Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Letter of Concern at work

275 replies

GettinReal2023 · 13/11/2023 17:29

My office has a half empty car park next to the office. We have been told our team cannot use it as staff from another nearby office don't have parking so no one can have parking (except the execs). Therefore, everyone struggles with parking. There is free staff parking 0.6 miles down the road though. Against company rules I have parked in the half empty car park. I didn't consider it a big deal as I wasn't taking anyone's space and when I couldn't find parking by the office I would use it.

Today, my Director spoke to me to say she had seen me using the car park and she is very angry. She found it disrespectful that I didn't follow a simple instruction and it is inappropriate behaviour. Therefore she will be issuing me with a letter of concern. I apologised and said I didn't realise it would upset anyone and that was not my intention. I accept I parked there when I shouldn't have and that's on me. She went on to say she felt it was personal against her instruction not to use it, and that I was giving her 'two fingers' and she didn't sleep the night she saw me it was so upsetting.

I accept I did wrong, but I am surprised she has taken this personally and feels that my exemplary three years service with no work issues counts for nothing and it's straight to a letter of concern. Am I being unreasonable to think this isn't a proportionate response? Is this a normal consequences?

OP posts:
Topsy44 · 13/11/2023 20:21

Imo that’s a totally disproportionate response. Totally bonkers.

2chocolateoranges · 13/11/2023 20:23

Crazy reason not to park in the car park!

the car park at my work doesn’t have enough spaces it’s a first come first served basis if you don’t get a space in it then you park in the surrounding streets. Easy as!

BorisIsACuntWaffle · 13/11/2023 20:24

Why can't you use the spaces. Union needs to be involved

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 13/11/2023 20:24

I agree it sounds OTT even though you deliberately disregarded your company's policy of not using the other carpark. For all you know the other company may have threatened legal action for trespass which resulted in your company issuing the policy about not parking there.

Oh I thought that the OP meant that another office nearby belonging to her company had no parking (unlike her own which obviously does) and so the company had decided (for batshit fairness) that neither office could have convenient parking.

SerafinasGoose · 13/11/2023 20:25

JaneAustensHeroine · 13/11/2023 20:19

Yes, all the more reason to be ultra reasonable and professional in response! The more unreasonable others get, the more professional and rational I become. Makes the other person question themselves. Works a treat!

I'd ensure you do it in writing, and keep it down to as few words as possible whilst still being cordial.

If you receive further directives from her verbally, confirm everything via email. Unless she contradicts you, you then have a solid record of what took place.

GuinnessBird · 13/11/2023 20:29

Christ she sounds unbearable.

Bouffe · 13/11/2023 20:31

fluffi · 13/11/2023 20:07

You’ve deliberately disobeyed a direct instruction not to do something because you think you know better / don’t like the rule / think it doesn’t apply to you.

If you can’t follow simple instructions whether you agree with them or not then how can you be trusted with anything else?

It does look bad to the other directors that she can’t get her staff to follow the basics so now she is cracking down because it sounds like you and others are not taking the company’s wishes seriously. You have let her down.

Although if someone in my team blantantly disobeyed company instructions regardless of how furious, disappoint or embarrassed I wouldn’t let the employee know I’d lost sleep.

Rules have to make sense to workers: there has to be a good reason for them. People aren't robots or children. Good managers manage by consent: you have to take your people with you. Ruling by diktat and getting emotional and punitive is what terrible managers do.

Most people, once a situation has been explained adequately, will go along with it. OP says that various staff have parked on site in the past and just been told not to do it again, so breaking the (apparently stupid) rules seems to be endemic. And quite right, too. Why should loyal employees be expected to walk in the rain when there are empty parking spaces on site unless there is good reason? Employees are a valuable asset.

MiddleParking · 13/11/2023 20:33

It sounds like she was inappropriately demonstrative but it is really, really fucking annoying as a manager when people can’t just follow instructions nor even be smart enough to be discreet about it. It’s not outwith the realms of possibility that your boss knows something about a stakeholder relationship that you don’t. And unless you’re a school child you shouldn’t need to be told that other people doing something wrong doesn’t make it right for you to do it too.

Zanatdy · 13/11/2023 20:35

Letter deserved given you didn’t follow a simple management instruction.

Greatbigfluffytrousers · 13/11/2023 20:40

What a pile of wank. The only way this rule makes any sense is if the car park isn’t actually under your company’s lease and therefore you are using space that the company has no right to use. Otherwise it is complete batshittery. Do you have a sandwich shop local to you? Do the other office? If no for you and yes for them, are they banned from using the sandwich shop as that’s not fair?

I work on an office park, some of the parking is leased by my company but most is not. If people are caught parking in the wrong place an email will be sent round reminding everyone not to and sometimes the email will have a specific car registration in it asking the owner to move that car. It seems really selfish if the company to be leaving empty spaces beside your office and for you to be taking spaces some distance away that presumably could be used by other people.

Greatbigfluffytrousers · 13/11/2023 20:43

How is the company in general OP? Their decision making doesn’t sound great if they have such stupid rules and they have someone in a management role who sounds ill suited to it.

abisothergran · 13/11/2023 20:45

I thought it was only public service managers(like schools and the NHS )who were batshit crazy like this and treat the front line workers like children.

Applesaarenttheonlyfruit · 13/11/2023 20:49

Doyoumind · 13/11/2023 20:13

Yes, it does seem to be bizarre and that's why there's probably more to it. They won't have made up a rule purely to annoy employees.

No, but they may lack logic and sound reasoning. You’re giving undue credit

LlynTegid · 13/11/2023 20:52

Have you any reason to think you have been singled out and others not challenged?

Mama9076 · 13/11/2023 20:53

Firstly you broke the rules so fair enough on the letter of concern.

I would say her reaction is extreme. If you lose a nights sleep over someone parking in the wrong place is very strange. I would look for a new job.

Citrusandginger · 13/11/2023 20:57

Boss is nuts. A simple reminder to park in the correct place is all that is required. Lucky manager if that's the worst she has to deal with.

You must all be incredibly well behaved.

StockpotSoup · 13/11/2023 21:00

So have I understood this correctly - your company owns the car park, but won’t let you use it because they are unable to provide the same facilities for one of their other offices?

Ensuring “parity of perks” is a genuine issue. The company I work for used to have three London offices, one of which provided free beers and wine last thing on a Friday (a legacy from when it was run as a separate company). People in our office complained that we didn’t get the same. We were told that the fact that we got a similar perk - free soft drinks all week - meant we weren’t entitled to this as well.

However, problems set in when the offices all merged. People from the Friday booze office argued that the were entitled to it under custom and practice. Our office argued the same about the soft drinks. They gave in and we all got both. I’m guessing a similar fight for parity (although one that would be costlier and more logistically challenging than in my example) is what OP’s bosses are worried about.

The problem here is the ridiculous, and all too literal, approach the management is taking. Rather than looking for a sensible solution - as another has suggested, charging a parking fee at the OP’s office, or offering employees in the other offices subsidised private parking - they have gone for the “simple”, but ludicrous and wasteful, option of simply closing off the car park they DO have available. It’s nuts, but unfortunately within their remit.

That said, in the OP’s shoes, I would 100% challenge the letter or concern on the basis of the manager’s ridiculous behaviour. I would state that while I am fully prepared to follow the parking rules on future, I absolutely refute the accusation (and it IS an accusation) that this was intended as a personal insult, and that I find it completely unacceptable to be emotionally blackmailed with outlandish comments that a minor infraction had caused a senior staff member to have sleepless nights. I would ask for these comments to be withdrawn, in front of a witness.

MiddleParking · 13/11/2023 21:02

Citrusandginger · 13/11/2023 20:57

Boss is nuts. A simple reminder to park in the correct place is all that is required. Lucky manager if that's the worst she has to deal with.

You must all be incredibly well behaved.

That very clearly isn’t all that’s required.

WilmaWonka · 13/11/2023 21:08

Was it her who came up with the stupid rule about the car park? Sounds like it could have been!

Parking issue could have been resolved by staff from both offices applying for permits in order of time served with the company with the rest on a waiting list. This has happened in various companies I’ve worked for and is a damn sight more logical and fairer than no one being able to park (except top brass) and half the car park being left empty!

Does she park in it?

She sounds batshit and on a complete power trip. Not a great person for a HR Director job who has to deal with firing people if she can’t sleep over a staff member rebelling against a stupid decision. Did she lose sleep over making her team redundant 🙄

I would go over her head and put in a complaint to the big boss of the company suggesting a more logical solution to having a half empty company car park that you are being disciplined for using!

Citrusandginger · 13/11/2023 21:08

Why not? Most disciplinary policies start with informal conversations, reminders to follow policy etc.

MiddleParking · 13/11/2023 21:21

Citrusandginger · 13/11/2023 21:08

Why not? Most disciplinary policies start with informal conversations, reminders to follow policy etc.

What I mean is, simply being told to follow the policy is clearly insufficient for OP who knows better.

christmascrackle · 13/11/2023 21:24

fluffi · 13/11/2023 20:07

You’ve deliberately disobeyed a direct instruction not to do something because you think you know better / don’t like the rule / think it doesn’t apply to you.

If you can’t follow simple instructions whether you agree with them or not then how can you be trusted with anything else?

It does look bad to the other directors that she can’t get her staff to follow the basics so now she is cracking down because it sounds like you and others are not taking the company’s wishes seriously. You have let her down.

Although if someone in my team blantantly disobeyed company instructions regardless of how furious, disappoint or embarrassed I wouldn’t let the employee know I’d lost sleep.

dear god!!

Backtomyoldname · 13/11/2023 21:24

On one hand you did go against instructions.

On the other its a petty rule.

So…. Lots of wet clothes, wellies etc all over the place every time you and your colleagues have to walk in the final 0.6 mile.

Let travellers know about an empty car park going spare.

Are those with disabilities allowed to use the car park? If not why not? Questioning that could take up loads of time.

Are you required to work elsewhere, for work, requiring you to use your car to get there?

christmascrackle · 13/11/2023 21:28

thank christ i don't have to work for/with you @fluffi i bet your staff utterly hate you and your power mad, company arse licking ways,

christmascrackle · 13/11/2023 21:31

or was your post a joke @fluffi?