Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP doesn't want DS to move in with us

76 replies

elder12 · 09/11/2023 22:12

Hi everyone I'm new here, I could do with some advice

My son is 20, I had him young. His dad was older and eventually turned out to be emotionally abusive, he had an affair and left me, still seeing DS until he was about 12. Shortly after contact stopped, I met my now DP. He got along great with DS and he became a father figure.

5 years ago, I gave birth to DS2. DS went off the rails and got involved in the wrong crowd, started being violent. I tried everything, showing him love, punishments, counselling but he wasn't having any of it. I felt like a bad mum and maybe I should've done more.

At 17 I kicked him out because the behaviour had gotten really bad, he refused to do anything I asked and was still being violent. He went to his dad and I didn't hear from him much. He occasionally messaged but not often and I didn't know if I wanted a relationship with him. In the time between then and early last year, he had been arrested for assault and was taking drugs - I didn't know any of this at the time.

He messaged me in March last year saying happy birthday and wanted to meet up, our relationship was very strained but we met up maybe once a month.

We started seeing each other more from May this year, we met up a couple of times a month. He wanted to see DS so I took him along a few times and he was good with him. DP didn't want me inviting him over here and I respected that but now I don't know what to do as he was staying with his (now ex) girlfriend and her family and saving for a place of their own. They've now split up and DS is staying with a friend that he works with. Which can't be long term.

I want to ask him to move in with us until he's ready to move out and get his own place, DP says no due to his behaviour but I believe he's changed. I'm also pregnant and if he did move in baby wouldn't have his own room, but he will be in with us for probably the first year anyway.

OP posts:
Teaandbiscuits1234 · 10/11/2023 08:34

reading the responses, yes I agree you wouldn’t want to welcome a violent ex addict into your home. But your son is your son and as a Mum I can see how you would do anything for your son and just turning your back on him wouldn’t be easy. I don’t think there’s a right answer. The best thing would just to be on the same page with your husband and try and get to a point where there’s a solution you’re both happy with.

NugatoryMatters · 10/11/2023 08:38

MumblesParty · 10/11/2023 08:33

Poor lad - abandoned by his father, new random bloke moved in, new baby born - all within 3 years, during puberty, the most difficult time of a child’s life. It doesn’t sound as if anyone gave his feelings much thought. No wonder he went off the rails. And now your lovely partner won’t give him a second chance.

What a sad way to treat your son.

This is unfair, emotive bullshit.

Intended to be nasty with a veneer of ‘I’m so kind and caring’.

THisbackwithavengeance · 10/11/2023 08:47

Can't believe the answers.

You have 3 DCs. Your eldest DC was clearly hard done to. No point casting blame, what's done is done.

But hey it's ok, you've got a new family and new kids now, so you can forget about him seems to be the answer on here.

Of course you should take him in or help him financially to rent on his own. I can't believe you're even asking. If your DH was any kind of decent man, he would already have suggested it.

QWERTYoutside · 10/11/2023 08:54

Naturally you are asking this question as a mother with regret and wondering if things could have been better for your son. At first I thought of course move him in! However if the roles were reversed would you want your dh grown up son with the same history to move in? I would not.
It might be better to improve relations between son and husband first. Or help him financially if you can.

bevm72yellow · 10/11/2023 08:57

You are his Mum. You can offer support in the background just as you are doing now. Meet ups doing activities together like a cinema ( maybe a funny even childish movie) walks in forested/ country area. Phone calls, facetimes all of those are supportive and validate that you support him. Your guilt will not support him. If he moves in it will affect your relationship with him and his expectations ( as happens when any young adult male/ female moves in) and it will affect your partners relationship with him in the long run. You would be trying to resolve conflicts in the family home or diffiuse conflicts. ( with young children in the mix) Allowing him to grow his own resilience and achieve what he needs to achieve I.e . accommodation/ car/ steady job will develop him and it will feel immense to him. There will be days he may be harsh/ angry/ emotional with you as you maintain your relationship with him but put a boundary in place to help keep things on course ( eg abusive language or manipulative behaviour)...wish you well

NugatoryMatters · 10/11/2023 09:16

THisbackwithavengeance · 10/11/2023 08:47

Can't believe the answers.

You have 3 DCs. Your eldest DC was clearly hard done to. No point casting blame, what's done is done.

But hey it's ok, you've got a new family and new kids now, so you can forget about him seems to be the answer on here.

Of course you should take him in or help him financially to rent on his own. I can't believe you're even asking. If your DH was any kind of decent man, he would already have suggested it.

No one is saying that.

in fact, if you weren’t so desperate to stick the stepfamily boot in, you’d probably realise that people would give the same advice in a nuclear family: support the adult DC with a history of violence a drug addiction outside the home, and protect the 4/5 year old and pregnant mother.

That is what good parenting looks like in complicated situations. The ridiculously naive notion that as a mother she must get her adult child to move back in helps no one.

ASGIRC · 10/11/2023 09:20

elder12 · 09/11/2023 22:42

I believe DS has changed, he no longer takes drugs and hasn't for over a year. He does have many saved but not much, as he had to buy the food for himself and his now ex, and give money towards the bills. I don't think he'll have enough for rent or even a deposit.

I worry if I don't help him, he'll end up going back to his old ways

Im sorry, but if buying food and contributing to bills means he couldnt save much, how is he EVER going to afford to have a place of his own?!

I understand saving for a deposit and moving costs, but maybe you can help him with that.

And maybe, if he cant afford to live on his own, he needs to look into a houseshare!

NoSquirrels · 10/11/2023 09:23

Your DS needs your help and support, absolutely.

But at 20 years old, and with the background, including his strained relationship with your DP, small children and a new baby on the way, it’s inappropriate for him to move back in.

He’s a young adult. He needs to get a room in a shared house, and live independently. But he should be welcome to visit you at home and rebuild a relationship with your DP and his younger siblings.

You can support him practically and emotionally without letting him move back in. It wouldn’t be good for any of you, frankly.

betterangels · 10/11/2023 09:26

Your DP is protecting your shared children. Good for him. There is no way MN would have told you it would be fine if you're DP had wanted to move his violent, adult son into your house.

YABU.

Fidgety31 · 10/11/2023 09:27

Your DP doesn’t sound like a very nice man if he is happy for you to abandon your son .

New man in your life . Get rid of the oldest son to have a new family with new man .
What a horrible way to treat your oldest son . Regardless of the difficulties he has had - you should have supported him not chucked him out at 17 and had a new baby instead . I wonder how much of that was down to your new DP.

betterangels · 10/11/2023 09:31

And maybe, if he cant afford to live on his own, he needs to look into a houseshare!

On another thread, posters are telling a 62-year-old man in employment to suck it up and get into a house share 'because we can't get all we want', so, yes, surely the same should apply here.

Soontobe60 · 10/11/2023 09:33

Ilovemycatalot · 09/11/2023 23:38

No wonder so many screwed up kids in the world today. A child is your blood and should come first not tossed out at the first sign of trouble. You should welcome him back not have to get permission from your partner if your own son can move home. Your partner obviously doesn’t give a shit about your son which shows what kind of a man he is really not attractive at all.

Her DP will likely know all about the behaviours the Ds has shown in the past. This man is a stranger to him - a stranger with a violent history - and he has 2 young children to consider. He has no responsibility to him.

Titicacacandle · 10/11/2023 09:44

Have a look for 16 to 25 aged homeless charities in your local area. They will be able to support him and make sure he's able to get things such a deposit for a shared house.

My initial thought was I wouldn't give a shit, my ds is moving back in whether dp likes it or not, but actually you can't do that and it will be a recipe for disaster.

I'd go with, homeless charity for young people, or to go and present as homeless at the council as they will have schemes for that age group.

It might be that he needs to sleep on the sofa rather than be street homeless for x amount of time until a place becomes available and I do think dp needs to compromise with that if that's the case - or he pays for a hotel. Don't tell the council that as if he has a bed for the night he won't be prioritised. Tell the council you can't have him back as the relationship between him and dp has completely broken down.

I think it's unfair that dp is putting you in the position of chosing between him and ds. There needs to be some understanding from dp about normal teenage reaction behaviours to the situation you and dp put him in with your new relationship and baby. Once ds is housed I'd be expecting dp to be welcoming ds for tea once a week and some effort to build a relationship.

Lavender14 · 10/11/2023 09:53

Soontobe60 · 10/11/2023 09:33

Her DP will likely know all about the behaviours the Ds has shown in the past. This man is a stranger to him - a stranger with a violent history - and he has 2 young children to consider. He has no responsibility to him.

He still knew that op had another child when they got together though. You don't take on a partner with a responsibility to their child unless you are willing to accept that relationship exists. I understand fully his concerns but a year sober is not a small achievement and to do it while sofa surfing and in unstable accommodation shows real determination. Op ultimately you're the one who's been rebuilding your relationship with your son, and ultimately you know in your gut whether you think this will work or if its likely to end badly. If you think it'll end badly then you can look at other options such as housing support charities for 16-25 Yr olds. Alternatively you can temporarily accommodate him but tell your local housing provider it is temporary while he's on the housing list as he wouldn't sustain hostel accommodation due to his vulnerabilities but that you're overcrowded and he needs to be moved ASAP. He should still get priority housing points but you'll need to do this before he moves in with you. So I'd go with him to your local housing provider and see what they offer first. I do think if he's serious about being clean, I would try it with him living with you because anywhere else he lives he will have very easy access and others around him who are using. But he'd be out the second he started again or was aggressive in any way.

Sapphire387 · 10/11/2023 09:56

The internalised misogyny is strong on this thread.

OP had a relationship with an older man who turned out to be abusive - he then had an affair, thus ending their relationship. They had a child together. Child stayed with OP.

OP had the absolute audacity to find happiness again with another partner and have another child (soon to be two children).

And we are blaming HER for her son's behaviour? He was violent and taking drugs and even got arrested for assault, but apparently this is her doing? I mean, I'd lay the blame with his so-called father, if anyone.

And women should not have to put up with abuse from men, even if the man in question happens to be her son.

OP - it would be madness to move him back in, and he is not even asking to move back in. Try and maintain a good relationship with him, and support him where you can, financially too if possible, to get on his feet. But it would be hugely risky to move a man with a history of violence back into your home with two very young children. I'm with your DP on that.

Londontown12 · 10/11/2023 09:58

Help him he is your SON !
your exactly correct if u don’t help him when he needs it and he is ok now he most probably with self destruct due to having no emotional parental support he will feel abandoned x x

Catsmere · 10/11/2023 10:01

Sapphire387 · 10/11/2023 09:56

The internalised misogyny is strong on this thread.

OP had a relationship with an older man who turned out to be abusive - he then had an affair, thus ending their relationship. They had a child together. Child stayed with OP.

OP had the absolute audacity to find happiness again with another partner and have another child (soon to be two children).

And we are blaming HER for her son's behaviour? He was violent and taking drugs and even got arrested for assault, but apparently this is her doing? I mean, I'd lay the blame with his so-called father, if anyone.

And women should not have to put up with abuse from men, even if the man in question happens to be her son.

OP - it would be madness to move him back in, and he is not even asking to move back in. Try and maintain a good relationship with him, and support him where you can, financially too if possible, to get on his feet. But it would be hugely risky to move a man with a history of violence back into your home with two very young children. I'm with your DP on that.

Couldn't agree more.

The "Oh, the poor mistreated boy! How could you?" handwringing all blithely overlooks that this grown man has a history of drug taking and violence (including arrest for assault).

Changednayme · 10/11/2023 10:04

You traumatised him and caused this and now you replaced him with a new family, HE should’ve stopped talking to YOU I hope he turns his life around for the better

Topseyt123 · 10/11/2023 10:08

NoSquirrels · 10/11/2023 09:23

Your DS needs your help and support, absolutely.

But at 20 years old, and with the background, including his strained relationship with your DP, small children and a new baby on the way, it’s inappropriate for him to move back in.

He’s a young adult. He needs to get a room in a shared house, and live independently. But he should be welcome to visit you at home and rebuild a relationship with your DP and his younger siblings.

You can support him practically and emotionally without letting him move back in. It wouldn’t be good for any of you, frankly.

This would be my approach.

OP, I fully understand why you want him to move back into the family home, and I also fully understand why your DP doesn't. I am with your DP on this though.

Help your eldest DS, but not by moving him in with you. Help him find accommodation, maybe supply some money for a deposit and first month's rent as others have suggested. Keep up the meet-ups and coffees together, go for meals and/or walks. Take his younger half sibling to see him for a couple of hours now and then.

BUT ........... keep building older DS's independence. Moving him back in "until he gets back on his feet" is far too nebulous a concept and could mean anything from a week or two to months and years, with resentment and bad behaviour resurfacing at intervals and ruining everything, not to mention compromising the safety of you, your younger children and your DP.

Gymnopedie · 10/11/2023 10:10

Imagine a different OP:

"DP's son used to live with us, he wouldn't do anything he was asked to do and was violent. His dad kicked him out and since then he's been arrested for assault and he's taken drugs. Now he has nowhere to live and DP wants him to come back and live here. I'm pregnant and I don't want him here but DP insists he's changed. AIBU for not wanting him to come back?"

Responses? 99% absolutely YANBU. Nothing about him feeling abandoned, or of course you help him he's your DP's SON. Or knowing that he already had a child and you take on that responsibility. No, it would all be no he can't move in now with that track record.

Topseyt123 · 10/11/2023 10:12

Sapphire387 · 10/11/2023 09:56

The internalised misogyny is strong on this thread.

OP had a relationship with an older man who turned out to be abusive - he then had an affair, thus ending their relationship. They had a child together. Child stayed with OP.

OP had the absolute audacity to find happiness again with another partner and have another child (soon to be two children).

And we are blaming HER for her son's behaviour? He was violent and taking drugs and even got arrested for assault, but apparently this is her doing? I mean, I'd lay the blame with his so-called father, if anyone.

And women should not have to put up with abuse from men, even if the man in question happens to be her son.

OP - it would be madness to move him back in, and he is not even asking to move back in. Try and maintain a good relationship with him, and support him where you can, financially too if possible, to get on his feet. But it would be hugely risky to move a man with a history of violence back into your home with two very young children. I'm with your DP on that.

Absolutely.

My God, there is so much bollocks being talked by some on this thread. Perhaps they read hardly any of OP's posts, or maybe they are hard of comprehension. Or both.

misssunshine4040 · 10/11/2023 10:14

I don't understand why you had more children while your first child is clearly traumatised.
Why do you think that's acceptable? He's 20 now and he has been through so much due to your life choices and you have to take responsibility for that.

Support him as best you can now. Not move him in no but do support him as much as possible.

HamsterBanana · 10/11/2023 10:19

I don't mean to be rude, but why did you have more children than concentrate on your existing child?

He clearly needs a lot of support & help, he probably went off the rails as you had a replacement family and kicked him out and had nothing to do with him for a while. This isn't all on him.

Catsmere · 10/11/2023 10:21

Just how long is OP supposed to do a breast-beating mea culpa for protecting herself by putting him out? What level of violence was she supposed to accept from him just because he's her PFB?

misssunshine4040 · 10/11/2023 10:25

@Sapphire387 I don't think it's internalised misogyny.
Of course his Dad is a POS and it's his fault but he's not here.
This doesn't mean Mum should be equally a POS and dump her son.
She had a relationship with a violent abusive man and then got into a new relationship which rightly or wrongly damaged her son.
We are only hearing one side of the story.
Not one person here is a perfect parent, no one. But we can do our best to help those affected by our life choices heal.
Maybe OP needed to wait longer and prioritise her son before getting into a new relationship and having more children.
He was a child and his awful behaviour is a symptom of something wrong.

Swipe left for the next trending thread