Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Letter of Concern at work

275 replies

GettinReal2023 · 13/11/2023 17:29

My office has a half empty car park next to the office. We have been told our team cannot use it as staff from another nearby office don't have parking so no one can have parking (except the execs). Therefore, everyone struggles with parking. There is free staff parking 0.6 miles down the road though. Against company rules I have parked in the half empty car park. I didn't consider it a big deal as I wasn't taking anyone's space and when I couldn't find parking by the office I would use it.

Today, my Director spoke to me to say she had seen me using the car park and she is very angry. She found it disrespectful that I didn't follow a simple instruction and it is inappropriate behaviour. Therefore she will be issuing me with a letter of concern. I apologised and said I didn't realise it would upset anyone and that was not my intention. I accept I parked there when I shouldn't have and that's on me. She went on to say she felt it was personal against her instruction not to use it, and that I was giving her 'two fingers' and she didn't sleep the night she saw me it was so upsetting.

I accept I did wrong, but I am surprised she has taken this personally and feels that my exemplary three years service with no work issues counts for nothing and it's straight to a letter of concern. Am I being unreasonable to think this isn't a proportionate response? Is this a normal consequences?

OP posts:
Bouffe · 14/11/2023 00:25

Whistleblowers don't break rules, what are you talking about!?

I was responding to this statement:

Regardless of how unreasonable the rule is, you are the employee and you are accountable to your employer.

Which is basically saying that if a company's paying you to work for it, you have to go along with what your employer tells you to go along with, regardless of how unreasonable it may be.

Whistleblowers are people who refuse to go along with things. They blow the whistle on shit that management would rather conceal. Management may say it supports whistleblowing but there's loads of evidence to show that when people do speak out they are punished for it — even when they've clearly done the right thing. They're seen as being disloyal and asking awkward questions and embarrassing management. Which is probably what's happened here with OP. The manager knows the parking rule is ridiculous but won't admit it or fight to change it on behalf of her staff, so instead she's unreasonably angry with OP.

Bellyblueboy · 14/11/2023 05:47

Whistleblowers aren’t people who break rules they don’t like 🤦‍♀️

they are people who report wrongdoing in the public interest!!

OP parked in a car park she wasn’t supposed to! She didn’t expose misuse of public funds. She is not a modern day hero. This was not a selfless act.

Aprilx · 14/11/2023 05:52

She has brought far too much emotion into a flouting of rules!

But I don’t blame her for speaking to your about it, for whatever reason, this space is not available for staff parking and you have somewhere else to park a short walk away.

VanGoghsDog · 14/11/2023 07:57

Bouffe · 14/11/2023 00:25

Whistleblowers don't break rules, what are you talking about!?

I was responding to this statement:

Regardless of how unreasonable the rule is, you are the employee and you are accountable to your employer.

Which is basically saying that if a company's paying you to work for it, you have to go along with what your employer tells you to go along with, regardless of how unreasonable it may be.

Whistleblowers are people who refuse to go along with things. They blow the whistle on shit that management would rather conceal. Management may say it supports whistleblowing but there's loads of evidence to show that when people do speak out they are punished for it — even when they've clearly done the right thing. They're seen as being disloyal and asking awkward questions and embarrassing management. Which is probably what's happened here with OP. The manager knows the parking rule is ridiculous but won't admit it or fight to change it on behalf of her staff, so instead she's unreasonably angry with OP.

Nothing about the original post here bears any resemblance to whistleblowers.

Whistleblowing is about matters that are in the public interest. The public has no (legitimate) interest in where a private company says staff have to park. Also, the OP didn't whistleblow, she just broke a rule.

A rule that is known about by everyone. So if she did try to "whistleblow", management would say "um, yes, thanks, we know about that, it's our rule".

Vitriolinsanity · 14/11/2023 09:16

Irrespective of your opinion of the ruling, you (and others) have ignored it. In your case, multiple times. You got caught out.

She may be as nutty as a squirrel picnic in your opinion, but she has identified an employee that has disregarded a management request. Hence the informal warning. I imagine you have an appeal process in your handbook, but you'd be arguing against a fact.

The smart thing would have been to collectively approach the decision maker and make your case.

The sensible thing to do now is move on. If you can't do that you have options, but if they don't suit you because you otherwise enjoy your job, suck it up.

sleepyscientist · 14/11/2023 09:33

Do you have a HR department? I can understand her being annoyed but as a 1st discussion regarding it the punishment is over the top. A quick hey seen you parking in the forbidden land, just an FYI take this as a warning that any further use will be seen as ignoring instruction. Then a quick email to all the team saying further use will lead to disciplinary action.

We would just get a parking ticket

IvorTheEngineDriver · 14/11/2023 09:42

You broke the 11th Commandment. There will always be consequences.

VanGoghsDog · 14/11/2023 10:15

Vitriolinsanity · 14/11/2023 09:16

Irrespective of your opinion of the ruling, you (and others) have ignored it. In your case, multiple times. You got caught out.

She may be as nutty as a squirrel picnic in your opinion, but she has identified an employee that has disregarded a management request. Hence the informal warning. I imagine you have an appeal process in your handbook, but you'd be arguing against a fact.

The smart thing would have been to collectively approach the decision maker and make your case.

The sensible thing to do now is move on. If you can't do that you have options, but if they don't suit you because you otherwise enjoy your job, suck it up.

You can't normally appeal against an informal warning. But equally, the informal warning means nothing anyway.

momonpurpose · 14/11/2023 15:37

Bellyblueboy · 14/11/2023 05:47

Whistleblowers aren’t people who break rules they don’t like 🤦‍♀️

they are people who report wrongdoing in the public interest!!

OP parked in a car park she wasn’t supposed to! She didn’t expose misuse of public funds. She is not a modern day hero. This was not a selfless act.

Edited

Exactly. I have actual experience with whistle-blower. Parking where you are told not to has zero to do with whistle-blowers. OP is not the champion for the cause and there won't be a movie made about her. Was the boss over emotional? Yes. Doesn't matter she was told not to park there and did anyway

iklboo · 14/11/2023 17:55

Do you have a HR department?

I think OP said the boss had sacked them made them all redundant.

rwalker · 14/11/2023 18:05

Greatbigfluffytrousers · 13/11/2023 21:45

Sometimes things like this are good for team bonding when everyone knows that the management are twats

they give you a direct instruction but you think your above that blatantly ignore it for no other reason than you have deemed it a none issue
then complain when your pulled up and dealt with about it

Greatbigfluffytrousers · 14/11/2023 18:38

Absolutely, it’s fucking hilarious 😆 Or should it be against company policy to speak of it to another soul? Hang your head in shame, OP, you have sinned.

It’s “you’re” in the context above and “non-“. And it’s generally good practice to punctuate - or do you think you are blatantly above that? Sheesh, some people, I don’t know. They’ll be parking wherever they like all over this thread in a minute. What is the world coming to. I think I’m gong to struggle to sleep tonight.

Messyhair321 · 14/11/2023 18:47

Manager sounds personality disordered. Who the hell stays awake at night because they have taken a parking spot personally?! Christ.
That rule & the reasoning is also strange.

Alwaysworriedwoman · 14/11/2023 18:52

Yeah you shouldn't have parked there but this director is "loosing sleep" over you parking here? Take it she she doesn't have a lot going on then? Not worrying about bills, dwindling health, family matters.... the things that keep me up, you know the things that count? If you are in a union maybe get them involved as I find this is absolutely laughable.

kthnxbai · 14/11/2023 19:03

You acted against instructions and are upset you've been pulled up for it? The rationale behind the instruction isn't relevant. Follow your employer's directions or quit.

Grimchmas · 14/11/2023 19:06

Car park rule is crackers. Boss shouldn't be saying things to you like this stopped her from sleeping at night. What's the company like to work for apart from the car park?

cannaecookrisotto · 14/11/2023 19:09

I'm a Director and wouldn't handle things this way.

Firstly, the car park would be used. First come first served. Get there early enough or park down the road.

Secondly, if it was that much of an issue, I'd just mention it lightly and say something like "please don't use the car park, I know it's annoying but it is what it is and if one person starts then everyone else will".

End of story. (Unless you continued to park there in which case I'd get your own manager to speak to you and be done with it).

AthenaMinerva · 14/11/2023 19:39

iklboo · 14/11/2023 17:55

Do you have a HR department?

I think OP said the boss had sacked them made them all redundant.

Worse - the boss is the HR director!

StockpotSoup · 14/11/2023 19:45

kthnxbai · 14/11/2023 19:03

You acted against instructions and are upset you've been pulled up for it? The rationale behind the instruction isn't relevant. Follow your employer's directions or quit.

I don’t think the OP is annoyed at being pulled up per se. It’s more the extreme reaction and emotional blackmail.

If you’re going to say the OP should follow instructions or quit, surely you need to apply as hard-edged an approach to the management? Namely “If you can’t sleep because of someone parking in the wrong spot, don’t become an HR Director”?

MargotBamborough · 14/11/2023 19:48

I think I'd be looking for another job. I couldn't be doing with people who wouldn't let you use the office car park for such a stupid reason. I expect they're petty about all sorts of things.

brokenbics · 14/11/2023 19:52

Yep, you did something you were told not to do and you'll have to face the consequences.
But not being able to sleep at night because of it? She needs to get a grip.

threatmatrix · 14/11/2023 19:54

I can’t see how you can be told not to use an empty carpark that your company doesn’t even own. Who the fuck do they think they are.

CarpetSlipper · 14/11/2023 20:02

She completely over reacted and sounds like she has some serious control issues.

MargotBamborough · 14/11/2023 20:08

threatmatrix · 14/11/2023 19:54

I can’t see how you can be told not to use an empty carpark that your company doesn’t even own. Who the fuck do they think they are.

I think they do own it?

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 14/11/2023 20:09

Messyhair321 · 14/11/2023 18:47

Manager sounds personality disordered. Who the hell stays awake at night because they have taken a parking spot personally?! Christ.
That rule & the reasoning is also strange.

I saw this as OP putting manager in a position to have to address her behaviour, so basically being told sort GettinReal2023 out as they are parking where they should not despite being told.

Not a good place to be to pull a direct report up on their behaviour. I can see why it might cause stress.

Swipe left for the next trending thread