Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to let DD buy this?

200 replies

Redpurplegreenblue · 30/09/2023 22:52

Our autistic DD wants to buy one of these 2 Christmas Jellycat’s when they come back in stock. She would be using her own money, although it’s a lot of money so she really wouldn’t have much left. DH has already said she can without even asking me but I’m more unsure about it because 1. It’s a lot of money and 2. DD has said she wants one to cuddle/sleep with but the 2 Jellycat’s she wants don’t look like they will be very comfortable to cuddle/sleep with 3. They are very big (the Christmas tree is 55cm x 15cm. And the wreath is 44cm x 37cm) and I just think they will be too big for her to sleep with comfortably and to cuddle comfortably 4. The wreath is likely to be an awkward shape to cuddle/sleep with.

DD expects them to be comfortable/cuddly to cuddle and sleep with every night. It’s a lot of money and I would hate for her to be disappointed if it comes and she can’t sleep/cuddle with it every night like she’s expecting.

Would I be unreasonable to tell her she can’t buy either of them? DD only wants one but would I be unreasonable to say that she can’t get either of these Jellycat’s?

DD (autistic) is 11. She would be using birthday money to buy it. I’ve already tried to explain to her that I don’t think the tree or wreath will be very comfortable to cuddle or sleep with every night but DD insists that they will be fine to cuddle and sleep with every night.

To refuse to let DD buy this?
To refuse to let DD buy this?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
YeahNoYeah · 01/10/2023 00:03

Why did your DH need to ask you?

Redpurplegreenblue · 01/10/2023 00:05

I will speak to DD tomorrow and see why it’s those 2 Jellycat’s that she wants in particular. If she really wants them then I will let her buy one when they are back in stock. I’ll probably try and guide her to get the tree instead of wreath because I think the shape of the wreath is likely to make it uncomfortable for DD to cuddle and sleep with?

OP posts:
Stars1979 · 01/10/2023 00:07

Jellycat are so cuddly, i doubt these would be different and im sure the wreath will be great to snuggle up to. Its not an actual wreath lol. It is a huge amount of money and you might think its a waste of money but it isnt to her and if it makes her happy and its her money, why not. I agree though that they outline the stockist so I would ask to wait until she can physically see one but she may just be sure in her head thats it. Im sure you have expressed your concern and thats all you can do. AND husband had already said yes, i think she will be more disappointment with you saying no, now your husband has said yes, than if cuddly toy doesnt live up to its hope. Good luck!

MolkosTeenageAngst · 01/10/2023 00:11

Why do you think the shape of the wreath would make it uncomfortable to sleep with? It’s not much different in shape to a round cushion? I sleep with soft toys, I can’t sleep unless I’m holding something and never have been able to, and find that flatter ones tend to be more comfortable than anything bulky. The wreath looks more comfortable than the tree to me, the tree looks like it would dig in if you lay with any of it under you and be too big to hold properly.

brielliance · 01/10/2023 00:12

Jellycats are really soft! I imagine the wreath would be nice for a child to sleep with too because they could tuck their arm into the hole to feel "safe" and ensconced. I thought there was an online returns policy though if you don't like the thing?

Redpurplegreenblue · 01/10/2023 00:21

brielliance · 01/10/2023 00:12

Jellycats are really soft! I imagine the wreath would be nice for a child to sleep with too because they could tuck their arm into the hole to feel "safe" and ensconced. I thought there was an online returns policy though if you don't like the thing?

This is actually why I thought DD might find the wreath uncomfortable to sleep and cuddle with. I thought the fact that she would have to hold it by putting her arm through the middle of the wreath might mean that she finds it uncomfortable? I just thought she would feel uncomfortable holding it like that every night/trying to cuddle it like that every night.

And the wreath may keep on falling over etc while trying to sleep or cuddle with it? Because of its shape/only being able to hold one side of it?

OP posts:
Redpurplegreenblue · 01/10/2023 00:23

on the other photos on the website the wreath doesn’t look very flat either.

To refuse to let DD buy this?
To refuse to let DD buy this?
To refuse to let DD buy this?
OP posts:
Niinja · 01/10/2023 00:25

I think either shape would be fine. It's not going to be very different to sleeping with a cushion. But then I have not worried about my autistic child taking a big textbook to bed with him either.

I am always pleased when he comes up with anything he wants to spend money on - it's a hard process for him to go through all the options and reach a decision. I would err on the side of validating the choice myself. Remind her she can return it if she likes but I would lay money that they will be beautifully soft.

Goodornot · 01/10/2023 00:28

Tell her no. That crazy money on a soft toy.

Goodornot · 01/10/2023 00:29

The wreath looks as if it is supposed to actually go on a door. It's actually described as a decoration

Redpurplegreenblue · 01/10/2023 00:33

Goodornot · 01/10/2023 00:29

The wreath looks as if it is supposed to actually go on a door. It's actually described as a decoration

To be fair the specifications/description does say it’s tested as a toy?

I think I’ll think about it but I think I’ll just have to tell DD that she can get either the tree or the wreath because DH has already told her that she can.

To refuse to let DD buy this?
OP posts:
SpacePotato · 01/10/2023 00:34

They will be soft but the tree is likely to be stuffed a bit firmer in order to stand up on it's own.

The good thing about these type of jellycat is they hold their value somewhat so if she's bored by next year you can sell it.

SpacePotato · 01/10/2023 00:36

To be fair the specifications/description does say it’s tested as a toy?

Yes they will all pass the stuffed toy CE requirements.

NatashaDancing · 01/10/2023 00:36

Talipesmum · 30/09/2023 23:38

I’ve never seen or felt a jellycat toy that wasn’t very cuddly. It feels like a pretty reliable bet. And it’s her birthday money. Fair enough if she was asking you to buy it for her (though I’d probably still get it as a main present if she wanted it more than anything else) but it’s her money. If she’s been warned it might not be great, and it’s v expensive, and she goes ahead anyway and ends up not liking it v much, then it’s a decent lesson in online shopping obsessions, using her own money. And I think there’s a strong chance it’ll be great to cuddle. I think it’s not reasonable to veto on this basis - you don’t know any more than she does, and they always reliably make these toys really nice and squishy.

There was a similar post a while ago from someone whose daughter wanted a birthday cake jellycat I think.

Jellycats are fabulously cuddly. They just cheer you up looking at them.

This appeared in my in-box. My husband is like the Colin Firth character in Fever Pitch who doesn't understand what ornaments are for and even he thought the mince pie was cute.

I don't put up Christmas decorations but I'm seriously considering getting the poinsettia (at least it won't die like every other poinsettia.)

Jellycats Christmas

Jellycat Poinsetta

Jellycat - Full Jellycat Collection

See our selection of the latest Jellycat soft toys with their super soft fur, smiling faces, and cute little features.

https://www.papertiger.co.uk/collections/jellycat/

weirdoboelady · 01/10/2023 00:46

I had an idea (I was surprised at how much I was thinking about this. I think it ties into my own insecurities about wasting money).

Could you talk to Jellycat, explain that DD has SEN, and ask if it is possible to return whichever JC you end up buying if it proves unsuitable for her needs? (Obviously in immaculate condition, but at least it would mean she could see and feel it before making a final decision). Involve DD in all this, suggest to her that you try on a 'try before you are totally committed' basis as it's such a lot of money. I suggest you ask JC for store credit if you do decide to return - sounds as if she loves JC stuff so could choose other stuff, and I reckon they would go for this deal.

Otherwise, if you live not too far from a store (Selfridges? JL?) could you make a special date to go and look at the real items? Sounds as if it would reassure you both if you could actually handle the goods before buying.

Goodornot · 01/10/2023 00:47

The avocado in ear muffs is so much cuter

brielliance · 01/10/2023 00:48

Redpurplegreenblue · 01/10/2023 00:21

This is actually why I thought DD might find the wreath uncomfortable to sleep and cuddle with. I thought the fact that she would have to hold it by putting her arm through the middle of the wreath might mean that she finds it uncomfortable? I just thought she would feel uncomfortable holding it like that every night/trying to cuddle it like that every night.

And the wreath may keep on falling over etc while trying to sleep or cuddle with it? Because of its shape/only being able to hold one side of it?

Honestly I think you're overthinking this. Everyone sleeps differently and I can see myself happily hugging that wreath to sleep in lots of different positions (I god, don't mean for it to sound that way). Again though, isn't it the law that you have a few months to returns online purchases?

icekandy · 01/10/2023 00:50

Reading these replies make me feel like I live on another planet.

£100 on a seasonal soft toy?! Plus the whole "it's her birthday money and if it's a mistake she'll learn a valuable lesson". Are you kidding me??

My 2 children get birthday and Christmas money each year, they save a proportion of it, along with some of their weekly pocket money. Absolutely no way would they be spending £100 on a soft toy, especially a seasonal one.

OP you are absolutely correct to be questioning this.

I have ADHD and all the previous replies saying "it's her money" do not apply to 1. People living to a budget and 2. Those who are neurodivergent.

Nottogetapenny · 01/10/2023 00:53

I have the wreath, it’s lovely. Very soft and squishy, your DD could sleep with it!

brielliance · 01/10/2023 00:54

@icekandy I know the price isn't what we're used to in a world of ultra cheap mass produced stuff (I don't mean this condescendingly at all but just to highlight the contrast)... But have you ever felt a jellycat? They are of stunning quality, incredibly soft and cuddly. Really durable as well. They have a whole autistic/ADHD fanbase, including adults. If anything, as someone with ADHD myself, I would say anything that brings comfort to neurodivergent people is all the more useful.

NeedTheSeaside · 01/10/2023 00:56

Caerulea · 30/09/2023 23:00

Honestly think jellycat are worth it but I have a thing against seasonal toys/furnishings/clothes etc because they do always get forgotten about outside that season. Could you perhaps nudge her to something else using that argument?

@Caerulea but Christmas is pretty predictable when it'll come around again! I LOVE getting my Christmas things out each year.

@Redpurplegreenblue

has she seen this little fella?https://www.plushpaws.co.uk/jellycat-christmas/merry-mouse-wreath.html?gclid=EAIaIQobChMIqIuFo8PTgQMVHpCDBx36gw1zEAQYGiABEgKlevD_BwE

Merry Mouse Wreath

Jellycat Merry Mouse Wreath Soft Toy

https://www.plushpaws.co.uk/jellycat-christmas/merry-mouse-wreath.html?gclid=EAIaIQobChMIqIuFo8PTgQMVHpCDBx36gw1zEAQYGiABEgKlevD_BwE

Playingintheshadow · 01/10/2023 00:59

Isn't there a smaller one? I know Jellycat are expensive (my 26 year old is addicted to them!!) but those are very dear?

I think as her dad has already said she can, then it would be a bit cruel to now say she can't...

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 01/10/2023 01:01

YeahNoYeah · 01/10/2023 00:03

Why did your DH need to ask you?

Honestly this was one of my first questions.

Why does DH have to check with you if it's ok for your (presumably shared, he isn't a Stepdad) DD to spend her OWN money on something she clearly really wants, that won't harm anyone and is adorable?

You turning round and saying "No" will undermine his authority and also might cause DD to resent you, see you as controlling and not trust you.

So what if she wants to spend £100 she has saved on one toy when she doesn't have any financial commitments? Plenty of time for the poor girl to be denying herself treats because the economy is fucked, let her enjoy this.

VivaciousRadish · 01/10/2023 01:04

I’m a huge Jellycat fan and have the blue spruce pictured above. It’s really really squishy. Whichever your daughter chooses will be amazing, and if she goes off it at a later date simply store it with your other Christmas decorations and get it out every year. My daughters are 24 and 22 and avid Jellycat fans, as are their friends, and even one daughters 30 year old boyfriend. One daughters pregnant and we’ve already bought it it’s first Jellycat (a little grey whale). Honestly I know it’s a lot of money, but she’ll love it for a long long time