Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Where did I go wrong financially?

331 replies

ogfs · 10/10/2023 16:45

I know this will sound bitter and I definitely do appreciate all I have in life. But here goes… I feel like I have messed you massively financially. I’m in my late thirties and despite thinking I had been very savvy with money, it turns out I am way behind the curve compared with most people. I have been an accountant since I was 25, I started on 30k and now earn 68k, I’m 38. In that time I have only managed to acquire 180k equity in my home and I have debt that is currently interest free. My car is on finance as I have never had enough to buy outright. I thought I was doing ok, that I had been sensible with money (credit card debt was to pay legal fees for house move and a down payment on a car). I have 4K savings, not used for debt as debt is serviced interest free.

It turns out that literally everyone I know is in a better financial situation. Nobody I know is in debt at all, people on much lowers salaries. Nearly everyone had paid off their mortgage. Everyone seems to buy nice cars, much pricier than mine! I don’t know if I missed the boat on investments or something? Or perhaps they didn’t have student loans that I had been paying off until last year? I can’t understand why I feel so financially precarious when other people in much less well paid jobs seem to have been much for astute about money. Obviously I feel even more stupid given I’m an accountant… I really thought I had been quite savvy with money. I can’t really change it now can I? It’s too late. I’m way behind the curve and have 60% loan to value on my home so never going to pay it off anytime soon. Where have I gone wrong?!

OP posts:
Teateaandmoretea · 10/10/2023 18:22

Papillon23 · 10/10/2023 18:17

Thinking about this as well: you have a £450k house - if you have a 60% LTV ratio and 180k equity i.e. 180k = 40% of the house. So your mortgage is £270k, which is pretty massive (especially given interest rates now), at 4x a pretty high income, and you are presumably therefore paying over £1500 on your mortgage plus your £150 overpayment, potentially could be £2k a month, depending how long your term is. Add on a car loan of even a couple of hundred a month and your costs are racking up.

With pension and student loan repayments (I know you said they have just finished) your take home was presumably down to £3,400 (Vs nearly £3800 without student loans).

It's actually then fairly easy to see how you might not have savings - you've maxed out your borrowing for a house worth nearly half a million quid, got more debt for a car on top - that's going to eat up your monthly income.

I have paid off my mortgage. It was 4.5x my salary when I took it out, and my salary has nearly tripled but I never upped my mortgage. My house is worth 200k. Is it possible the people you're thinking of just had much smaller mortgages?

Edited

It isn’t just smaller mortgages.

On our first house we had a tracker that was base rate plus 0.25. Interest rates at the time were 6%. We managed to port that to the new house (it wasn’t worth paying off even though we could have) and got another that was base rate plus 2%. So with interest rates at 0.5% it was easy.

The way interest rates have gone you just can’t compare it to now.

kiddosbedtimealready · 10/10/2023 18:22

Don't be daft. Who you comparing with! You're an accountant (at a big firm?). You will be surrounded by a disproportionate number of people who went to private schools and were gifted massive deposits or actual houses by their parents. It is the way of things in professional services, which have always been harder to access for the humble folk. If you are single, home owner, with pension accruing and £180k equity in your house, you are doing incredibly well. You are probably just feeling the Costnof Living squeeze, which is now biting the middle class because of mortgage payments. I'm going to give you permission to be proud of yourself and your achievements!

Shinyandnew1 · 10/10/2023 18:21

I didn’t know anyone at 38 who had paid their mortgage off, let alone all of my friends. I feel the group of people you know are unusual!

Are you saying that they all earn less than you, have no debt nicer cars and have nearly all paid their mortgage off?

HipTeens · 10/10/2023 18:20

You're my age and you earn three times as much as me, even though I have a degree.

If you're behind the curve, where am I?

SparklyLeprechaun · 10/10/2023 18:19

It's not that difficult for others to be in a better financial situation. If you cut your spending to the bone and only spent on the bare necessities, you'd have much larger savings. A pretty miserable life as well, but more money in the bank. Imagine how much you've spent on holidays, haircuts, new clothes, takeaways, etc in the past 13 years, you'll be surprised how much it adds up to. But I personally wouldn't want to live like this. You're doing fine.

ShanghaiDiva · 10/10/2023 18:19

You need to look at where you are spending your money. My dh is a retired finance director and we have a budget for everything: food, dentist, gifts, utilities etc. This is reviewed on a monthly basis to check expenditure is on track.
when we were both working (retired now) we lived on one salary and saved the other and we had savings targets. I realise this all sounds very dull but we had a very specific target in mind (dh retired at 53) and we managed savings, investments and expenditure to achieve that.

TeenLifeMum · 10/10/2023 18:19

I’m 41 and only have one mortgage free friend -oxford graduate… her dad gifted her £300k 10 years ago.

don’t compare to others but do use it as an opportunity to review finances and boost the savings. We currently have £30k in savings but that’ll reduce dramatically when we buy our next car.

Papillon23 · 10/10/2023 18:17

Thinking about this as well: you have a £450k house - if you have a 60% LTV ratio and 180k equity i.e. 180k = 40% of the house. So your mortgage is £270k, which is pretty massive (especially given interest rates now), at 4x a pretty high income, and you are presumably therefore paying over £1500 on your mortgage plus your £150 overpayment, potentially could be £2k a month, depending how long your term is. Add on a car loan of even a couple of hundred a month and your costs are racking up.

With pension and student loan repayments (I know you said they have just finished) your take home was presumably down to £3,400 (Vs nearly £3800 without student loans).

It's actually then fairly easy to see how you might not have savings - you've maxed out your borrowing for a house worth nearly half a million quid, got more debt for a car on top - that's going to eat up your monthly income.

I have paid off my mortgage. It was 4.5x my salary when I took it out, and my salary has nearly tripled but I never upped my mortgage. My house is worth 200k. Is it possible the people you're thinking of just had much smaller mortgages?

WtP · 10/10/2023 18:15

I'm 20 years older than you and have only been mortgage free for 2 years. Have only ever bought SH cars and was the sole income in a marriage.
In my 40's I was maxed out on my credit cards and overdraft.
But TBH I never felt hard done by & in the next 10 years got my act together and paid everything off, sadly my partner died as a consequence of their medical condition 4 years ago.
Financially I'm very well off now but still miss them so much (I am in a new relationship that is great)

I know you work in the financial sector but money isn't the be all and end all of happiness.

Princessfluffy · 10/10/2023 18:15

Why not read the FIRE books?

Coffeerum · 10/10/2023 18:13

this is the thing, I rarely buy clothes etc and if I do they are from the supermarket so v cheap! I do spend quite a bit on food I guess?! But I honestly don’t think I spend too much. The only subscription I have is Netflix.

How can you possibly be a decent accountant without knowing basics like where your own money is going? You earn 68k, only overpay on your mortgage by £150, can’t save towards things like a car but somehow think you have low spending despite getting into debt too.

Hayliebells · 10/10/2023 18:10

I'm really surprised everyone you know (if they're a similar age) has almost paid off their mortgage. I think still having a relatively large mortgage at that age is normal, and not a sign of financial mismanagement. I don't feel the same about car finance though. I think getting a car (or anything else) on finance is unwise. Cars don't need to be expensive, you have savings of £4k, that could get you a pretty decent car. Then when you've bought the car with cash, keep saving some money every month so you can get a new second hand car, when this one dies. Depending on milage, that's going to be 10-15 years, so plenty of time to save for another. I would question if you're that financially savvy if you've gone down the car finance route rather than buying what you can afford in cash.

IDriveMySupernova · 10/10/2023 18:09

Beezknees · 10/10/2023 16:52

Jesus. I'm 33, earn £22k and have zero assets and only a couple of grand in my pension. What exactly are you worried about?

This. Bloody hell

WombatChocolate · 10/10/2023 18:08

Why is it that OP isn’t prepared to say if she has kids? She’s been asked at least 4 times.

Someone with 4 kids will have considerable expenses. They are likely to be in a much worse position than someone with none..and especially if they started having them young.

This vital but if info is needed to be able to make any sense of the OP’s position. But the key Q has repeatedly been ignored. Why is that?

ginandtonicwithlimes · 10/10/2023 18:07

Why don't you stop comparing your situation with that of others? They might not be telling the truth. Also this is meant kindly but count your blessings. You earn so much more than many who will be struggling to pay bills.

Teateaandmoretea · 10/10/2023 18:05

The ‘not normal to be mortgage free’ surely depends on where you bought and when? We are (well before 50) but that’s largely because we haven’t bought a bigger house even though we could afford it and bought a house for 85k in 2000. We paid that off (interest rates went from 6% to 0.5%) and then had mortgage of 120k 15 years ago on our second house which is now worth about 450k. We overpaid what we could but had some luck along the way plus there were 2 of us.

Then if you have no mortgage saving is easy. I’ve also never had a car on finance, and keep them till they are about 10.

It sounds like you are doing really well to me OP.

springtome · 10/10/2023 18:05

I'm not sure I know anyone who has paid off their mortgage. We are in our mid 40's so some of our friends are about 5 years away from paying off.

We earn about £40,000 each, have about £90,000 equity in our home. We have about £7/£8,000 in savings and only debt is our new car (about £16,000).

We have good public sector pensions.

We would both like to have more savings but are spenders. We are at a stage where we could save £500 a month but don't always buy try and spend it on longer terms things like holidays, diy, white goods rather than on daily living.

OhwhyOY · 10/10/2023 18:03

I read sn article recently in the FT that said lots of younger people are gifted money or homes by their parents or grandparents yet don't want to admit it to others as they fear being seen as overprivileged. Perhaps this is what's going on. And/or two people engaging in the same behaviours as you on a similar salary in the same property and thus acquiring equity twice as fast as you.

Goodas91 · 10/10/2023 18:03

As a fellow accountant I think we are notoriously bad with our own money! Probably because we spend all day thinking about other people’s money so the last thing we want to do when we get home is think about our own…

cherrypeachparfait · 10/10/2023 17:58

Why don’t you buy a second hand car? That’s what I’ve always done. It’s considerably cheaper and they work fine!

In other respects, well I’ve messed up financially but people who’ve done well have worked full time at the well paid jobs. They’ve married people who are high earners. And a lot of people have a lot of help from their parents and grandparents and don’t always admit it.

elizzza · 10/10/2023 17:58

There’s no secret to paying off a mortgage by your 30s that you’ve missed - your friends almost certainly had family help. When you can’t make sense of someone’s financial situation the answer is always either debt or family money.

Chocolatepeanutbuttercupsandicecream · 10/10/2023 17:57

Surely most of the mortgage free people will be due to inheritance or similar? It’s definitely not the norm otherwise. In fact, home ownership isn’t even the norm in my peer group, lots of us still renting (either council or private) and unlikely to get on the property ladder.

Puncturedbicycle85 · 10/10/2023 17:56

Around the same age. I earn 52k, have equity of about 80k, savings of 10k and my mortgage term lasts til I'm 68. I have done it all on my own without a partner though, although I am now in a relationship (we don't live together and don't share finances). I have a crappy car but I manage okay and I'm much better off than others. I don't know anyone other than those who have inherited or bought something for 90k 15 years ago who are anything close to mortgage free. I know many who will never be able to buy and some who have mortgages of 400k to service. I also know some who have done pretty well out of having a wealthy and older partner, parental help and who struck it lucky on the property market. I didn't have any of that so I'm okay with it. My boyfriend got fucked financially from a divorce so at least I never had something and then lost it. He's also got a long mortgage and same sort of savings as me. He earns 66k so similar to you and isn't any better off than you. We live in the SE so maybe that makes you used to being over stretched.

Littlegreene82 · 10/10/2023 17:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

KermitTheSecond · 10/10/2023 17:54

Do you have any kids @ogfs ?