Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or did this guy overreact to our dog approaching him?

536 replies

MrsH1992 · 05/10/2023 21:04

So we were walking our doodle on the beach who's about a year old and 4kg. Most the beach is no-dogs allowed in summer but this is the only bit they are allowed on. She's usually really good but sometimes has bad recall if she sees someone she knows. There was a guy in a red coat who I think she mistook for my dad as he has a similar coat/ build and she ran over to him and put her front paws up on his knees. We were running after her apologising when the guy tries to repeatedly stomp and kick her. She ran back to me terrified. This guy is now screaming at us and swearing really badly. He has a little kid with him (maybe three) so we say sorry but he needs to calm down. He then threatened us and was trying to square up to my husband. We're just trying to get round him but he's blocking our way (we need to continue along the shore line to get back to our car). In the end we get past but I was on the verge of calling the police.

So I know some people really don't like dogs and we should have her under control but it was the dog section of the beach plus she's tiny. I think he massively overreacted and shouldn't come to the dog beach if he feels that strongly and is liable to loose his temper like that. AIBU?

OP posts:
Northernladdette · 08/10/2023 10:48

Why refer to it as a Doodle if it’s a Poochon? Big difference, I suspect most mumsnetters would think Labradoodle 🙄

AnneValentine · 08/10/2023 10:46

MrsH1992 · 05/10/2023 21:36

To clarify my dog was 11 months old and usually has perfect recall and on this one occasion did not. She never jumps up at people she does not know apart from this one time which is why I'm sure she mistook this guy for my dad.

For those who asked she's a bichon poodle cross and was 4kg then and 5.4kg now fully grown.

I don't think one isolated incident makes her an 'out if control' dog as most of you seem to think. Even the best trained dog can't be 100% reliable at all times, just like people they can get confused and make mistakes so unless you want all dogs on leads at all times (which would potentially be a fair argument) I will respectfully disagree with most of you.

The person with the dog charging at them does not care about their normal behaviour. They care that they’re being charged at. Keep the dog on a lead if you cannot guarantee control at all times and accept that if your dog isn’t on a lead and is out of control you owe people an apology.

CatMadam · 08/10/2023 10:44

dizzzydeee · 07/10/2023 23:25

YANBU the guy who attacked your dog and lost his shit in front of your kids and his is BU .. No brainier. If you're that scared of a wee dog then stay at home sweetheart because there's way more terrifying things out there than a friendly dog that reaches your knees 😂😂😂

I see you’ve just ignored the many comments on this thread describing how a ‘friendly dog’ attacked them/ their children?

stargazer2012 · 08/10/2023 10:43

Tbh I think you were both unreasonable. This has happened to me with my 3 year old and although the dog was not aggressive but it didn't listen to its owner when recalled. It jumped up onto my child repeatedly and my son was terrified. It took him YEARS to stop being scared of dogs. The owner told us to chill out, the dog 'loved' children etc. Completely irresponsible. To add insult to injury this was in a open planned children's park!
Tbf to you the gentleman shouldn't have squared up , but I suppose he was worried about the child.

Chocolatepiggy · 08/10/2023 10:41

No he shouldn't of squared up or been aggressive towards you or your husband but you should of had control of your dog (doesn't matter what size or age the dog is). They don't know she is harmless, their child could be terrified of dogs. I grew up with dogs but now don't have any and it annoys me no end the entitlement of some dog owners who leave their dogs off lead "they're okay" no they're not, keep her on a lead until you can control her and respect other people around you who don't want to be chased or jumped upon.
Sorry but in this, YBU.

Puffinsandcreeks · 08/10/2023 10:28

*Unfortunately I now know that my dog is probably hated by a lot of people, and probably so am I, because I run with it off the lead and it stops to say hello to lots of dogs and the encounters aren't always 100% friendly. I believe- dogs are dogs, just like humans are humans, and we don't all like each other. (clearly) Plus there are reasons dogs posture up to each other, to establish hierarchy (like humans) - ever hear the phrase "top dog?"

I have no intention of changing my behaviour so I guess just hope you don't have to ever encounter me, or my dog!!*

You sound like a pain in the ass.
If you had bothered to research the species you care for, you would know that hierarchies and notions of top dogs were disproven decades ago.
Why should dogs who dislike being approached by other dogs because of their own trauma (plenty have been bitten by off lead dogs for example) have to deal with people like you? "I have no intentions of changing my behaviour" shows a real level of ignorance and a lack of accountability for needing to have your dog under control in public. Not doing so is breaking the law. Letting it approach lots of dogs isn't always considered under control.

Your own dog is going to get bitten one day because of your lack of awareness and it is entirely your own fault. If the encounters aren't always friendly then stop inflicting them on other people and their dogs. Plenty of adult dogs don't like being approached by dogs that they don't know, that is quite normal.

Alwayswildatheart · 08/10/2023 00:47

Thoroughly fed up with selfish dog owners who do not have their dogs under control in public places.

We cannot walk our reactive dog who is very much under control, including wearing a muzzle, harness, double ended lead in public due to other lazy and ignorant dog owners. Yesterday being an example, leaving the beach. A cavapoo, off lead 5 metres in front of owner, approached us and wouldn't get out of my dog's space. Owners did nothing until I loudly exclaimed "FFS get your dog under control" and when they finally grabbed their little ankle nipper, it reacted by trying to bite them. We, who had both our dogs on the lead, were told we were rude, should not be on the beach with a reactive dog and the man went on to make threats of violence against us.

Yet today a responsible owner who's dog was off lead that my dog reacted to apologised, immediately called her dog back immediately to put his lead on, which in turn calmed my dog on the single track lane we were passing on. We managed to have a civilised and friendly conversation which again defused both owners and dogs.

I implore dog owners to act responsibly with their dogs and take on board humans and some dogs can feel threatened by dogs getting in their personal space.

dizzzydeee · 08/10/2023 00:26

Alwayswildatheart · 08/10/2023 00:19

Your dog is considered dangerously out of control if it:

  • injures someone
  • makes someone worried that it might injure them

Joke right? The guy is dangerous in this scenario

dizzzydeee · 08/10/2023 00:24

Ceebeegee · 08/10/2023 00:04

They other person felt threatened, maybe frightened, i assume. They were probably instinctively protecting themselves and their child from a potential dog attack.
So yes , it's reasonable to assume their response will be highly emotional , and angry.

I think you should read the OP the dog was called back to the owner who apologised. A man stomps on the dog and follows and berates her repeatedly in front of her children and his. But let's all gloss over the fact that a grown ass man was apparently so terrified of a small dog that he was compelled to bully and use his masculinity against a woman? Personally I'd be more scared of the man

MrsH1992 · 08/10/2023 00:22

Ceebeegee · 08/10/2023 00:04

They other person felt threatened, maybe frightened, i assume. They were probably instinctively protecting themselves and their child from a potential dog attack.
So yes , it's reasonable to assume their response will be highly emotional , and angry.

I'm sure they did feel something between fright to annoyance. I guess I don't see why that gives them the justification to try to get aggressive with the owner who's just trying to leave. I can even accept kicking the dog as self defence but once the situation is over (dog in my arms) I don't think they have the right to square up and threaten to punch the owner.

OP posts:
Alwayswildatheart · 08/10/2023 00:19

Your dog is considered dangerously out of control if it:

  • injures someone
  • makes someone worried that it might injure them
Ceebeegee · 08/10/2023 00:04

They other person felt threatened, maybe frightened, i assume. They were probably instinctively protecting themselves and their child from a potential dog attack.
So yes , it's reasonable to assume their response will be highly emotional , and angry.

nocoolnamesleft · 07/10/2023 23:54

dizzzydeee · 07/10/2023 23:25

YANBU the guy who attacked your dog and lost his shit in front of your kids and his is BU .. No brainier. If you're that scared of a wee dog then stay at home sweetheart because there's way more terrifying things out there than a friendly dog that reaches your knees 😂😂😂

You mean an out of control dog that reaches at least the waist of his toddler.

dizzzydeee · 07/10/2023 23:25

YANBU the guy who attacked your dog and lost his shit in front of your kids and his is BU .. No brainier. If you're that scared of a wee dog then stay at home sweetheart because there's way more terrifying things out there than a friendly dog that reaches your knees 😂😂😂

CashewGal · 07/10/2023 21:36

Seriously amazed by all the hate permeating this thread, and the ridiculous comments, like dogs aren't social or interested in each other. Hmm, some animal that is infamous for sniffing the other's bum upon meeting, what could it be, I can't think.

Or just google "are dogs social" and you will get your answer straight away.

And then the over the top fear about a dog touching you, or a dog walking into you. I was knocked to the ground earlier this year by a zippy cocker spaniel and was stunned to find myself on the ground but it didn't even occur to me to get upset at the dog or the owner. And surprise, it was coming to say hi to my dog.

Unfortunately I now know that my dog is probably hated by a lot of people, and probably so am I, because I run with it off the lead and it stops to say hello to lots of dogs and the encounters aren't always 100% friendly. I believe- dogs are dogs, just like humans are humans, and we don't all like each other. (clearly) Plus there are reasons dogs posture up to each other, to establish hierarchy (like humans) - ever hear the phrase "top dog?"

I have no intention of changing my behaviour so I guess just hope you don't have to ever encounter me, or my dog!!

That said, I will always apologise if my dog makes another dog or a person uncomfortable in any way, and put my dog on the lead if I see that dog or person anywhere near us, because that is just common courtesy. But I'd argue that those people should stay away from places where dogs are allowed to be off lead if they are so uncomfortable because unexpected run-ins are inevitable.

And let's keep things in perspective -- other humans are a much greater threat to us all than dogs. Dog attacks are far less frequent per capita.

ChilliNoodleGoodness · 07/10/2023 07:56

People react 'disproportionately' when in fear

DrinkingMyWaterMindingMyBiz · 07/10/2023 01:30

LucieLemon · 07/10/2023 01:16

This is going round in circles .... the question was "did this man overreact" and the answer has been pretty much "probably, but it was in mitigating circumstances"

When approached by an unfamiliar animal there are a range of responses. The man on the beach responded in an extreme manner but none of us can give any insight into why. The only thing that the majority have agreed on is that you had the power to prevent that altercation. Hopefully, since then you've taken measures to avoid a repeat scenario.

This is going round in circles .... the question was "did this man overreact" and the answer has been pretty much "probably, but it was in mitigating circumstances"

And to be honest, the more I read the OPs replies, the less convinced I am that the man actually did all of the things mentioned. The picture I’m getting now is a dog owner doing that lighthearted “he’s just playing” thing that so many dog owners do, expecting the other person to just laugh it off, and being taken aback when he didn’t. If he had just laughed it off, I can almost guarantee that this wouldn’t be the last time OP’s dog jumped up on strangers, because it’s assumed that everyone loves “playful” dogs.

LucieLemon · 07/10/2023 01:16

This is going round in circles .... the question was "did this man overreact" and the answer has been pretty much "probably, but it was in mitigating circumstances"

When approached by an unfamiliar animal there are a range of responses. The man on the beach responded in an extreme manner but none of us can give any insight into why. The only thing that the majority have agreed on is that you had the power to prevent that altercation. Hopefully, since then you've taken measures to avoid a repeat scenario.

LucieLemon · 07/10/2023 01:05

But you did accept it though? I take it you didn't report him to any local authorities or make efforts to identify the man?

nocoolnamesleft · 07/10/2023 01:05

I think you may be on the wrong website. Swearing is acceptable on here. And I have not sworn at you, I have sworn about your dog. I have not used any abusive terms about you. But yes, you seize on a flimsy excuse for a flounce, as this thread isn't going the way you may have expected.

MrsH1992 · 07/10/2023 01:03

nocoolnamesleft · 07/10/2023 00:53

He made no physical contact with you. Your dog made physical contact with him. If you had only controlled your fucking dog none of this would have happened. The problem, yet again, was an irresponsible dog owner: you.

Back to swearing - maybe you could do with a little more control. I won't be replying again as I've told you previously not to swear at me and I don't accept your abusive behaviour just as I don't accept his.

OP posts:
nocoolnamesleft · 07/10/2023 00:53

He made no physical contact with you. Your dog made physical contact with him. If you had only controlled your fucking dog none of this would have happened. The problem, yet again, was an irresponsible dog owner: you.

MrsH1992 · 07/10/2023 00:51

nocoolnamesleft · 07/10/2023 00:48

No, I identify with the victims of dog attacks. As 1)I was knocked over by a dog on one of those dangerous extending leads and nearly went over a cliff, and 2)debriefed a good friend and colleague after he was on the team that tried and failed to save a small child savaged by a dog, some years ago.

Dogs should be under control at all times, and it is grossly irresponsible not to control your dog. This is your fault.

So you think it was ok for this man to verbally abuse us and attempt a physical attack?

OP posts:
SpringViolet · 07/10/2023 00:48

Agree with PP it doesn’t matter what size your dog is, DH was bitten on the leg by a Frenchie this week and is now on a course of antibiotics which he had to pay for obviously and affects his immune system. Dog had never done it before of course and it was a playful nip! Perhaps this man or his child had been previously bitten.

You do know it not a dog beach OP? It’s a beach that allows dogs. Dog owners don’t pay to use it or clear the dog shit from it and humans have more of a right to be there than fricking dogs.

Keep your dog away from people then you won’t be offended that people get cross when you don’t! Dog owners need to read the room. People quite rightly have no patience with badly behaved dogs and idiots who think it’s OK to let their filthy mutt jump on them.

nocoolnamesleft · 07/10/2023 00:48

No, I identify with the victims of dog attacks. As 1)I was knocked over by a dog on one of those dangerous extending leads and nearly went over a cliff, and 2)debriefed a good friend and colleague after he was on the team that tried and failed to save a small child savaged by a dog, some years ago.

Dogs should be under control at all times, and it is grossly irresponsible not to control your dog. This is your fault.