Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or did this guy overreact to our dog approaching him?

536 replies

MrsH1992 · 05/10/2023 21:04

So we were walking our doodle on the beach who's about a year old and 4kg. Most the beach is no-dogs allowed in summer but this is the only bit they are allowed on. She's usually really good but sometimes has bad recall if she sees someone she knows. There was a guy in a red coat who I think she mistook for my dad as he has a similar coat/ build and she ran over to him and put her front paws up on his knees. We were running after her apologising when the guy tries to repeatedly stomp and kick her. She ran back to me terrified. This guy is now screaming at us and swearing really badly. He has a little kid with him (maybe three) so we say sorry but he needs to calm down. He then threatened us and was trying to square up to my husband. We're just trying to get round him but he's blocking our way (we need to continue along the shore line to get back to our car). In the end we get past but I was on the verge of calling the police.

So I know some people really don't like dogs and we should have her under control but it was the dog section of the beach plus she's tiny. I think he massively overreacted and shouldn't come to the dog beach if he feels that strongly and is liable to loose his temper like that. AIBU?

OP posts:
TwoBoyMamma · 06/10/2023 12:12

Yabu you say your dog has bad recall keep it on a lead - I don’t care if you say it does it if it knows someone clearly not as it mistook this man for someone he wasn’t. I dread to think if this was a xl bully it’d been put down for such behaviour! His behaviour was wrong but your actions prompted it and sometimes you gotta face up to it you was in the wrong hopefully you’ve learnt from it

Cosyblankets · 06/10/2023 12:09

If her recall is poor keep her on the lead for her own safety.
Yes he over reacted
Yes she should be on a lead

Hernameisdeborah · 06/10/2023 12:07

That man definitely overreacted and i certainly don't think trying to kick and stomp a small dog is justified in any circumstances.

cheddercherry · 06/10/2023 11:02

His reaction was extreme and not ok BUT you shouldn’t have your dog off a lead if it’s got bad recall. End of. Then there’d have been nothing for him to react to.

So sick of dogs jumping at me in parks and on beaches and owners passively shouting “oh they’re friendly”. It’s not on me to know your dog jumping at me isn’t a threat (but at the very least is a nuisance). My little boy doesn’t like dogs for the very reason that they constantly have jumped up and ran at him in places he loves like the park and beach while their owners watch from afar. It’s exhausting, especially if you KNOW your dog has these tendencies.

phoenixrosehere · 06/10/2023 09:52

MrsBinx · 06/10/2023 08:35

So many precious pathetic people terrified of a tiny puppy. How do you all cope in every day life? Such an over the top response.

Dogs don’t have to be terrifying for people not to want them running up or touching them whatever their size. Small dogs bite too.

It is not difficult to keep a dog on a lead in a public place. Agree the guy overreacted but OP should have kept her dog on a lead so the encounter wouldn’t have happened in the first place.

Booksandwine80 · 06/10/2023 09:50

He overreacted but the dog shouldn’t be off lead. I’m personally sick of off lead dogs wandering everywhere, particularly down the middle of the road 🙄then shitting everywhere because they’re not in site of the owner.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 06/10/2023 09:47

onlyoneoftheregimentinstep · 05/10/2023 21:08

Your dog should not be off the lead unless he has perfect recall. End of.

This.

I'd be bloody annoyed if someone's dog ran up to me too, even if they thought I was their owner.

However, I wouldn't be on a dog-friendly beach.

I also agree that given some of the aggressive and reactive dogs around these days, you need to protect your dog, too.

Also, if people kept their dogs on leads more often they might not lose them as often (perhaps not so much of an issue on a beach).

GladAllOver · 06/10/2023 09:44

I'm not frightened of dogs, but if that happened to me when I was walking with a small child I would have reacted in just the same way. I hope you have learned from this.

flaxensunshine · 06/10/2023 09:36

LakieLady · 06/10/2023 08:53

Your daxie is too heavy to be a miniature! The breed standard is 11lbs max, and yours is over 13lbs.

I used to know a dachshund breeder who used to show her dogs, and I'm sure she told me that they are weighed at shows and disqualified if they're over 11lbs.

I don’t show him thanks! They need to be 5kg to show them but plenty are bigger (and smaller) than that!!!

Alika · 06/10/2023 09:22

Your "small puppy" will still be terrifying to someone scared of dogs. Just because you think they're small, cute and harmless, that doesn't apply to everyone.

I wouldn't have lost it or hurt the dog, but I would have had some stern words for both of you, as my own toddler would have been in full meltdown for goodness knows how long after that, and as a previous dog owner I wouldn't have my dog off lead around strangers if something minor like a red coat causes them to run off and not listen to you.

The other issue for us would have been our dog (always on a short lead). She would have attacked any dog who came that close. I can't recall how many times dogs who "usually had perfect recall" or were "just friendly" bounded up to ours while the owner ignored our shouts of "our dog isn't friendly" along with the short lead and notice we had on it to warn other owners.

Vistada · 06/10/2023 09:13

LakieLady · 06/10/2023 08:53

Your daxie is too heavy to be a miniature! The breed standard is 11lbs max, and yours is over 13lbs.

I used to know a dachshund breeder who used to show her dogs, and I'm sure she told me that they are weighed at shows and disqualified if they're over 11lbs.

Mine was sold to me as a mini and hes now 7.3kg (very lithe so he is just big built) - when I see him next to other minis I'm like awww yes hun you're half and half at a push.

Tbf i've since learnt there's no such thing as a true mini really, they just keep breeding the smallest of each litter

CatMadam · 06/10/2023 09:12

@2024815pm why so condescending? And what’s with all the personal attacks? It really doesn’t help your case at all.

Y7jahbb33 · 06/10/2023 09:11

He shouldnt of threatened you or your husband but your dogs size is irrelevant. Smaller dogs can be aggressive too

There is a small dog near ours that is always loose, barking at people, chasing and nipping them. Its smaller than a spaniel but it's still scary.

Keep your dog on a lead, you can buy all sorts of long leads

Sloth66 · 06/10/2023 09:06

He should not have reacted like that, but you say your dog put its paws on him and had no recall. Why wasn’t your dog on a lead?

Puffinsandcreeks · 06/10/2023 09:02

Again we have her on lead now but I don't know how we could have predicted this event from a perfect track record unless you think no dog should ever be off lead which may be a fair argument - not to say it was ok but I do think it was a disproportionate reaction for a minor wrong.

I think posters are saying this as you've said your dog will run up to people that they know, and this person resembled your dad.
My dog would take extra interest in people that he thought he knew when he was young, so he either stayed on lead (short or long) unless I had eyes everywhere and if I spotted somebody I thought he might approach, he was straight back on.

You have no idea what this guy's experiences of off lead dogs are either, in fairness. This might be a one off for you but maybe not for him, it could happen a lot.

Once upon a time I'd love a friendly dog running up to me and saying hi. Nowadays, when I have a child, and a dog that doesn't like other dogs running over (he's been bitten by so many), it annoys me. It happens so, so often. I don't engage with the dog but I do quietly judge the owner if they aren't apologetic (which it sounds as though you are!). Not so quietly if they're making no efforts to recall their off lead dog from my on lead one. If the dog is medium sized or above I will usually block it from getting to my DC because I don't like her being approached by dogs that we don't know.

Dulra · 06/10/2023 09:02

go to the no dog beach... A beach is a beach no idea where you are but I have never seen beaches sectioned off as dogs and no dogs. Every beach I have ever been on have signs saying dogs must be kept on a lead. Yes most people ignore them but it is my expectation as a non dog owner that people should keep their dogs on a lead on beaches so no idea why this guy and his child should be expected to go to a different section of the beach because dog owners are not sticking to the rules.

I agree that the guys reaction was over the top, so much so, I wonder has it been exaggerated?

LakieLady · 06/10/2023 08:56

Your dog was in the wrong, but the guy's reaction was totally disproportionate, especially with such a tiny dog.

Trying to kick a dog is an excellent way to get bitten.

MrsH1992 · 06/10/2023 08:54

Bellaboo01 · 06/10/2023 08:46

It's not a 'dog beach' though. It is part of the beach which allows dogs.

Have your dog on the lead if he runs off at the sight of a red coat.

I'm not saying it's a dog beach, I'm just saying if you're the sort of person who will physically try to beat people up from a dog interaction maybe go to the no dog beach - which by us is almost all of it. Again we have her on lead now but I don't know how we could have predicted this event from a perfect track record unless you think no dog should ever be off lead which may be a fair argument - not to say it was ok but I do think it was a disproportionate reaction for a minor wrong.

OP posts:
LakieLady · 06/10/2023 08:53

flaxensunshine · 05/10/2023 21:20

I have a miniature dachshund who is 6kg so I highly doubt yours is 4kg!!

keep on the lead! But yes he shouldn’t have threatened you!

Your daxie is too heavy to be a miniature! The breed standard is 11lbs max, and yours is over 13lbs.

I used to know a dachshund breeder who used to show her dogs, and I'm sure she told me that they are weighed at shows and disqualified if they're over 11lbs.

LucieLemon · 06/10/2023 08:51

At 11 months old I don't think your dog was old enough to establish that they had perfect recall, therefore should have been on a leash for their safety as well as the public.

The man's reaction was extreme and if that reaction had been towards your child that had run up to him, I would say he was in the wrong and a violent, dangerous individual. However, it was towards your dog and that does put a different perspective on things. As extreme as his reaction was there is a possibility it was motivated by fear, and his flight, fight, freeze response was in full swing. Off this isolated incident it would be unfair to demonise the man.

You may be confident in your dogs behaviour, but this is a perfect example of how we don't know how others will react or respond. We can only control what's in our power, and on that occasion you hadn't taken all measures that you could have, regardless of the reasoning behind that.

Puffinsandcreeks · 06/10/2023 08:49

It does sound like the guy over reacted but having a dog not responding to recall in public is breaking the law. Doesn't matter if they're on the dog beach. Fortunately as your dog is so little they did not run up to a dog on lead that doesn't like incoming dogs. Just take it as a learning curve.

If you've taken measures to prevent this happening in future such as using a long lead then there's no issues going forward. You've learnt from it. It is the people who see this happen once and then allow it to continue happening, that are a problem. Mistakes happen but if they happen continously then they aren't mistakes.

Your dog is an adolescent and you are likely to have occasional recall wobbles until they are two years old, even with plenty of training and reinforcement. Once they're an adult their behaviour can become slightly more predictable on a day to day basis.

MrsH1992 · 06/10/2023 08:49

Bellaboo01 · 06/10/2023 08:44

What cross is a doodle out of interest? Poodle i assume but, with what. Just generally interested as i love dogs.

Poochon - bichon poodle cross 🙂

OP posts:
Bellaboo01 · 06/10/2023 08:46

It's not a 'dog beach' though. It is part of the beach which allows dogs.

Have your dog on the lead if he runs off at the sight of a red coat.

Bellaboo01 · 06/10/2023 08:44

What cross is a doodle out of interest? Poodle i assume but, with what. Just generally interested as i love dogs.

FastBlueHedgehog · 06/10/2023 08:43

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 06/10/2023 08:41

I say the same every time a woman complains about my manspreading*.

I say “why are you so terrified of my thighs, they’re just legs love” I mean most people have two of them, and we encounter them every day, it’s not like I’m kicking them.

Weirdly the women don’t react kindly to that and look at me with disgust and sometimes say hurtful things. So over the top.

*Of course I don’t do this, I keep my legs close to myself and under control at all times because I’m not a twat.

🤣🤣🤣 I think I sat next to you on a train earlier this week