised I needed to send her with cash, and was about to type something else when she said 'you didn't, but I just didn't expect to buy another pizza'

The woman's a knob. A 5 yr old will say all sorts but that's why you only ever get boring kids' food like plain margarita or golden food for their parties. You expect them to be awkward.

Give her a tenner to shut her up and tell her you'll pay rest later. Then pay her the rest in front of as many parents as possible, if you remember... Cheeky f parent how dare she.

Casperroonie · 14/11/2023 17:33

SkySecret · 14/11/2023 11:18

Something just doesn’t sit right about this.

so she went to her mates house and they only ordered two pizzas to feed a family of 4 plus a guest kid? And didn’t ask what the singular guest likes on her pizza before ordering them? And one happens to be anchovies (weird choice of topping) and OP also just happens to have anchovies on pizzas too?

I dunno what it is but it just all sounds odd 🤣

Omg I didn't realise she was the only non fam member!!! I definitely wouldn't pay, she's blatantly asking for someone else to pay for her family dinner!!!!!

intotheblueagain · 14/11/2023 17:37

The mother is a CF and her daughter is a grass 😂
Give her the twenty quid then avoid them like the plague - otherwise I foresee years of oddness ahead with you always being the one who is disadvantaged!

Mama2910 · 14/11/2023 17:42

YANBU
For a party of five years olds the mum should have made sure she asked the parents of kids attending what she should give them for lunch (thinking allergies to dairy for one!) or at very least made she there was a plain cheese pizza. Anchovies in particular are an acquired taste and I know I wouldn’t want a pizza with that on it. And they would leave a taste on the pizza even if picked off. At 5 would your daughter think to pick the sweetcorn off? Or did the mum offer to pick it off for her? And also £20 for a whole new pizza for one girl is OTT. Mum is being cheeky cow. Her choice to buy a new pizza. Even could have made her a sandwich or something didn’t have to buy a full new £20 pizza 🤔

Autumnleaves89 · 14/11/2023 17:43

Absolutely cringing for this mum. She is the unreasonable-as if you’d ask for 29 quid!! Your daughter is five, I doubt she has demanded an entire pizza to herself.

GFBurger · 14/11/2023 17:45

Aha! A key point to the mystery! And a 5 year old’s brain.

Playdate Mum suggests list of items from the menu to 5yr old.
5 yr old: ‘I like anchovies and corn!’ With no realisation of what the actual intention of question was!!

Anchovy and Sweetcorn pizza turns up… 5 yr old is upset… emergency pizza purchase ensues.

The rest of the play date family is just staring at an anchovy and sweetcorn pizza thinking ‘gross’!!

I’d pay up the £20 and ask the play date mum in person what happened and laugh about it. If they are actually an anchovy on pizza loving family it sounds like you might have found a firm friend!!

I once upset my friends young daughter when she thought I was withholding food from her! She kept on asking for ‘numbers’ for breakfast. I had no idea what she was asking for. Later I figured out she had seen a tin of Heinz number pasta in our cupboard and just thought I was being rude for not letting her have it! It’s funny now!