Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or did this guy overreact to our dog approaching him?

536 replies

MrsH1992 · 05/10/2023 21:04

So we were walking our doodle on the beach who's about a year old and 4kg. Most the beach is no-dogs allowed in summer but this is the only bit they are allowed on. She's usually really good but sometimes has bad recall if she sees someone she knows. There was a guy in a red coat who I think she mistook for my dad as he has a similar coat/ build and she ran over to him and put her front paws up on his knees. We were running after her apologising when the guy tries to repeatedly stomp and kick her. She ran back to me terrified. This guy is now screaming at us and swearing really badly. He has a little kid with him (maybe three) so we say sorry but he needs to calm down. He then threatened us and was trying to square up to my husband. We're just trying to get round him but he's blocking our way (we need to continue along the shore line to get back to our car). In the end we get past but I was on the verge of calling the police.

So I know some people really don't like dogs and we should have her under control but it was the dog section of the beach plus she's tiny. I think he massively overreacted and shouldn't come to the dog beach if he feels that strongly and is liable to loose his temper like that. AIBU?

OP posts:
nocoolnamesleft · 05/10/2023 23:47

2024815pm · 05/10/2023 23:45

Has anyone actually read the OP A man attacked her, this isn't really about a wee dog its totally about an angry man getting his own way

Nah, if he'd had his own way he wouldn't have had a strange out of control dog jumping all over him whilst he was on the beach with his toddler.

2024815pm · 05/10/2023 23:45

Has anyone actually read the OP A man attacked her, this isn't really about a wee dog its totally about an angry man getting his own way

MrsH1992 · 05/10/2023 23:41

BotanicalNames · 05/10/2023 21:55

But you said 'She's usually really good but sometimes has bad recall if she sees someone she knows. There was a guy in a red coat who I think she mistook for my dad as he has a similar coat/ build' So she must have had bad recall previously for you to say that - so not just on 'this one occasion'. Don't change your story, we can all read.

How have I changed my story? I always said she had 100% recall with strangers up until that point but not 100% with friends and family. As she had never approached a stranger before and this guy looked just like my dad I assume she got confused. When she saw this guy's face she immediately retreated which is why again I think she was confused. I'm not saying it's ok what she did but just explaining why until this incident we trusted her off lead

OP posts:
2024815pm · 05/10/2023 23:37

I'm totally on your side

Marblessolveeverything · 05/10/2023 23:29

It's basic human instinct to protect the child. If the dog moved they won't be injured if they don't then the child or him could have been bitten.

Every week there is stories of dog attacks. It really is important to keep dogs in leads or right beside you, for their sake.

MrsH1992 · 05/10/2023 23:25

MereDintofPandiculation · 05/10/2023 23:22

I can't help thinking it's a sad that most people seem to think it would be ok to stomp a 4kg puppy that was obviously confused. You don't seem to have read the replies. Saying your dog should have been on a lead for her own safety is not the same as saying it's OK to stomp on a puppy.

My question was did this guy overreact and 77% say no so I assume they think stomping a puppy is ok

OP posts:
Universalsnail · 05/10/2023 23:23

Your dog should be on a lead or long line but he does sound like he needs to get a serious grip and his behaviour was massively inappropriate

MereDintofPandiculation · 05/10/2023 23:22

I can't help thinking it's a sad that most people seem to think it would be ok to stomp a 4kg puppy that was obviously confused. You don't seem to have read the replies. Saying your dog should have been on a lead for her own safety is not the same as saying it's OK to stomp on a puppy.

MrsH1992 · 05/10/2023 23:22

Marblessolveeverything · 05/10/2023 22:29

You are really ignoring the responses. He didn't know your dog, your dog jumped up on him he had no way of knowing if your dog is violent and he had a child.

The idea h could "tell" the dog made a mistake is laughable.

I adore dogs and have had many family pets but I certainly wouldn't be very happy to be jumped on by a strange dog.

I never said he should of known it was a mistake, obviously he would have no idea what the dog is like. I'm just confused why a lot of people are saying I should of known better when this dog had never approached or jumped up at a stranger before. I do think he overreacted as as soon as he looked at her she started running away back to us and he proceeded to try to kick and stomp her chasing towards us.

OP posts:
2024815pm · 05/10/2023 23:18

So a guy being aggressive and physically violent is ok? He kicked the OPs dog

lap90 · 05/10/2023 23:15

His behaviour was extreme but you need to have your dog on a lead.

2024815pm · 05/10/2023 23:11

PandaExpress · 05/10/2023 23:00

He shouldn't have reacted the way he did, but it's you in the wrong here.
It's not always obvious that certain areas of the beach are dog friendly and some aren't. His child could have had a fright from a dog recently or he may have been attacked himself. It doesnt matter, because unless you have perfect recall, your dog should be on a lead.
I don't know what it is about the beach that makes dog owners so irresponsible. You can barely sit on a beach in England, without an uncontrolled dog running round you and jumping all over your stuff. And the owners laugh like it's adorable. It's not. I say all this as a dog owner!

This isn't about a wee dog saying hello anymore. It's about a nasty bully of a guy getting his own way and MN agreeing. You're shameful

ballsdeep · 05/10/2023 23:05

@MrsH1992
i can’t reply but if your dog hasn’t got recall, keep it on the lead .

MrsH1992 · 05/10/2023 23:03

ballsdeep · 05/10/2023 22:39

n. She's usually really good but sometimes has bad recall if she sees someone she knows

you just wrote this in your op so why now are you saying 100% recall? You expected people to go on your side and now you’re changing your stance

I said 100% recall until this point with strangers and that she wasn't 100% when greeting friends and family. Please don't misquote me.

OP posts:
PandaExpress · 05/10/2023 23:00

He shouldn't have reacted the way he did, but it's you in the wrong here.
It's not always obvious that certain areas of the beach are dog friendly and some aren't. His child could have had a fright from a dog recently or he may have been attacked himself. It doesnt matter, because unless you have perfect recall, your dog should be on a lead.
I don't know what it is about the beach that makes dog owners so irresponsible. You can barely sit on a beach in England, without an uncontrolled dog running round you and jumping all over your stuff. And the owners laugh like it's adorable. It's not. I say all this as a dog owner!

MrsH1992 · 05/10/2023 22:57

Jade31 · 05/10/2023 22:52

Shame you wasn’t so arrogant & confrontational during the incident. Since you clearly think you’re in the right 🤷‍♀️😂

My question was did this guy overreact and yer I think I am right that stomping a 4kg puppy is an overreaction...

OP posts:
Jade31 · 05/10/2023 22:52

MrsH1992 · 05/10/2023 21:36

To clarify my dog was 11 months old and usually has perfect recall and on this one occasion did not. She never jumps up at people she does not know apart from this one time which is why I'm sure she mistook this guy for my dad.

For those who asked she's a bichon poodle cross and was 4kg then and 5.4kg now fully grown.

I don't think one isolated incident makes her an 'out if control' dog as most of you seem to think. Even the best trained dog can't be 100% reliable at all times, just like people they can get confused and make mistakes so unless you want all dogs on leads at all times (which would potentially be a fair argument) I will respectfully disagree with most of you.

Shame you wasn’t so arrogant & confrontational during the incident. Since you clearly think you’re in the right 🤷‍♀️😂

easylikeasundaymorn · 05/10/2023 22:51

nobody has said it's okay to stomp a puppy, ffs.

I imagine most people who said/voted YABU also think the guy was BU. Out of the 2 of you, he was probably more unreasonable because his reaction sounds disproportionate for such a small dog.

BUT

if you hadn't caused the issue (by having the dog off lead) then he wouldn't have had the chance to be unreasonable. Also sometimes fear (for himself or his small child) can lead to involuntary inappropriate reactions whereas you don't have that excuse - his reaction was influenced by surprise and possibly fear, you made the decision to leave your dog off lead completely rationally without any pressure/time constrictions.

That's why people are blaming you, and even then nobody thinks your puppy deserves to get stomped.
Just that ultimately it was you that caused the situation, which he then reacted badly to.

Bluecocoon · 05/10/2023 22:51

It isn’t just a dog beach though, it is a human beach which dogs are allowed on. Aka a shared space, so he has as much right to be there as you. It was a strong reaction but maybe there’s a reason for it, keep your dog on the lead if that’s likely to happen again.

LemonWaterSugar · 05/10/2023 22:51

Eugh, I honestly hate taking my toddler walking anywhere at the minute as there are so many "friendly" dogs off the lead doing what the hell they want with owners barely in the vicinity.

Dogs should be on a lead in public places no exceptions.

AvengedQuince · 05/10/2023 22:44

Why have you allowed your dog to think it is acceptable to jump at people it knows or thinks it knows?

KissKiss29 · 05/10/2023 22:43

I don't hate dogs at all but I have a severe allergic reaction and almost always have an asthma exacerbation leading to hospitalisation when I am around dogs. It is such a pain when someone's dog comes up to me and I start getting itchy and wheezy.

My DS at 6 months and is suspected to have a similar problems. A dog came up to him recently and jumped on him, my reaction was to freeze but I could easily have hit the dog if I thought my son was going to be in hospital because of it.

StarDolphins · 05/10/2023 22:42

Bigcoatweather · 05/10/2023 22:33

I’m curious as to why other people should tolerate my dogs running and jumping at them?

They shouldn’t. I don’t ever let my dog do this & I think op should’ve 100% had her dog either on lead or with recall at 100%.

Wgat is irrational is comments like what if the toddler was pushed over by the dog & it was brain damaged & that the dog was violent & attacked the man. Worst case neurotic replies.

Yes the dog ‘could’ve’ knocked them over & killed them on tarmac beach or ‘what if’ the dog had eaten them all’ you know, like all the stories in the news. None of this happened.

SemperIdem · 05/10/2023 22:39

I have a bichon poodle cross. They really are very small dogs.

Similarly, mine has brilliant recall - until he doesn’t. They’re exuberant and sociable dogs by nature. I don’t let him off lead because of this.

I live in a diverse area, so perhaps I’m extra mindful about not letting my dog approach people willy nilly, I bring him closer when passing people etc. Ultimately, it doesn’t matter how tiny and cute my dog is, not everyone likes dogs and size doesn’t matter.

Lots of young children are wary of dogs, it’s important to me that my dog doesn’t contribute to their fearfulness and is instead a positive experience. Often that positive experience seems to be simply that they can pass by without being jumped at/on.

IcedBananas · 05/10/2023 22:39

Control your f-ing dog. The 3 year old could have been badly injured and terrified for life if he’d been jumped on by your dog. The problem with dogs is all the irresponsible owners who think this sort of stuff is okay because their dog is harmless and their dog would never hurt anyone. It does hurt and scare people when an animal suddenly appears charging at you and jumping on you and we don’t know if your dog bites until we’re bitten do we? So just keep the dog on a leash in public.