Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Letter of Concern at work

275 replies

GettinReal2023 · 13/11/2023 17:29

My office has a half empty car park next to the office. We have been told our team cannot use it as staff from another nearby office don't have parking so no one can have parking (except the execs). Therefore, everyone struggles with parking. There is free staff parking 0.6 miles down the road though. Against company rules I have parked in the half empty car park. I didn't consider it a big deal as I wasn't taking anyone's space and when I couldn't find parking by the office I would use it.

Today, my Director spoke to me to say she had seen me using the car park and she is very angry. She found it disrespectful that I didn't follow a simple instruction and it is inappropriate behaviour. Therefore she will be issuing me with a letter of concern. I apologised and said I didn't realise it would upset anyone and that was not my intention. I accept I parked there when I shouldn't have and that's on me. She went on to say she felt it was personal against her instruction not to use it, and that I was giving her 'two fingers' and she didn't sleep the night she saw me it was so upsetting.

I accept I did wrong, but I am surprised she has taken this personally and feels that my exemplary three years service with no work issues counts for nothing and it's straight to a letter of concern. Am I being unreasonable to think this isn't a proportionate response? Is this a normal consequences?

OP posts:
cansu · 13/11/2023 18:33

What a load of nonsense! I would expect her to simply reiterate that you are not allowed to use it. It is also completely crazy that you cannot use a car park that has plenty of spaces.

daisychain01 · 13/11/2023 18:34

She went on to say she felt it was personal against her instruction not to use it, and that I was giving her 'two fingers' and she didn't sleep the night she saw me it was so upsetting.

Thats ridiculous! She's not up to the job of Director getting that upset and overinvested in something so trivial.

TinySaltLick · 13/11/2023 18:38

Well her response is not overly professional mentioning her likely inflated emotional response to what is quite a petty disagreement.

The policy does seem ludicrous though, they are solving the wrong problem.

Obviously accept the feedback but don't feel bad for her ficticious explanation and attempted emotional blackmail

AbbeyGailsParty · 13/11/2023 18:38

It all sounds rather pathetic , a half empty car park yet not allowed to use it. And “she didn't sleep the night she saw me it was so upsetting. “ Bloody hell I hope she never has a stressful job if she’s this fragile.
I’d be looking for another job, OP, couldn’t be arsed with crap like that. I’d accept her letter as it’s terribly important to her and at some point ask her if she’s feeling better, slight head tilt.

saraclara · 13/11/2023 18:39

She didn't sleep?! For goodness sake, as an HR director she must surely have much more stressful things to deal with. How on earth does she cope?

mbonfield · 13/11/2023 18:39

I would inform the woman that you have been picked on as others have done it and not had any letters of concern. Inform her that you have been picked on or intimidated.

I would not make any excuses for her she sounds a right dragon.

EmmaEmerald · 13/11/2023 18:39

It's ridiculously unfair OP but I'm afraid it's exactly what I'd expect from a director, especially HR.

I'd just keep quiet and get your brownie points back somehow.

tommyhoundmum · 13/11/2023 18:39

Your boss sounds very insecure. "Awake all night so upset" Utterly ridiculous.

You know you were in the wrong and apologised.

Doyoumind · 13/11/2023 18:39

I imagine there's a reason behind staff not using the car park that you're not fully aware of. If you make it look like people don't listen to her instructions and she's already stressed and perhaps worried about her own position, then I can see how she would be pissed off.

Just do what you're told and if you don't, expect to be pulled up for it.

The fact others have done it means nothing. Criminals don't get let off because other people did something wrong and weren't caught.

Baffledandalarmed · 13/11/2023 18:41

Doyoumind · 13/11/2023 18:39

I imagine there's a reason behind staff not using the car park that you're not fully aware of. If you make it look like people don't listen to her instructions and she's already stressed and perhaps worried about her own position, then I can see how she would be pissed off.

Just do what you're told and if you don't, expect to be pulled up for it.

The fact others have done it means nothing. Criminals don't get let off because other people did something wrong and weren't caught.

This ^. There is clearly a bigger issue here re. stress and she doesn't need junior members of staff undermining her.

Separately;

There is free staff parking 0.6 miles down the road though.

0.6 MILES!? That's nothing - not even a 10 minute walk. So to confirm; there was nothing within 0.6 miles. Why not park 1 mile away? That's a 15 minute walk. Tbh OP you sound pretty lazy...

sgtz · 13/11/2023 18:42

This is the kind of completely arbitrary batshit nonsense that makes me so glad I am self-employed. The reason for not using the car park in the first place was ridiculous, and I’d have used it too.

It reminds me of my old workplace’s ‘policies’ which I would always question. We had to wear uniform in a non-clinical office setting, despite not coming into contact with patients at all, and when asked if we could wear our casual wear during the heatwave got told no, because it’s not fair that people who work in hospital have to wear their uniform… even though we don’t work in a hospital! Madness. Similarly, why should it be your office’s problem that the other office doesn’t have to have a half empty car park next to it?!

VanGoghsDog · 13/11/2023 18:43

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 13/11/2023 17:36

What is actually a Letter of Concern? It’s not a warning is it?

Not a warning, just a pointless thing some employers do that has zero legal standing.

I think OP is lucky this is all she's getting, I'd have put through a formal disciplinary myself. It's insubordination.

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 13/11/2023 18:45

She went on to say she felt it was personal against her instruction not to use it, and that I was giving her 'two fingers'

Well, you basically did from her point of view. You say you are a very good employee but you were expressly told not to do something, you thought the rule was ridiculous and decided it didn't apply to you and did it anyway.

itsmyp4rty · 13/11/2023 18:45

She didn't sleep?

I'd advise her that she really needs to work on her resilience.

ThisOldThang · 13/11/2023 18:46

FreeRider · 13/11/2023 17:55

I've got a friend who doesn't seem to understand - at nearly 40 - that when his boss tells him not to do something, that means he's not to do it.

Before covid, he was allowed to work from home temporarily for a few days (can't remember why, I think the computer system at work was down). Literally months later, when he was working at various offices around our county, so therefore ran his own diary, he decided that he was going to have a long weekend every week by 'working' from home every Monday. He got caught, told that under no circumstances would he be allowed to work from home again. His boss then went off on compassionate leave for a month after her spouse died unexpectedly...and my friend decided to take advantage of her absence by working from home again...he got caught again, he retaliated by taking 3 months off 'sick'... when he returned he was told his role was being axed and he was made redundant. He'd been there less than 2 years. He's now working at a job making less than half he was...but still hasn't learnt a single thing from the experience.

If you don't agree with your boss's decision, it doesn't meant that you get to decide that it therefore doesn't apply to you.

If it took his boss months(?) to notice that he was working from home, then his work clearly wasn't suffering - so why shouldn't he work from home?

His boss (and you) sound like a nightmare.

Jifmicroliquid · 13/11/2023 18:47

What a waste of a car park. Why can’t it be a first come first served kind of thing, like normal office car parks?

Blackandwhitemakesgrey · 13/11/2023 18:48

NumberTheory · 13/11/2023 18:30

It does seem like an OTT response for what you’ve done. And if others have been caught doing the same and not given a letter of concern, surely you have good grounds to protest getting one? Unequal treatment is unreasonable and can be grounds for a constructive dismissal claim. Though, if just telling people not to park there again hasn’t been working, perhaps this increase in sanction is a company wide policy to address it, rather something aimed at you personally. But it sounds more like the director taking her stresses out on you as if that were the case an announcement would be more effective than springing it on you.

Apart from that, do you like the company? The reasoning over the car park sounds a bit batshit, do they have similar petty restrictions in other areas? Is this just a really odd blip, or representative of poor company culture?

I agree it sounds OTT even though you deliberately disregarded your company's policy of not using the other carpark. For all you know the other company may have threatened legal action for trespass which resulted in your company issuing the policy about not parking there.

AFAIK you cannot bring other's actions into disciplinary. At least that was the policy some years ago when a number of people I knew were dismissed from a company because of their inappropriate email usage. A few of them brought unfair dismissal action against the company and were told they could not bring other people's actions into the proceedings. Maybe that has changed.

Your manager sounds nuts though. Losing sleep over seeing an employee parking in a carpark?

You've accepted the letter of concern. AFAIK it doesn't mean anything other than staying on your file. If you have any internal interviews you could mention it yourself as one of your ''lessons learned/regrets/changes you have made - whatever way the interviewer asks for 'weaknesses'. Tell them you parked them in a fluster without thinking and how on reflection you realised that regardless of it being a once off, it shouldn't have happened etc etc. The interviewer will not mark your card because of a once off by a manager who has probably shown them who she is in mgmt. meetings already.

ThisOldThang · 13/11/2023 18:51

Being held to different standards to your colleagues is a form of workpiece bullying.

easylikeasundaymorn · 13/11/2023 18:52

VanGoghsDog · 13/11/2023 18:43

Not a warning, just a pointless thing some employers do that has zero legal standing.

I think OP is lucky this is all she's getting, I'd have put through a formal disciplinary myself. It's insubordination.

You'd struggle if OP then put in a counter claim for discrimination, on the basis that several employees had done the exact same thing and only she was being disciplined for it.

All those saying if you break the rules, tough luck...you still have to demonstrate proportionality even if carrying out a formal disciplinary policy. e.g. good luck sacking someone for not putting their teaspoon in the dishwasher even if it is against expressed instructions.

Basically the very first response by @GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut has it - yes suck it up because you were wrong (but depending on what a 'letter of concern' is I'd just chuck it straight in the bin and think no more about it) but I'd be seriously considering whether I want to work somewhere so batshit and ridiculous!

PinkLemons99 · 13/11/2023 18:54

What a bizarre response from an HR professional although I can’t say I’m entirely surprised as in my limited experience, they’re often a bit underwhelming.

ProfYaffle · 13/11/2023 18:54

It was a reasonable management instruction and you didn't comply with it. An informal warning sounds proportionate. The whole 'not sleeping at night' thing may be batshit, you may disagree with the parking policy but none of that matters. Just accept the warning, it'll disappear after 6 or 12 months depending on your policy. Don't do it again and it'll go away.

timetorefresh · 13/11/2023 18:57

It's a fucking stupid rule though, you're not wrong with that

sparklefresh · 13/11/2023 18:59

She sounds nuts. Some rules aren't worth following.

MustWeDoThis · 13/11/2023 18:59

1st) What she has done is inappropriate behaviour and disciplinary treatment of a staff member. She has used emotional guilt to manipulate you into feeling guilty. You either used the car park, or didn't turn up for work. - Put in a grievance and report her to HR.

  1. Ask them who owns this car park and where is their written policy and guidance which strictly prohibits you from parking in this space. The other office might feel slighted, but they cannot actually tell you where and where not to park unless it's on land they own, and/or rent.

  2. Advise your boss you will be handing a written letter of concern to HR, a Union Rep, CAB, and ACAS regarding her intimidating, threatening, and personal behaviour. You felt she over-shared her sleeping issues and put them on you which was unfair, her reprimand was informal and not in line with 1st warning, or formal sit down talks and you felt backed into a corner.

  3. Seriously. Get on the phone to ACAS and your union rep. This is bizarre and highly inappropriate behaviour for a boss.

  4. Directly challenge the parking and ask what will happen if you park there again? If they say it's a sackable offence - Ask them to show you where it says that in written terms.

Jetstream · 13/11/2023 19:00

GettinReal2023 · 13/11/2023 17:29

My office has a half empty car park next to the office. We have been told our team cannot use it as staff from another nearby office don't have parking so no one can have parking (except the execs). Therefore, everyone struggles with parking. There is free staff parking 0.6 miles down the road though. Against company rules I have parked in the half empty car park. I didn't consider it a big deal as I wasn't taking anyone's space and when I couldn't find parking by the office I would use it.

Today, my Director spoke to me to say she had seen me using the car park and she is very angry. She found it disrespectful that I didn't follow a simple instruction and it is inappropriate behaviour. Therefore she will be issuing me with a letter of concern. I apologised and said I didn't realise it would upset anyone and that was not my intention. I accept I parked there when I shouldn't have and that's on me. She went on to say she felt it was personal against her instruction not to use it, and that I was giving her 'two fingers' and she didn't sleep the night she saw me it was so upsetting.

I accept I did wrong, but I am surprised she has taken this personally and feels that my exemplary three years service with no work issues counts for nothing and it's straight to a letter of concern. Am I being unreasonable to think this isn't a proportionate response? Is this a normal consequences?

But OP, it is not for you to make that decision. You were told not to use the carpark. It doesn’t matter if there are no cars parked. Your director is pissed off because you decided to break a rule.
If you are usually a reliable employee it makes it worse not better in her eyes.
I have seen similar parking arrangements before, usually there is a private security company overseeing it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread