Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Where did I go wrong financially?

331 replies

ogfs · 10/10/2023 16:45

I know this will sound bitter and I definitely do appreciate all I have in life. But here goes… I feel like I have messed you massively financially. I’m in my late thirties and despite thinking I had been very savvy with money, it turns out I am way behind the curve compared with most people. I have been an accountant since I was 25, I started on 30k and now earn 68k, I’m 38. In that time I have only managed to acquire 180k equity in my home and I have debt that is currently interest free. My car is on finance as I have never had enough to buy outright. I thought I was doing ok, that I had been sensible with money (credit card debt was to pay legal fees for house move and a down payment on a car). I have 4K savings, not used for debt as debt is serviced interest free.

It turns out that literally everyone I know is in a better financial situation. Nobody I know is in debt at all, people on much lowers salaries. Nearly everyone had paid off their mortgage. Everyone seems to buy nice cars, much pricier than mine! I don’t know if I missed the boat on investments or something? Or perhaps they didn’t have student loans that I had been paying off until last year? I can’t understand why I feel so financially precarious when other people in much less well paid jobs seem to have been much for astute about money. Obviously I feel even more stupid given I’m an accountant… I really thought I had been quite savvy with money. I can’t really change it now can I? It’s too late. I’m way behind the curve and have 60% loan to value on my home so never going to pay it off anytime soon. Where have I gone wrong?!

OP posts:
Makingplansfor2029 · 12/10/2023 17:14

UsernamenotavailableBob · 12/10/2023 15:59

A car lease for a ford fiesta is c.£250pm on a 36 months contract with a £2300 down payment totalling £11,500. For 36 months.

You can get a 5 year old fiesta for £5-6k at the moment. Why would you lease?

because you don’t want to drive a 5 year old fiesta and would prefer to spend £300 a month on a nicer car. Is if that hard to believe. I don’t want a fiesta and I’m happy to spend £300 a month on a really nice all singing and dancing car which gives me huge pleasure every time I get into it and wouldn’t want to pay £30k up front for the pleasure of it

toomuchfaff · 12/10/2023 17:03

stop comparing your life to other, stop looking back, you are where you are, look forward on how to make it better, you'll achieve more

UsernamenotavailableBob · 12/10/2023 15:59

A car lease for a ford fiesta is c.£250pm on a 36 months contract with a £2300 down payment totalling £11,500. For 36 months.

You can get a 5 year old fiesta for £5-6k at the moment. Why would you lease?

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 12/10/2023 14:37

Lucyh999 · 12/10/2023 13:50

Because it’s much better than paying quadruple to rent one?!

Quadruple? Aye, if you say so! Buy a cheaper car but you'll have to cough up for all the extras. Rent and it'll be covered.

Lucyh999 · 12/10/2023 13:56

Well, the only thing that you’ve done wrong is by expecting us to have any more knowledge of your friends financial position than you? We don’t know. We can’t advise you on that.

Youre in a great position. I’m 37 and most of my friends are only just on the property ladder and only just having children etc. even with decent jobs, teachers, musicians, computer tech type people. Etc. etc.

What is wrong is your expectations. Why set yourself the goal of being mortgage free, what’s the point?! It’s not the arbiter of success! You’re doing really well and are in a much better position than a lot of ‘successful’ people I know.

I do think you should be able to save more and you sound quite naive. You haven’t shared your outgoings etc or how much money you have left over and nor should you, but you can’t actually expect financial advice without those things?! You should be able to save more so start doing that and change your focus. What is the point in getting so caught up in all of this?! Enjoy your life!! Everyone’s situations are different and you’re single and we all know it’s harder to pay your way on your own. You really sound like you need to let it go.

Lucyh999 · 12/10/2023 13:50

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 10/10/2023 17:39

Don't fear not buying a car, why would you own a depreciating asset?

Because it’s much better than paying quadruple to rent one?!

Anna79ishere · 12/10/2023 13:07

You don’t know people financial situation so you should not compare.
All the people I know who are mortgage free at 40 are 1. Investment bankers making a few millions a year and having bought a house worth £4-5m 2. People who bought a small property at 25 in central London, sold it 10-12 years later for 6-7 times their value and bought a bigger property outside
with 60-70% equity so were able to overpay their mortgage and finish it off in 10 years as a couple 3. People who got inerithance, gifts from family or other income from family wealth, such as regular rent coming in etc.
everybody else is potentially a bit better off than you if they have your income and are a couple or way way worst off.
you can’t compare yourself really to anyone as you don’t know.

Anetaaa · 12/10/2023 11:42

You need to take account families that so many people get help from . You seem so be doing very well. I wouldn’t expect to have my mortgage paid off by 38..

LT1982 · 12/10/2023 11:41

ogfs · 10/10/2023 16:45

I know this will sound bitter and I definitely do appreciate all I have in life. But here goes… I feel like I have messed you massively financially. I’m in my late thirties and despite thinking I had been very savvy with money, it turns out I am way behind the curve compared with most people. I have been an accountant since I was 25, I started on 30k and now earn 68k, I’m 38. In that time I have only managed to acquire 180k equity in my home and I have debt that is currently interest free. My car is on finance as I have never had enough to buy outright. I thought I was doing ok, that I had been sensible with money (credit card debt was to pay legal fees for house move and a down payment on a car). I have 4K savings, not used for debt as debt is serviced interest free.

It turns out that literally everyone I know is in a better financial situation. Nobody I know is in debt at all, people on much lowers salaries. Nearly everyone had paid off their mortgage. Everyone seems to buy nice cars, much pricier than mine! I don’t know if I missed the boat on investments or something? Or perhaps they didn’t have student loans that I had been paying off until last year? I can’t understand why I feel so financially precarious when other people in much less well paid jobs seem to have been much for astute about money. Obviously I feel even more stupid given I’m an accountant… I really thought I had been quite savvy with money. I can’t really change it now can I? It’s too late. I’m way behind the curve and have 60% loan to value on my home so never going to pay it off anytime soon. Where have I gone wrong?!

Comparison is the thief of joy.

IMO you are doing very well to be comparatively debt free in the current economic climate

grabitwithbothhands · 12/10/2023 08:25

I haven't read the full thread, just your updates (the last from 2 days ago so I'm guessing you're not going to come back now) but if you're earning £68k and you say you live fairly frugally you should have hundreds, if not over £1000 leftover each month to save, or use to overpay the mortgage since you seem to be obsessed with that.
On that point, I'll +1 to what lots of others have said, mortgage paid off by late 30s is very unusual both in my experience and if you look at the statistics.
Not saying your friends are lying, but that is genuinely unusual and I wouldn't use them as a benchmark.

ScaryM0nster · 12/10/2023 08:11

It does sound like you’re not managing your money that brilliantly.

On £68k in the midlands it feels like should be fairly achievable to be saving or overpaying more.

You’ll be getting nearly £4K/ month take home.

With £1000 on mortgage and another £1000 on bills and core living costs that’s still £2k a month of discretionary spend.

What are you spending £500/week on over and above basic life costs.

NeonSoda · 12/10/2023 07:15

I’m 38 and bought my first house last year. I’ve never had a car on finance, I’ve always bought second hand for under £4k. I’ve got both undergrad and postgrad student loans and I earn less than half than you do.

Most of my friends have not bought their first house yet. I can only think of one person vaguely my age (ten years older) who has paid his house off.

You must have an exceptional group of friends and acquaintances.

Paternosta · 12/10/2023 07:08

You earn £68K, have a house, a car and your health and nearly everyone you know is better off? You want to widen your friendship circle.🤣.

I earn half what you do but still consider myself well off compared with some of my friends! It's all relative.

GRex · 12/10/2023 07:03

I expect you've spent a lot more on your car and holidays than you've realised. Just because a car is necessary, doesn't mean you need an expensive one bought with finance, which then has higher insurance premiums etc. You need to look a bit more clearly at ALL your costs if you want to save more. Or don't; just accept you're doing ok and are happy with the choices you've made.

Raylaqueen · 12/10/2023 06:33

You haven't gone wrong anywhere. You just have a bunch of friends who have in one way or another done excessively well. I have spent years with friends who have worked hard in their professions and gotten married and had kids. They out earn me significantly. If I looked at my life based on their success, my life would look poor by comparison. But it isn't, I'm on the average national wage, I own my car after paying off finance, I co habit otherwise I'd live with my mum as renting is expensive and I'm privileged to have that option. My credit score is excellent and I want for nothing. I'm actually in a fortunate situation compared to others. I just have friends who are in a better situation. Don't use your friends as a stick to beat yourself with, just be pleased you have good friends and be happy for them. We are all poor and made poor decisions compared to someone else. Equally if a paid off mortgage and a paid off car are your only aspirations, find an interesting hobby to take your mind off it, this is a type of jealousy (we can't help jealousy, but we can help how we deal with it) brooding on it will not help.

LeedsMum87 · 12/10/2023 06:31

£68k is about what we earn as a married couple so that’s a high salary for someone single but then again a lot of the costs we have as a couple would be the same for a single person, i.e. mortgage, house maintenance, car, fuel, nursery fees, utilities, subscriptions, insurance, pet costs etc. We just scrape by on our income and don’t have a lavish lifestyle. I guess it depends on if you have kids, do you spend a lot on clothes/holidays/socialising etc, how expensive is your house? You could look at downsizing and having a smaller cheaper house, cheaper car and put away more of your disposable income away.

Lalalalala555 · 12/10/2023 05:46

I think the thing here is doing well is subjective.
There's that phrase 'comparison is the theif of joy'.

From my perspective you're doing really well in life financially.
I think the way your viewing yourself is being skewed by comparison with your friends?

Everyone has different circumstances, and moreover, people don't tend to disclose everything. Ie inheritance or debt unless they're really really close. So you just won't know if what other people are saying is the truth, full truth and how they got there if on their own or with legs up. And if they're fine on the surface but struggling.

If you are generally concerned about your finances, irrespective of comparison.

Have a sit down with yourself, and go through your essential costs.
Then figure out what you have left.
You can even reduce essential costs by moving somewhere cheaper, and looking at ways to reduce bills.
Car (potentially) and type of car is a choice.
Food budget can go down.
You can automate savings. Automate investments.

Look after your health. Enjoy your free time doing things and spending time with people. Not spending money on appearances or luxury. You'll soon save loads that way.

Your income is really good.

middler · 12/10/2023 05:12

Here is a case study from the UK
https://www.frugalwoods.com/2021/10/29/reader-case-study-buddhist-in-england-desires-a-simple-secure-financial-future/
They really help you to see how people spend their money and where you can cut back and save yourself. Beware the US salaries can be intimidating as in two nurses can easily be making 250 k because so many jobs just pay much better in the US where I would say the cost of living is higher for almost everything, but then they may be paying 1800$ a month for their health insurance so they need the higher salary for that expense you just do not have to worry about in the UK.

record everything you have going out and then do what you do better than 99% of us on here, crunch the numbers.

Reader Case Study: Buddhist in England Desires a Simple, Secure Financial Future

Reader Case Study: Buddhist in England Desires a Simple, Secure Financial Future - Frugalwoods

Lotus lives in the beautiful rural South of England with her partner, Rowan, and their 12-year-old son. She currently works as a communications manager for a

https://www.frugalwoods.com/2021/10/29/reader-case-study-buddhist-in-england-desires-a-simple-secure-financial-future

middler · 12/10/2023 04:57

I think I would have more savings than that after 13 years on a decent salary but maybe you overpaid the mortgage? I had not bought a home at your age so had no equity, but had about 100k in savings so overall less than you. I had been a stay home mum so no second income for 6 years though.
If you are not in London you must be spending lots to not have a paid off car and no savings. This blog is interesting and she does case studies so you cna write in and stay anonymous and she analyses all your outgoings to see how you could save more. I have got lots of tips from it and we are now saving hard to try and retire when we want rather than in our 60s but having got on the housing ladder late we still have a big chunk to pay off there.https://www.frugalwoods.com/2023/09/29/reader-case-study-yearning-for-a-debt-free-future/

Reader Case Study: Yearning For a Debt-Free Future

Reader Case Study: Yearning For a Debt-Free Future - Frugalwoods

Brian and Michael, both 34, live with their two cats in central Connecticut. Michael works as a project coordinator for a state behavioral health agency

https://www.frugalwoods.com/2023/09/29/reader-case-study-yearning-for-a-debt-free-future

Haruka · 12/10/2023 04:21

OP your post is tone deaf and you know it!

I'm your age, on 2/3rds of the money you're on, have only just been able to buy an old house in a shitty area with loads of work that needs doing, but it was all I could afford (your equity being more than my whole house is worth). My car is nearing vintage age and looks it. I barely have any savings because something is always breaking and I have to feed and clothe myself and two kids. No debt but it only takes my car to stop working completely and I'm there.

I hope this post makes you feel much more superior in how "savvy" you are.

Luckyduc · 12/10/2023 03:57

Basically ....are the people you are comparing yourself to married? Are they both working and do they earn under 51,000 each? Because you should be paying 40 % tax which is a big amount deduction from your 68.000. That would also mean they could be bringing home up to 100,000 and paying a lower tax plus have a bigger income anyway because theirs 2. Makes a big difference. They maybe bought a cheaper house (you can find that info out online what they paid on zoopla) but also like everyone else has said, their parents maybe gave them money or grandparents. But no....its definitely not normal normal pay off a mortgage by 40. Most people take a 25 year mortgage and your friend would have only got that at 18 and would still be paying it into her early 40s.

Katy123456 · 12/10/2023 03:31

On the mortgage and car I'd say your not unusual at all. On the debt, it depends how much. We have had a lot of debt at points - and it felt like everyone else we knew (on a range of salaries) didn't - there's no big reasoning for it, we simply spent more than we had at times. You will not be the only one with other debt. We did prioritise making a plan to clear our car and other debt at one point and mentally it's very freeing. I'd set out two plans to clear debt faster (one to clear the most high interest debt first, one to clear the smallest debt first so mentally it's off your list) - see how they compare and what impact they have on your lifestyle, then choose if you actually want to do it.

Dontworkmondays · 12/10/2023 02:44

Do you know their true financial position? Ie is this based it on your unique position of seeing the accounts of clients you are working on? If not, you don’t know what their debt status is. I’m 39 have built about £1.5M net in assets, no debt before I got married. My husband has 7 properties, buys expensive watches and cars but is financed to death so is net only about £200k. On the surface everyone thinks he’s the one with the money. If you are in London 68k is only just about enough for a single person to get by. It sounds like you didn’t invest so I don’t need to tell an accountant that’s how you build wealth and why you are behind.

Coffeeismyfriend1 · 11/10/2023 22:11

I’m 39 and LTV ratio on our mortgage is 75%. Nearly everyone I know is similar. Your situation seems relatively normal to me.

Yazo · 11/10/2023 22:08

You don't know for sure people's finances and they sugar coat things. We've been gifted or inherited money, I can't see how anyone could pay off a large mortgage otherwise before even 50 years old tbh. As for not being able to buy a car outright, I disagree with you a bit there. My last car was £4k and still going after 11 years. Expensive cars are never a good investment and if you pay monthly it's a lot of money down the drain!