Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to pay for her lunch? DD is 5

471 replies

prideinmystrides · 13/11/2023 20:25

Okay so DD is in Reception class

A classmate's mum had a cake taken in for her (I have done the same and they all seem to really enjoy it! It's a small village school with only 14 kids)

My DD apparently took an extra slice. As reported to this girls mum by her own daughter, the birthday girl

DD was invited over for birthday tea, cake and play. They were going to a trampoline park on Saturday to celebrate properly

The girls mum has messaged to say

'Hi, it was lovely having L round. She's very sweet. Would you please transfer me £20? We got pizzas in but she said she doesn't eat the ones we had so we got her the one she wanted'

AIBU not to transfer her? I have already spoken to DD and asked if she said she wouldn't eat the pizzas the woman had got? She said she wouldn't, because she put sweetcorn on one, and anchovies on the other one?

I haven't asked the woman if this information is true or not, but DD was very matter of fact and just said she couldn't eat it.

I have already explained to her that she was better off just picking those toppings off as it is quite rude fo ask for a separate pizza. She got a little bit embarrassed, seemed to take this on board and just said 'Okay mummy'

AIBU though not to transfer this? I replied that I hadn't realised I needed to send her with cash, and was about to type something else when she said 'you didn't, but I just didn't expect to buy another pizza'

OP posts:
RosiePeel · 14/11/2023 00:32

Absolutely no way would I be paying. This is complete and utter insanity.

Meandermoanda · 14/11/2023 00:38

Yanbu

I mean my kids are beyond the norm and eat all kinds of toppings but when we host parties and friends I serve plain pizza.

It's just logical!

She's unreasonable to not serve food five year olds will like

LizzBurg · 14/11/2023 05:20

Invite her child over for McDonald’s and then tell the mum that she didn’t like the pickle so you ordered Five Guys and now she owes you £30 for the privilege.

Whiteday · 14/11/2023 05:58

Pareny · 14/11/2023 00:15

Your kid should eat what is provided imo.

Don't be so ridiculous! Everyone has stuff they don't like! Anchovies are not a good a lot of people like.

I presume you don't host people?

FlickFlackTrap · 14/11/2023 06:13

GigiAnnna · 13/11/2023 21:32

Very rude and strange of her to ask you to pay. Who the hell does that? If they just wanted their anchovy pizzas they could have just not invited your daughter as they must have known most 5 year old aren't going to eat that. I would probably pay but then have nothing to do with her out of school and decline future invitations for your daughter.

This.
But I’d probably offer half of the £20 very begrudgingly. You don’t invite a guest and then not pay for their meal. Either everyone in the group chooses their own favourite pizza or no one does. Who pays £20 for a pizza for a 5 year old?

TolkiensFallow · 14/11/2023 06:38

This is such weird behaviour from the host. I always check with kids parents what they eat when I invite them as kids that age are often very particular about what they eat. Even parents of non fussy eaters know this!

I would get socially awkward and pay her then avoid her like the plague. I don’t think your daughter was unreasonable or really rude to say she didn’t like anchovies, she was probably asked and answered honestly.

if I was as confident as some posters on here, I would ask dd how many slices she had and then text the host snd say “ok great, I’ve not cooked and dd says she only had 4 slices so I’ll pop round with the £20 and collect the rest of my pizza”

£20 is nuts isn’t it? A kids pub meal is usually £6.99 and that’s a meal, not essentially cheese on toast!

Muchof · 14/11/2023 06:38

prideinmystrides · 13/11/2023 20:28

Can I ask why? You can go halves on a pizza so if a 5 year old was being that difficult as I'm getting the feeling my daughter must have been, surely you'd just do that?

I wouldn't pay out for a completely separate pizza in the first place. And certainly wouldn't be charging the parent?

I suspect your daughter was being difficult and the other parent had to buy something to keep her quiet. I really don’t believe the pizzas were smothered in anchovies or sweetcorn either, that makes no sense. Perhaps there was a delivery charge on the pizza.

Whiteday · 14/11/2023 06:46

So who do you think is lying then?

Caterpillarsleftfoot · 14/11/2023 06:53

On a side note I find it bizarre that people think sweetcorn is an unusual choice for a 5 year old. Surely that's a very run of the mill thing to eat?

Also whilst I think £20 is extortion and I wouldn't have asked for the money. I would be frustrated by a child refusing to eat anything offered. Especially when picking off the sweetcorn and eating the pizza is an easy alternative. This is the problem with children eating different meals to adults at home and not being expected to eat whatever is on offer.

In our house the children have always from 6 months old eaten with us, exactly the same foods and not been given an alternative. It wouldn't even cross their minds that something else would be offered at someone's house.

SD1978 · 14/11/2023 07:10

As I've already said- I would probably pay for it- but I'd also be pretty annoyed that since I'd paid for the whole thing, I'd expect the leftovers sent home with her!

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 14/11/2023 07:19

Not the point, I know, but more than once dd has provided pizzas for their young dcs’ birthday parties (masses of kids) and they only ever get just cheese and tomato margaritas, because so many kids have ‘issues’ with ‘green bits’ or anything else on them.

Whiteday · 14/11/2023 07:34

Caterpillarsleftfoot · 14/11/2023 06:53

On a side note I find it bizarre that people think sweetcorn is an unusual choice for a 5 year old. Surely that's a very run of the mill thing to eat?

Also whilst I think £20 is extortion and I wouldn't have asked for the money. I would be frustrated by a child refusing to eat anything offered. Especially when picking off the sweetcorn and eating the pizza is an easy alternative. This is the problem with children eating different meals to adults at home and not being expected to eat whatever is on offer.

In our house the children have always from 6 months old eaten with us, exactly the same foods and not been given an alternative. It wouldn't even cross their minds that something else would be offered at someone's house.

Edited

Some people like sweetcorn some don't, sone people let their children have a choice in what food they like and don't send trek to bed hungry because they'll get no alternative!

We raise our children differently!

I've yet to meet and adult or child that eats absolutely everything served?

Do you not have any food you dislike? !

fruitbrewhaha · 14/11/2023 07:35

Pay up and there will be more demands of some bullshit in the future.

YourNameGoesHere · 14/11/2023 07:42

fruitbrewhaha · 14/11/2023 07:35

Pay up and there will be more demands of some bullshit in the future.

I've said this more than once throughout the thread, which is why I'm surprised this morning so many people are still saying the OP should pay.

If she pays for this for a quiet life this won't be the last cheeky request as she will have the OP down as a doormat who will pay up to avoid awkwardness. Cheeky fuckers like this are rarely cheeky only once.

Whatafustercluck · 14/11/2023 07:53

This whole situation is very strange. Anchovies on a child's pizza that costs £20?!

My dd turns 7 soon. When the parents replied to the invitation I asked if their child likes pizza and gave them two choices - pepperoni or cheese and tomato. The pizzas will cost a quid or two each. Admittedly, shop bought and cooked at home but still!

Are the parents those try-hards, whose little Arabella eats avocado for breakfast, anchovies and artichoke on pizza, and so they're showing off about how amazingly well their little darling eats?

No, I wouldn't be paying £20. I'd probably offer to pay half.

sollenwir · 14/11/2023 07:58

I'd be inclined to reply with something like....'thanks for making sure DD didn't go hungry - I didn't realise she'd need money with her, although I'm not sure what she ate that cost £20 for just her?'.

Olika · 14/11/2023 07:59

£20 for a pizza for a 5 year old is too much. They were hosting so they shouldn't be asking for money.

JSMill · 14/11/2023 08:02

What's the cake story got to do with it? Tbh if you are in England, I find it very hard to believe a school allowed someone to bring in a birthday cake, between allergy concerns and healthy eating policies.

Whatafustercluck · 14/11/2023 08:11

Caterpillarsleftfoot · 14/11/2023 06:53

On a side note I find it bizarre that people think sweetcorn is an unusual choice for a 5 year old. Surely that's a very run of the mill thing to eat?

Also whilst I think £20 is extortion and I wouldn't have asked for the money. I would be frustrated by a child refusing to eat anything offered. Especially when picking off the sweetcorn and eating the pizza is an easy alternative. This is the problem with children eating different meals to adults at home and not being expected to eat whatever is on offer.

In our house the children have always from 6 months old eaten with us, exactly the same foods and not been given an alternative. It wouldn't even cross their minds that something else would be offered at someone's house.

Edited

Two children here, raised exactly the same. Eldest tries most things, eats all vegetables and is very adventurous. Youngest devoured corn on the cob at a year old, but at 7 eats only two types of vegetable. Vegetables also have to be in a separate bowl and not touching other food. She loves olives but will only eat them separately - not in or on things. And it wouldn't have occurred to her to pick off any toppings she didn't like at the age of 5 in strange surroundings. She'd actually probably make up an excuse to avoid eating it altogether. Yes, my child is ND, but my point is that children can be raised in the same way and have completely different preferences/ personalities.

Katbum · 14/11/2023 08:19

Yes and some people are super sensitive about food. My brother (now 34) has never been able to stomach ‘wet food’ like curries or even tomato sauce or mayonnaise: if my mother tried to get him to eat something like that he would throw up. My nephew gags at all vegetables. It is obviously not easy to cater to people like this, but when you choose to host someone in your home, you are supposed to do that with a modicum of generosity, and if that person is a child, be aware that many children have food sensitivities that you are offering to cater for.

Liv999 · 14/11/2023 08:24

She's a cf, you don't invite kids to a birthday party and then ask the parents for 20 quid to feed a child! Who gives anchovies and sweetcorn on pizzas to kids anyway? She needs to suck it up and put it down to experience, no way would I be paying

fruitbrewhaha · 14/11/2023 09:07

Don’t pay.

”No, I didn’t authorise you to make this purchase on my behalf. You could have given her a sandwich or asked me to collect her if she was being rude or awkward. Pizza costs £3 in the supermarket or less than £20 from local delivery Takeaways. When you invite someone over for tea, you don’t present them with an invoice.”

And I’d tell everyone at the school/village. She is getting you to subsidise her takeaway.

KarmenPQZ · 14/11/2023 09:35

How many slices of a £20 pizza can a 5 year old eat. If you pay, make sure you ask for the leftovers!!!

ClareBlue · 14/11/2023 11:04

So it was the family plus the daughter of the OP. They ordered pizzas that they obviously like, but are a bit of an acquired taste. Their invited guest didn't like the ordered pizas, perfectly understandable and asked (demanded!) a different one. They got it and are now charging OP for it.
Why didn't they ask what their guest would like on their pizza before ordering. Why assume their 5 year old guest would like those Pizzas. This is completely down to the host. You don't order Pizzas to share with an invited guest without asking what they like.
Especially those Pizzas. You don't then charge the guest for food that you provided.
It's not a 5 year old fault that a host just ordered what they like without checking if she would eat it.
I wouldn't eat either of those and I would be pussed off if I was invited to someone's house and they ordered pizzas without asking me what I actually like.
But as others have said, sometimes it's better to just move on for the bigger picture. So unless it really is going to cause hardship, I would pay the ridiculous 20.

ClareBlue · 14/11/2023 11:13

This wasn't a party. The 5 year old was invited to the House. They ordered Pizzas that they like without asking what the 5 year old might like. The choice that they like is not standard. Who actually orders Pizza for a group without asking what people like. The preference of the 5 year old were completely ignored and when they asked for something they actually liked the hosts did a charge back to the parents.
Now everyone is making out the daughter is some kind of demanding fussy Princess.
It's the hosts who lack awareness here. They even have the nerve to double down by demanding payment for their mistake.