Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider a deferral for dc1 because it is unfair for her to be the youngest in her year while her little sister will be the oldest in her year?

402 replies

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 10:42

Hello
I have two dcs, one born in 19/7/2020 and the other in 2/9/2022.
First dc is due to enter Reception in Sept 2024 at 4 +2 months due to state cut off, and the second will be due in Sept 2027 at 5 yo.

I feel like it is unfair for dc1 to be expected to act/ achieve at a level of 3 years ahead of dc2 when she is practically only 2 years older than dc2. Dc1 has ASD while dc2 is very likely NT, which adds to that.

I am considering a deferral for dc1 mainly because of this reason, which DH thinks is ridiculous.

Any ideas on whether I should defer dc1?

For some context both dcs are academically bright, but dc1 is really babyish compared to other 3 yo and dc2 seems more mature than other 1yo.

OP posts:
sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 10:44

Advice particularly from mammas here who has been in a similar situation will be appreciated

OP posts:
DonaNobisPacem · 26/09/2023 10:44

Nothing wrong with considering deferral but you should decide what's best for each girl based on her own needs- the fact that DC2 will be the oldest in the year isn't relevant to whether DC1 should defer.

Give0fecks · 26/09/2023 10:45

There’s no right answer, but mine are pretty similar ages - my eldest is actually younger in the year than yours (Aug 2020) and my youngest September 22. My oldest as well is also quite challenging and young for her age but I think she’ll benefit from the structure of school so I’m not deferring her.

StillTryingtoBuy · 26/09/2023 10:48

I would consider a deferral for any summer born child - I think your other child being September born has brought the issue to light for you and made you consider the best approach but yes, now you need to think about what is best for each child. YANBU to consider a later start for your summer born child, YABU to do so only because they have a sibling born in September.

LaLaLouella · 26/09/2023 10:49

You should base decisions about DD1 purely on her needs and not those if others e.g, you and DD2.

Unless you have an extremely good reason don't take her away from her peer group and force her into younger classes so the gap with her sister will be artificially 'narrowed'.

Freezingcoldinseptember · 26/09/2023 10:50

I have dc in June /August and September.. Never occurred to me to tamper with their education opportunities.. Do you plan on holding 1 dc back in other areas to make it 'fair' also?

Esmereldapawpatrol · 26/09/2023 10:51

My DC have the very similar birthdays to yours although three school years apart but DC1 was youngest and DC2 the oldest in their years. DC1 has just left primary and although struggled a bit to start with he is now right where he needs to be and ahead in most areas. DC2 has been flying from the start due to being that bit older.

It makes the journeys in Primary different but ultimately both doing great. Socially DC1 was really ready for school so deferring him didn't enter my mind.

Mumofoneandone · 26/09/2023 10:54

I have a similar situation, August first born and September second born. Both bright. Eldest was in a kindergarten unti she was nearly 5. She then went straight into year 1 and is absolutely flying (wasn't reading and writing at that stage).
Youngest into reception at nearly 5, but split time between Rec and year 1 as he needed it academically. He's doing really well!
Hadn't planned to put DC in main stream until older, but had to and it has worked well for them both.
Always worth deferring a summer born if in their interests.

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 10:55

Esmereldapawpatrol · 26/09/2023 10:51

My DC have the very similar birthdays to yours although three school years apart but DC1 was youngest and DC2 the oldest in their years. DC1 has just left primary and although struggled a bit to start with he is now right where he needs to be and ahead in most areas. DC2 has been flying from the start due to being that bit older.

It makes the journeys in Primary different but ultimately both doing great. Socially DC1 was really ready for school so deferring him didn't enter my mind.

This is exactly what I predict will happen and thus think it will be unfair for dc1

OP posts:
HowcanIhelp123 · 26/09/2023 10:55

Leave DC2 out of it and focus whats best for DC1. Also look at what the schools rules are. Some schools allow you to defer reception but would make the child 'catch up' and enter at year 1. This could be the case if you moved schools for example also, or could lead to problems when moving up to secondary school and sixth form (some won't let you in when older than the correct year group and limit options to colleges instead). Not sure if it would affect funding for A levels etc also.

Personally unless its really necessary I wouldn't do it, too much faff and potential for issues down the line if circumstances change.

Lookingforasilverlining · 26/09/2023 10:55

You need to decide what is in the best interests of DD2. For most summer born children deferral is in their best interests.

Have a read of this

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/182664/DFE-RR017.pdf

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/182664/DFE-RR017.pdf

Lookingforasilverlining · 26/09/2023 10:57

Also ask on the flexible entry for summer born page on facebook. There is also false information on this thread and the facebook group will be able to guide you to the facts.

PhantomErik · 26/09/2023 10:57

I have 3 DC, with birthdays in January & 2 end of July. All at secondary now.

20th January is set 1 & 2
Young for age but clever. Quiet & a bit alternative/quirky

18th July is set 1 for everything
Quiet, sensitive, very well behaved & well liked.

22nd July is set 3 & 4
Creative/artistic, struggles with behaviour & possibly would have benefitted from a delayed start.

PomegranateRose · 26/09/2023 10:57

I was born at the very end of July and thus one of the very youngest in my year. It never posed an issue for me, though obviously I hesitate to compare my neurodivergence with others at the best of times, let alone with a child, and one I have never met.

I did think schools still accounted and explored for each child's capabilities and "readiness" at the nursery stage (the bit before reception when I was at school) and advised on which cohort they would be best served in - am I wrong? I know that when I was at this age they "staggered" starting school for this reason.

As other PPs have said, I think you would be unreasonable to consider their start times against each other, but I do think it would be reasonable to consult with school/childcare staff and make them aware that you suspect she might be young for her year and that you're wondering if deferring would better serve her, if that's a possibility. But I suspect that would need quite specific assessment and rationale what with government cutoffs etc? My work in education isn't with children this young so I'm sorry I can't shed more specific light but I suspect others here can!

luckylavender · 26/09/2023 10:57

I have an August born DC, adult now. I would not have dreamed of doing that, because where does it stop? Your youngest is just 1, how can you make assumptions yet?

DC did well at sport, went to an RG Uni. I also think that being with elder children was good for him.

Charlotte120221 · 26/09/2023 10:57

No this wouldn't cross my mind.

I would only consider whether dc1 was ready for school.

Someone always has to be the oldest and someone the youngest in the year - no one will have any expectations of your older dc based on the age gap to her younger sibling?

smallshinybutton · 26/09/2023 10:57

That is a ridiculous reason

jannier · 26/09/2023 10:58

Some children are more than ready for school at 3 but get left in nursery. How does she cope with her peers I think she would struggle missing reception year and going straight to year 1.

instantpotnoodle · 26/09/2023 10:58

My eldest is v v late august. We didn’t defer. He was totally and utterly ready to go. He’s now year 3 and exceeds on all counts. My youngest is early October. He’ll be so ready, but our decision about our eldest had no relation to my youngest’s birthday. You will know your own child but don’t get bogged down in your other child’s birthdate.

Parlourgames · 26/09/2023 11:00

I’ve got an august born child and while it clearly challenged her to be the youngest I am not sure it was a bad thing overall. She’s very bright so has coped intellectually.

Make a decision based entirely on her, not in comparison to her sibling.

caban · 26/09/2023 11:00

I'd 100% defer.

I have an older August born and a younger September born, and the September born had a hugely easier time.

My summer born did fine, managed, was ok but it was totally different to thriving and sailing through early school, always being one of the oldest, biggest, most articulate, most confident.

There's a reason why Autumn borns are statistically more likely to be on sports teams, get speaking roles in plays and do better in their exams.

Summer borns have a disadvantage and Autumn borns have an advantage. Some able Summer borns will succeed despite the disadvantage which is obviously great, but not sure why anyone would choose not to give their child an advantage if they have the opportunity.

Araminta1003 · 26/09/2023 11:00

“Dc1 has ASD” - yes, I would definitely defer. And having to keep up with your sibling is also an issue.

I had one academically gifted NT girl who was September born and streets ahead in state primary, but by secondary I was so happy she was one of the eldest because it made life so much easier for her socially and emotionally speaking. It gave her all that extra maturity at GCSE etc too.

poolviewthanks · 26/09/2023 11:01

Just remember that "fair" does not mean "equal"

What is fair is that they are both treated by their parents in a manner that is appropriate to them as individuals. Comparing your children is a horrible thing to do. Regardless of where their birthday falls both will have different experiences in school and life.

caban · 26/09/2023 11:02

jannier · 26/09/2023 10:58

Some children are more than ready for school at 3 but get left in nursery. How does she cope with her peers I think she would struggle missing reception year and going straight to year 1.

If you defer your child goes into Reception age 5, so the oldest of the class, rather than skipping R and going into Y1 as the youngest.

Cluelessat33 · 26/09/2023 11:02

I mean someone will always be the youngest 🤷‍♀️