Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How am I supposed to teach these covid zombies?

304 replies

tapdancingaardvark · 09/10/2023 21:46

Please don't send your children to school with covid. Three times today I've had to speak to normally intelligent, engaged children to find out why they are sitting there apparently stunned into stupor, unable to follow a lesson or even keep their eyes open. Each has told me they have been off with covid but have "recovered" now.

No they have not recovered.

It isn't a badge of honour to send your child in after the mandatory 3 days and say everything is normal if it isn't. These kids need a proper recovery time, relaxing at home until really better, not staggering around in school wasting everyone's time and infecting other people. They can't learn in this state. They won't get better as fast either.

Last week was bad enough, this week I've sent 3 children back home already, and it is only Monday

YABU - its only covid, its only a cold, they can sit there and suffer and get some work done
YANBU - unwell children need to be looked after at home

OP posts:
tapdancingaardvark · 10/10/2023 00:28

Rudderneck · 09/10/2023 23:58

You are vulnerable to covid but not other illnesses?

The management of different respiratory illnesses are exactly the same, at least until you are in poor enough shape that you are looking at hospital admissions, testing gives you no advantages.

covid is potentially a lot more serious than many other illnesses. Covid is a lot more infectious than many other illnesses. Covid needs to be treated much faster than many other illnesses. I have 48 hours to get treatment or I am likely to be hospitalised. Last month I was treated within 48 hours, and still came close to being hospitalised

OP posts:
PrudeyTwoShoes · 10/10/2023 00:34

Not all parents get paid time off to look after their sick children so many won't have a choice, especially in the COL crisis, to keep them at home.

Hawkins0009 · 10/10/2023 00:38

all the best op

Nanny0gg · 10/10/2023 00:38

Almahart · 09/10/2023 21:54

YANBU but we got a letter from school a couple of weeks ago saying that unless your child is vomiting or has a high temperature they have to go to school.

Obviously I ignored that, but lots of people won't.

What can they do if you ignore them?

ZiriForEver · 10/10/2023 00:42

Verbena17 · 10/10/2023 00:14

I didn’t mean for that last post to sound mean - I’m just confused as to why anybody is bothering to test.

Like, say if the government’s told whoever to stop producing any more tests - so nobody could get hold of one. What would people do? Wouldn’t they just simply manage their cold/fly just as before (and currently)…..at home and go to A&E if it turned into pneumonia etc, just as they would have before 2020?

For many people recovering from COVID takes longer than from normal cold. It is useful to get the info soon, so you pay more attention or plan for more recovery.
There is treatment for those most vulnerable which has to be administered fast. If you have someone like that around you, your own positive test can help diagnosing them fast.

If the government said that, people can smuggle tests to the UK. I don't think the border dogs are trained to sniff covid tests.

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/10/2023 01:02

gotomomo · 09/10/2023 21:59

It might be because they need to be in world do they can afford food!

Not everyone can stay home with a mildly ill child. My dp had it recently and it really couldn't be called illness now, unless you are specifically vulnerable, 3 days off is plenty

A healthy 29 year old with no underlying conditions died in my town from it.

It's simply ignorant to say it couldn't be called an illness now.

tapdancingaardvark · 10/10/2023 05:06

Verbena17 · 10/10/2023 00:04

So if you’re vulnerable, do you also test for colds?

Or if your throat is the first symptom of feeling poorly? Or if you have a headache? I’m genuinely interested at what point do you pull out a ‘fraudulent’ covid test?

Because aren’t the ‘symptoms’ of what they like to call ‘Covid’, the same as pretty much every other respiratory sickness/cold/tonsillitis/flu?

They might be similar, but in me, and in many other people are quite distinctive

OP posts:
tapdancingaardvark · 10/10/2023 05:08

PurpleWisteria1 · 09/10/2023 23:58

Are you a teacher? You are coming across as totally out of touch with parents and what’s actually happening the other side of the curtain.

I am a teacher and a parent.

I care not one whit if my children's absences are recorded as "unauthorised"

OP posts:
tapdancingaardvark · 10/10/2023 05:11

Verbena17 · 10/10/2023 00:14

I didn’t mean for that last post to sound mean - I’m just confused as to why anybody is bothering to test.

Like, say if the government’s told whoever to stop producing any more tests - so nobody could get hold of one. What would people do? Wouldn’t they just simply manage their cold/fly just as before (and currently)…..at home and go to A&E if it turned into pneumonia etc, just as they would have before 2020?

The government is still providing tests. The government is still recording test results. Vulnerable people still need to know ASAP if they have covid to get the treatment as fast as possible. People are still turning up in A and E with covid, needing the correct treatment - of course testing is still widely available at home and in medical settings. Why would it ever not be? It will always be needed, it will always be available.

OP posts:
PriOn1 · 10/10/2023 05:40

I expect it’s a combination of things.

Parents probably treat letters the school send out as if the school means it, especially if they think there’s a risk of prosecution.

If the school doesn’t mean it, then they need to start objecting strongly to Offsted and campaign against the current ridiculous attendance paranoia that the UK has. Of course parents threatened with fines and bribed with attendance prizes will send in sick children. Don’t blame the parents for something Offsted and the school have created.

In addition, the UK has an appalling attitude to workers. There should be statutory days off available for parents to look after sick children. Where I live, parents each get ten days off each year to look after their sick children. Getting extra childcare for a sick child is not feasible, and it’s now very difficult for parents to live on one wage. Women are now expected to work but the attendance at work ethic hasn’t changed to reflect this. People are also expected to drag themselves in when sick, thus spreading everything, all the time.

The system is to blame, not the parents.

NoMor · 10/10/2023 05:41

Poor communication is key. If the schools have to send out threatening letters but they can be ignored TELL THE PARENTS THAT.

I can attest that the threatening letter for non-attendance after my daughter's mental breakdown and suicide attempt was the last thing I needed! A quick email in advance to tell me it's only a formality would have been nice!

You seem to think that everyone should know this but they clearly don't so obviously schools need to use a bit of common sense and show a little empathy and make sure parents know and are reminded that sometimes they should ignore letters from the school. Stop complaining to us and start complaining to Ofsted!

jays · 10/10/2023 05:43

Covid aside, if attendance isn’t a badge of honour, perhaps schools shouldn’t hand out award certificates to pupils for top attendance. That’s literally a badge of honour.

Year13novice · 10/10/2023 05:46

My kids have been told they can’t go to prom unless they have a certain number of “points”. Any time off means points are deducted and they can gain points from individual teachers for good work etc. Mine has had points deducted for going to the orthodontist as well as being off with what seemed like covid but wasn’t and currently has negative points and is already stressing about prom… it’s a bit shit!

Lastchancechica · 10/10/2023 05:55

Op you are not being realistic at all - I
understand your personal health concerns but non attendance can and does lead to court action and potential custody. You can’t dismiss that prospect op. For most parents it’s very stressful having a child sick for longer than a day or two.

I am on day 21 with this new covid strain. I am still like a zombie, what happens then? Three weeks is clearly too long to take off school and yet I am still ill. So what do parents do? Sadly the world no longer stops just because we are ill. I wish it did. I am sure those poor children wish it did. I hope you are showing them some kindness, this thing is absolutely ghastly.

GreenVelvetCushions · 10/10/2023 06:10

Perhaps their parents have to go to work op.

need2findwork · 10/10/2023 06:11

our school is that mad that the attendance officer will do a home visit after 3 days off! We had that twice in the last year as DC has a health condition which required some more time off then usual then the letters. We have been in hospital for a month... and then got letters to threaten us to take us to court.

Your school may be lax. Ours isn't.

picturethispatsy · 10/10/2023 06:15

Year13novice · 10/10/2023 05:46

My kids have been told they can’t go to prom unless they have a certain number of “points”. Any time off means points are deducted and they can gain points from individual teachers for good work etc. Mine has had points deducted for going to the orthodontist as well as being off with what seemed like covid but wasn’t and currently has negative points and is already stressing about prom… it’s a bit shit!

Controlling much?!
What a shit way to deal with young people 😞

wedonttalkaboutyouno · 10/10/2023 06:33

Back in the ‘Covid days’ when they still did online learning for children that needed it, my DS had a positive test on two occasions, and had to follow the government guidance of staying at home (I can’t remember how long it was for at that time, but we followed the rules!), so he did online learning with school every day of his absence. We still received a letter about his attendance, stating that his education will have been impacted by his poor attendance, and he could not afford to have any more time off basically!
I suppose with your way of thinking, we should have just ignored the government guidance of the day, as knowing it was just nonsense.

Wheelz46 · 10/10/2023 06:46

The secondary schools in our area penalise children who do not have 100% attendance. They get treat days, trips away, awards and the awards are very appealing to the children.

This isn't anything to do with OFSTED, it's school encouraging kids to come to school sick because believe me it's usually the parents saying 'sorry you are too ill for school today' and the child having a breakdown because they don't want to miss out on all the fun 100% stuff. Totally needs abolishing!

IncomingTraffic · 10/10/2023 06:48

I don’t believe that your school isn’t badgering parents about attendance. The DfE is obsessed with attendance rates (because they’re easy to measure and seem like they should be easily comparable between schools).

Also remember that parents need to work - they do have to make a choice based on being well enough to go.

LadyPenelope68 · 10/10/2023 06:50

MoltenLasagne · 09/10/2023 22:01

I chose YABU but only because this is a direct result of schools being ridiculous about attendance. At our school, if you had a child off for 3 days they'd be actively chasing why they weren't returning and sending threatening letters.

Please don’t blame the schools for these letters, blame OFSTED. We don’t have a choice, we have to send the letters out, most teaching staff I know don’t agree with them.

Rockbird · 10/10/2023 06:53

Agree we are obliged to send these letters. We don't want sick children in school, we send plenty of them home when they're clearly too sick to be there. The letters are usually box ticking but we have to do it. We are well aware of the families that actually need intervention due to non attendance and it isn't the ones wh

Rockbird · 10/10/2023 06:54

who are sick.

CornedBeef451 · 10/10/2023 06:55

I kept DD off for a week with Covid as she was exhausted and have had the mandatory letter.

It's very annoying as she caught it at school, likely off her English teacher.

I have a colleague who is very proud that his DCs always have 100% attendance but it does make me wonder how they manage it as surely they must be ill during the year?

TiredandLate · 10/10/2023 06:59

I'm so glad I saw this thread today! The 3 years of being hounded by school about my teenagers attendance are over! The phone calls demanding I get transcripts of GP telephone appointments, asking for written proof from her consultants (not just evidence of the appointment), asking me to film her seizures as proof I'm not a lazy lying slacker who cba sending her in, it's all just a pretend game we've been playing. Phew. Thank you OP. I can't wait to tell them.