Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP doesn't want DS to move in with us

76 replies

elder12 · 09/11/2023 22:12

Hi everyone I'm new here, I could do with some advice

My son is 20, I had him young. His dad was older and eventually turned out to be emotionally abusive, he had an affair and left me, still seeing DS until he was about 12. Shortly after contact stopped, I met my now DP. He got along great with DS and he became a father figure.

5 years ago, I gave birth to DS2. DS went off the rails and got involved in the wrong crowd, started being violent. I tried everything, showing him love, punishments, counselling but he wasn't having any of it. I felt like a bad mum and maybe I should've done more.

At 17 I kicked him out because the behaviour had gotten really bad, he refused to do anything I asked and was still being violent. He went to his dad and I didn't hear from him much. He occasionally messaged but not often and I didn't know if I wanted a relationship with him. In the time between then and early last year, he had been arrested for assault and was taking drugs - I didn't know any of this at the time.

He messaged me in March last year saying happy birthday and wanted to meet up, our relationship was very strained but we met up maybe once a month.

We started seeing each other more from May this year, we met up a couple of times a month. He wanted to see DS so I took him along a few times and he was good with him. DP didn't want me inviting him over here and I respected that but now I don't know what to do as he was staying with his (now ex) girlfriend and her family and saving for a place of their own. They've now split up and DS is staying with a friend that he works with. Which can't be long term.

I want to ask him to move in with us until he's ready to move out and get his own place, DP says no due to his behaviour but I believe he's changed. I'm also pregnant and if he did move in baby wouldn't have his own room, but he will be in with us for probably the first year anyway.

OP posts:
Mistystar99 · 09/11/2023 23:14

You're pregnant but are not looking out for the children you already have?

Saffrom · 09/11/2023 23:16

Your first responsibility is to your baby and your five year old. You cannot move a violent man, even a ‘reformed’ violent man, into their home.

You would be a terrible terrible mother to your baby and five year old if you invite this man into their home.

I get it. You’re full of mother hormones, you’re sad that your first child turned out so bad. But that is not on you, it’s probably the crap genes he got from his birth dad.

Please protect your baby and five year old and do not invite him to your home it will end in violence if you do.

CrotchetyQuaver · 09/11/2023 23:26

I think your best solution would be not to bring him home but instead help him find a house share and some financial help setting him up with what he needs. And your time of course. Keep seeing him regularly and hopefully he'll stay clean and a nice person. Bringing him home isn't going to do him any good as your partner is obviously going to be hostile.
Woukd this friend consider taking him as a lodger

Catsmere · 09/11/2023 23:29

Your DP is right, no way should you let this man back into the home. As PP have said, one month will turn to six ... and who's to say he won't go back to drugs from the "pressure" of having to live in your and DP's house and rules?

My brother was a violent drinker. One attack was enough, Mum threw him out. He would have been about 21 and had lived on his own at uni, so there was no "oh my poor little boy" stuff there. She was protecting herself and me.

DisquietintheRanks · 09/11/2023 23:29

Why are people referring to the OPs son as an addict? Using drugs for a period doesn't automatically make one an addict and there's nothing in the OP'S posts to suggest her son is one.

BOOTS52PollyPrissyPants · 09/11/2023 23:38

I actually feel sorry for your son as he was so young and all the trauma he has been through and he seems to have sorted him self but is still so young and does need support. Also agree with DisquietintheRanks just because someone smoked a few joints etc does not make them a drug addict ... Can you not help him to find a place to rent near you and just be a support for him without moving him into the house. For me I would always put my son over any partner even if he had his struggles. So many men are so glad to see the step child gone. He needs support so try to help in whatever way you can. There has to be some organization that can support him as basically he is homeless. I just feel sorry for him as he must feel so abandoned and he was crying out for help with all he went through.

Ilovemycatalot · 09/11/2023 23:38

No wonder so many screwed up kids in the world today. A child is your blood and should come first not tossed out at the first sign of trouble. You should welcome him back not have to get permission from your partner if your own son can move home. Your partner obviously doesn’t give a shit about your son which shows what kind of a man he is really not attractive at all.

Maddy70 · 09/11/2023 23:42

Orangeslush · 09/11/2023 22:27

Yabvu if you think it’s acceptable to move an adult, violent addict back into your home where you have a younger child and a new baby on the way.

Once an addict always an addict. Hopefully he’s changed but chances are it’ll end in tears and unless you want the cycle to repeat itself you need to keep him as far away from your other children as possible.

Support him as best you can but at arms length.

Wow. Glad you're not my parent!

Lots of people recover from addiction. And I'm damn sure I wouldn't be turning my back on my son

He needs clear boundaries but it has to be a joint decision. I can understand your dhs point of view but no way would my dh say no

Catsmere · 09/11/2023 23:44

It wasn't "first sign of trouble" it was repeated violence, among other things.

From OP:

5 years ago, I gave birth to DS2. DS went off the rails and got involved in the wrong crowd, started being violent. I tried everything, showing him love, punishments, counselling but he wasn't having any of it. I felt like a bad mum and maybe I should've done more.

At 17 I kicked him out because the behaviour had gotten really bad, he refused to do anything I asked and was still being violent. He went to his dad and I didn't hear from him much. He occasionally messaged but not often and I didn't know if I wanted a relationship with him. In the time between then and early last year, he had been arrested for assault and was taking drugs - I didn't know any of this at the time.

Why does blood relationship make any of this something OP should tolerate? Why should her and her younger children have to endure any of this?

BOOTS52PollyPrissyPants · 09/11/2023 23:46

So you just have more children and forget about the firstborn child you had and offer no support and that is to a poster above.

Lavender14 · 09/11/2023 23:47

StarDolphins · 09/11/2023 22:24

I feel sorry for your son. Saw abuse, his dad left, he got a new father figure, then a new baby, then he got chucked out & you weren’t sure if you wanted a relationship with him. He’s still young & it’s a lot of trauma. It must’ve been extremely hard for you too to deal with the way he was.

Sounds like he’s grown up a bit & reflected. I would let me move back in without doubt.

I mainly agree with this but I think you'd need to agree set boundaries with DP first and then ds needs to sign up to those 100% because you need to protect your younger child and also look after yourself in pregnancy. I'd look along the lines of him engaging with support for his mental health and addictions, absolutely no substance use while living with you even out and about, no violence or aggression of any type, and being respectful, tidy and busy during the day working studying or volunteering because being busy keeps the demons at bay. I'd put that to dh see what he'd add to and then see what your ds says. If he doesn't stick to it then he's out again because you need to maintain a safe happy home for everyone who lives in it and he is as responsible for creating and benefiting from that as the rest of you are. I do think you'll need dp on side as it'll take a bit of adjustment for everyone

Edinburghmusing · 09/11/2023 23:50

Sounds like your son is deeply deeply traumatised and needs long term supportive therapy.

kweeble · 10/11/2023 07:52

It’s not an option as your partner doesn’t agree. You’ll need to keep up contact and do what you can to help him find somewhere.

saraclara · 10/11/2023 07:59

Ilovemycatalot · 09/11/2023 23:38

No wonder so many screwed up kids in the world today. A child is your blood and should come first not tossed out at the first sign of trouble. You should welcome him back not have to get permission from your partner if your own son can move home. Your partner obviously doesn’t give a shit about your son which shows what kind of a man he is really not attractive at all.

If a woman, pregnant with a small child, posted here about her partner wanting to move his son in - a son who'd previously lived with them and been violent and abusive, there would be a 100% vote telling her not to let it happen. Blood would count for nothing.

NugatoryMatters · 10/11/2023 07:59

I think there are ways that you can support your son and continue to rebuild the relationship without having him move in. He’s an adult who has been living outside a parental home for 3 years now - moving in is probably not the right thing for anyone.

In fact, having him move in may well undermine the progress you’ve seen recently. There is a considerable risk that it will all go horribly wrong and irreparably damage your relationship with your son (and potentially your partner too).

Of course your partner is worried about it, and the effect on his children. Given the history, he is reasonable in that. Try to recognise that.

The solution here needs to be sustainable, recognise your DS is an adult and work for everyone.

BeingGivenMoney · 10/11/2023 08:03

Orangeslush · 09/11/2023 22:27

Yabvu if you think it’s acceptable to move an adult, violent addict back into your home where you have a younger child and a new baby on the way.

Once an addict always an addict. Hopefully he’s changed but chances are it’ll end in tears and unless you want the cycle to repeat itself you need to keep him as far away from your other children as possible.

Support him as best you can but at arms length.

My thoughts exactly.

You’re mad to even consider it.

saveforthat · 10/11/2023 08:03

I would let him move in with some ground rules on the understanding one strike and he's out.

PaperSky · 10/11/2023 08:13

When you say ‘he was still being violent’, so you mean he was being violent to you? If so, can understand why you felt unsure about continuing a relationship with him.

I agree with the others who said you should try and work on the relationship, and just see him/speak to him often without moving him back in.

My first reaction was I’d never turn my child away, but realistically if they had been violent towards me I’d probably feel differently. Particularly with young children in the house.

What’s your DPs opinion of your relationship?
Does he want you to continue to build a relationship, is he happy for him to be around the other children in general, visit the house etc?

Just trying to see the dynamic, so people can offer practical advice to move forward

NugatoryMatters · 10/11/2023 08:18

saveforthat · 10/11/2023 08:03

I would let him move in with some ground rules on the understanding one strike and he's out.

In which case, the partner would be quite reasonable to ask the OP (and her adult son with a recent history of violence and drug abuse) to leave to protect his young child.

And social services may also be interested in this stuff. Because the OP is pregnant but isn’t really showing sufficiently protective instincts for her younger children in a situation where the older child has responded violently to a situation where his mother is pregnant and has a baby previously.

That ‘one strike’ may represent a very dangerous act. Why risk that when there are far better ways to help the 20 year old?

PaperSky · 10/11/2023 08:18

PaperSky · 10/11/2023 08:13

When you say ‘he was still being violent’, so you mean he was being violent to you? If so, can understand why you felt unsure about continuing a relationship with him.

I agree with the others who said you should try and work on the relationship, and just see him/speak to him often without moving him back in.

My first reaction was I’d never turn my child away, but realistically if they had been violent towards me I’d probably feel differently. Particularly with young children in the house.

What’s your DPs opinion of your relationship?
Does he want you to continue to build a relationship, is he happy for him to be around the other children in general, visit the house etc?

Just trying to see the dynamic, so people can offer practical advice to move forward

Sorry, just quoting myself, as I can see you’ve answered a lot of that already!

I started reading the replies before commenting.

If your DP doesn’t even want him in the house, then it’s just not realistic he can move in. It’s going to cause resentment and friction all round.
My advice would be to keep up seeing him/speaking to him regularly, and build up to where you can all be in the same house together. Eg having him round for dinner once a week/every two weeks, allow him to rebuild a relationship with your DP and develop one with the smaller children.

And then take it from there. Baby steps really.

Whataretheodds · 10/11/2023 08:21

elder12 · 09/11/2023 22:42

I believe DS has changed, he no longer takes drugs and hasn't for over a year. He does have many saved but not much, as he had to buy the food for himself and his now ex, and give money towards the bills. I don't think he'll have enough for rent or even a deposit.

I worry if I don't help him, he'll end up going back to his old ways

Is he working, or in education?

I agree there needs to be a period of rebuilding trust and it's understandable both that you want to help DS and that your partner wants to protect you, DS2 and your unborn child.

Could you lend him the deposit and first month's rent for a room in a shared house or HMO? Then he pays the ongoing rent and bills and eventually pays you back for the loan - you can be generous with the timeframe.

Can you invite him over for meals, for example?

user1492757084 · 10/11/2023 08:22

At 20 your son is managing well with his independence.
I would keep seeing him but not ask him to move in.
Encourage his work and saving; help him look for accommodation if need be and have him over for a meal every now and again.
Keep interested in who his friends are and whether he indulges in any substance abuse or violent behaviour.
Reward him with real help for his reform success such as a warm, smart, coat, a new phone for work and inviting him and nice friends up for the weekend.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 10/11/2023 08:26

Can you help him in other ways; with financing somewhere to live-help with deposit etc? A shared house might be good for him.

determinedtomakethiswork · 10/11/2023 08:32

I wouldn't want him living at home and I don't think he would want to live there either. He is independent now and he wouldn't want to live with a young family and his mum and stepfather. I would help him with a deposit and the first month's rent, but what I would never do is be a guarantor for him. If he goes off the rails then the rent and repairs are on you.

MumblesParty · 10/11/2023 08:33

Poor lad - abandoned by his father, new random bloke moved in, new baby born - all within 3 years, during puberty, the most difficult time of a child’s life. It doesn’t sound as if anyone gave his feelings much thought. No wonder he went off the rails. And now your lovely partner won’t give him a second chance.

What a sad way to treat your son.