Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To contact the school on Monday about comments on social media

163 replies

crappycomments · 11/11/2023 17:04

My eldest DD helped out at a sixth form open evening last week, where prospective sixth formers from the same and other schools were invited to attend a presentation from the headteacher and head of sixth form in the school hall, followed by circulation around the different subject areas to get a taste of what activities are on offer in sixth form lessons.
My DD along with about 25 others was a subject ambassador, in that she helped set up and then demonstrate some activities. She also additionally acted as a tour guide to help direct people around the school.
Either later the same evening or the following day, several photos of the event were posted on Facebook by the school, including some of the subject staff and also a selection of the students who helped out. My DD was one of the students pictured.
Over the last couple of days many people have commented on the event and the students, many being complimentary about the event and how helpful the students were. However there appears to be a number of negative comments appearing about my DD and her appearance in particular, which she is obviously upset about and I'm not sure how to go about stopping it.
Do I contact the school to ask them to remove the article/photos; I don't know how to stop the comments.

OP posts:
lostonmars · 12/11/2023 14:49

Jibo · 12/11/2023 14:37

I would hope that the school wouldn't allow boys or girls to wear their uniform with their arses hanging out, especially at an event where the school is trying to make a good impression to prospective parents. Those complaining of misogyny are missing the point. It's not OK to post nasty comments on Facebook but there is a lesson to be learned here for the school and its students.

What happened to "it doesn't matter as much for boys?"

lostonmars · 12/11/2023 14:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

If the school was that bothered, I don't think they would've posted the photos in the first place. Also not sure how it's relevant if other students were commented on or not.

Lovelymoon · 12/11/2023 14:46

FestiveSandman · 11/11/2023 18:24

If she’s “a bit upset” then hopefully she’ll take this as a lesson to wear her uniform correctly.

Other students doing the same doesn’t make it okay.

You’re a twat

Jibo · 12/11/2023 14:37

I would hope that the school wouldn't allow boys or girls to wear their uniform with their arses hanging out, especially at an event where the school is trying to make a good impression to prospective parents. Those complaining of misogyny are missing the point. It's not OK to post nasty comments on Facebook but there is a lesson to be learned here for the school and its students.

YouCanExfilNow · 12/11/2023 14:36

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

LlynTegid · 12/11/2023 14:25

I am glad to read the school's response.

If it is found to be a parent or parents, perhaps the school should act. Not sure police are the right way to go though.

ohtowinthelottery · 12/11/2023 14:22

I drove through town on Friday as the local Secondary school was kicking out. I'd say that a very high proportion of the girls had skirts which were much shorter than I feel sure that their uniform policy specifies. My teenage NDN - who goes to a different secondary school wears similarly short skirt and I know for a fact that their uniform policy dictates knee length skirts as my DC went there. I'm surprised anyone bats an eyelid about it these days (unless it's one of those headline seeking schools who sends 100 kids home in a day for uniform breaches) let alone have the energy to comment on it on Social media.
Glad that your DDs school have taken action now and hopefully they will identify those involved and send them a strongly worded letter.

Fionaville · 12/11/2023 14:08

Jibo · 12/11/2023 13:56

LOL. Boys wearing their trousers pulled down isn't the same because no older female finds the sight of teenage boys' underwear erotic! Quite the opposite.

DD insists on wearing her school skirt short because "everyone does" but has also told me she feels awkward and exposed wearing it so short. I back up the school on the rare occasions they try to enforce the uniform rules, but the rest of the time I encourage her to do what she's comfortable with and leave the choice to her. I rolled my skirt up at school (and personally I enjoyed the attention that got me) but wore my uniform according to regulations when representing the school at open evening - nothing else was permitted.

It's not the worst thing for young girls to be discouraged from exposing their bodies in situations where that's inappropriate and it's good for 6th formers to have opportunities to practise behaving "professionally". Were the school's female teachers also wearing skirts rolled up to show off as much of their legs as possible? I doubt it.

If older males - Men, find the site of a 16 year old girls legs erotic, then he's a dirty, perving sex pest. It's not up to girls to control these men and their illegal desires. They are just legs. Female athletes wear short shorts. Should they stop too, incase a man can't control himself? Grown women wear mini skirts and hot pants. Is the problem just because they are school girls, so it's not fair on men?
We shouldn't be making young girls feel self conscious about their legs. My 10 year old still spends all spring and summer in shorts, not long shorts, just shorts. At what age do I have to tell her, she needs to wear knee length things otherwise old pervs will be after her? I've raised my son to be better than that. That's the answer, to raise better men. Not to make girls afraid.

lostonmars · 12/11/2023 14:04

Jibo · 12/11/2023 13:56

LOL. Boys wearing their trousers pulled down isn't the same because no older female finds the sight of teenage boys' underwear erotic! Quite the opposite.

DD insists on wearing her school skirt short because "everyone does" but has also told me she feels awkward and exposed wearing it so short. I back up the school on the rare occasions they try to enforce the uniform rules, but the rest of the time I encourage her to do what she's comfortable with and leave the choice to her. I rolled my skirt up at school (and personally I enjoyed the attention that got me) but wore my uniform according to regulations when representing the school at open evening - nothing else was permitted.

It's not the worst thing for young girls to be discouraged from exposing their bodies in situations where that's inappropriate and it's good for 6th formers to have opportunities to practise behaving "professionally". Were the school's female teachers also wearing skirts rolled up to show off as much of their legs as possible? I doubt it.

Why does the fact that older women aren't attracted to it make it better? Why are TEENAGE GIRLS in the wrong because of old pervy men? She's not being discouraged, she's being called horrible, misogynistic names. The victim blaming on this thread is astounding.

Jibo · 12/11/2023 13:56

Tobacco · 12/11/2023 10:42

It's depressing that in 2023 there are still people that think a sixth former in a short skirt is immoral and deserving of being called "tarty" (someone on this thread) or slapper or slut. I'm 52 and my mum wore mini skirts in the 60s before I was born.

There used to be a fashion for boys to wear their trousers pulled low at the back so you could see their underwear. They were laughed at but no one was calling them slappers or saying they deserved to attract sexual attention. So bloody misogynistic.

LOL. Boys wearing their trousers pulled down isn't the same because no older female finds the sight of teenage boys' underwear erotic! Quite the opposite.

DD insists on wearing her school skirt short because "everyone does" but has also told me she feels awkward and exposed wearing it so short. I back up the school on the rare occasions they try to enforce the uniform rules, but the rest of the time I encourage her to do what she's comfortable with and leave the choice to her. I rolled my skirt up at school (and personally I enjoyed the attention that got me) but wore my uniform according to regulations when representing the school at open evening - nothing else was permitted.

It's not the worst thing for young girls to be discouraged from exposing their bodies in situations where that's inappropriate and it's good for 6th formers to have opportunities to practise behaving "professionally". Were the school's female teachers also wearing skirts rolled up to show off as much of their legs as possible? I doubt it.

sunglassesonthetable · 12/11/2023 13:37

I feel better that at least something has been done but obviously my daughter is still pretty upset by it, and is blaming herself for attracting these comments, and still thinking that I will be annoyed with her.

Please wholeheartedly explain to your daughter she is in no way responsible for these odious, pathetic comments.

She should in no way take on responsibility for the social misfits who would do something like this.

I'm pretty sure you would be doing that though. You sound like a sensible person.

Good luck to your DD with sixth form. She sounds great and very involved.

Queucumber · 12/11/2023 13:15

I’m glad the school is on it.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/parents_of_adult_children/4925531-my-daughters-15-minutes-of-fame-devastated?page=1

This thread talks about a lot of the abuse women (and girls) face online just for being female. It’s grim that it is so common but maybe reading some of it would help your daughter to see that it’s nothing she’s done that’s caused this.

My Daughter's 15 minutes of fame - devastated | Mumsnet

I have a daughter in her late 20's. She has set up really successful business and is not only earning a good salary but she mentors and supports...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/parents_of_adult_children/4925531-my-daughters-15-minutes-of-fame-devastated?page=1

crappycomments · 12/11/2023 12:15

I emailed the school last night, I only had email addresses for the safeguarding person and the head's PA so I emailed both. Within an hour I had received a reply from the one of the school admin team apologising for the distress that the comments on the Facebook page had caused, and that the commenting feature had been disabled and negative comments removed. They also said that someone from senior leadership would contact me on Monday to discuss the issue.
I feel better that at least something has been done but obviously my daughter is still pretty upset by it, and is blaming herself for attracting these comments, and still thinking that I will be annoyed with her.
To answer some of the previous posters questions, the comments appeared to be from adults, as I said none of her friends uses Facebook. She only became aware of it from one of her friends whose mother had seen it.
I reply to the comments/criticisms from other posters about how she wears her uniform, I don't tend to worry too much about how my children look for school in that they know what the expectations of their primary/secondary schools are, and they know that I will always back the school if they transgress their behaviour/uniform policies. Additionally I am often already at work by the time they leave the house for school so it's up to them to sort themselves out.

OP posts:
Tobacco · 12/11/2023 10:42

It's depressing that in 2023 there are still people that think a sixth former in a short skirt is immoral and deserving of being called "tarty" (someone on this thread) or slapper or slut. I'm 52 and my mum wore mini skirts in the 60s before I was born.

There used to be a fashion for boys to wear their trousers pulled low at the back so you could see their underwear. They were laughed at but no one was calling them slappers or saying they deserved to attract sexual attention. So bloody misogynistic.

sunglassesonthetable · 12/11/2023 10:36

Tie and top button, no big deal. But as the person buying her uniform, why are you buying her skirts that are so short? Or not pulling her up on it if she's rolling up a waistband to make a decent skirt shorter? It's not a good look and is a magnet for getting comments like this, and potential unwanted sexual attention.

Oh please. fgs Anyone putting comments on a young person's pictures should be f**ing ashamed of themselves.

This school girl had been helping and contributing all evening at the event and people are banging on about the length of her skirt???!!!

The school were proud of her that's enough. They can tell her about the length of her skirt if they deem it relevant to anything.

OP contact the school ASAP. I am sure they will be horrified. They can remove comments and block any more. Personally I would not want photo taken down as your DD has NOTHING to be ashamed of. She sounds like a hard working, contributing member of the school.

I rolled my skirt up at school. So bloody what??

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 12/11/2023 10:19

AlmostAJillSandwich · 12/11/2023 04:19

Tie and top button, no big deal. But as the person buying her uniform, why are you buying her skirts that are so short? Or not pulling her up on it if she's rolling up a waistband to make a decent skirt shorter? It's not a good look and is a magnet for getting comments like this, and potential unwanted sexual attention.

No. Stop victim blaming.

If the school wants to pull her up on her uniform, then they will. If her mum wants to talk to her about how she dresses, that's between them.. Regardless of what she is wearing or whether it's a "good look", it is never acceptable for random strangers to post nasty comments about how a young girl is dressed on the Internet. And it is never acceptable to impose "unwanted sexual attention".

Describing what she is wearing as a "magnet" for bad behaviour is disgusting. People who want to make shitty comments or impose unwanted sexual attention on teenage girls will do it regardless of what she wears.

Afteropening · 12/11/2023 10:03

crappycomments · 11/11/2023 20:04

Ok if you really want to know, the comments ranged from criticising how she looked in terms of not representing the school in a positive light given that it's a well regarded high achieving school, through to her looking like a 'slut' and a 'slapper'

Have you looked at the profiles of those making these comments? Adults or students?

Afteropening · 12/11/2023 10:00

fuzzystar · 12/11/2023 07:35

I mean given the words "slut" and "slapper" were used I'm not sure it really matters the context.

Oh I missed that!

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 12/11/2023 07:40

wow how disgusting that people think it is appropriate to comment on a picture of a child on social media. Even if it was just concern for school uniform rules, that could have been directed to the school not posted publicly on a photo of a child on social media. The “slut” type comments are absolutely abhorrent. I’m afraid I’m such a nutter I would do why I can to find out who the posters were and if I were able to find out who they were they’d be getting a massive dose of their own medicine.

in your shoes I’d contact the school and ask whoever runs the account to delete the comments. I’d also ask the school to consider if posts like that really need to have the comments open- I think the school can post but keep comments closed.

Sadly as this is a reality of modern life it might be a good opportunity to speak to DD about social media, privacy and being safe online. I hope your DD is ok.

fuzzystar · 12/11/2023 07:35

Afteropening · 12/11/2023 06:56

Were the nature of the comments that she was not representing the school well by looking scruffy?
or that she was looking tarty?

I mean given the words "slut" and "slapper" were used I'm not sure it really matters the context.

LlynTegid · 12/11/2023 07:35

Perhaps you should suggest to the school they stop using Facebook and put photos on their own website instead.

And that if the comments are attributed to other children at the school they act on that.

catattacks · 12/11/2023 07:30

Yes the school can delete comments

Surprised that they haven't already

Email now

Afteropening · 12/11/2023 06:56

Were the nature of the comments that she was not representing the school well by looking scruffy?
or that she was looking tarty?

AlmostAJillSandwich · 12/11/2023 04:19

Tie and top button, no big deal. But as the person buying her uniform, why are you buying her skirts that are so short? Or not pulling her up on it if she's rolling up a waistband to make a decent skirt shorter? It's not a good look and is a magnet for getting comments like this, and potential unwanted sexual attention.

Tobacco · 12/11/2023 02:01

crappycomments · 11/11/2023 20:04

Ok if you really want to know, the comments ranged from criticising how she looked in terms of not representing the school in a positive light given that it's a well regarded high achieving school, through to her looking like a 'slut' and a 'slapper'

That's awful. The people slagging off her appearance and name calling are the ones who should be ashamed not your daughter. What they're doing is far worse than not wearing the uniform perfectly