Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider a deferral for dc1 because it is unfair for her to be the youngest in her year while her little sister will be the oldest in her year?

402 replies

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 10:42

Hello
I have two dcs, one born in 19/7/2020 and the other in 2/9/2022.
First dc is due to enter Reception in Sept 2024 at 4 +2 months due to state cut off, and the second will be due in Sept 2027 at 5 yo.

I feel like it is unfair for dc1 to be expected to act/ achieve at a level of 3 years ahead of dc2 when she is practically only 2 years older than dc2. Dc1 has ASD while dc2 is very likely NT, which adds to that.

I am considering a deferral for dc1 mainly because of this reason, which DH thinks is ridiculous.

Any ideas on whether I should defer dc1?

For some context both dcs are academically bright, but dc1 is really babyish compared to other 3 yo and dc2 seems more mature than other 1yo.

OP posts:
MonchichiMonchichi · 26/09/2023 19:19

My daughter is Summerborn and we made the decision for her to start Reception a year later at Compulsory School Age at the age of 5.The Department for Education says that these children should not have to miss either Year 6 or Year 7 in order to transition into secondary school. We have just had approval from 6 secondary schools to allow us to apply for a Year 7 out of year group place next year. Which means that she will transition to secondary with her adopted cohort.

Best decision we ever made, back when she was four.

Highfivemum · 26/09/2023 19:11

You have to look at each child as individual. I didn’t defer my aug DC as they were ready. One of the mums who I met in hospital did and it was the worse thing. Her DS got bored in nursery/playgroup and started misbehaving. His behaviour went backwards. She regrets it.

Stokey · 26/09/2023 19:06

I think it's quite common to defer and the OP is mainly being given a hard time due to her comparing her two DC.

For 11+ exams, schools adjust marks depending on when in the year the child was born so being young for your year is still perceived as an educational disadvantage even in Y6.

Darkmode2 · 26/09/2023 19:06

FawltyTower · 26/09/2023 18:45

Trying to make the life experiences of your dc equal or 'fair' is where madness lies. Because you'll never achieve it.

One dc may be cleverer than the other. One may have a far nicer group of friends and more social opportunities than the other. One may get picked for the residential/abroad trip in Comp and the other will miss it. A million other things that you can't control.

You'll never make their life experiences equal because they're individuals. Treat them like individuals. The one who's older in their year will have to spend longer in childcare/nursery. The younger school entrant gets to start building their school friendship group at a younger age, possibly better for their long term social skills.

Embrace their different opportunities and experiences and make the best of them or you'll drive yourself nuts trying to 'level them up'.

👏👏

PlasticineKing · 26/09/2023 19:04

I think you need to stop adding in the “fairness” factor. This decision should be based purely on each individual child, and nothing to do with their sibling.

It sounds as because the child you want to defer is likely to not be NT, that would be enough grounds for it. And I believe you get the option to do that now, which is great. All the research has already been quoted and you know that. But you have to account for the outliers too.

Comparing your children at any age is not healthy. Your children will never have the exact same lives or opportunities and you can’t ever make it that way. Your eldest will grow up having had a couple of years of just you. Your youngest will grow up with an older sibling. It goes on and on.

It’s admirable that you want to give them a level plying field, but you can’t give them the exact same. They are different people and you need to bring them up to respect that and cater to their individual needs.

Ladyoftheknight · 26/09/2023 19:00

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 13:53

Well of course she didn't read them all by herself; I read them to her and she gives me reactions like she understands

This is the most mental thing I've ever read. OP, give your head a really good wobble for your childrens sake. Your children are normal children, they are different from each other and are much more resilient than you are allowing them to be. You're also not the first person to ever be a parent, or a parent to possbly ND children.

You have asked for advice, we have told you your idea is mad, bad and not based on fact or good reasoning. Speak to some professionals so you can hear it from them too.

azlazee1 · 26/09/2023 18:59

My sister started school at an earlier age than the other students. She always felt out of place at school and felt it had adversely affected her life. It does sound like your child would be at a disadvantage. I would go for the deferral.

Mindyaownbeeswax · 26/09/2023 18:57

You should totally defer. Why on earth would you potentially make life even harder for your child when you don't need to? Lots of "well I was fine" mentality on here - and lots of people who essentially think it's not fair! It's so hard with all the pressures on them anyway - why make them do them a year earlier than others when they don't have to?! Learn to drive a year later, drink a year later - give them a step up, defer them. Particularly if ND as the school system isn't designed for anything beyond NT and so each year is pot luck with regards to support and knowledge.
You will not be made to miss y1. They will not be made to 'catch up' at some point. That just becomes their year group.

Bemyclementine · 26/09/2023 18:56

Also to add - the summer birn disadvantage so far hasn't affected dc1 . He's streets ahead of his classmates across the board.

WeightoftheWorld · 26/09/2023 18:56

BeeHappy12 · 26/09/2023 18:51

Being the oldest in a year group is statistically an advantage and being the youngest is a disadvantage which will last until they finish schooling therefore we held our DC back and i don't regret it.

I don't even think it's really about being the oldest vs youngest but actually about the very young age that the summer borns actually start schooling. Research from other countries with later school starting ages shows that the gap between eldest and youngest is much less in those cases.

Our DC1 started reception this year at 5 and I'm very glad we didn't send them last year. They are loving school so far and have come on leaps and bounds from a year ago in terms of confidence.

Bemyclementine · 26/09/2023 18:55

Dc are currently 6 and 8 yrs 2 and 4. Dc 1 was born later July than yours, dc2 born a week later in Feb than yours, so pretty much the same age gap and years of school etc

Honestly didn't occur to me to defer for tge reason you're thinking of. Dc1 was def socially younger, but so bright. He really blossomed at school.

Dc2 much more "forward" socially.

Theyre 2 school years apart and it works well.

BeeHappy12 · 26/09/2023 18:51

Being the oldest in a year group is statistically an advantage and being the youngest is a disadvantage which will last until they finish schooling therefore we held our DC back and i don't regret it.

deadrave · 26/09/2023 18:49

I dont think it’s wrong to consider it - I did. My DC was 4+1 week when he started school. Nursery said he was ready. He’s has thrived at school I was initially worried like you! Someone has to be the youngest and to be honest I doubt your child will be. There are 3 August birthdays in my sons class and 2 in July that I know of. He was initially emotionally a bit younger than the others - preferred younger toys for a little younger than the September borns however I don’t think it’s had that much of an impact on him, after all he’s only a year younger than a certain % born in September. Many are born only 3-4 months before him.

Takeachance18 · 26/09/2023 18:46

ImInACage · 26/09/2023 18:41

There will always be children more academically able, in every class. As (an ex) teacher, it is our job to differentiate the work to the needs of the individuals. My own DC is able, but deferred for emotional and social reasons. He's never been bored at school as his teachers have been skilled at making sure the work is tailored to all ability levels.

Your child is lucky, work can be differentiated but the gap can be wide, I know one year group where the maths levels in year 6 were year 8 level to foundation. Teacher also can't go beyond the year now and can only deep dive

FawltyTower · 26/09/2023 18:45

Trying to make the life experiences of your dc equal or 'fair' is where madness lies. Because you'll never achieve it.

One dc may be cleverer than the other. One may have a far nicer group of friends and more social opportunities than the other. One may get picked for the residential/abroad trip in Comp and the other will miss it. A million other things that you can't control.

You'll never make their life experiences equal because they're individuals. Treat them like individuals. The one who's older in their year will have to spend longer in childcare/nursery. The younger school entrant gets to start building their school friendship group at a younger age, possibly better for their long term social skills.

Embrace their different opportunities and experiences and make the best of them or you'll drive yourself nuts trying to 'level them up'.

WelshFlyer · 26/09/2023 18:44

My DC1 started reception at 4 years and 2 days. He is the youngest in the year. DC. 2 is the opposite and will turn 5 2 days after term starts. When DC1 was small I considered deferring if he wasn't emotionally ready. But I felt he was ready so he started and I'm glad he did as he is ahead of most the class for reading and about the same level with other skills. He is quite clearly less emotionally mature than some others but he has made some friends and he would have been so bored being held back a year and it would have delayed his learning.

As others have said, deferring is fine, but do it for the right reasons for that child, your other child's situation doesn't really come into it.

Daddydog · 26/09/2023 18:44

Our daughter was a late July baby and started school in September. She's loving it so much and has always been lightyears ahead. She was bored stiff at nursery and was probably ready for school a year ago! So much so, when she had just turned two her nursery somehow assumed she was 3 going on 4 and started getting her ready for school! She was born into total chaos and somehow ended up an old soul in a young body. Our youngest who recently turned 1 last month is a very very late Aug baby and she's so different from her sister at the same age. She's still my baby where as her sister at the same age was already very much a little lady! Every kid is different and I guess a late birth month may not mean all that much in the grand scheme of things.

ImInACage · 26/09/2023 18:41

Takeachance18 · 26/09/2023 18:38

What happens when they are board because if academically able, being board can be a big barrier in school as much as being behind. If they get board after year 10, if held back, they can't be forced to school as beyond compulsory school age, if you need school transport, due to distance, that can end and if you have a grammar in the area, will be harder to get in. If they took part in sport outside of school, they would be in their age group not school year group, so could be hard.

At secondary if in right age group, they would probably find their group, primary depending on group my be harder, but it really does depend on the random group that gets thrown together based on admissions particularly in smaller schools.

There is no right or wrong and both have advantages and disadvantages.

Edited

There will always be children more academically able, in every class. As (an ex) teacher, it is our job to differentiate the work to the needs of the individuals. My own DC is able, but deferred for emotional and social reasons. He's never been bored at school as his teachers have been skilled at making sure the work is tailored to all ability levels.

BingBongBoo86 · 26/09/2023 18:41

Join the Facebook group Flexible Admissions for Summer Borns, you’ll find loads of information. There’s off shoot groups for local authorities, you’ll find out more information about your particular area. There’s lots of misinformation on this thread e.g your child will be forced into missing a year.

I’ve chosen to delay my July 2019 DD1’s entry to reception until she’s 5 and 1 month. For me it was a decision based on how I felt about how ready she was for school. I also considered how much of a disadvantage she will experience being a summer born based on data. I did a lot of research before making my decision. There is a reason the DFE has introduced the ability to delay your child’s start to school, because summer borns perform worse, on average, than autumn borns. This trend continues even at degree level.

I understand your concerns, my DD2 is a September baby and it struck me how unfair it is that she would be nearly a year older when she started school compare to DD1.

My local education authority was an automatic yes, all schools I asked were very supportive. My reason was purely because my DD is a summer born. She had no additional needs.

I’m so glad I delayed my DD’s start to school, we start kids very early in this country. The curriculum has changed since I was at school. The expectations are very high for kids now.

Good luck with your decision.

paddyclampofthethirdkind · 26/09/2023 18:39

What happens if you defer? Do they stay in the wrong year group for the rest of their school career?

Takeachance18 · 26/09/2023 18:38

What happens when they are board because if academically able, being board can be a big barrier in school as much as being behind. If they get board after year 10, if held back, they can't be forced to school as beyond compulsory school age, if you need school transport, due to distance, that can end and if you have a grammar in the area, will be harder to get in. If they took part in sport outside of school, they would be in their age group not school year group, so could be hard.

At secondary if in right age group, they would probably find their group, primary depending on group my be harder, but it really does depend on the random group that gets thrown together based on admissions particularly in smaller schools.

There is no right or wrong and both have advantages and disadvantages.

ImInACage · 26/09/2023 18:38

Exactly Somuchgoo, not one of the 20+ high schools I contact said they would ever consider moving a child out of their adopted year group, or force them to skip a year. It's purely theoretical, but extremely rare in practice. Even if one does try, usually a swift call to the LA does the trick as they remind them of the legislation and their responsibility to assess each case on the individual child's needs, as well as detailed proof as to how it would benefit the child to miss an entire year of the curriculum.

Iateallthechocolate · 26/09/2023 18:36

I'd defer and give them another year to mature emotionally.
It may not make a big difference now, its easier to be one of the oldest in the year in secondary school though.

Hayliebells · 26/09/2023 18:35

Beware that with deferral, the schools don't necessarily have a plan for how to manage it going forward, so I'd think about that carefully. When would she realign with her year group? If they stay in a deferred group until the end of primary school, a secondary school does not have to agree to let them start in Year 7, they could insist they start at Year 8. Primary schools have an obligation to allow deferred entry at reception, but what happens after that is not guaranteed. They could insist they stay in a deferred year group, with the parent forced to apply for a regular Year 7 place at 11, missing Year 6. How would you feel about that. It's not cut and dried as there is no agreed procedure for what happens beyond deferment. In many cases it's not worth it imo.

Somuchgoo · 26/09/2023 18:34

TheGuv1982 · 26/09/2023 18:28

When I looked at a deferred entry, it’s made clear that when it comes to secondary school, they can be made to start in year 8. How likely that is, it doesn’t say, but not a risk I was willing to take.

The school/LA would need to show it's in the child's interests to rejoin cohort - ie miss year 7.

So its a theoretical option thats often used to worry parents into not delaying their child, but in reality its almost impossible for the school to do this. Given the drive for good attendance, how can a school show that missing an entire year of education is in a child's best interests?

I've even checked with our local grammar school and there's no issue there about joining out of cohort. I appreciate that our particular circumstances (really no option other than delaying) probably have made schools more cooperative than they'd have been than if we'd just chosen to avoid, but the guidance they have to follow is the same.