Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Called aside in the office today...

530 replies

whatty · 17/10/2023 23:11

I work in London in a hub office (many businesses under common ownership using the same space) in a senior role (I am female in my 40s). It is a hot desking set up- sit where you like when you come in. Some areas in the office have music playing & some don't (some context!).

At the end of my day today, a senior male colleague (50s) from another business asked to have a word with me. I have met him a few times at sessions where the businesses have been collaborating/ doing leadership workshops. He didn't remember me, so introduced himself.

He then proceeded to tell me that as I had been on calls all day (11.30-6.30 with a short lunch break) that I had been distracting people around me, and "many" people (from his area of the business) had reached out to him mention that they had found me distracting. For info- I had a headset on, and was working with colleagues on budget documentation & talking to my team re: work they were tackling.

He recommended that I use a pod/ room in future if I was going to be on lots of calls. I questioned whether there was a policy re: working in silence/ being a silent space- and he admitted that it was just different approaches to working, and that the team he works in tends to avoid being on calls in the open plan. He then said he hoped that this conversation would be taken in the way in which it was intended. I was confused to be honest- so I said it wasn't clear how it was meant. But that I'd consider his feedback.

When we left the room where we had his conversation, it was clear that those from his business around me were all aware that I was being "pulled aside".

I was livid if I'm being honest- and upset too. I am really busy at work, have been doing long hours, and felt that he had no right to tell me what to do in a shared office space. I accept that I am tired and emotional though, so perhaps should just leave it and move on. However- I also feel like he wouldn't have had that conversation with me if I was male. And that I wouldn't be unreasonable to pull him aside/ talk to him when I next encounter him with some measured feedback of my own.

What do you think? Would I be unreasonable to stew on this- and think up some direct home truths? Or should I keep quiet in the office and on the feedback front. TIA for any guidance you can offer!

OP posts:
Wonderfulstuff · 18/10/2023 12:18

Something weird has happened during the push to get people back in the office after covid and that is that people have forgotten that offices are noisy places. Pre Covid I would spend most of the day on the phone and nobody cared.

Post Covid I spend most of the day on zoom. And yet it has now become verboten to make noise in the shared office space. In our fancy city office the pods don't have ac (small usb powered fans are available) so I can't spend the day in a pod. Meeting rooms are of a premium so understandably you get kicked out if you are on you're own. My only option is to work/zoom at my desk.

Of course I could do this from home and not be a bother to anyone but then I'd be missing 'important water cooler moments'... i.e. someone bitching about the lack of meeting rooms and how they are distracted by all the noise and not able to get their work done.

EarlGreywithLemon · 18/10/2023 11:49

Well done taking the responses here on board. I'm also in my 40s, relatively senior, working for a London based company with an open plan office. I also often have back to back calls. For all it's worth, I'm glad times have changed (if that's the reason- I think it's more that etiquette is different from office to office). I started my career in a very noisy open plan office. I got used to it, but if I had to do any drafting or work that required deep concentration, I had to put headphones on.

The office I work in right now is, thankfully, quiet, and it turns out I can get much better quality of work done. Calls are taken in phone booths or meeting rooms. Very rarely, someone will take a call in the open plan office, and it's so distracting. I'm sorry to say that there are murmurs of "have they never heard of a meeting room?" between their colleagues.

If you know you have a day of calls ahead and don't want to sit in a booth, why not work from home that day?

If you don't mind me saying, it's a bit disingenuous to bemoan that you can't talk to people if you're in a pod. You can't talk to them anyway if you're in back to back calls. All you're doing, I'm sorry to say, is disturbing them.

Countryliving0180 · 18/10/2023 11:44

I had this once. Lady pretty much didn't get off the phone once. I was so frustrated I had to leave. I wasn't frustrated at her as she had no choice it was her job BUT I couldn't handle it. Also don't think she knew how much her voice travelled or how loud she actually was

MaryMcCarthy · 18/10/2023 11:43

To caveat the story with "some areas have music playing" just suggests you don't understand the impact you're having.

They've chosen to have music playing. They haven't chosen to hear someone talking about irrelevances for six hours. That's a real lack of self awareness. Bringing sexism into it and threatening "home truths" is just childish and pathetic. Attitudes like yours make it harder for other women. Sorry but you really don't come across like someone in a senior role.

PlumpAndDeliciousFatcat · 18/10/2023 11:42

AIstolemylunch · 18/10/2023 11:18

Yes, I'm not saying that is appropriate. Publicly pulling someone aside to give them a dressing down is not a grown up (or professional) conversation. And doing it to someone who doesnt actually work for you is an HR issue.

Having read your other posts I genuinely don't think you have seen what a grown-up, professional conversation looks like in the workplace. Your company sounds very badly run indeed.

justaboutslim · 18/10/2023 11:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Fightyouforthatpie · 18/10/2023 11:36

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 18/10/2023 10:48

I find it really confusing that people find this annoying? I hadn't considered that my experience wasn't universal.

@whatty someone - or multiple someone's - taking calls don't bother me. I started working in a contact centre, and when I'm in the office it's still a contact centre. If we all had to take calls in a room we'd never get anything done and just be queuing for them all day. I will go in a room if the meeting has confidential elements or if I have to concentrate more than usual.

The vocal hum of others talking around me doesn't bother me. And I'm honestly surprised it bothers so many people - haven't you learned how to tune it out by now?!

II don't mind the general hum - but quite a significant minority of people seem to become really loud when talking on the phone/computer, and that is really annoying.

BrightGreenMoonBuggy · 18/10/2023 11:36

Sorry OP as I know it’s made you feel really crap but I’m with him. Six hours of non-stop talking and calls in a quiet communal space where nobody else is doing that makes you the one that needs to adjust your behaviour to your surroundings, not him / them. Take your cue from the sort of work others are doing and the sort of atmosphere they all need to do their jobs. If they are all working quietly and keeping noise minimal, you on a headset for six hours is going to make them go mad.

That said, Apple noise-cancelling EarPods are a godsend. You can drown out anyone with those.

MaryMcCarthy · 18/10/2023 11:29

Yeah it would be considered common courtesy in my company to book a room for yourself if you were going to be on calls for that long.

If many people felt the need to mention it, it's likely you were in the wrong.

Things have probably changed in recent years but I'd feel embarrassed to be on calls for that long in an office full of people doing other work. It's self important and inconsiderate.

Oreosareawful · 18/10/2023 11:29

yabu

Bellaboo01 · 18/10/2023 11:27

you’re in a shared space. Sounds like you were being quite loud and clearly distracting others from their work.

speaking on a phone for many hours in an office environment is very different to background music which generally is easy on the ear and quite calming.

crazy4cats · 18/10/2023 11:25

Does my head in when people spend all day on calls or have long loud calls in the office. we have a new office building with plenty of meeting rooms and pods, so take your laptop there!

Of course the office shouldn't be silent, but there's a difference between chatting to colleagues and taking calls in an open plan office

VWdieselnightmare · 18/10/2023 11:22

AIstolemylunch · 18/10/2023 11:18

Yes, I'm not saying that is appropriate. Publicly pulling someone aside to give them a dressing down is not a grown up (or professional) conversation. And doing it to someone who doesnt actually work for you is an HR issue.

He didn't give her a dressing down. He gave her some feedback and asked her to do things better in future. A good manager should be able to take feedback and to give it to others. To be frank, the OP doesn't sound as if she has the kind of professional skills to be a good manager. He does. There was a problem and he took her aside, explained what the problem was, told her how she could deal with it (book an office) and requested that she do that in future when she had a call-heavy day. This is adult behaviour. OP's 'Oh, but I'll miss the social aspect of being with colleagues' response indicates how this is all about her and not about the greater good.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 18/10/2023 11:21

It's not a dressing down. It's an informal request to use a different space if you're going to be on a lot of calls. Might become an issue if OP gets arsey about it, which she isn't, but strip away the corporate bollocks and it's just someone saying, "Your calls are distracting, could you do them in a pod or at home in future?"

Coffeerum · 18/10/2023 11:21

AIstolemylunch · 18/10/2023 11:18

Yes, I'm not saying that is appropriate. Publicly pulling someone aside to give them a dressing down is not a grown up (or professional) conversation. And doing it to someone who doesnt actually work for you is an HR issue.

Your experience of the working world is frankly bizarre.

Speaking to a peer, in terms of seniority level, in a private one to one setting to address an issue which is affecting multiple people is absolutely the professional option.

You adding that it was a "dressing down" is adding ridiculous context that you do not have. Nothing in OP's description backs up that statement. He simply told the OP that multiple people had reported the issue to him as distracting, and could she use a private pod the next time.

And no, it is not a "HR issue" to have a conversation with someone who doesn't work for you.

AIstolemylunch · 18/10/2023 11:18

PlumpAndDeliciousFatcat · 18/10/2023 11:00

It is so messed up that you think this is better than one person having a grown-up conversation with another.

Yes, I'm not saying that is appropriate. Publicly pulling someone aside to give them a dressing down is not a grown up (or professional) conversation. And doing it to someone who doesnt actually work for you is an HR issue.

PositanoBay · 18/10/2023 11:17

@whatty He wasn't being unreasonable. Lots of others mush have said something for him to have had to hàve done this. Especially if you were in a quiet space. Must have been distracting for others

ThanksItHasPockets · 18/10/2023 11:17

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 18/10/2023 10:48

I find it really confusing that people find this annoying? I hadn't considered that my experience wasn't universal.

@whatty someone - or multiple someone's - taking calls don't bother me. I started working in a contact centre, and when I'm in the office it's still a contact centre. If we all had to take calls in a room we'd never get anything done and just be queuing for them all day. I will go in a room if the meeting has confidential elements or if I have to concentrate more than usual.

The vocal hum of others talking around me doesn't bother me. And I'm honestly surprised it bothers so many people - haven't you learned how to tune it out by now?!

Paradoxically many people on calls is much easier to tune out than one person. Multiple calls will combine into the 'vocal hum' that you describe and yes, this can be tuned out. One person on a call is much more invasive.

VWdieselnightmare · 18/10/2023 11:14

Must have been a nightmare for anyone trying to concentrate on what they were doing with you talking for 7 hours. He was correct to raise his staff's concerns to you: he's their manager, he needs to get the best out of his team and if they're distracted and unable to focus then he's failing. I bet, like most people on the phone, you were talking a lot more loudly than you think you were.

My question is why you think it's okay for you to dominate a shared space? Why do you think your needs outweigh the peace and comfort of everyone around you?

JFDIYOLO · 18/10/2023 11:12

Thoughts from what you provided.

You're in your 40s in a senior role. So part of that includes role modelling and leading by example in a set up where others need to be considered.

He asked to have a word with you - an in person chat is always more effective than an email or teams message. The interpersonal element.

Your back to back calls in an environment where people were trying to get on with their work were distracting them - if it's a call / contact centre fair enough but it's important to consider the impact of that on people trying to quietly think and deliver.

I wonder of the fact that people had spoken to him rather than to you reflects how you're seen in the office?

Is there an element of prickliness there, as comes across in your post?

Pods are great for creating a private enclosed environment which keeps things confidential for you and keeps a quiet atmosphere for the others.

Saying he wouldn't have done this with a man feels like grabbing at straws unless there is lots of previous form for that.

He's a senior person, colleagues have asked him for help - so yes, he had a right and a duty to do that.

But letting everyone see you being taken aside - I agree, that could have been done better.

Being able to seek, accept and act on feedback when your behaviour's had an impact on others is a great skill for any professional, expecially a senior.

Don't do any 'measured feedback of my own/ direct home truths' other than 'thankyou for letting me know '.

Getting livid and wanting to have a go isn't a good look. It reads like lashing out in retaliation and may account for why they didn't feel they could approach you themselves.

Mumsnet | The UK’s most popular website for parents | Mumsnet

Mumsnet makes parents’ lives easier by pooling knowledge, advice and support on everything from conception to childbirth, from babies to teenagers.

https://www.mumsnet.com/

DrMarshaFieldstone · 18/10/2023 11:11

saraclara · 18/10/2023 11:09

There is nothing that makes me think less of a manager than if they issue an email or put up a notice to address something that only one person is doing.

It's a short cut to letting me know that they have no balls and are too scared to actually have a conversation with that person. That they'd rather imply that we're all guilty, than face an uncomfortable chat.

I'm amazed that some people in this thread think that weasely passive aggressiveness is preferable to actual leadership.

Absolutely. It is cowardly and it absolutely torpedoes morale when the whole staff have to listen to (or read) a telling-off that they all know is addressed at one individual.

saraclara · 18/10/2023 11:09

There is nothing that makes me think less of a manager than if they issue an email or put up a notice to address something that only one person is doing.

It's a short cut to letting me know that they have no balls and are too scared to actually have a conversation with that person. That they'd rather imply that we're all guilty, than face an uncomfortable chat.

I'm amazed that some people in this thread think that weasely passive aggressiveness is preferable to actual leadership.

PlumpAndDeliciousFatcat · 18/10/2023 11:00

AIstolemylunch · 18/10/2023 09:32

Nope. Not where I work. Zero chance that this would have happened. They would have bitched behind his back maybe or moaned to his manager in the pub but ZERO chance they would have publicly pulled him into a room to reprimand him. Absolutely no way this would have happened.

It is so messed up that you think this is better than one person having a grown-up conversation with another.

Maddy70 · 18/10/2023 10:56

I don't think he did anything wrong. He raised an issue his team we having It is very distracting hearing someone's voice. You may be louder than you think too.

If there is a more suitable place to talk and receive calls then use it

SawX · 18/10/2023 10:54

AIstolemylunch · 18/10/2023 09:32

Nope. Not where I work. Zero chance that this would have happened. They would have bitched behind his back maybe or moaned to his manager in the pub but ZERO chance they would have publicly pulled him into a room to reprimand him. Absolutely no way this would have happened.

Well your workplace sounds utterly shit. Not sure why you're promoting it as if we should all act like bitchy schoolchildren instead of having adult conversations.