Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How am I supposed to teach these covid zombies?

304 replies

tapdancingaardvark · 09/10/2023 21:46

Please don't send your children to school with covid. Three times today I've had to speak to normally intelligent, engaged children to find out why they are sitting there apparently stunned into stupor, unable to follow a lesson or even keep their eyes open. Each has told me they have been off with covid but have "recovered" now.

No they have not recovered.

It isn't a badge of honour to send your child in after the mandatory 3 days and say everything is normal if it isn't. These kids need a proper recovery time, relaxing at home until really better, not staggering around in school wasting everyone's time and infecting other people. They can't learn in this state. They won't get better as fast either.

Last week was bad enough, this week I've sent 3 children back home already, and it is only Monday

YABU - its only covid, its only a cold, they can sit there and suffer and get some work done
YANBU - unwell children need to be looked after at home

OP posts:
Verbena17 · 09/10/2023 23:14

Poorly children should obviously be at home in bed but I do wonder why people are still testing for ‘Covid’ 🤔.

Aside from the fact that so many academies are saying any attendance below 95% is unacceptable, nobody needs to or is required to test!

Why, as soon as anyone is getting cold symptoms, are they doing covid tests?

If say for some sensible reason, you didn’t test, wouldn’t you simply assume you had a cold?

TooOldForThisNonsense · 09/10/2023 23:14

Kids should be at home if they are too ill to be at school. For any illness, nothing special about Covid.

Todaysproblem · 09/10/2023 23:14

tapdancingaardvark · 09/10/2023 22:05

I just don't understand why anyone would pay it the slightest attention- ignore it! ignore it! ignore it!

Mmm… it’s not just the letters, we were told by phone call to try to send in ill child and see how they get on for attendance purposes. That’s harder to ignore! ignore! ignore!

Softnatural · 09/10/2023 23:16

But there is a "badge of honour" when the school is handing out attendance awards and putting pressure on parents and children over % attendance targets.

Boomboom22 · 09/10/2023 23:20

Also about average attendance. By pestering all the good parents to send conscientious kids who would catch up anyway in it can slightly mask the ones who essentially bunk or whose parents can't be bothered or who need them home to help parent younger siblings etc.

Hibiscrubbed · 09/10/2023 23:24

tapdancingaardvark · 09/10/2023 21:59

why do any parents pay any attention to that? It is just a letter that ofsted insists schools send out - it doesn't mean anything to the parents or to the school

Well, it does when schools adopt the ludicrous practice of rewarding the children with 100% attendance, thus penalising the chronically ill and unlucky.

Jennybeans401 · 09/10/2023 23:28

It's the attendance letters, they are quite scary and if your child is unlucky to catch all the winter viruses the attendance will drop quickly. This is why you've got Covid zombies.

Starlightstarbright2 · 09/10/2023 23:28

Yes it’s pointless - a sick child spreads virus’s / bugs so more children are off .

I attended my Ds’s college induction the other day . They talked about expecting 100% attendance.. My Ds already doesn’t because he had a cold / temperature - not Covid and for those who ask - I work in a workplace expected to test with symptoms - still provided by government. Lots also test due to vulnerable relatives.

The point about babysitting is a dumb comment also .. of course it is childcare.. obviously ideal world parents stay home look after sick child but some people can’t afford to or it is looked down by employers .

anunlikelyseahorse · 09/10/2023 23:29

I guess you're not teaching in England then OP, because it's the LEA not Ofstead that deal with attendance. Sure ofstead can make a big song and dance about attendance levels, but I'm pretty sure it's the LEA who set the target for each school, and get arsey with the school's head, if the school falls below that acceptable level.

barbieofswanlake · 09/10/2023 23:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ZiriForEver · 09/10/2023 23:36

That's a complete madness. I know you in the UK are used to blindly follow whatever nonsense the school announces (I can't imagine school telling me that the child can't come or leave the school alone - it is parental responsibility, school policy just can't go beyond the law).

However, with COVID being known to take longer to recover and come with a bigger risk of long term health effects, effectively forcing the young population to contract it again and again just to be able to declare it is politically over should be seen as a criminal behaviour.

(My country has less strict attendance rules and the GP can prescribe a parent a sick-care leave for a week and half, which isn't technically a 100% pay, but for lower income levels it is very close. Of course our system has other flaws and we don't do enough either, but at least our rules don't make it worse on industrial scale)

AhhSlippedOnMahBeansRitaaa · 09/10/2023 23:37

Last week I was told by school to take my kids in even if the COVID test was positive.

tapdancingaardvark · 09/10/2023 23:40

Verbena17 · 09/10/2023 23:14

Poorly children should obviously be at home in bed but I do wonder why people are still testing for ‘Covid’ 🤔.

Aside from the fact that so many academies are saying any attendance below 95% is unacceptable, nobody needs to or is required to test!

Why, as soon as anyone is getting cold symptoms, are they doing covid tests?

If say for some sensible reason, you didn’t test, wouldn’t you simply assume you had a cold?

I tested because I am vulnerable. My children were ill at the same time, presumably with the same thing. If a group or family all have it at once, and one is vulnerable and tests positive, then the assumption is they all have the same thing. At school if 4 children on a table of 6 all fall ill within 48 hours of each other, and one has a vulnerable person in their family and tests positive, then the assumption is they all have the same thing. If you fall ill knowing you have been in close contact with covid, you might choose to test. If you have a bad unknown illness with horrible symptoms that wont go away, and you want to know what is going on, you may test. If you have a medical appointment, or go to A and E because you are so unwell, you might test. Many reasons

OP posts:
ReadingSoManyThreads · 09/10/2023 23:41

Whilst I absolutely agree with you that parents should not be sending unwell children into school, I however think schools are pretty hypocritical for the following reasons:

  1. Their militant stance on attendance.
  2. Their hosting of the live flu vaccine sprays in schools, spreading the live flu virus around from the shedding.
Bagpuss2022 · 09/10/2023 23:45

My son was constantly sent home high blood sugars low blood sugars phoning to pick him up as he’s not “well” enough to be in school it was a symptom of his condition type 1 diabetes and still got the “letters”
obviously education is important but I feel more and more parents are being dictated to by schools. He’s just doing his masters now whilst management of his condition. really glad I’m not a parent to reception kids as they seem worse

Fairysteps11 · 09/10/2023 23:52

My daughter was off last week for 4 days. I've, just this morning, received a letter from school stating that if there are absences without proof then they will go as unauthorised. It also stated on the letter that maybe my child has a undiagnosed illness and that they would appreciate me trying to help her back into school.
She was very ill with a sore chest and throat, headache and had a temperature. I cannot change that to suit the schools attendance records. I would rather my child feel fit and well, not crying because they feel like rubbish warmed up. I would also rather not lose out on a weeks wages.
The schools need to realise that parents are doing the best we can. We are torn between our children's wellbeing, losing money by not working and the judgement from schools.
They are our children and we should be able to keep our children off, should we see fit without threatening letters from Attendance Officers.
If schools don't want parents bringing their still unwell child to school, stop with the attendance harassment and judgement!!!

Rudderneck · 09/10/2023 23:55

YABU.

I know many teachers hate the whole "babysitting" idea, but that is how our society has been set up. Almost always, both parents have to work, many people don't live near their families for help with childcare, and many grandparents and other relatives work anyway. Parents are limited i the time they can take off.

I thought it became abundantly apparent during the pandemic that expecting that to be a sustainable system was foolish, but it is the system we have.

It's also not always clear to parents how sick a child is. Some kids seem much perkier first thing, or will pretend to be better. Other kids are malingerers and so it is difficult to judge when they are really ill. Some kids have a snotty nose half the year, especially the first year or so of school, or if they are prone to allergies, and sometimes it's hard to tell if they are really ill or just having an allergy flare up.

Fionaville · 09/10/2023 23:55

My sons old high school wrote on attendance emails to send kids in when they are ill with a cold or Covid. And that they would have to learn to work through these illnesses for when they are in the workforce. Like they could actually learn and retain information when they aren't well. It's just an attendance, box ticking exercise.
I have never sent my kids in when they are ill and never would. It actually pisses me off when people do.

theduchessofspork · 09/10/2023 23:56

KickHimInTheCrotch · 09/10/2023 21:53

I agree with you in principle but threatening emails from the school about attendance including advice to send them in with covid unless obviously unwell is contradictory.

Plus most parents have to work to pay the bills. If the kid ain't puking they need to be in school realistically.

This and this

Life is tough, innit

PurpleWisteria1 · 09/10/2023 23:58

tapdancingaardvark · 09/10/2023 22:07

because there are clearly people here who take stupid attendance policies seriously, or are using school as a babysitting service for sick children - and the problem is wide spread, nit confined to one school or area

Are you a teacher? You are coming across as totally out of touch with parents and what’s actually happening the other side of the curtain.

Rudderneck · 09/10/2023 23:58

tapdancingaardvark · 09/10/2023 23:40

I tested because I am vulnerable. My children were ill at the same time, presumably with the same thing. If a group or family all have it at once, and one is vulnerable and tests positive, then the assumption is they all have the same thing. At school if 4 children on a table of 6 all fall ill within 48 hours of each other, and one has a vulnerable person in their family and tests positive, then the assumption is they all have the same thing. If you fall ill knowing you have been in close contact with covid, you might choose to test. If you have a bad unknown illness with horrible symptoms that wont go away, and you want to know what is going on, you may test. If you have a medical appointment, or go to A and E because you are so unwell, you might test. Many reasons

You are vulnerable to covid but not other illnesses?

The management of different respiratory illnesses are exactly the same, at least until you are in poor enough shape that you are looking at hospital admissions, testing gives you no advantages.

clappyjay · 10/10/2023 00:02

There’s emphasis on attendance that then continues on into the world of work. I’ve had the phone slammed down on me for phoning in sick to work with flu before despite rarely having time off. There is this attitude that people should power through, anyone who phones in sick is ‘skiving’ or being lazy.

Verbena17 · 10/10/2023 00:04

tapdancingaardvark · 09/10/2023 23:40

I tested because I am vulnerable. My children were ill at the same time, presumably with the same thing. If a group or family all have it at once, and one is vulnerable and tests positive, then the assumption is they all have the same thing. At school if 4 children on a table of 6 all fall ill within 48 hours of each other, and one has a vulnerable person in their family and tests positive, then the assumption is they all have the same thing. If you fall ill knowing you have been in close contact with covid, you might choose to test. If you have a bad unknown illness with horrible symptoms that wont go away, and you want to know what is going on, you may test. If you have a medical appointment, or go to A and E because you are so unwell, you might test. Many reasons

So if you’re vulnerable, do you also test for colds?

Or if your throat is the first symptom of feeling poorly? Or if you have a headache? I’m genuinely interested at what point do you pull out a ‘fraudulent’ covid test?

Because aren’t the ‘symptoms’ of what they like to call ‘Covid’, the same as pretty much every other respiratory sickness/cold/tonsillitis/flu?

Verbena17 · 10/10/2023 00:14

I didn’t mean for that last post to sound mean - I’m just confused as to why anybody is bothering to test.

Like, say if the government’s told whoever to stop producing any more tests - so nobody could get hold of one. What would people do? Wouldn’t they just simply manage their cold/fly just as before (and currently)…..at home and go to A&E if it turned into pneumonia etc, just as they would have before 2020?

AlfredaTheGrape · 10/10/2023 00:18

Plenty of explanation on the thread what the problems with not sending children in might be. I do agree with you in principle if these factors were not included - recovering children OUGHT to be at home recovering in an ideal world. However, I am sure you can find something for them to do that isn't too taxing? Intelligent lively children are allowed off days when they just cruise, just as adults need this sometimes.