Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider a deferral for dc1 because it is unfair for her to be the youngest in her year while her little sister will be the oldest in her year?

402 replies

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 10:42

Hello
I have two dcs, one born in 19/7/2020 and the other in 2/9/2022.
First dc is due to enter Reception in Sept 2024 at 4 +2 months due to state cut off, and the second will be due in Sept 2027 at 5 yo.

I feel like it is unfair for dc1 to be expected to act/ achieve at a level of 3 years ahead of dc2 when she is practically only 2 years older than dc2. Dc1 has ASD while dc2 is very likely NT, which adds to that.

I am considering a deferral for dc1 mainly because of this reason, which DH thinks is ridiculous.

Any ideas on whether I should defer dc1?

For some context both dcs are academically bright, but dc1 is really babyish compared to other 3 yo and dc2 seems more mature than other 1yo.

OP posts:
JustHereWithMyPopcorn · 26/09/2023 11:31

I think your reasoning is unreasonable. Being a July baby is not a problem, there are many summer babies who excel just as there ae many Autumn babies that do not. The ASD is something to consider if you think it is bringing learning difficulties.

Namerequired · 26/09/2023 11:30

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 11:20

Do you find it unfair for your younger child to have to adapt to an age group older than what he is? Particularly when compared to your oldest?

Not at all. It’s something that happened gradually and naturally. Maybe he would have been more mature regardless, who knows. There’s ups and downs to both sides. My younger one would have been ready before the year was up, but I know there’s an advantage in being older in the beginning. However if they ever need to repeat a year (both have health issues) I know that would be easier for the younger as the older is already a year older than some. I don’t notice a gap with either with their friends/year group at this stage, but these gaps narrow as they get older anyway. I wouldn’t overthink it. If your child is ready send them, if not don’t.

Dizzydeers · 26/09/2023 11:29

Defer your DD if you think she needs it’s as an individual not because you are comparing her to her sister.

It’s especially important not to compare her as she has ASD and you suspect her sibling is NT.

PomegranateRose · 26/09/2023 11:29

Goodornot · 26/09/2023 11:18

What is this new fad of not sending appropriately aged children to school?

Every day there is a thread on it.

One of my exes was a 29th August baby. He went to school only a week after his 4th birthday along with children nearly a year oldwr than him. He is now a top consultant and graduated top of his class at medical school at only 22. He wasn't 23 until the August after med school ended of course.

I do think it's good to recognise that children will vary developmentally and that sometimes deferring might serve that better (but so might SEN support but going ahead in the "right" chronological cohort of course). But you would think that early years teachers especially (though I've worked in secondary education and found all the schools I've worked in to be very hot on spotting/referring SEN) would be keen-eyed at spotting developmental differences and where they might warrant additional help/adjustment.

I sometimes suspect it is a well intended but misplaced desire for control/mediating factors - if you know your child is chronologically young for the year and that education and eventually jobs etc. are getting more competitive than ever, the economy is struggling and so on, you're naturally going to want to give your child the most advantageous circumstances you can - but actually you just can't ever 100% accurately anticipate or control for these things. Indeed, I was one of the absolute youngest in my year, but friends with mostly the "older" kids and gave pretty much all of them a run for their money at school, and would say socially I benefited from being alongside them, went to a RG, about to finish my second degree, etc. etc.; I honestly think as long as you're a present and aware parent and act when it's called for, it's swings and roundabouts in the end, and as other PPs have said, once you start deferring purely based on age, where does it end? It just shifts the "youngest" around.

BerriesNutsConkers · 26/09/2023 11:28

My birthday falls on the 4th Sept so eldest in the year, my best friend through school was born on the 30th of August, the youngest in the year. Age was never an issue and we were equal academically. I think you are trying to solve a problem where there isn't one!

My dc is July born and I never found it to be an issue.

elderflowerandpomelo · 26/09/2023 11:28

I'm an end of August child. Stayed w my year group. Excelled academically. I wish that I'd been kept back a year, I really do. What seems so mad now is that my two best friends from childhood were both Sept born and went to school early... I expect (and hope) that if the same situation arose now, my mum would have held me back.

TriumphantElephant · 26/09/2023 11:28

My July kid did better than my Sept child. NT children. Decide based on the child.

We would have done the July one a huge disservice to defer her based on an arbitrary factor, without considering her actual abilities and needs.

bridgetreilly · 26/09/2023 11:25

Someone has to be the youngest in the year and someone will be oldest. Teachers know and expect those differences in reception classes. Just send them at the normal time.

BlueRabbitWasNaughty · 26/09/2023 11:24

I think it's silly to say all summer borns should defer - as other posters have said, where does it stop?

One of mine was youngest in the year but was academically able and never struggled. He did get tired at school initially but wasn't the only one (to have a nap in the library corner!).

The teachers took age into account for academics up until about year 2 but it wasn't necessary in my experience. He played in numerous sports teams at all ages and got top A'level grades so I wouldn't defer unless they seem particularly immature compared to peers.

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 11:23

Charlotte120221 · 26/09/2023 10:57

No this wouldn't cross my mind.

I would only consider whether dc1 was ready for school.

Someone always has to be the oldest and someone the youngest in the year - no one will have any expectations of your older dc based on the age gap to her younger sibling?

Its not exactly about the age gap, but for example when dc1 is 7 she will be expected to behave and learn at a year 3 level but for dc2 at 7 only year 2 level.

OP posts:
Andywarholswig · 26/09/2023 11:22

My daughters have the same gap (DD2 even born on the 19 July). I can honestly say it hasn’t been a problem for the youngest. She is happy, confident and doing really well at school despite being one of the youngest. I think I’d we had deferred her she would have been soo bored and as it is it works really well with friendships as everyone is a similarish age and the girls all get on well together

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 11:21

PhantomErik · 26/09/2023 10:57

I have 3 DC, with birthdays in January & 2 end of July. All at secondary now.

20th January is set 1 & 2
Young for age but clever. Quiet & a bit alternative/quirky

18th July is set 1 for everything
Quiet, sensitive, very well behaved & well liked.

22nd July is set 3 & 4
Creative/artistic, struggles with behaviour & possibly would have benefitted from a delayed start.

hi do you regret not deferring your 22/7 kid?

OP posts:
sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 11:20

Namerequired · 26/09/2023 11:14

You need to base it on the children. I am in the same boat only opposite. Our cut off is 1st July and my older son missed it by less than a week and started a year later. My next child was mid June so started young. There’s a full 3 years between them (bar 3weeks) but they are only 2 school years apart.
Honestly while it’s noticeable at 1st as time goes on they adapt to the age they are with. I find the older one a little less mature than his age and the younger who started young more mature. Both are academically able.
They suit their school years. It’s hard to believe if their birthdays had been the other way about they would be 4 school years apart. There’s no way there’s a 4yr gap between them. 2 actually seems more plausible than the factual 3yrs apart they are.

Do you find it unfair for your younger child to have to adapt to an age group older than what he is? Particularly when compared to your oldest?

OP posts:
Goodornot · 26/09/2023 11:18

What is this new fad of not sending appropriately aged children to school?

Every day there is a thread on it.

One of my exes was a 29th August baby. He went to school only a week after his 4th birthday along with children nearly a year oldwr than him. He is now a top consultant and graduated top of his class at medical school at only 22. He wasn't 23 until the August after med school ended of course.

ThePaperTrail · 26/09/2023 11:15

Precipice · 26/09/2023 11:06

Someone has to be the youngest. This is just how your kids were born.

For those saying to defer most summer born children - so you think most summer born children should be going in as essentially autumn born children, making the cut-off effectively earlier in the year; then suddenly those born in late spring will be the youngest and so disadvantaged by your lights. Should they then also be allowed to defer? Where does it stop? How does this make sense?

Exactly.

I'm an August-born and was the youngest in my class. It was hard when two years were mixed together at primary school (so was almost two years younger than the oldest child in the class) and I would avoid a school with that set-up.

However, I was still able to keep up with the class. By secondary school it wasn't an issue. Most other children aren't born in September anyway - the majority of children seemed to be born in the spring and summer months! It's not like being born in August is some huge disability.

Namerequired · 26/09/2023 11:14

You need to base it on the children. I am in the same boat only opposite. Our cut off is 1st July and my older son missed it by less than a week and started a year later. My next child was mid June so started young. There’s a full 3 years between them (bar 3weeks) but they are only 2 school years apart.
Honestly while it’s noticeable at 1st as time goes on they adapt to the age they are with. I find the older one a little less mature than his age and the younger who started young more mature. Both are academically able.
They suit their school years. It’s hard to believe if their birthdays had been the other way about they would be 4 school years apart. There’s no way there’s a 4yr gap between them. 2 actually seems more plausible than the factual 3yrs apart they are.

Wallywobbles · 26/09/2023 11:14

I have it the opposite way round. 2 years academically and 14 months in age. When the youngest wanted to move up following her IQ test the form teacher refused to sanction it. In the long terms it's been fine. Interestingly our GP recommended against it as she had been the youngest in her class and felt that she'd never quite fitted in.

StorminanDcup · 26/09/2023 11:12

Very much depends how she is when the time comes but I wouldn’t do a straight comparison.
No two children / siblings have the same experience in life.

My DC1 is late summer, DC2 is a winter baby so much older in their school year.

DC1 met milestones a lot earlier than DC2 did, is physically more robust, seems more academically minded (loves learning) and took to school like a duck to water. DC2 is confident and happy in nursery but does not show the same “quickness” to learn, preferring to play and just pootle around.
Both lovely kids and both confident but their respective summer / winter position does not seem to have influenced their development or where they fall in the spectrum of learning / ability.

It is completely dependent on the child. My summer baby would have hated being left behind his peers and although he is younger it actually suits him much better to be along side them challenging himself rather than being unchallenged and a bit bored doing the nursery / reception level stuff for an addition year.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 26/09/2023 11:10

My DD is October born so one of the oldest in her year and DS is August so one of the youngest. He's just started secondary, is in top sets and has a big group of lovely mates so for that reason I'd say YABU but I guess it does depend on the child. Someone has to be the youngest though!

Hihey · 26/09/2023 11:10

I'm a summer baby and never struggled at school with the work or with socialising, even in EYFS. I won't be deferring my July baby although I'm concerned that she could be in a class with children up to 15 months older than her due to deferrals. I think deferrals should only be for children with certain SEN or developmental delays.

BIossomtoes · 26/09/2023 11:09

Precipice · 26/09/2023 11:06

Someone has to be the youngest. This is just how your kids were born.

For those saying to defer most summer born children - so you think most summer born children should be going in as essentially autumn born children, making the cut-off effectively earlier in the year; then suddenly those born in late spring will be the youngest and so disadvantaged by your lights. Should they then also be allowed to defer? Where does it stop? How does this make sense?

This. I was the youngest in my year. It was fine.

Weepingwillows12 · 26/09/2023 11:09

I have a July born and was worried about this but actually reception teachers are used to looking after kids with differing levels of knowledge. Some kids knew how to read, others didn't. Some had done more nursery and others had never left their parents before. A lot of reception is social skills and teaching behaviour initially anyway. My DS and the other July and August born's never noticeably struggled or were left behind.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 26/09/2023 11:09

My eldest has ADHD and is one of the oldest in her year. It gives her so much breathing space, I'd say she's around the bottom 1/3 of her class academically and bottom 1/4 socially. I think she would have sunk and really struggled if she'd been born just a couple of weeks earlier.

Ladyoftheknight · 26/09/2023 11:07

You need to make sure you realise your children are entirely different people. It doesn't matter what age/stage the other is at. And hundreds/thousands of children go to school at 4+ a few months with literally zero issues

Precipice · 26/09/2023 11:06

Someone has to be the youngest. This is just how your kids were born.

For those saying to defer most summer born children - so you think most summer born children should be going in as essentially autumn born children, making the cut-off effectively earlier in the year; then suddenly those born in late spring will be the youngest and so disadvantaged by your lights. Should they then also be allowed to defer? Where does it stop? How does this make sense?