Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or did this guy overreact to our dog approaching him?

536 replies

MrsH1992 · 05/10/2023 21:04

So we were walking our doodle on the beach who's about a year old and 4kg. Most the beach is no-dogs allowed in summer but this is the only bit they are allowed on. She's usually really good but sometimes has bad recall if she sees someone she knows. There was a guy in a red coat who I think she mistook for my dad as he has a similar coat/ build and she ran over to him and put her front paws up on his knees. We were running after her apologising when the guy tries to repeatedly stomp and kick her. She ran back to me terrified. This guy is now screaming at us and swearing really badly. He has a little kid with him (maybe three) so we say sorry but he needs to calm down. He then threatened us and was trying to square up to my husband. We're just trying to get round him but he's blocking our way (we need to continue along the shore line to get back to our car). In the end we get past but I was on the verge of calling the police.

So I know some people really don't like dogs and we should have her under control but it was the dog section of the beach plus she's tiny. I think he massively overreacted and shouldn't come to the dog beach if he feels that strongly and is liable to loose his temper like that. AIBU?

OP posts:
enchantedsquirrelwood · 06/10/2023 17:55

BigDahliaFan · 06/10/2023 12:23

His reaction was competely disproportionate and he was in the wrong. Unfortunately though there are dog hating gits out there - so you do need to train the dog.

Your lifestyle choices should not have a disproportionately adverse effect on others.

Train dogs and keep them on short leads (not those infernal extendable ones) so they don't inconvenience others (including other people with dogs).

CashewGal · 06/10/2023 17:44

@Lostcotter "people feel others shouldn’t get a dog if they don’t have their own space for it because they feel private premises and private space are where (off-lead) dogs should get to spend a lot of their time."

Says who? Dogs are social creatures, they want to interact with other dogs. If you want to see badly behaved dogs go to the countryside where they are used to roaming their own patch and don't know how to deal with other dogs.

MrsH1992 · 06/10/2023 17:39

DrinkingMyWaterMindingMyBiz · 06/10/2023 17:29

@MrsH1992 it’s very clear that you don’t think you were BU at all, not many people can see it from your perspective but you were the only one who was truly there, so that’s fair enough, but I have to ask - if you’re so sure that you were not being unreasonable, why did you start the thread?

I agree the dog 100% should not have done it and that was on us, I guess my original question was that I think it was an unreasonable and disproportionate response from the man based on what the encounter was to then try to attack the dog, verbally attack us and physically threaten both of us - it's genuinely the closest I've ever felt to being punched and I think if we hadn't made a quick get away he would of got physical. I am super surprised that the majority feel this was a reasonable reaction but there you, I'm clearly in the minority.

OP posts:
Spanne · 06/10/2023 17:38

The question was did the bloke overreact. The answer can only be yes. There was absolutely no reason for him to try and start a fight. No one would be making excuses for a man being aggressive for anything other than something dog related.

Lostcotter · 06/10/2023 17:33

I always find it odd that in this country so many people think it is so inhumane to keep a dog that doesn't have a garden, or a cat that stays indoors, yet when you do give the animal freedom all you hear is moaning about it. I find the UK extremely anti-dog.

It’s not odd unless you are missing the point - people feel others shouldn’t get a dog if they don’t have their own space for it because they feel private premises and private space are where (off-lead) dogs should get to spend a lot of their time.

It follows that they are then equally annoyed that someone who has chosen to get a dog in the full knowledge they don’t have a garden for it - would then try and use public spaces as their garden for Fido to run about jumping about on people, disrupting picnics and pooing everywhere!

The point being is they’re inflicting their lack of foresight on us all and it’s not good for the dog or for others.

DrinkingMyWaterMindingMyBiz · 06/10/2023 17:29

@MrsH1992 it’s very clear that you don’t think you were BU at all, not many people can see it from your perspective but you were the only one who was truly there, so that’s fair enough, but I have to ask - if you’re so sure that you were not being unreasonable, why did you start the thread?

CashewGal · 06/10/2023 17:29

YANBU and my blood is boiling from all the righteous nonsense peope are spouting!! Humans are supposed to be "under control" at all times too but that doesn't stop them from invading others' space or striking up inane or offensive conversation without invitation or otherwise being extremely annoying--or much worse. Not to mention all the awful children who invade space/create disturbances in public places while parents do nothing about it.

Hello, we live in the real world, where people don't always behave well and dogs run around parks and beaches, out of grabbing distance of their owners.

I always find it odd that in this country so many people think it is so inhumane to keep a dog that doesn't have a garden, or a cat that stays indoors, yet when you do give the animal freedom all you hear is moaning about it. I find the UK extremely anti-dog.

And I really can't stand the upright dog owners that say they would never let their dog off the lead without perfect recall. Lovely for you but not every dog can learn perfect recall, or perhaps can just be a little unpredictable or make a mistake, like this one did, and think they recognise someone. To say that dog should never come off a lead, because of the small chance it will run up to someone or god forbid growl at your precious dog because your dog is posturing up to it --well get a life!!!

It's a dog eat dog world. Deal with it.

Lostcotter · 06/10/2023 17:29

This is just semantics at this point @MrsH1992

“Putting paws up” or jumping is all the same result really. I’d say the action of a dog throwing their front legs up to put on someone or something is often termed “jumping” but again -semantics!

The bottom line is the dog is putting their paws and claws on someone’s legs without their consent.

You don’t seem to realise the seriousness of it. You were in breach of the dangerous dog act no matter how tiny and cute you think Fido is!

MrsH1992 · 06/10/2023 17:20

Boomboom22 · 06/10/2023 17:11

So it did attack him not immediately turn around when it saw his face. Self defence to kick it off. Not to chase after it. Very clear I think.

She went over. Put front paws on his knees. Did not 'jump up' or bark, jump up implies leaving the ground. He looked down. She immediately retreated. He chased and stomped.

Please stop misquoting me and saying my story has changed. I hope now I have spelled it out in minute detail you can grasp it.

OP posts:
DrinkingMyWaterMindingMyBiz · 06/10/2023 17:14

MrsH1992 · 06/10/2023 17:03

'she ran over to him and put her front paws up on his knees'

Check your facts and don't miss quote people. Never says jumped. Never says repeatedly. Story never changed.

Edited

Which is… jumping up on him? Is that not what it means when people say “the dog jumped up on me,” - putting its front paws up on your legs?

Boomboom22 · 06/10/2023 17:11

So it did attack him not immediately turn around when it saw his face. Self defence to kick it off. Not to chase after it. Very clear I think.

MrsH1992 · 06/10/2023 17:03

Boomboom22 · 06/10/2023 16:52

Actually if he kicked it off him that's self defence and totally legal. If he went after it when it was not on him def illegal. As the story keeps changing its not clear but in the op she said repeatedly jumped on him. Then when everyone said yabu she said it approached him then immediately turned when it realised the man was a stranger. Quite different scenarios.

Also I've never known dog owners to keep their dogs off the no dog beaches. They let them run for miles out of sight disturbing others. Or they walk them on the path next to the beach which doesn't really help much.

'she ran over to him and put her front paws up on his knees'

Check your facts and don't miss quote people. Never says jumped. Never says repeatedly. Story never changed.

OP posts:
Boomboom22 · 06/10/2023 16:52

Actually if he kicked it off him that's self defence and totally legal. If he went after it when it was not on him def illegal. As the story keeps changing its not clear but in the op she said repeatedly jumped on him. Then when everyone said yabu she said it approached him then immediately turned when it realised the man was a stranger. Quite different scenarios.

Also I've never known dog owners to keep their dogs off the no dog beaches. They let them run for miles out of sight disturbing others. Or they walk them on the path next to the beach which doesn't really help much.

CornishClott · 06/10/2023 16:30

So if this guy had actually stomped and kicked this puppy seriously injuring it that would have been ok ? Yes can understand him being angry though and yelling .

Beachwalker66 · 06/10/2023 15:51

The man overreacted and sounds unhinged.

However, there are nutters like him everywhere, which is why your dog shouldn’t have been offlead in that situation.

You need to protect your dog from potential dangers and in this instance, you failed them.

Whyohwhywyoming · 06/10/2023 15:49

YABU. My dog has poor recall and so he isn’t off lead unless we are in a space we know is safe eg fenced field. It’s just not worth the risk. And we know he won’t hurt anyone, but no one else knows that. A dog bite is a dog bite. My DS has a friend who is so terrified of dogs she shakes all over and even tiny, adorable little dogs have exactly the same effect on her as big hulking dogs.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 06/10/2023 15:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Knowivedonewrong · 06/10/2023 14:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

DrinkingMyWaterMindingMyBiz · 06/10/2023 14:00

YABVU.

Bloom15 · 06/10/2023 13:55

BigDahliaFan · 06/10/2023 12:23

His reaction was competely disproportionate and he was in the wrong. Unfortunately though there are dog hating gits out there - so you do need to train the dog.

Dog haters because dogs should be trained - just let more people be mauled then (!)

CatamaranViper · 06/10/2023 13:31

MrsH1992 · 06/10/2023 00:46

So everyone keeps saying the dog shouldn't of been off lead but why should a dog with no prior history of approaching strangers be on lead - genuinely interested. I agree following the incident the dog should be on lead until properly trained and trustworthy.

They should be on the lead in case they mistake a stranger for a friend or family in a public place and jump up at them.

Like I said earlier, what if that man had a reactive dog with him that went for your dog? You know what would have prevented that? You keeping your dog on a lead.

Lostcotter · 06/10/2023 12:29

The funny thing is if this man or his kid just left you looking frightened but stayed silent you’d probably not have posted this or given it another thought.

You wouldn’t have cared about how it’s affected their day and their sense of safety and mental health. You’d have continued to have let your dog be off leash in public area.
Only now you’ve been inconvenienced and shaken up you finally take notice!

As someone pointed out maybe if more people reacted like that the irresponsible type of dog owners would finally realise not everyone wants their off leash out of control dog jumping all over them, their children or saying “hello” 🙄 to their (on-leash) dog.

It’s like my neighbour didn’t give a damn the first time her dog jumped on me because I just froze and left the reception area quickly. It was only when it attempted to jump on me the following day for a second time and I told her clearly to get her damn dog under control and to make sure it never touches me again or I’d escalate the report I’d already made, did she start getting bothered!

So glad to see many dog owners on this thread are not condoning your behaviour because with your dog being out of control you were breaking the law. Not all dog owners are selfish thankfully.

and btw many people who are neutral or even love dogs don’t like strange dogs jumping on them and would be frightened by it. People having a phobia or even a legitimate fear since many dogs do cause you harm and reacting out of fear is not always “dog hating”.

Most people who are cruel to dog, are dog owners!

To the posters trivialising it because of the size of the dog that’s BS. The law applies to all breeds and sizes of dogs, because they all have sharp teeth and claws and capable of doing damage to you.

BigDahliaFan · 06/10/2023 12:23

His reaction was competely disproportionate and he was in the wrong. Unfortunately though there are dog hating gits out there - so you do need to train the dog.

Letitgonowgr · 06/10/2023 12:20

I have a 7 year old toy poodle who is 3kg so maybe you mean poodle not doodle?! In any case, the man overreacted but maybe is terrified of dogs?! I couldn’t have got worked up like this as I love dogs but some people don’t. My poodle isn’t allowed off lead as her recall is terrible and whilst I know she wouldn’t hurt anyone, she’s too gentle to even pull her own toys out of her box! I worry she might get hurt or run away!

user1498572889 · 06/10/2023 12:15

Put your dog on a lead unless you are alone where you are walking.